Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Because in AA, the "belief" aspect is neither shared nor specific

Well, if it's not specific it's because of people who constantly redefine terms into uselessness.

"Out here in South Africa,"

Hooray, South-African AA is more tolerant than AA in other places. Good for them, actually.

It's already been noted that as long as we AGREE to use the same definition, we can communicate effectively. Now what we got here is, failure to communicate -- but it's worse than that. We haven't even reached a consensus on whether this is a simple exercise in the proper use of english words, or a philosophical investigation into the underlying meanings of the words we use. If it is the former, then your objection may be sustained. But if it is the latter, my attempt at defining "religious" in a more exacting way may be allowed.

Tell you what: why don't we simply NOT try to define "religious", go with the definitions from the dictionary, and explain why people insist that AA is not religious ?

The problem (for you) is that a great many other things are as well. "Acknowledge" as the "ultimate reality" the nature and origin of the universe as described by the Big Bang Theory and Einsteinian relativity, and you've just become "religious" under at least one of the above definitions.

Amazing. You are so desperate to "win" this thread that you have now crossed into complete nonsense territory.

There IS NO ultimate reality in science. No supernatural entities, no paranormal events. You are AGAIN broadening all definitions to ensure that, if AA is religious, everything else is. Your entire strategy in this thread has been nothing but muddle the issue. When it's not redefining terms into uselessness, it's attempts at equivocation like the one above.
 
Well, if it's not specific it's because of people who constantly redefine terms into uselessness.
I disagree. In AA, the belief aspect is not merely non-specific, but explicity so.

Hooray, South-African AA is more tolerant than AA in other places. Good for them, actually.
It has been noted many, many times in this thread that AA is very much subject to local variation. Hence, making sweeping statements regarding AA as a whole is a dubious undertaking at best.

Tell you what: why don't we simply NOT try to define "religious", go with the definitions from the dictionary, and explain why people insist that AA is not religious ?
In the first place, because "going with the definitions from the dictionary" IS an attempt at defining "religious"; just a rather feeble one -- and in the second place, because it does not reflect a sincere interest in attempting to actually answer the question at hand.

There IS NO ultimate reality in science.
Arguably true -- but that isn't a barrier to some poorly informed person adopting the stance that there is -- leaving open the question of whether such a person deserves to be called "religious" even though his adopting that stance meets one of the above definitions of that word.

You are AGAIN broadening all definitions to ensure that, if AA is religious, everything else is.
Not guilty. My name is neither Merriam nor Webster, nor was I consulted in the compiling of the dictionary definitionS YOU provided above. I am merely pointing out that regardless of whether it is "useful" to your purpose here, those definitions easily subsume some things that are clearly NOT religious in the context of this discussion. Don't shoot the messenger.

Your entire strategy in this thread has been nothing but muddle the issue.
Again, not guilty. You started out muddled, and have done a pretty good job of staying that way despite some rather energetic attempts to provide clarification -- suggesting that you never really were very interested in answers to the OP's question, having already made your mind up before the thread was ever started. I see nothing to gain by either confusing you or convincing you; carry your biases and misconceptions to the grave if you want; it's no skin off my ass.
 
The problem (for you) is that a great many other things are as well. "Acknowledge" as the "ultimate reality" the nature and origin of the universe as described by the Big Bang Theory and Einsteinian relativity, and you've just become "religious" under at least one of the above definitions.

I just gotta love the way you use the Creationist's Straw Man arguments to blur the distinction between science and religion. Why do you keep trying to argue that AA is not religious by using Religious Apologist tactics?

GB
 
The only place to find God.........
god-1.jpg
 

Actually, my point should have been quite clear even to the dimmest of minds. AAers say it is a spritual program, not religious. That is the short answer to the OP.
Investigating both words would be the honest approach to the discussion.

Hooray, South-African AA is more tolerant than AA in other places. Good for them, actually.

Again, I think you miss the point. It was stated earlier that there are no articles anywhere (Grapevine) from people who haven't found god in their recovery. Obviously there are.
 
Actually, my point should have been quite clear even to the dimmest of minds. AAers say it is a spritual program, not religious. That is the short answer to the OP.
Investigating both words would be the honest approach to the discussion.

1spir·i·tu·al adj
\ˈspir-i-chə-wəl, -i-chəl, -ich-wəl\
Definition of SPIRITUAL

1
: of, relating to, consisting of, or affecting the spirit : incorporeal <spiritual needs>
2
a : of or relating to sacred matters <spiritual songs>
b : ecclesiastical rather than lay or temporal <spiritual authority> <lords spiritual>
3
: concerned with religious values
4
: related or joined in spirit <our spiritual home> <his spiritual heir>
5
a : of or relating to supernatural beings or phenomena
b : of, relating to, or involving spiritualism : spiritualistic

Sure, AA is Spiritual. Religious Organizations like AA are also Spiritual by definition.

But when your Sacred Texts refer constantly to a Deity and the attendant Religious Doctrines, claiming that they are "Spiritual but not Religious" is a lie.

GB
 
Last edited:
Because in AA, the "belief" aspect is neither shared nor specific -- nor even necessarily supernatural. One member writes:

"Out here in South Africa, many of our city meetings are multi-faith -- a Xhosa member the other night invoked the help of a family ancestor. Younger members are Buddhist or Sufi, some are animist, and many are secular and consider themselves to be in recovery from the abuses of missionary Christianity. Others are Christian, not a majority and generally they seem far more tolerant and accepting than is the case elsewhere. I am not anti-religious, I come from a multifaith perspective and so long as no particular group tries to impose their Higher Power on everyone else, there is no problem. We don't end meetings with the Lord's Prayer because others might want to say prayers to their particular deities and there isn't time. Furthermore, the saying aloud of specific prayers would exclude the agnostics and atheists in the meetings and that is unacceptable."

So your "...nor even necessarily supernatural" example is one filled with... the supernatural?

Oh, but they don't close the meeting with the Lord's Prayer so obviously, they're not religious. And the only reason this fellow's group does not close with the Lord's Prayer? Because there's not enough time to recite everyone else's prayers too, not because there's no need for them in the first place.

To be fair, he does go on to say that saying prayers (multiple ones) would be exclusive of those with a non-theistic bent. I sure wish the United States would be so thoughtful as that in the meetings I've attended.

Or maybe the AA World Organization could change their official texts to be more inclusive!

What a novel concept! But, nah.

It's also interesting to me to note that while AA and 12step meetings have been declared by some courts to be religious enough to run afoul of the 1st Amendment, that Rational Recovery, SOS, and LifeRing (for example) have never had these same problems, yet they all seem to claim that they're not religious.

How would one suggest I go about testing the various claims made by these organizations?
 
Last edited:
Again, I think you miss the point. It was stated earlier that there are no articles anywhere (Grapevine) from people who haven't found god in their recovery. Obviously there are.

Tell me page number and issue number of an AA Grapevine article written by an atheist that you've read. Point out to me a story in the back of the big book, any edition, which does the same.

I never made the claim that there are no stories of sober atheists in AA. I made the claim that the AA World Organization has never once published a story of a sober atheist in any official publication.

My point being that in seventy years, the leaders of the AA organization are perfectly happy with it being a religious organization trying to hide under the vague concept of Higher Powers and cafeteria-style "take whatever you want" so-called spirituality.
 
Sure, AA is Spiritual. Religious Organizations like AA are also Spiritual by definition.

But when your Sacred Texts refer constantly to a Deity and the attendant Religious Doctrines, claiming that they are "Spiritual but not Religious" is a lie.

The argument Alfie is hiding behind is pretty silly. It's like a national security agency deciding the threat level is yellow because the threat fits the definition of yellow but failing to recognize (refusing in Alfie's case) that the threat also fits the definition of a red alert.
 
Oh, but they don't close the meeting with the Lord's Prayer so obviously, they're not religious. And the only reason this fellow's group does not close with the Lord's Prayer? Because there's not enough time to recite everyone else's prayers too, not because there's no need for them in the first place.

I have never ever been at a meeting that recites the lords prayer. I asssume that goes for the entirety of Australia, I have been to meetings in every single state.

I never made the claim that there are no stories of sober atheists in AA. I made the claim that the AA World Organization has never once published a story of a sober atheist in any official publication.

So the grapevine isn't an official AA publication?
 
I have never ever been at a meeting that recites the lords prayer. I asssume that goes for the entirety of Australia, I have been to meetings in every single state.

Great. It's been my experience that it's been the opposite; I think there was one meeting which didn't recite the Lord's Prayer at the meetings' close.



So the grapevine isn't an official AA publication?



Yes, it is. Do you have any evidence to show that my contention is mistaken? Like I said, I've never found one letter yet.
 
Great. It's been my experience that it's been the opposite; I think there was one meeting which didn't recite the Lord's Prayer at the meetings' close. [/quote0

Precisely my point. It proves that at local level, the locals make their own rules for their own meeting.

Yes, it is. Do you have any evidence to show that my contention is mistaken? Like I said, I've never found one letter yet.

In answer to that question we need to ask where Dynamic got that South African members' quote. I did make a mistake there btw - I thought I read/assumed it was from the grapevine.

That said, I have read the experience, strength and hope of members who have found sobriety without a traditional god in the grapevine (and elsewhere). But even when that is provided, what would it prove to you?
 
Great. It's been my experience that it's been the opposite; I think there was one meeting which didn't recite the Lord's Prayer at the meetings' close.

Precisely my point. It proves that at local level, the locals make their own rules for their own meeting.

I for one, have never argued that the locals didn't "make their own rules" per se.

My issue is that they mostly continue to use the same 12 Steps and the Big Book promulgated by the Central Organization, which rather undercuts the notion that they really are "making their own rules."

I did point out, and post, earlier on this thread the Secular 12 Steps. While it is certainly an improvement, it demonstrates that the religious doctrines are still the same; changing "God" and "Power greater than ourselves" to "The Group" doesn't fundamentally alter the doctrines, it justs masks the Religious context far better than "as we understood."

I'm not sure how much of an improvement that really is though, as masking the religious context of the Doctrines just allows people to internalize the doctrines without really understanding where they come from. Much like the Secular Puritanism involved in the Drug War. In other words, Protestant values become so ubiquitous that they form the background assumptions that shape our perspective of reality, and frame the debate.

Nor have I yet to see evidence that the Secular 12 Steps have been widely adopted in the US. But that's not really a surprise as the US population really is more religiously inclined than those of many other Western Secular Nations--which is a fair point that you have made Alfie.

I doubt you'd be able to provide any solid stats Alfie, but I'd be curious to find out if you have actually come across any Australian Locals that use the Secular 12 Steps rather than the GSO approved Traditional Religious 12 Steps.

GB
 
Last edited:
Precisely my point. It proves that at local level, the locals make their own rules for their own meeting.

Sure. It proves that some local groups don't follow the program as laid out by Bill W. and the other founders and some local groups just make it up as they go.



That said, I have read the experience, strength and hope of members who have found sobriety without a traditional god in the grapevine (and elsewhere). But even when that is provided, what would it prove to you?


It would help prove that the AA World Organization is serious that they're willing to make changes to help include their non-religious, non-spirituality-believing members.

It would help dispel the idea that they're a religious organization by including people who are successful models of SOBRIETY and not just successful models of sobriety through religious methods.

But that would mean that the AA World Organization will have to go against all of what Bill W. wrote and envisioned for this group as a whole and how he thinks sobriety can be reached.

