Well, I was under the impression that "dogma" and "doctrine" were pretty much equivalent, so under that assumption your definition seems circular.
A degree of circularity is not uncommon in dictionary definitions -- yet another of the inherent weaknesses in relying entirely on the dictionary. "Doctrine" can be defined simply as "a body of teachings". An authoritative aspect may be considered to be implied, but the implication is much stronger in the word "dogma". Agreed? AA does not oblige members to accept any specific version of "higher power", nor does it even define that. Therefore:
explicitly non-specific.
Just about as much as making a simple observation is doing science.
Science often begins with simple observation. Theory is the process of explaining
why a thing is observed to be a certain way. Practical lexicography is simple observation of the way words are used in the language. Theoretical lexicography is the process of explaining
why words are used in certain ways.
You'll forgive me if I decided to use my own definitions for those words, which I'll be happy to provide for you in 14-15 pages.
Thanks for illustrating my point. If there is no agreement, either implicit or explicit, as to the meanings of the words we're using, then what may make perfect sense to one person may look like complete gibberish to another.
They don't follow YOUR usage, but the general usage. That's why using the dictionary definition is usually an easier way to communicate.
The problem, of course, being that "THE dictionary definition" is usually a list of
a number of possible definitions which may differ from one another significantly. When I propose adherence (rigid, dogmatic adherence, if you will) to a set of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs as a definition for "religious", I'm claiming that this is what most people mean when they use the word (unless it is being used in a sense not relevant to the context of this discussion, such as "Mary practices her piano lessons religiously").
Then what did you mean by this:
Dymanic said:
Not guilty. My name is neither Merriam nor Webster, nor was I consulted in the compiling of the dictionary definitionS YOU provided above. I am merely pointing out that regardless of whether it is "useful" to your purpose here, those definitions easily subsume some things that are clearly NOT religious in the context of this discussion. Don't shoot the messenger.
Asked and answered:
"Taking all of those senses of the word as THE definition of "religious" results in a definition too broad to be useful here". Broad enough to include AA? I thought it too obvious to require stating, but in retrospect, I guess I could have made it clearer.
I don't really care what you can believe.
To be frank, I'm questioning your sincerity (it's become all the rage in this thread). It looks like a "dumb act" to me. If you're really having trouble following my reasoning, I'm happy to make the effort to clarify, but I keep getting the sneaking suspicion that this is just a game for you; that you actually understand perfectly well what I'm saying and are simply pretending not to, perhaps just for the sake of amusement.
And those were YOUR definitions...
No, Belz,
they weren't. I made it VERY clear that I was referring to "the dictionary
definitionS YOU provided above."
"Based on evidence only." ? What in the blue hell is that supposed to mean ?
Sans semantics.
So in other words, "religious" is a subset of "spiritual".
I think it's more complicated than that. "Spiritual" seems to be much more loosely defined
in common usage -- and much more subjective -- than "religious". The person who takes "spiritual" to refer to: "
of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual" (one of the
dictionary definitions above) may not expect to find that at the Baptist church on the corner, perhaps because he considers it unlikely that anything going on there will qualify as "
showing much refinement of thought and feeling" (another of the
dictionary definitions above). On the other hand, he might go there precisely because he
does expect to find that.
The only real difference being one of organization, really.
Another way of saying that the beliefs are
specific and
shared, and there exists an organized approach to
teaching those specific, shared beliefs.
But since AA is most definitely organized...
Not with respect to teaching specific, shared, supernatural beliefs, it isn't.
It was quite clear from GB's post. Please.
After he
doctored his posts, you mean. He now claims (in BIG red letters) to have "posted the entire set of definitions for Spiritual" -- yet notably absent in the definitions he posted are any definitions resembling those I obtained through the same process he used:
1.of the spirit or the soul as distinguished from the body or material matters
2.of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual
3.of or consisting of spirit; not corporeal
4.characterized by the ascendancy of the spirit; showing much refinement of thought and feeling
Are you buying
that, too? Do you agree that GB's definitions represent "the entire set of definitions for Spiritual"?