Belz...
Fiend God
Because in AA, the "belief" aspect is neither shared nor specific
Well, if it's not specific it's because of people who constantly redefine terms into uselessness.
"Out here in South Africa,"
Hooray, South-African AA is more tolerant than AA in other places. Good for them, actually.
It's already been noted that as long as we AGREE to use the same definition, we can communicate effectively. Now what we got here is, failure to communicate -- but it's worse than that. We haven't even reached a consensus on whether this is a simple exercise in the proper use of english words, or a philosophical investigation into the underlying meanings of the words we use. If it is the former, then your objection may be sustained. But if it is the latter, my attempt at defining "religious" in a more exacting way may be allowed.
Tell you what: why don't we simply NOT try to define "religious", go with the definitions from the dictionary, and explain why people insist that AA is not religious ?
The problem (for you) is that a great many other things are as well. "Acknowledge" as the "ultimate reality" the nature and origin of the universe as described by the Big Bang Theory and Einsteinian relativity, and you've just become "religious" under at least one of the above definitions.
Amazing. You are so desperate to "win" this thread that you have now crossed into complete nonsense territory.
There IS NO ultimate reality in science. No supernatural entities, no paranormal events. You are AGAIN broadening all definitions to ensure that, if AA is religious, everything else is. Your entire strategy in this thread has been nothing but muddle the issue. When it's not redefining terms into uselessness, it's attempts at equivocation like the one above.