After seventy years, we now know of more effective ways to reach and maintain sobriety (CBT for example) that happen to be secular; yet for all the protestations that AA's only goal is to help alcoholics achieve sobriety, there has been no change whatsoever in the core steps, traditions, or processes.
 
Sure. It proves that some local groups don't follow the program as laid out by Bill W. and the other founders and some local groups just make it up as they go.


Er, actually the traditions cover that and the groups are following the program as laid out by the founders. Here's a sample ...

http://www.aa.org.au/members/twelve-traditions.php

3. Our membership ought to include all who suffer from alcoholism. Hence we may refuse none who wish to recover. Nor ought AA membership ever depend upon money or conformity. Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group, provided that, as a group, they have no other affiliation.

4. With respect to its own affairs, each AA group should be responsible to no other authority than its own conscience. But when its plans concern the welfare of neighbouring groups also, those groups ought to be consulted. And no group, regional committee, or individual should ever take any action that might greatly affect AA as a whole without conferring with the trustees of the General Service Board. On such issues our common welfare is paramount.

It would help prove that the AA World Organization is serious that they're willing to make changes to help include their non-religious, non-spirituality-believing members.

There is no need, the non religious members (I do not know of any member who considers themselves "non-spiritual") understand there is no requirement for God in their life. As anecdotal evidence from myself will be disbelieved, can you believe Tinyal?

It would help dispel the idea that they're a religious organization by including people who are successful models of SOBRIETY and not just successful models of sobriety through religious methods.

Like the people sharing at AA meetings you mean?

But that would mean that the AA World Organization will have to go against all of what Bill W. wrote and envisioned for this group as a whole and how he thinks sobriety can be reached.

Um, no. It wouldn't.
He outlined what he did, and makes suggestions. Nothing more, nothing less.

After seventy years, we now know of more effective ways to reach and maintain sobriety (CBT for example) that happen to be secular; yet for all the protestations that AA's only goal is to help alcoholics achieve sobriety, there has been no change whatsoever in the core steps, traditions, or processes.

More effective?
Cool. Can you furnish stats on CBT please?
 
I disagree. In AA, the belief aspect is not merely non-specific, but explicity so.

"God as you understand Him" is not specific ? News to me.

It has been noted many, many times in this thread that AA is very much subject to local variation. Hence, making sweeping statements regarding AA as a whole is a dubious undertaking at best.

And yet you're trying to show that AA isn't religious based on South-African AA or other single-cases.

In the first place, because "going with the definitions from the dictionary" IS an attempt at defining "religious"

That is so silly that I don't even know where to start. NOT defining something is really defining it ?

Arguably true -- but that isn't a barrier to some poorly informed person adopting the stance that there is -- leaving open the question of whether such a person deserves to be called "religious" even though his adopting that stance meets one of the above definitions of that word.

No.

Not guilty. My name is neither Merriam nor Webster, nor was I consulted in the compiling of the dictionary definitionS YOU provided above. I am merely pointing out that regardless of whether it is "useful" to your purpose here, those definitions easily subsume some things that are clearly NOT religious in the context of this discussion. Don't shoot the messenger.

Wait, what ? First, do you really think that you can make up definitions for words ? Do you think this is a good way of communicating if no one uses the same definitions ? And why does this only happen in debates ? Second, how is AA NOT religious under those definitions ? Your reply about science being a religion under the same definitions seemed to be a implicit agreement that it was; otherwise why use it ?

Again, not guilty. You started out muddled, and have done a pretty good job of staying that way despite some rather energetic attempts to provide clarification

We've already covered this. You simply didn't understand what I said.

suggesting that you never really were very interested in answers to the OP's question, having already made your mind up before the thread was ever started.

I had a tentative conclusion and was willing to be proven wrong. Since you have no evidence, however, and rely on semantics only, you're not likely to change my mind.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom