Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Now if you could only demonstrate YOUR assertions with Evidence and Logic.
GB, I'm so proud of you! That you would append your usual demand for EVIDENCE with "Evidence and Logic" makes me think this whole effort may have actually accomplished at least one tiny thing. Just made my day, you did.
 
You know Dymanic, this is the main reason I call your arguments a lie.

I haven't been arguing that all the individual members of AA are religious. I have been arguing that the members of AA belong to a Religious Organization. And I have made this point repeatedly. A point that you deliberately and rigorously deny that I have made (I think you said something about "crickets chirping").

So, unless you are claiming that you aren't reading my posts, you are just lying.

And no-one is making up "special definitions" of religious except you.

GB
 
GB, I'm so proud of you! That you would append your usual demand for EVIDENCE with "Evidence and Logic" makes me think this whole effort may have actually accomplished at least one tiny thing. Just made my day, you did.

Another lie. I have repeatedly pointed out that logic without evidence to back it up is merely an exercise in rhetoric. And you have openly confessed that you don't need evidence.

Why do you keep lying?

GB
 
And I have lovely chats with Mainstream Christians who consider Jehovah's Witnesses and Mormons as Heretical. Yet the members of all these religious organizations STILL BELONG TO A RELIGIOUS ORGANIZATION.
They all belong to religious organizations, to be sure; but not to a single religious organization -- and not merely because those organizations declare themselves to be independent of one another but because they do not share the same specific supernatural beliefs.

I haven't been arguing that all the individual members of AA are religious. I have been arguing that the members of AA belong to a Religious Organization. And I have made this point repeatedly. A point that you deliberately and rigorously deny that I have made (I think you said something about "crickets chirping").
Yes, you've argued that AA is religious because its members belong to a Religious Organization. I have noticed that, and I'm not denying that you argued thusly. But before you get too far into your meltdown here, I'd still be interested in hearing which of the three criteria I have enumerated: specific, shared, supernatural you would argue are not necessary aspects of "religious" belief. And if you feel like throwing in your actual reasons (as sort of an extra bonus), that would be great.
 
They all belong to religious organizations, to be sure; but not to a single religious organization -- and not merely because those organizations declare themselves to be independent of one another but because they do not share the same specific supernatural beliefs.

Yes, you've argued that AA is religious because its members belong to a Religious Organization. I have noticed that, and I'm not denying that you argued thusly. But before you get too far into your meltdown here, I'd still be interested in hearing which of the three criteria I have enumerated: specific, shared, supernatural you would argue are not necessary aspects of "religious" belief. And if you feel like throwing in your actual reasons (as sort of an extra bonus), that would be great.

I already have explained in great detail (in black and white and red and white in large fonts. Why are you still lying?

GB
 
Here is some Very Interesting Internal AA recent discussions on attempts to be more inclusive to agnostics and atheists. These documents are confidential, and examples of info which is only rarely available to members, and hardly ever available to the public or researchers. Note: AA requires majorities around 90% to make substantial changes, and so far, those who want to make some inroads into lessening the god-bothering are less than - by far - an amount that would trigger these changes. These are long, involved documents dozen's of pages long. I'm not the first to post this stuff, so I'm not the one breaking the public seal on these.

http://www.orange-papers.org/Letter_from_Nebraska_Delegate_Area_41_to_GSO_3_Dec_2009.pdf

http://www.orange-papers.org/Minority_Opinion_Appeal_to_AA_Fellowship.pdf
 
Last edited:
I agree.

The fundamental underpinnings of AA may well be religious, but one need not adhere to any religious belief in order to benefit from what AA has to offer. You work your own program. Do what it takes to stay sober. If that means receiving support to live a sober life while dismissing superstition, dandy. Some may say, "You're not working the AA program!" So what? The objective is sobriety.

Then don't drink. AA members make alcohol into a god.
 
AA members make alcohol into a god

Actually Satan would be more accurate in the deity description.

Cunning, baffling, powerful, human/deity attributes that must be battled with the powers of a Good higher power to win....

The ever vigilant Satan, just waiting to sneak up on you and force a fifth of vodka down your throat. :blush:

Classic stuff really.......

People pray to make hurricanes turn too, you just never know what them super powers can do.....
 
Actually Satan would be more accurate in the deity description.

Cunning, baffling, powerful, human/deity attributes that must be battled with the powers of a Good higher power to win....

The ever vigilant Satan, just waiting to sneak up on you and force a fifth of vodka down your throat. :blush:

Classic stuff really.......

People pray to make hurricanes turn too, you just never know what them super powers can do.....

Luckily I've never been to any AA meeting that indicated that.

Maybe you should find another group. ;)
 
Luckily I've never been to any AA meeting that indicated that.

Maybe you should find another group. ;)

Well, if AA is as Universalist as All That, I suppose Satan can be your Higher Power right? :D

I wonder if someone "shared" their Satanic Higher Power with the Group and proffered a Satanic version of the Serenity Prayer, how well THAT would go over. ;)

GB
 
Well, if AA is as Universalist as All That, I suppose Satan can be your Higher Power right? :D

I wonder if someone "shared" their Satanic Higher Power with the Group and proffered a Satanic version of the Serenity Prayer, how well THAT would go over. ;)

GB
Anything to help an alcoholic who wants to stop drinking and develop some useful coping skills seems appropriate to me.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it would raise that many eyebrows. It would certainly be different.

But if someone was to use satan as ther HP, then that would be their choice, the rest of the fellowship would respect that choice. One would hope that if there was a destructive element within it, then that individual would accept some guidance with the bottom line being their sobriety.

Using Satan as a higher power would seem somehow at odds with living a new and sober life, but nothing anywhere would preclude it afaik.

I have seen wiccans and witches in AA doing very nicely with their respective HPs - no-one cares.
 
Just did. Take your time, you'll find it. It's right there in the snippet you just quoted.

No, not really. Nowhere in that post do you define "religious".

That you now have me saying it's irrelevant indicates either that I am still having a very great deal of trouble making myself understood or you aren't making much effort to understand me.

Either those or you have no idea what a definition is. You can't support a definition with logic and reason, because definitions are, by definition, arbitrary. However it's only when we agree to use the SAME definition that we can communicate. So you're actually doubly wrong.

This has been all about defining terms since the beginning

Unless you've been living under a rock these last few decades, you should know what the definition of "religious" is, and we shouldn't have to redefine it for this thread's purposes.

The only reason to redefine a term is to have it conform to what we already have decided we want that term to mean.

Why do people insist AA is not religious? Because not everyone defines "religious" in the same way.

From Merriam-Webster:

1: relating to or manifesting faithful devotion to an acknowledged ultimate reality or deity <a religious person> <religious attitudes>
2: of, relating to, or devoted to religious beliefs or observances <joined a religious order>
3a : scrupulously and conscientiously faithful

Who defines "religious" otherwise ?
 
That just a supposition yet, or have you supposed it up to "Belz Fact" status?

Wrong in any case.

More irrelevancy.

Why do you even bother posting ?

By the way, there are only three Belz facts:

1. The universe is messed up.
2. Belz... is always right
3. If Not(2), see 1.
 
Last edited:
From Merriam-Webster:

1: relating to or manifesting faithful devotion to an acknowledged ultimate reality or deity <a religious person> <religious attitudes>
2: of, relating to, or devoted to religious beliefs or observances <joined a religious order>
3a : scrupulously and conscientiously faithful

Who defines "religious" otherwise ?

Now pull up some definitions of spiritual.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom