So, wait. You ask him what passages, he responds by noting that he DID quote them in the past, and now his post devoid of content and personal conviction ?
Devoid of content and
filled with personal conviction. Based almost entirely on personal conviction, as a matter of fact.
I'm quite well aware of what GB has posted in the past. I'm also quite well aware (though perhaps you are not) that he has NOT posted anything to show that what AA's teachings are when it comes to the sort of details I referred to above, not the least reason being that there simply
aren't any. Does AA embrace the Nicene creed? If I blaspheme against the holy ghost, am I doomed to a life of drunkenness? Can even an alcoholic get exalted if he has enough wives? Is it really that important to say God's name just right, especially considering that we have to guess at the vowel sounds not provided by the original written language we're working from?
Are these not the details that distinguish one religion from another, and the religious from the secular?
GB has just claimed to have "posted the relevant passages" from AA literature which clarify AA's stance on such questions, But GB invariably responds the same way to
every request I make that he address my arguments directly, which is simply to claim that he's already done so ad nauseum, etc. Track back through the thread and show me where he posted those passages. Yeah, I know, it's a long thread. Who's going to take that trouble? Nobody. GB's
counting on it. One thing for sure is that YOU certainly aren't going to make that effort. But in this particular instance, it's not even
possible for him to have posted any such evidence, because
AA literature is completely silent on these sorts of details. What you'll find is GB
extrapolating from sparse data to reach the conclusions he started out with: that AA is thinly disguised Protestant Christianity (quickly skipping over the doctrinal differences
within this division of Christianity), and atheists who deny it are liars. Not quite sure how he feels about
Christians who deny it and point to the stark contrast between passages like these:
"
To us, the Realm of the Spirit is broad, roomy, all inclusive; never exclusive, or forbidding...."
(Alcoholics Anonymous, p. 46.)
"
Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it"
(Matt 7:13-14).
Now here you are taking a very GB-esque approach:
On the other hand, I'd like to point out that I have several times noted that your definitions change quite readily.
See, here's the problem I have with that, Belz: First, I categorically deny that my definitions have changed, and challenge you to show
how they've changed, quoting any of my posts you'd care to if necessary as a means to that end. Second, I've already asked you to back up your claim by doing that, and here
again you respond in vacuous GB fashion, simply restating your claim, and in addition, restating your claim to have already provide these answers. Tiresome. Disappointing. This is typing practice, nothing more.
Don't you see a bit of dishonesty in that ?
I
am seeing a bit of dishonesty here, now that you mention it. I've had suspicions previously, though I wanted to allow for such possibilities as that I was mostly just seeing laziness, or perhaps a slight deficiency in short term memory. But this latest round of posts is making it harder for me to continue to extend the benefit of that doubt.