I've only presented it like a couple of dozen times, Belz: Adhering to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs. You're either in the thread, or you're just doing drive-bys. Please decide which one it's going to be.Nowhere in that post do you define "religious".
Funny, that's exactly what I thought I was doing. It's certainly true that you don't have to support a definition with logic and reason (as some here have so clearly demonstrated), but considering just where this discussion is taking place, I think one sometimes does occasionally incur an obligation to at least try.You can't support a definition with logic and reason
I will stipulate that some are more arbitrary than others.because definitions are, by definition, arbitrary.
That may explain the difficulty we're having here -- in fact, that was pretty much the point I was making when I mentioned that not everyone defines "religious" in the same way.However it's only when we agree to use the SAME definition that we can communicate.
I guess it depends in how much genuine interest you have in answering the OP's question. If "common usage" and "common knowledge" are good enough for you, then it might be a fairly trivial exercise.Unless you've been living under a rock these last few decades, you should know what the definition of "religious" is, and we shouldn't have to redefine it for this thread's purposes.
Did you happen to notice that the definition you just provided specifies three separate senses of the word? Did you notice that the first one alone provides for, what, four unique permutations (relating to OR manifesting; ultimate reality OR deity)? How about "relating to an acknowledged ultimate reality"? That sounds to me like it could easily refer to a philosophical stance more than anything (depending on the exact nature of this "ultimate reality"), but it is allowable under the above definition -- so, thanks for illustrating my point.From Merriam-Webster:
1: relating to or manifesting faithful devotion to an acknowledged ultimate reality or deity <a religious person> <religious attitudes>
2: of, relating to, or devoted to religious beliefs or observances <joined a religious order>
3a : scrupulously and conscientiously faithful
Who defines "religious" otherwise ?
There are certain situations in which a system of classification that does not permit the drawing of such important distinctions as those between, say, a grizzly bear and a housecat (because it goes no further than to note that they are "both mammals") will not only fail, but will do so rather dramatically.Of course they do. That's how classifying works. It's like saying that bears and cats aren't both mammals because they're not part of the same genus.

