Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is a nice example of what I do NOT consider to be a serious effort toward challenging the definition.

Why would I even bother ? Your definitions are as constant as a bowl of Jell-O.

Under the definition I have proposed, it is indispensible to the shared aspect.

That's odd. I was under the impression that most people who come to AA already have heard of the Christian deity and its associated nonsense.
 
Why would I even bother ?
Yeah, that's what I thought.

Your definitions are as constant as a bowl of Jell-O.
Your accusations are as vague as a mist's shadow. Care to quote the posts which you feel best demonstrate this lack of constancy? No, probably not. Too much like work. Might involve actually going back further than about one post.

That's odd. I was under the impression that most people who come to AA already have heard of the Christian deity and its associated nonsense.
As have many who show up at one church or another -- but they are taught nonetheless. And how.

There seems to be no end of details and nuances regarding the nature of this deity, the inner workings of his mind, his paradoxical status as both infinite god and mortal man (in the form of himself as his own son, or something; I never was entirely clear on that), the holy ghost (which, as best I understand it, isn't a deity, exactly, or at least not a separate deity, though some disagree) -- and then there's the Virgin Mary, who is considered (by some) to be "more honorable than the Cherubim and more glorious than the Seraphim" (more deities, as I take it). This business of "the Christian deity" is apparently fairly complicated, and the details vary from one church to another. In some instances, they vary a LOT, and the various adherents consider some of those differences to be VERY important.

These details are what I mean by specific, supernatural teachings.

If churches didn't teach which doctrines they embrace and which ones they reject, how would the members know whether to genuflect and eat the cracker or fall on the floor and start speaking in tongues? Observing the sabbath on the wrong day of the week or failing to address God by his correct name gets you a ticket to Hell in some churches (or "outer darkness", which may or may not be the same thing, depending on whom you consult -- at the very least, you won't "inherit the Kingdom").

I've been to thousands of AA meetings, and I've read the Big Book more times than I'd care to count, but I don't recall having ever gleaned from those experiences one single thing regarding any of these sorts of details. Where are AA's specific supernatural teachings?
 
Last edited:
I've been to thousands of AA meetings, and I've read the Big Book more times than I'd care to count, but I don't recall having ever gleaned from those experiences one single thing regarding any of these sorts of details. Where are AA's specific supernatural teachings?

In the 12 Steps themselves, and yes, in The Big Book.

I suppose you now want to parse the word "teachings" to death.

:deadhorse

GB
 
In the 12 Steps themselves, and yes, in The Big Book.
Do tell. Can you provide me with the relevant passages I would need to consult if I wanted to know, say, whether AA embraces the Nicene creed, or whether plural marriage is a requirement for exaltation?

Or anything of an even remotely similar nature?
 
Do tell. Can you provide me with the relevant passages I would need to consult if I wanted to know, say, whether AA embraces the Nicene creed, or whether plural marriage is a requirement for exaltation?

Or anything of an even remotely similar nature?

I HAVE quoted the relevant passages. How large of a font, what colors do you want me touse, how much highlighting, bolding, italicizing do you want me to use when I repost them?

Your arguments are as bereft of any EVIDENCE, merit, credibility, or honesty as any of those from the the most blatant Theists posting on JREF.


GB
 
I HAVE quoted the relevant passages.
Bla bla bla. Standard GB response. Filled with personal conviction and vitriol, devoid of actual content. There's something important here that you just aren't getting GB. I tried to make the point with sarcasm but it went over your head, so here it is straight-on: the truth value of your claims is not increased by the strength of your conviction. Don't feel too bad; a lot of people don't get that. The whole teabagger thing is a shining example; long on conviction, short on facts and logic. Can you not see what a cheap trick you're trying to play here? Can you not understand why it so often works? The preacher seems so sincere, so full of confidence and enthusiasm, why, there just must be something there! Those people all swear that their magnetic bracelets do a wonderful job of cleansing their blood, it must be true! The guy is adamant that he was abducted by aliens...

How many Christians do you suppose there are who were initially drawn to that "faith" by the strength of someone else's conviction? Humans are hard-wired to attribute undue weight to that sort of thing, and you're trying to exploit that feature without even realizing that you're doing it. Trust me, GB: no one who has been following this thread has the slightest doubt that you are VERY heavily emotionally invested in this, and the more you try to underscore that, the more obvious it becomes that it's clouding your judgement. Want to prove me wrong? Then take a few deep breaths, identify the passages you want to present as examples of specific supernatural AA teachings, and then present them.

(Note: if you think mere references to "God" are acceptable as examples, please re-read my previous two posts carefully before you begin).

(And you might keep this in mind as well: While some of the most persuasive arguments I've ever read anywhere were presented in this forum's default font size and color, the most delusional ravings of the utterly clueless have often appeared in large font and in various colors -- so often, in fact, that I tend to scroll right past them on the assumption that they aren't worth reading. I suspect that a lot of others here do the same).
 
I HAVE quoted the relevant passages. How large of a font, what colors do you want me touse, how much highlighting, bolding, italicizing do you want me to use when I repost them?

Your arguments are as bereft of any EVIDENCE, merit, credibility, or honesty as any of those from the the most blatant Theists posting on JREF.


GB

Pot, meet pot.
 
Last edited:
Bla bla bla. Standard GB response. Filled with personal conviction and vitriol, devoid of actual content.

I think you have mistaken your posts for GB's.

There's something important here that you just aren't getting GB. I tried to make the point with sarcasm but it went over your head, so here it is straight-on: the truth value of your claims is not increased by the strength of your conviction.

GB never said they were and you lie in saying that he has. His claims have always been based on evidence unlike yours which are based on emotion and wishful thinking.

The fact that GB will not be swayed by your repeating the same mistakes and fallacies is proof of nothing except he doesn't tolerate your silliness.

(Note: if you think mere references to "God" are acceptable as examples, please re-read my previous two posts carefully before you begin).

But your posts are wrong. rereading fallacies doesn't make them right. Re-read the bible until you come to believe it all is a christian argument to non-believers. Fake it 'til you make it is AA's version of that same claim.

(And you might keep this in mind as well: While some of the most persuasive arguments I've ever read anywhere were presented in this forum's default font size and color, the most delusional ravings of the utterly clueless have often appeared in large font and in various colors -- so often, in fact, that I tend to scroll right past them on the assumption that they aren't worth reading. I suspect that a lot of others here do the same).

On the other hand. With all the colours and font changes GB has used to draw your attention to the facts, his posts are far less delusional than anything many others have written in this thread.

And even with all the techniques GB uses to get you to read the facts, you refuse. Isn't that the definition of delusional . . . or at least a major part of it.
 
I think you have mistaken your posts for GB's.
So you liked my little joke. I can always tell when you find something I've said to be witty because of the way you spit it right back at me as if you'd thought of it yourself.
 
When there's no 'there' there, they've got to do something to impress the rest of the KewlKidz.
 
I have trouble believing thay you're this dense.

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for civility.


"Spiritual" implies supernatural; and the only distinction I see between "spiritualism" and "religion" is one of organization, not of nature.

But what you see, and what the rest of the world acknowledge are (again) two different things. Whilst I might acknowledge that if we use your black and white use of the word spiritual one will be obliged to see things as religious; there are other practical uses.
Please look them up and let me know what you find out. I have posted a number of different explanations. definitions and examples that support the oft heard explanation that "it is a spiritual program", not religious.

And AA is definitely an organisation. One with litterature and procedures (the steps) which promote not only religion, but a thinly-veiled, specific one. I call that religious.

I call it suggestions for recovery, but there you go.

I would also be very intrerested in seeing this "litterature" you keep referring to. Is your misuse of the word a joke?

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for civility.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Your accusations are as vague as a mist's shadow. Care to quote the posts which you feel best demonstrate this lack of constancy? No, probably not. Too much like work. Might involve actually going back further than about one post.

I hope you're getting someone else to read your posts with you. Hopefully you have someone to pat you on the back for your cleverness.

On the other hand, I'd like to point out that I have several times noted that your definitions change quite readily. Maybe YOU'd like to go back a few posts and remind yourself of that fact.

I've been to thousands of AA meetings, and I've read the Big Book more times than I'd care to count, but I don't recall having ever gleaned from those experiences one single thing regarding any of these sorts of details. Where are AA's specific supernatural teachings?

Perhaps before you asked this question you should have waited for me to actually agree about the teaching part.
 
Bla bla bla. Standard GB response. Filled with personal conviction and vitriol, devoid of actual content. There's something important here that you just aren't getting GB. I tried to make the point with sarcasm but it went over your head, so here it is straight-on: the truth value of your claims is not increased by the strength of your conviction.

So, wait. You ask him what passages, he responds by noting that he DID quote them in the past, and now his post devoid of content and personal conviction ?

Don't you see a bit of dishonesty in that ?
 
Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited moderated content.

How so ? All you've presented are personal testimonies.

But what you see, and what the rest of the world acknowledge are (again) two different things.

Spoken like a theist. Basically, evidence is worthless because it's always interpreted by the person mentioning it.

Whilst I might acknowledge that if we use your black and white use of the word spiritual one will be obliged to see things as religious; there are other practical uses.

Such as ? The definitions provided in the last few posts don't seem to indicate much in the realm of the mundane.

Please look them up and let me know what you find out. I have posted a number of different explanations. definitions and examples that support the oft heard explanation that "it is a spiritual program", not religious.

Weaseling. You've been shown wrong and now you're trying to find another word to fit AA into. The bitch of it is: "spiritual" is religious without the organization. AA, however, is definitely organized.

I call it suggestions for recovery, but there you go.

But what you see, and what the rest of the world acknowledge are (again) two different things.

I would also be very intrerested in seeing this "litterature" you keep referring to.

You're not aware that AA has a book they refer to ? What rock were you hiding under all those years ?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So, wait. You ask him what passages, he responds by noting that he DID quote them in the past, and now his post devoid of content and personal conviction ?
Devoid of content and filled with personal conviction. Based almost entirely on personal conviction, as a matter of fact.

I'm quite well aware of what GB has posted in the past. I'm also quite well aware (though perhaps you are not) that he has NOT posted anything to show that what AA's teachings are when it comes to the sort of details I referred to above, not the least reason being that there simply aren't any. Does AA embrace the Nicene creed? If I blaspheme against the holy ghost, am I doomed to a life of drunkenness? Can even an alcoholic get exalted if he has enough wives? Is it really that important to say God's name just right, especially considering that we have to guess at the vowel sounds not provided by the original written language we're working from?

Are these not the details that distinguish one religion from another, and the religious from the secular?

GB has just claimed to have "posted the relevant passages" from AA literature which clarify AA's stance on such questions, But GB invariably responds the same way to every request I make that he address my arguments directly, which is simply to claim that he's already done so ad nauseum, etc. Track back through the thread and show me where he posted those passages. Yeah, I know, it's a long thread. Who's going to take that trouble? Nobody. GB's counting on it. One thing for sure is that YOU certainly aren't going to make that effort. But in this particular instance, it's not even possible for him to have posted any such evidence, because AA literature is completely silent on these sorts of details. What you'll find is GB extrapolating from sparse data to reach the conclusions he started out with: that AA is thinly disguised Protestant Christianity (quickly skipping over the doctrinal differences within this division of Christianity), and atheists who deny it are liars. Not quite sure how he feels about Christians who deny it and point to the stark contrast between passages like these:

"To us, the Realm of the Spirit is broad, roomy, all inclusive; never exclusive, or forbidding...."
(Alcoholics Anonymous, p. 46.)

"Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it"
(Matt 7:13-14).


Now here you are taking a very GB-esque approach:
On the other hand, I'd like to point out that I have several times noted that your definitions change quite readily.
See, here's the problem I have with that, Belz: First, I categorically deny that my definitions have changed, and challenge you to show how they've changed, quoting any of my posts you'd care to if necessary as a means to that end. Second, I've already asked you to back up your claim by doing that, and here again you respond in vacuous GB fashion, simply restating your claim, and in addition, restating your claim to have already provide these answers. Tiresome. Disappointing. This is typing practice, nothing more.

Don't you see a bit of dishonesty in that ?
I am seeing a bit of dishonesty here, now that you mention it. I've had suspicions previously, though I wanted to allow for such possibilities as that I was mostly just seeing laziness, or perhaps a slight deficiency in short term memory. But this latest round of posts is making it harder for me to continue to extend the benefit of that doubt.
 
Last edited:
I am seeing a bit of dishonesty here, now that you mention it. I've had suspicions previously, though I wanted to allow for such possibilities as that I was mostly just seeing laziness, or perhaps a slight deficiency in short term memory. But this latest round of posts is making it harder for me to continue to extend the benefit of that doubt.

qft
 
Devoid of content and filled with personal conviction. Based almost entirely on personal conviction, as a matter of fact.

I'm quite well aware of what GB has posted in the past. I'm also quite well aware (though perhaps you are not) that he has NOT posted anything to show that what AA's teachings are when it comes to the sort of details I referred to above, not the least reason being that there simply aren't any. Does AA embrace the Nicene creed? If I blaspheme against the holy ghost, am I doomed to a life of drunkenness? Can even an alcoholic get exalted if he has enough wives? Is it really that important to say God's name just right, especially considering that we have to guess at the vowel sounds not provided by the original written language we're working from?

Are these not the details that distinguish one religion from another, and the religious from the secular?

GB has just claimed to have "posted the relevant passages" from AA literature which clarify AA's stance on such questions, But GB invariably responds the same way to every request I make that he address my arguments directly, which is simply to claim that he's already done so ad nauseum, etc. Track back through the thread and show me where he posted those passages. Yeah, I know, it's a long thread. Who's going to take that trouble? Nobody. GB's counting on it. One thing for sure is that YOU certainly aren't going to make that effort. But in this particular instance, it's not even possible for him to have posted any such evidence, because AA literature is completely silent on these sorts of details. What you'll find is GB extrapolating from sparse data to reach the conclusions he started out with: that AA is thinly disguised Protestant Christianity (quickly skipping over the doctrinal differences within this division of Christianity), and atheists who deny it are liars. Not quite sure how he feels about Christians who deny it and point to the stark contrast between passages like these:

"To us, the Realm of the Spirit is broad, roomy, all inclusive; never exclusive, or forbidding...."
(Alcoholics Anonymous, p. 46.)

"Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it"
(Matt 7:13-14).


Now here you are taking a very GB-esque approach:
See, here's the problem I have with that, Belz: First, I categorically deny that my definitions have changed, and challenge you to show how they've changed, quoting any of my posts you'd care to if necessary as a means to that end. Second, I've already asked you to back up your claim by doing that, and here again you respond in vacuous GB fashion, simply restating your claim, and in addition, restating your claim to have already provide these answers. Tiresome. Disappointing. This is typing practice, nothing more.

I am seeing a bit of dishonesty here, now that you mention it. I've had suspicions previously, though I wanted to allow for such possibilities as that I was mostly just seeing laziness, or perhaps a slight deficiency in short term memory. But this latest round of posts is making it harder for me to continue to extend the benefit of that doubt.

Why should I repeatedly post the EVIDENCE that proves that AA is a Religious Organization when you dismiss it without providing any EVIDENCE to back up your assertions?

You have NOTHING! You argue without any facts to back your arguments up. Tiresome. Disappointing. And Dishonest in the extreme.

GB
 
In other words, "I have nothing, cant produce anything but will spit BS at every opportunity".

You speak of honesty GB? Let's see you be honest now and produce what has been asked for. If you have produced it before, great, let's see it again. It can't be that hard for you to find your own post as you know your own work.

Put up or shut up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom