Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Explicitly non-specific. The opposite of dogma, defined as "a specific tenet or doctrine authoritatively laid down, and not to be disputed, doubted, or diverged from by the practioner or believers". Do you accept that definition of "dogma"?

Well, I was under the impression that "dogma" and "doctrine" were pretty much equivalent, so under that assumption your definition seems circular.

Posting a dictionary definition is "NOT defining something"?

Just about as much as making a simple observation is doing science.

When the words we're using have multiple senses (as so many do), I consider it not merely permissible to at least clarify which sense we're using, but obligatory.

Well in that growl this entire catapult is not very gleeful.

You'll forgive me if I decided to use my own definitions for those words, which I'll be happy to provide for you in 14-15 pages.

Dictionaries do not dictate usage, they follow it.

They don't follow YOUR usage, but the general usage. That's why using the dictionary definition is usually an easier way to communicate.

Try reading it again. I wasn't saying that.

Then what did you mean by this:

Not guilty. My name is neither Merriam nor Webster, nor was I consulted in the compiling of the dictionary definitionS YOU provided above. I am merely pointing out that regardless of whether it is "useful" to your purpose here, those definitions easily subsume some things that are clearly NOT religious in the context of this discussion. Don't shoot the messenger.

?

I can't believe you don't get this.

I don't really care what you can believe. In fact, since you can believe a door knob can be a higher power, I'd rather not know at all.

I am saying that a scientific or philosophical stance can be subsumed under some of the above definitions of "religious". Is that me saying that science is religion? No. It's me saying that taking all of those senses of the word as THE definition of "religious" results in a definition too broad to be useful here.

And those were YOUR definitions...

We all know what the word "bald" means. Based on evidence only, define the boundaries of "the set of all bald guys".

"Based on evidence only." ? What in the blue hell is that supposed to mean ?
 
GB's carefully cherry-picked definition of the word "spiritual" was obviously intended to support the contention that these are equivalent. Even this was not entirely successful; for one thing, though (as I have argued) "supernatural" beliefs are an indispensible aspect of religiousity, not everything "related to supernatural beings or phenomena" easily qualifies as religious. What about beliefs in such things as ghosts, or dowsing, or astrology?

That defect aside, we're talking about common usage here, so we need to include other ways in which this word is used, not merely the ones that GB thinks will help his case.

Some other definitions (or senses) available from online dictionaries include:

1.of the spirit or the soul as distinguished from the body or material matters
2.of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual
3.of or consisting of spirit; not corporeal
4.characterized by the ascendancy of the spirit; showing much refinement of thought and feeling

Now, we could go off on tangents having to do with the validity of the underlying assumptions reflected in some of these definitions (and in fact, we have done some of that in this thread), but we don't really need to do that in order to determine whether these definitions are valid representations of ways in which the word "spiritual" is used in the language. Is there good empirical evidence for the existence of a "soul", or a "self", or an "intellect", or a "personality", or a "consciousness", or a "spirit"? Doesn't matter. What we're interested in here is what people mean when they use those words. The meanings of the meanings? Possibly interesting, but not critical to answering the question at issue.

These people who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious", are not redefining these words, nor even attempting to define them more rigorously (as I have done) in the hope of learning more about the meanings of the meanings of the words. They are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as they understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as they understand THAT.

So in other words, "religious" is a subset of "spiritual".

The only real difference being one of organization, really.

But since AA is most definitely organized...
 
"Sure, AA is Spiritual. Religious Organizations like AA are also Spiritual by definition" constitutes a very clear statement that "the set of all Spiritual Entities includes some that are NOT Religious"? Can you explain HOW it does that?

Dymanic, seriously, AlBell is busy enough digging his little hole, don't imitate him.

It was quite clear from GB's post. Please.
 
It would help if you actually answered my question, mind you.

I have already posted in a number of forms how 'spiritual' does not have to include a belief in a supernatural being. This supernatural being seems to underpin every religious connotation from your side.

It is (in short) the difference that many (including me) make between the religious and spiritual and goes a long way to answering the OP.
 
Well, I was under the impression that "dogma" and "doctrine" were pretty much equivalent, so under that assumption your definition seems circular.
A degree of circularity is not uncommon in dictionary definitions -- yet another of the inherent weaknesses in relying entirely on the dictionary. "Doctrine" can be defined simply as "a body of teachings". An authoritative aspect may be considered to be implied, but the implication is much stronger in the word "dogma". Agreed? AA does not oblige members to accept any specific version of "higher power", nor does it even define that. Therefore: explicitly non-specific.

Just about as much as making a simple observation is doing science.
Science often begins with simple observation. Theory is the process of explaining why a thing is observed to be a certain way. Practical lexicography is simple observation of the way words are used in the language. Theoretical lexicography is the process of explaining why words are used in certain ways.

You'll forgive me if I decided to use my own definitions for those words, which I'll be happy to provide for you in 14-15 pages.
Thanks for illustrating my point. If there is no agreement, either implicit or explicit, as to the meanings of the words we're using, then what may make perfect sense to one person may look like complete gibberish to another.

They don't follow YOUR usage, but the general usage. That's why using the dictionary definition is usually an easier way to communicate.
The problem, of course, being that "THE dictionary definition" is usually a list of a number of possible definitions which may differ from one another significantly. When I propose adherence (rigid, dogmatic adherence, if you will) to a set of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs as a definition for "religious", I'm claiming that this is what most people mean when they use the word (unless it is being used in a sense not relevant to the context of this discussion, such as "Mary practices her piano lessons religiously").

Then what did you mean by this:
Dymanic said:
Not guilty. My name is neither Merriam nor Webster, nor was I consulted in the compiling of the dictionary definitionS YOU provided above. I am merely pointing out that regardless of whether it is "useful" to your purpose here, those definitions easily subsume some things that are clearly NOT religious in the context of this discussion. Don't shoot the messenger.
Asked and answered: "Taking all of those senses of the word as THE definition of "religious" results in a definition too broad to be useful here". Broad enough to include AA? I thought it too obvious to require stating, but in retrospect, I guess I could have made it clearer.

I don't really care what you can believe.
To be frank, I'm questioning your sincerity (it's become all the rage in this thread). It looks like a "dumb act" to me. If you're really having trouble following my reasoning, I'm happy to make the effort to clarify, but I keep getting the sneaking suspicion that this is just a game for you; that you actually understand perfectly well what I'm saying and are simply pretending not to, perhaps just for the sake of amusement.

And those were YOUR definitions...
No, Belz, they weren't. I made it VERY clear that I was referring to "the dictionary definitionS YOU provided above."

"Based on evidence only." ? What in the blue hell is that supposed to mean ?
Sans semantics.

So in other words, "religious" is a subset of "spiritual".
I think it's more complicated than that. "Spiritual" seems to be much more loosely defined in common usage -- and much more subjective -- than "religious". The person who takes "spiritual" to refer to: "of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual" (one of the dictionary definitions above) may not expect to find that at the Baptist church on the corner, perhaps because he considers it unlikely that anything going on there will qualify as "showing much refinement of thought and feeling" (another of the dictionary definitions above). On the other hand, he might go there precisely because he does expect to find that.

The only real difference being one of organization, really.
Another way of saying that the beliefs are specific and shared, and there exists an organized approach to teaching those specific, shared beliefs.

But since AA is most definitely organized...
Not with respect to teaching specific, shared, supernatural beliefs, it isn't.

It was quite clear from GB's post. Please.
After he doctored his posts, you mean. He now claims (in BIG red letters) to have "posted the entire set of definitions for Spiritual" -- yet notably absent in the definitions he posted are any definitions resembling those I obtained through the same process he used:

1.of the spirit or the soul as distinguished from the body or material matters
2.of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual
3.of or consisting of spirit; not corporeal
4.characterized by the ascendancy of the spirit; showing much refinement of thought and feeling

Are you buying that, too? Do you agree that GB's definitions represent "the entire set of definitions for Spiritual"?
 
I have already posted in a number of forms how 'spiritual' does not have to include a belief in a supernatural being. This supernatural being seems to underpin every religious connotation from your side.

It is (in short) the difference that many (including me) make between the religious and spiritual and goes a long way to answering the OP.

AA's Sacred Texts contain Numerous references to a Supernatural Being and Doctrines pertaining to the Supernatural Being.

GB
 
After he doctored his posts, you mean. He now claims (in BIG red letters) to have "posted the entire set of definitions for Spiritual" -- yet notably absent in the definitions he posted are any definitions resembling those I obtained through the same process he used:

1.of the spirit or the soul as distinguished from the body or material matters
2.of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual
3.of or consisting of spirit; not corporeal
4.characterized by the ascendancy of the spirit; showing much refinement of thought and feeling

Are you buying that, too? Do you agree that GB's definitions represent "the entire set of definitions for Spiritual"?

Lets compare:
1spir·i·tu·al adj
\ˈspir-i-chə-wəl, -i-chəl, -ich-wəl\
Definition of SPIRITUAL

1
: of, relating to, consisting of, or affecting the spirit : incorporeal <spiritual needs>
1.of the spirit or the soul as distinguished from the body or material matters(i.e. of, relating to, consisting of, or affecting the spirit: incorporeal)

2.of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual (i.e. of, relating to, consisting of, or affecting the spirit: incorporeal)

3.of or consisting of spirit; not corporeal (i.e. of, relating to, consisting of, or affecting the spirit: incorporeal)

4.characterized by the ascendancy of the spirit; showing much refinement of thought and feeling (i.e. relating to, consisting of, or affecting the spirit)
2
a : of or relating to sacred matters <spiritual songs>
b : ecclesiastical rather than lay or temporal <spiritual authority> <lords spiritual>
3
: concerned with religious values
4
: related or joined in spirit <our spiritual home> <his spiritual heir>
5
a : of or relating to supernatural beings or phenomena
b : of, relating to, or involving spiritualism : spiritualistic
4.characterized by the ascendancy of the spirit; showing much refinement of thought and feeling (i.e. of, relating to, or involving spiritualism)

Shocker: Dymanic's set of definitions are all covered by the dictionary set of definitions.

Yet Dymanic's set of definitions conveniently leaves out the set of definitions relating to:
1) Supernatural Beings or Phenomena
2) of or relating to sacred matters <spiritual songs>
3) ecclesiastical rather than lay or temporal <spiritual authority>
4) concerned with religious values


Shocker again: Dymanic proves to be the cherry-picker once again. He leaves out all the definitions that are related to religious phenomena.

GB

EDIT: Almost forgot this one: related or joined in spirit <our spiritual home> <his spiritual heir> (i.e. Spiritual Brotherhood)
 
Last edited:
Shocker: Dymanic's set of definitions are all covered by the dictionary set of definitions.

Yet Dymanic's set of definitions conveniently leaves out the set of definitions relating to:
1) Supernatural Beings or Phenomena
2) of or relating to sacred matters <spiritual songs>
3) ecclesiastical rather than lay or temporal <spiritual authority>
4) concerned with religious values

Shocker again: Dymanic proves to be the cherry-picker once again. He leaves out all the definitions that are related to religious phenomena.
Sorry, GB, but that just ain't gonna fly. You made a quite transparent attempt to spin the definition of "spiritual", and I pointed it out by adding the definitions you (quite obviously deliberately) omitted. You can try to turn the tables by invoking a child's response and trying to accuse me of doing what you did, but I seriously doubt if anyone here is going to buy it. The very point I've been making is that dictionary definitions of "spiritual" vary widely, and you won't find any post by me that even remotely suggests that I deny that some of those definitions include religious phenomena. On the other hand, I'll bet that a more thorough search would reveal other instances of you saying "Spiritual = Religious" (in one form or another) beyond the one I already referenced. You willing to take that bet?

At this point it is thoroughly and glaringly obvious who the disingenuous poster is here. I'd say your best bet is to fess up, lose the attitude, and resolve to learn from the experience. There is still a chance for us to discuss this in a forthright and civil matter.
 
I predict more font sizes, bolding, even more colors, and highlite is still an option.
 
Sorry, GB, but that just ain't gonna fly. You made a quite transparent attempt to spin the definition of "spiritual", and I pointed it out by adding the definitions you (quite obviously deliberately) omitted. You can try to turn the tables by invoking a child's response and trying to accuse me of doing what you did, but I seriously doubt if anyone here is going to buy it. The very point I've been making is that dictionary definitions of "spiritual" vary widely, and you won't find any post by me that even remotely suggests that I deny that some of those definitions include religious phenomena. On the other hand, I'll bet that a more thorough search would reveal other instances of you saying "Spiritual = Religious" (in one form or another) beyond the one I already referenced. You willing to take that bet?

At this point it is thoroughly and glaringly obvious who the disingenuous poster is here. I'd say your best bet is to fess up, lose the attitude, and resolve to learn from the experience. There is still a chance for us to discuss this in a forthright and civil matter.

Your arguments are Childishly Petulant and Moronic. You can't admit it when you're just wrong.

I have previously stated in posts that the distinctions between Spiritual and Religious are too fuzzy to clearly distinguish between them.

Further investigation has demonstrated that I was wrong:

One CAN make certain Distinctions between Religious and Spiritual, insofar as Religious is a subset of Spiritual.
Thus the religious language and doctrines of AA can ALSO be construed as Spiritual, but it DOES NOT NEGATE THE FACT that AA is a Religious Organization.

This is what an honest debater does, they admit it when they are wrong.
So,YES, it is very clear who is doing the spinning, obfuscation, lying, distorting, cherry-picking etc. Again, it sure ain't me.

GB

EDIT: You have consistently denied that AA is Religious, therefore you are denying that in the Special Case of AA Spiritual is not a "definition that includes Religious Phenomena." This is called Special Pleading.
 
Last edited:
I have previously stated in posts that the distinctions between Spiritual and Religious are too fuzzy to clearly distinguish between them.

Further investigation has demonstrated that I was wrong:

One CAN make certain Distinctions between Religious and Spiritual, insofar as Religious is a subset of Spiritual.
The two surely are indistinguishable under some definitions of those words. Under others, the distinction is clearer. I agree that some definitions of "spiritual" subsume "religious" (or vice versa). But I believe I can make a good case that the two are intersecting sets.

If you Google "of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual" (including the quotes), you will immediately see where I obtained the list of definitions that includes that one. Now, I'll grant you this: for every person who would accept that as an adequate definition of "spiritual", there are probably a dozen who would regard it as the very antithesis of "spiritual", so we're back to the problem with different people defining these terms in different ways. But I would conjecture that a vanishingly small percentage of people ("religious" or otherwise) would regard the activities of the Westboro Baptist Church as "spiritual" in nature, yet it's hard to deny that they are inspired by (justified by is probably a better choice of words) a system of "religious" beliefs -- in other words, religious, but not spiritual. There are other possible examples with which we are all familiar: the Spanish Inquisition, the Crusades, etc.

You have consistently denied that AA is Religious,
I think I have been pretty consistent in framing my argument in terms like this:

With allowances for local variation, my observation is that the AA average is "spiritual but not religious", and I would have to assume that while individual members define "spiritual" in a myriad of different ways, they're all using roughly the same definition of "religious" -- a definition which describes a system of practices centered on beliefs with the three essential qualities I have listed: specific; shared; supernatural.

I would also allow that there may be some significant number of AA members who, despite invoking the SBNR meme to describe their own beliefs, would turn out on close examination to be holding beliefs that actually do meet those requirements. Some posters here would be quick to conclude that those AA members would simply be lying about their beliefs, presumably motivated by a desire to make AA seem more acceptable to agnostics and whatnot, and while I cannot dismiss that possibility outright, I still don't see what those individual members would see themselves having to gain from such a deception.

It might also be that some of them are just mistaken, having simply never given much thought to exactly how to distinguish between the "spiritual" and the "religious" (which, to be fair, is somewhat more difficult that it might appear on a first glance). Yet another possibility is that they might be attempting to describe a difference they perceive in the role their religious beliefs play in their lives by comparison with others who share the beliefs but not the experience of recovery.


GB said:
therefore you are denying that in the Special Case of AA Spiritual is not a "definition that includes Religious Phenomena."
No, I'm not. I'm not claiming that "AA" uses any special definitions for either "spiritual" or "religious", and I'm not claiming that AA explicitly excludes religious beliefs. I'm simply pointing out that AA does not teach religious beliefs (as in: specific, shared, supernatural).
 
No, I'm not. I'm not claiming that "AA" uses any special definitions for either "spiritual" or "religious", and I'm not claiming that AA explicitly excludes religious beliefs. I'm simply pointing out that AA does not teach religious beliefs (as in: specific, shared, supernatural).

Based on the Sacred Texts of AA, your statement is incorrect.


GB
 
I have already posted in a number of forms how 'spiritual' does not have to include a belief in a supernatural being.

Considering that "spiritual" means in relation to the SPIRIT, which is a supernatural entity, I find it hard to believe that you could define it to exclude the supernatural.
 
A degree of circularity is not uncommon in dictionary definitions -- yet another of the inherent weaknesses in relying entirely on the dictionary.

Once more, you twist everything in order to avoid having to admit to being wrong.

AA does not oblige members to accept any specific version of "higher power", nor does it even define that. Therefore: explicitly non-specific.

I'm willing to conced this: explicitely non-specific religious.

Thanks for illustrating my point.

By copying some of your annoying behaviours, I'm illustrating your point ?

If there is no agreement, either implicit or explicit, as to the meanings of the words we're using, then what may make perfect sense to one person may look like complete gibberish to another.

And yet the only reason why there is no agreement is because one side of the debate has a clear apologetic agenda.

The problem, of course, being that "THE dictionary definition" is usually a list of a number of possible definitions which may differ from one another significantly.

Which is why we can make up new definitions with wild abandon, right ?

When I propose adherence (rigid, dogmatic adherence, if you will) to a set of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs as a definition for "religious", I'm claiming that this is what most people mean when they use the word

And I submit you will define "shared" and "specific" so that AA cannot be religious.

Asked and answered: "Taking all of those senses of the word as THE definition of "religious" results in a definition too broad to be useful here". Broad enough to include AA? I thought it too obvious to require stating, but in retrospect, I guess I could have made it clearer.

So now, you can say something is clearly NOT religious in a context, then claim it's broad enough to include that something... you're all over the place.

To be frank, I'm questioning your sincerity

Yes, and I'm questioning yours. Par for the course, I suppose.

Sans semantics.

No, you've shown this to be impossible.
 
No, I'm not. I'm not claiming that "AA" uses any special definitions for either "spiritual" or "religious", and I'm not claiming that AA explicitly excludes religious beliefs. I'm simply pointing out that AA does not teach religious beliefs (as in: specific, shared, supernatural).

Since when is teaching required in order to be religious ?
 
Considering that "spiritual" means in relation to the SPIRIT, which is a supernatural entity, I find it hard to believe that you could define it to exclude the supernatural.

I did not exclude the supernatural, that is an assumption you have just made.

There are more meanings for spiritual than just the one dimensional definition you seem to like to use. And at the risk of repeating myself :rolleyes: it is that difference that many at AA (and elsewhere - eg. psychology) use and it is clearly where you are having problems.

What you find hard to believe and what is factual are two different things altogether, and is your problem alone.

Might I suggest some actual research as a cure for your black and white approach/view?
 
Since when is teaching required in order to be religious ?

I think you will find that very early in the thread, some of 'your team' were stating exactly that: That AA taught religion via the big book, meetings etc. Moreover - if memory serves - 'your' much loved orange papers made the comparison between priests and older members as well as religious teachings and the AA meeting.

So in answer to your question, it was in fact 'your side' that initiated this comparison and part of the discussion.

Do you still have those movable goal posts?
 
Once more, you twist everything in order to avoid having to admit to being wrong.
Wait. You point out a perceived circularity in a dictionary definition, I point out that this is a common weakness in dictionary definitions and then go on to resolve the particular case (at least partially) by noting a subtle but important difference between the words "doctrine" and "dogma", and then I asked whether you agreed. I suppose that "you twist everything" is one possible way of answering that question, but it might have been nice if you had made at least some attempt to explain why you do not agree.

I'm willing to conced this: explicitely non-specific religious.
Much earlier, I proposed the term: "meta-religious", and expressed a willingness to acknowledge that some passages of AA literature may be taken as pointers to religious belief (i.e., they may be loosely interpreted as suggesting that the alcoholic "get religion"). I actually regard this as generous, and would insist on the inclusion of an escape clause noting that this interpretation is not forced. I've repeated the offer of this stipulated agreement at least once. Do we finally have terms?

By copying some of your annoying behaviours, I'm illustrating your point ?
No, you're illustrating the point that all of us are prone to the error of assuming that others are using the same definitions of terms we are using, and that when this happens, the results are a failure to understand one another. I thought you illustrated it quite nicely, as a matter of fact.

Which is why we can make up new definitions with wild abandon, right ?
Assuming (because I see no other choice) that you are referring to my definition of "religious" as "adherence to a set of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs", I will demur that I'm not actually making up a definition there, but merely clarifying what people mean when they use the word "religious" in the sense that is relevant here. If you'd like to be the first poster in this thread to make a serious effort toward challenging that definition, or if you'd like to present an argument against my claim that this IS what people mean when they use that word, then by all means, please proceed.

And I submit you will define "shared" and "specific" so that AA cannot be religious.
This is a nice example of what I do NOT consider to be a serious effort toward challenging the definition.

So now, you can say something is clearly NOT religious in a context, then claim it's broad enough to include that something... you're all over the place.
I'm going to give the benefit of the doubt here and continue to assume that you really are not able to work your way through this simple logic. If you define a thing too loosely, the problem you encounter is that you unavoidably include things that do not properly belong. Define it too strictly and you unavoidably exclude things that do properly belong. Is the guy with three little hairs on his head a bona fide member of the set of all bald guys? The guy with a patch of hair on top thin enough that some scalp shines through?

Yes, and I'm questioning yours. Par for the course, I suppose.
Hardly surprising, considering that the thread BEGAN with a tacit assumption which takes the form of an accusation. There is, after all, a portion of the OP's question which was not openly stated, but is there nonetheless. In its complete form, the question reads: "Why do people falsely claim that AA is not religious when it is so blatantly obvious that it is?" It might save some time if we could all agree that we are taking it as a given that the "others" are arguing disingenuously, and focus instead on the actual arguments -- but maybe that's not possible here, as establishing motive appears to be central to the whole discussion.

Since when is teaching required in order to be religious ?
Under the definition I have proposed, it is indispensible to the shared aspect.
 
I did not exclude the supernatural, that is an assumption you have just made.

I have trouble believing thay you're this dense. "Spiritual" implies supernatural; and the only distinction I see between "spiritualism" and "religion" is one of organization, not of nature.

And AA is definitely an organisation. One with litterature and procedures (the steps) which promote not only religion, but a thinly-veiled, specific one. I call that religious.

The rest of this thread is semantics and individual testimonies.
 
I think you will find that very early in the thread, some of 'your team' were stating exactly that: That AA taught religion via the big book, meetings etc.

I disagree with them, then.

Moreover - if memory serves - 'your' much loved orange papers made the comparison between priests and older members as well as religious teachings and the AA meeting.

I certainly never mentioned those papers.

So in answer to your question, it was in fact 'your side' that initiated this comparison and part of the discussion.

I don't have a side. That's the problem with you in this thread: you have a side to defend. I'm just going with the evidence at hand.

Do you still have those movable goal posts?

No, I gave them back to you a while ago.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom