Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nowhere in that post do you define "religious".
I've only presented it like a couple of dozen times, Belz: Adhering to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs. You're either in the thread, or you're just doing drive-bys. Please decide which one it's going to be.

You can't support a definition with logic and reason
Funny, that's exactly what I thought I was doing. It's certainly true that you don't have to support a definition with logic and reason (as some here have so clearly demonstrated), but considering just where this discussion is taking place, I think one sometimes does occasionally incur an obligation to at least try.

because definitions are, by definition, arbitrary.
I will stipulate that some are more arbitrary than others.

However it's only when we agree to use the SAME definition that we can communicate.
That may explain the difficulty we're having here -- in fact, that was pretty much the point I was making when I mentioned that not everyone defines "religious" in the same way.

Unless you've been living under a rock these last few decades, you should know what the definition of "religious" is, and we shouldn't have to redefine it for this thread's purposes.
I guess it depends in how much genuine interest you have in answering the OP's question. If "common usage" and "common knowledge" are good enough for you, then it might be a fairly trivial exercise.

From Merriam-Webster:

1: relating to or manifesting faithful devotion to an acknowledged ultimate reality or deity <a religious person> <religious attitudes>
2: of, relating to, or devoted to religious beliefs or observances <joined a religious order>
3a : scrupulously and conscientiously faithful

Who defines "religious" otherwise ?
Did you happen to notice that the definition you just provided specifies three separate senses of the word? Did you notice that the first one alone provides for, what, four unique permutations (relating to OR manifesting; ultimate reality OR deity)? How about "relating to an acknowledged ultimate reality"? That sounds to me like it could easily refer to a philosophical stance more than anything (depending on the exact nature of this "ultimate reality"), but it is allowable under the above definition -- so, thanks for illustrating my point.

Of course they do. That's how classifying works. It's like saying that bears and cats aren't both mammals because they're not part of the same genus.
There are certain situations in which a system of classification that does not permit the drawing of such important distinctions as those between, say, a grizzly bear and a housecat (because it goes no further than to note that they are "both mammals") will not only fail, but will do so rather dramatically.
 
Of course they do. That's how classifying works. It's like saying that bears and cats aren't both mammals because they're not part of the same genus.
Nah. It's like saying people who are not alcoholics and have never attended an AA meeting know what AA 'actually is; that being a religious ceremony' much better than people who've attended meetings for significant periods of time, who note that AA isn't a religious ceremony.
 
And the fact that lots of folks don't doesn't get factored in, right ?

I can only offer my opinion. You're right. The fact that a lot of folks don't is immaterial where the goal, sobriety, is concerned. You've got a huge majority who believe in god, in AA and out. So what? Unless you're there for reasons other than achieving and maintaining sobriety, it just doesn't matter. Regardless of where you go, there's a pretty good chance that you're going to be surrounded by folks who believe in god. Why expect AA to be any different?

Getting back to the topic of the thread: Why do people insist AA is not religious? I, personally, don't and it wouldn't surprise me in the least to learn that some see their participation in AA as an extension of their religious walk. Nor, however, do I insist that it is. In my day-to-day life, I don't give a rat's ass. But, if I were to venture a guess as to why some might insist that it isn't, I'd have to say that it's probably because the goal, leading a sober life, supersedes any particular system of religious beliefs or lack thereof.
 
Did you happen to notice that the definition you just provided specifies three separate senses of the word? Did you notice that the first one alone provides for, what, four unique permutations (relating to OR manifesting; ultimate reality OR deity)? How about "relating to an acknowledged ultimate reality"? That sounds to me like it could easily refer to a philosophical stance more than anything (depending on the exact nature of this "ultimate reality"), but it is allowable under the above definition -- so, thanks for illustrating my point.

And funnily enough, as I keep pointing out ad infinitum, AA fits the bill for EVERY DEFINITION of Religious. Notice that NONE of the definitions of Religious define Religious as: NOT RELIGIOUS--which is what YOU want it to mean. :p

GB
 
And funnily enough, as I keep pointing out ad infinitum, AA fits the bill for EVERY DEFINITION of Religious.

Orly?

1: relating to or manifesting faithful devotion to an acknowledged ultimate reality or deity

Which ultimate reality or deity, specifically?

2: of, relating to, or devoted to religious beliefs or observances

Which religious beliefs or observances, specifically?
 
Orly?

1: relating to or manifesting faithful devotion to an acknowledged ultimate reality or deity

God as you know him. (See Twelve Steps of AA)

Which ultimate reality or deity, specifically?

God as you know him, (See Twelve Steps of AA)

2: of, relating to, or devoted to religious beliefs or observances

Which religious beliefs or observances, specifically?

God as you know him. (See Twelve Steps of AA)

Man, it is mind boggling how many fundamentalists don't read the literature they claim to be authorities on. :rolleyes:
 
Nah. It's like saying people who are not alcoholics and have never attended an AA meeting know what AA 'actually is; that being a religious ceremony' much better than people who've attended meetings for significant periods of time, who note that AA isn't a religious ceremony.

Well, it isn't just those who haven't attended meetings. A lot of people who attend meetings state that it is very religious. Some agree with the religosity of AA, some don't, and some don't care but they all say it is religious.

There are a small group of apologists who try to explain away the religosity. They aren't respected by many. The ones who like AA's religosity have no respect for them, the ones who don't like the religosity have no respect for them and the ones who don't care . . . well , they don't care which means they have little respect either.
 
Orly?

1: relating to or manifesting faithful devotion to an acknowledged ultimate reality or deity

Which ultimate reality or deity, specifically?

2: of, relating to, or devoted to religious beliefs or observances

Which religious beliefs or observances, specifically?

Also answered AD INFINITUM WITH STATEMENTS AND THE EVIDENCE TO BACK THEM UP!

You might want to ask yourself why you're addicted to asking questions which have been repeatedly answered clearly and with evidence.

GB
 
Nowhere in that post do you define "religious".

I've only presented it like a couple of dozen times, Belz

Are you admitting that your claim was a lie, now ?

Adhering to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.[/QUOTE]

Thank you.

And how does AA not fit that definition ?

That may explain the difficulty we're having here -- in fact, that was pretty much the point I was making when I mentioned that not everyone defines "religious" in the same way.

And yet you've just given me a definition of the word that meshes quite well with mine.

Did you happen to notice that the definition you just provided specifies three separate senses of the word?

Wel, gee darn ! A guess a had'n, billy bob !

OF COURSE I noticed. It's nothing new that words have several ACCEPTED definitions. It doesn't give you a license to make up your own.

Did you notice that the first one alone provides for, what, four unique permutations (relating to OR manifesting; ultimate reality OR deity)? How about "relating to an acknowledged ultimate reality"? That sounds to me like it could easily refer to a philosophical stance more than anything (depending on the exact nature of this "ultimate reality"), but it is allowable under the above definition -- so, thanks for illustrating my point.

What's actually funny about all this is that, all while thanking me for illustrating your point, you're actually making mine.

AA is religious under ALL the definitions you've given.
 
Nah. It's like saying people who are not alcoholics and have never attended an AA meeting know what AA 'actually is; that being a religious ceremony' much better than people who've attended meetings for significant periods of time, who note that AA isn't a religious ceremony.

Yes, and that's kinda like saying that someone who hasn't done their physics doctorate can't tell you what Relativity is all about.

When you step down from your elitist pedestal, let me know.
 
I can only offer my opinion. You're right. The fact that a lot of folks don't is immaterial where the goal, sobriety, is concerned. You've got a huge majority who believe in god, in AA and out. So what? Unless you're there for reasons other than achieving and maintaining sobriety, it just doesn't matter. Regardless of where you go, there's a pretty good chance that you're going to be surrounded by folks who believe in god. Why expect AA to be any different?

You gotta love apologists.

So basically it's okay for the majority to bully the minority because that's what we expect people to do.

Yeah, that'll get a guy sober. :rolleyes:
 
So basically it's okay for the majority to bully the minority because that's what we expect people to do.

I didn't realize that we were discussing bullying and have no idea as to how you could have interpreted my words to mean the above. It's a misrepresentation.

Yeah, that'll get a guy sober. :rolleyes:

If you seek sobriety and feel that you have been the victim of bullying at an AA meeting, I suggest you try another group. If you want to convince people that a belief in the supernatural is irrational (a stance with which I happen to agree), then I suggest you seek a different audience.

Aside: You might want to consider addressing people in a less antagonistic manner in your attempts to achieve a meeting of the minds.
 
And how does AA not fit that definition ?
Because in AA, the "belief" aspect is neither shared nor specific -- nor even necessarily supernatural. One member writes:

"Out here in South Africa, many of our city meetings are multi-faith -- a Xhosa member the other night invoked the help of a family ancestor. Younger members are Buddhist or Sufi, some are animist, and many are secular and consider themselves to be in recovery from the abuses of missionary Christianity. Others are Christian, not a majority and generally they seem far more tolerant and accepting than is the case elsewhere. I am not anti-religious, I come from a multifaith perspective and so long as no particular group tries to impose their Higher Power on everyone else, there is no problem. We don't end meetings with the Lord's Prayer because others might want to say prayers to their particular deities and there isn't time. Furthermore, the saying aloud of specific prayers would exclude the agnostics and atheists in the meetings and that is unacceptable."

It's nothing new that words have several ACCEPTED definitions. It doesn't give you a license to make up your own.
It's already been noted that as long as we AGREE to use the same definition, we can communicate effectively. Now what we got here is, failure to communicate -- but it's worse than that. We haven't even reached a consensus on whether this is a simple exercise in the proper use of english words, or a philosophical investigation into the underlying meanings of the words we use. If it is the former, then your objection may be sustained. But if it is the latter, my attempt at defining "religious" in a more exacting way may be allowed.

And yet you've just given me a definition of the word that meshes quite well with mine.
I'm glad to hear that.

AA is religious under ALL the definitions you've given.
The problem (for you) is that a great many other things are as well. "Acknowledge" as the "ultimate reality" the nature and origin of the universe as described by the Big Bang Theory and Einsteinian relativity, and you've just become "religious" under at least one of the above definitions.
 
I can only offer my opinion. You're right. The fact that a lot of folks don't is immaterial where the goal, sobriety, is concerned.

Have you really thought that through? If an alcoholic finds AA too religious (and by AA I mean the organization not individuals at a meeting) because of all the god and higher power stuff and doesn't return, isn't that material to the goal of sobriety as espoused by AA?

You've got a huge majority who believe in god, in AA and out. So what? Unless you're there for reasons other than achieving and maintaining sobriety, it just doesn't matter.

How does the belief in god demonstrate someone's only reason for attending AA is to get sober but someone who doesn't believe must have other reasons?

Regardless of where you go, there's a pretty good chance that you're going to be surrounded by folks who believe in god. Why expect AA to be any different?

As stated above. It isn't the individual AA members who are the problem, it is the 12 step program of AA that is. If it is all inclusive, why aren't atheist beliefs taken into account? AA caters to the religious but claims to not be a religious organization. Why don't they stop the waffling and choose which one AA will be?

Getting back to the topic of the thread: Why do people insist AA is not religious? I, personally, don't and it wouldn't surprise me in the least to learn that some see their participation in AA as an extension of their religious walk. Nor, however, do I insist that it is.

So, your answer is that AA is religious but is not religious. Well, that clears it up.:rolleyes:

In my day-to-day life, I don't give a rat's ass. But, if I were to venture a guess as to why some might insist that it isn't, I'd have to say that it's probably because the goal, leading a sober life, supersedes any particular system of religious beliefs or lack thereof.

Unless one looks at the evidence of course. Obviously, people, including AA directors and non-religious members of AA have found AA religosity to be a problem so leading a sober life does not supersede any system of belief.
 
godpc2.gif
 
I didn't realize that we were discussing bullying and have no idea as to how you could have interpreted my words to mean the above. It's a misrepresentation.

It's okay to have "god" because most people believe in god and those who don't will just have to deal with it. Right ?

If you seek sobriety and feel that you have been the victim of bullying at an AA meeting, I suggest you try another group. If you want to convince people that a belief in the supernatural is irrational (a stance with which I happen to agree), then I suggest you seek a different audience.

And all that is irrelevant to the OP.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom