Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
And is crap.

As usual I am completely defenseless against by your well thought out and insightful arguments. :rolleyes:

How is "spiritual" and "religious" so different ?

And again, this is precisely my point. There is a substantial difference between the two. Unfortunately you don't seem able to distinguish said difference hence my recent request that the definitions to religious and spiritual be looked at.
 
"God as you understand Him" is not specific ?
Explicitly non-specific. The opposite of dogma, defined as "a specific tenet or doctrine authoritatively laid down, and not to be disputed, doubted, or diverged from by the practioner or believers". Do you accept that definition of "dogma"?

NOT defining something is really defining it ?
Posting a dictionary definition is "NOT defining something"?

First, do you really think that you can make up definitions for words ?
When the words we're using have multiple senses (as so many do), I consider it not merely permissible to at least clarify which sense we're using, but obligatory. Practical lexicography is the art or craft of compiling, writing and editing dictionaries. It does not involve "making up" definitions for words, but merely finding those definitions which best represent the way words are used in the language. Dictionaries do not dictate usage, they follow it. Any assumptions contained in that usage, be they dualistic, idealistic, anthropomorphic, teleological, theological, astrological, or what-have-you, it is not the business of the practical lexicographer to unpack and examine them. That work is left to philosophers -- and since Wittgenstein, (analytic) philosophers are no longer allowed to "make stuff up"; facts are provided by science, and philosophers help to interpret them (with considerable emphasis on the language used in describing the findings).

Second, how is AA NOT religious under those definitions ?
Try reading it again. I wasn't saying that.

Your reply about science being a religion under the same definitions seemed to be a implicit agreement that it was; otherwise why use it ?
I can't believe you don't get this. I am saying that a scientific or philosophical stance can be subsumed under some of the above definitions of "religious". Is that me saying that science is religion? No. It's me saying that taking all of those senses of the word as THE definition of "religious" results in a definition too broad to be useful here.

I had a tentative conclusion and was willing to be proven wrong. Since you have no evidence, however, and rely on semantics only, you're not likely to change my mind.
Identifying points of agreement is about the best we're likely to do here. If you think this whole thing is not an exercise in sematics (the study of meaning), then let's see how an "evidence only" approach works when applied to something simpler. We all know what the word "bald" means. Based on evidence only, define the boundaries of "the set of all bald guys".
 
Great. It's been my experience that it's been the opposite; I think there was one meeting which didn't recite the Lord's Prayer at the meetings' close. [/quote0

Precisely my point. It proves that at local level, the locals make their own rules for their own meeting. In answer to that question we need to ask where Dynamic got that South African members' quote. I did make a mistake there btw - I thought I read/assumed it was from the grapevine.

That said, I have read the experience, strength and hope of members who have found sobriety without a traditional god in the grapevine (and elsewhere). But even when that is provided, what would it prove to you?

So do Baptists but they're still a religion.
 
3. Our membership ought to include all who suffer from alcoholism. Hence we may refuse none who wish to recover. Nor ought AA membership ever depend upon money or conformity. Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group, provided that, as a group, they have no other affiliation.

4. With respect to its own affairs, each AA group should be responsible to no other authority than its own conscience. But when its plans concern the welfare of neighbouring groups also, those groups ought to be consulted. And no group, regional committee, or individual should ever take any action that might greatly affect AA as a whole without conferring with the trustees of the General Service Board. On such issues our common welfare is paramount.

I'm a little confused about how these ideas hang together. If each AA group is free to do its own thing (subject only(?) to the "no other affiliation" rule), then how could the actions of any one group "greatly affect AA as a whole"? I mean, other than some rather absurd hypotheticals (the AA group in Springfield decides to picket the meetings of the Shelbyville AA group).

I suppose tradition three also implies that AA groups must also "refuse none who wish to recover" and not require "money or conformity." And some of the other traditions seem to state requirements as well -- #10 seems rather absolute on "outside controversial issues"). But then, if those rules are absolute, then what is the point in "consulting" or "conferring" with other groups or the trustees?

I'm not really trying to make any particular point in this post; I'm just not seeing how this all hangs together. What are the kinds of things that an individual group has had to consult on?
 
Last edited:
How is "spiritual" and "religious" so different ?
GB's carefully cherry-picked definition of the word "spiritual" was obviously intended to support the contention that these are equivalent. Even this was not entirely successful; for one thing, though (as I have argued) "supernatural" beliefs are an indispensible aspect of religiousity, not everything "related to supernatural beings or phenomena" easily qualifies as religious. What about beliefs in such things as ghosts, or dowsing, or astrology?

That defect aside, we're talking about common usage here, so we need to include other ways in which this word is used, not merely the ones that GB thinks will help his case.

Some other definitions (or senses) available from online dictionaries include:

1.of the spirit or the soul as distinguished from the body or material matters
2.of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual
3.of or consisting of spirit; not corporeal
4.characterized by the ascendancy of the spirit; showing much refinement of thought and feeling

Now, we could go off on tangents having to do with the validity of the underlying assumptions reflected in some of these definitions (and in fact, we have done some of that in this thread), but we don't really need to do that in order to determine whether these definitions are valid representations of ways in which the word "spiritual" is used in the language. Is there good empirical evidence for the existence of a "soul", or a "self", or an "intellect", or a "personality", or a "consciousness", or a "spirit"? Doesn't matter. What we're interested in here is what people mean when they use those words. The meanings of the meanings? Possibly interesting, but not critical to answering the question at issue.

These people who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious", are not redefining these words, nor even attempting to define them more rigorously (as I have done) in the hope of learning more about the meanings of the meanings of the words. They are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as they understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as they understand THAT.
 
GB's carefully cherry-picked definition of the word "spiritual" was obviously intended to support the contention that these are equivalent. Even this was not entirely successful; for one thing, though (as I have argued) "supernatural" beliefs are an indispensible aspect of religiousity, not everything "related to supernatural beings or phenomena" easily qualifies as religious. What about beliefs in such things as ghosts, or dowsing, or astrology?

That defect aside, we're talking about common usage here, so we need to include other ways in which this word is used, not merely the ones that GB thinks will help his case.

Some other definitions (or senses) available from online dictionaries include:

1.of the spirit or the soul as distinguished from the body or material matters
2.of, from, or concerned with the intellect; intellectual
3.of or consisting of spirit; not corporeal
4.characterized by the ascendancy of the spirit; showing much refinement of thought and feeling

Now, we could go off on tangents having to do with the validity of the underlying assumptions reflected in some of these definitions (and in fact, we have done some of that in this thread), but we don't really need to do that in order to determine whether these definitions are valid representations of ways in which the word "spiritual" is used in the language. Is there good empirical evidence for the existence of a "soul", or a "self", or an "intellect", or a "personality", or a "consciousness", or a "spirit"? Doesn't matter. What we're interested in here is what people mean when they use those words. The meanings of the meanings? Possibly interesting, but not critical to answering the question at issue.

These people who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious", are not redefining these words, nor even attempting to define them more rigorously (as I have done) in the hope of learning more about the meanings of the meanings of the words. They are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as they understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as they understand THAT.

I pointed out that the set of all Religious Entities are Spiritual by definition, but that the set of all Spiritual Entities includes some that are NOT Religious (and no, I am not using entities in the "Spiritual" sense, i.e. ghosts, gods, fairies, angels, poltergeists, etc ;) ). This can in no way be described as "cherry-picking."

So your argument is either another lie, or evidence of your inability to grasp my very clear statement. However, as I don't believe you are unintelligent, I'm going to go conclude your argument is just another lie.

GB
 
I pointed out that the set of all Religious Entities are Spiritual by definition, but that the set of all Spiritual Entities includes some that are NOT Religious
And where was it again that you pointed that out? Oh, wait, I know the answer:

"Answered AD INFINITUM WITH STATEMENTS AND THE EVIDENCE TO BACK THEM UP!"
"Nearly every post that is a response to yours has an example."
"And no, I'm not going to repost all my posts to prove my point"
"Etc, etc".

-- same response you make, in one form or another, every time I ask you to show where it was that you said something you claim to have said and that I can't recall you having said.

Are you willing to give any hints? Were those your exact words? How many pages back would I have to go to find you saying that? I just did a manual search back about 10 pages -- nothing. Using Google, I did find some relevant quotes, though.

I have you saying on page 17 that "In the case of AA, Spiritual does = Religious." I guess that could be taken to imply that in other cases it does not, but it seems to fall a bit short of the "very clear statement" you're claiming to have made.. And I have qayak saying on page 48 that "There are times that spitiual definitely does not mean religious." Could you have confused yourself with him? It would be an easy enough mistake to make. Oh, I did find one statement by you which may be of particular interest here:

"What I DO hate (with a passion) is dishonest debate tactics."
 
And where was it again that you pointed that out? Oh, wait, I know the answer:

"Answered AD INFINITUM WITH STATEMENTS AND THE EVIDENCE TO BACK THEM UP!"
"Nearly every post that is a response to yours has an example."
"And no, I'm not going to repost all my posts to prove my point"
"Etc, etc".

-- same response you make, in one form or another, every time I ask you to show where it was that you said something you claim to have said and that I can't recall you having said.

Are you willing to give any hints? Were those your exact words? How many pages back would I have to go to find you saying that? I just did a manual search back about 10 pages -- nothing. Using Google, I did find some relevant quotes, though.

I have you saying on page 17 that "In the case of AA, Spiritual does = Religious." I guess that could be taken to imply that in other cases it does not, but it seems to fall a bit short of the "very clear statement" you're claiming to have made.. And I have qayak saying on page 48 that "There are times that spitiual definitely does not mean religious." Could you have confused yourself with him? It would be an easy enough mistake to make. Oh, I did find one statement by you which may be of particular interest here:

"What I DO hate (with a passion) is dishonest debate tactics."

Sure, AA is Spiritual. Religious Organizations like AA are also Spiritual by definition.

But when your Sacred Texts refer constantly to a Deity and the attendant Religious Doctrines, claiming that they are "Spiritual but not Religious" is a lie.

GB

Looks pretty clear to me.

GB
 
Looks pretty clear to me.
"Sure, AA is Spiritual. Religious Organizations like AA are also Spiritual by definition" constitutes a very clear statement that "the set of all Spiritual Entities includes some that are NOT Religious"? Can you explain HOW it does that?
 
"Sure, AA is Spiritual. Religious Organizations like AA are also Spiritual by definition" constitutes a very clear statement that "the set of all Spiritual Entities includes some that are NOT Religious"? Can you explain HOW it does that?

Sure, read the whole quote in context:

1spir·i·tu·al adj
\ˈspir-i-chə-wəl, -i-chəl, -ich-wəl\
Definition of SPIRITUAL

1
: of, relating to, consisting of, or affecting the spirit : incorporeal <spiritual needs>
2
a : of or relating to sacred matters <spiritual songs>
b : ecclesiastical rather than lay or temporal <spiritual authority> <lords spiritual>
3
: concerned with religious values
4
: related or joined in spirit <our spiritual home> <his spiritual heir>
5
a : of or relating to supernatural beings or phenomena
b : of, relating to, or involving spiritualism : spiritualistic

(set of all Spiritual Entities includes some that are NOT religious)

Sure, AA is Spiritual. Religious Organizations like AA are also Spiritual by definition.

But when your Sacred Texts refer constantly to a Deity and the attendant Religious Doctrines, claiming that they are "Spiritual but not Religious" is a lie. (set of all Religious Entities are Spiritual)

GB

Clear enough now? :p

That's why I posted the entire set of definitions for Spiritual.

Looks like someone's cherry-picking, but it sure ain't me.

GB
 
Last edited:
From wiki

If spirituality is understood as the search for or the development of inner peace or the foundations of happiness, then spiritual practice of some kind is essential for personal well being.

This activity may or may not include belief in supernatural beings.

If one has such a belief and feels that relationship to such beings is the foundation of happiness then spiritual practice will be pursued on that basis: if one has no such belief spiritual practice is still essential for the management and understanding of thoughts and emotions which otherwise prevent happiness. Many techniques and practices developed and explored in religious contexts, such as meditation, are immensely valuable in themselves as skills for managing aspects of the inner life.



My bold.
 
From wiki

If spirituality is understood as the search for or the development of inner peace or the foundations of happiness, then spiritual practice of some kind is essential for personal well being.

This activity may or may not include belief in supernatural beings.

If one has such a belief and feels that relationship to such beings is the foundation of happiness then spiritual practice will be pursued on that basis: if one has no such belief spiritual practice is still essential for the management and understanding of thoughts and emotions which otherwise prevent happiness. Many techniques and practices developed and explored in religious contexts, such as meditation, are immensely valuable in themselves as skills for managing aspects of the inner life.



My bold.

That sounds lovely Alfie. Now does it say anything about Sacred Texts which refer to God? ;)

EDIT: Glad you agree that Spiritual AA is also Religious. :)

GB
 
Last edited:
Clear enough now?
No, it isn't clear enough.

So my argument was either another LIE, or evidence of my inability to grasp your very clear statement -- the one you now claim resides in some context. Context which, at best, might just barely have been inferred from what you posted. If you think modifying your "very clear" statement to show this context by using the quote feature to put up some clumsily appended versions of you own prior posts makes that problem go away, then I have some bad news. It says a very great deal about the depth of your passion when it comes to dishonest debate tactics. That you can imagine for even a moment that it solves the problem also says quite a bit about your ability to practice anything remotely resembling logic. But it does nothing to show that your embracing the difference between "spiritual" and "religious" is anything but a hasty effort to abandon a failed argument. Could you possibly do it with less grace and skill? I'll bet you could. Why not crack out the BIG red letters and show us what you've really got?
 
No, it isn't clear enough.

So my argument was either another LIE, or evidence of my inability to grasp your very clear statement -- the one you now claim resides in some context. Context which, at best, might just barely have been inferred from what you posted. If you think modifying your "very clear" statement to show this context by using the quote feature to put up some clumsily appended versions of you own prior posts makes that problem go away, then I have some bad news. It says a very great deal about the depth of your passion when it comes to dishonest debate tactics. That you can imagine for even a moment that it solves the problem also says quite a bit about your ability to practice anything remotely resembling logic. But it does nothing to show that your embracing the difference between "spiritual" and "religious" is anything but a hasty effort to abandon a failed argument. Could you possibly do it with less grace and skill? I'll bet you could. Why not crack out the BIG red letters and show us what you've really got?

Sure, read the whole quote in context:
1spir·i·tu·al adj
\ˈspir-i-chə-wəl, -i-chəl, -ich-wəl\
Definition of SPIRITUAL

1
: of, relating to, consisting of, or affecting the spirit : incorporeal <spiritual needs>
2
a : of or relating to sacred matters <spiritual songs>
b : ecclesiastical rather than lay or temporal <spiritual authority> <lords spiritual>
3
: concerned with religious values
4
: related or joined in spirit <our spiritual home> <his spiritual heir>
5
a : of or relating to supernatural beings or phenomena
b : of, relating to, or involving spiritualism : spiritualistic

(set of all Spiritual Entities includes some that are NOT religious)
Sure, AA is Spiritual. Religious Organizations like AA are also Spiritual by definition.

But when your Sacred Texts refer constantly to a Deity and the attendant Religious Doctrines, claiming that they are "Spiritual but not Religious" is a lie. (set of all Religious Entities are Spiritual)

Clear enough now? :p

That's why I posted the entire set of definitions for Spiritual.

Looks like someone's cherry-picking, but it sure ain't me.

GB

Your arguments are Moronic!

GB

EDIT: Only an Idiot wouldn't be able to follow my argument. YOU are NOT AN IDIOT.
 
Last edited:
CLARIFICATION FOR THE SIMPLE-MINDED:

Religion/Religious are a SUBSET of Spiritual.

Religion/Religious pertains to a belief in a Deity or Deities and the attendant Doctrines.

AA's texts explicitly promote a Deity and its attendant Doctrines.

Therefore AA is Religious, and being religious it is part of a SUBSET of Spiritual.

Therefore claims that AA is "Spiritual but not Religious" is complete BS

GB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom