Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have offered a definition for "religious" which still remains unchallenged here -- in fact, I don't recall one person having even "seen fit" to clarify whether they were rejecting that definition or accepting it but arguing that AA members DO adhere to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.

Love how you tamper with the definitions. And ya gotta love it when you claim that no-one's challenged your tampered definitions.

I seem to recall a very recent post that pointed out that the "shared" aspect of those that attend a religious organization is not necessarily "shared" at all.

Your Honour, I am NOT attempting to convict Dymanic of being a Theist. But I WILL prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he belongs to a Religious Organization known by the name of Alcoholics Anonymous.

How will I do that you ask? The same way I can prove beyond a Reasonable Doubt that many non-praying/praying silently/word-mouthing/God mentioning once or twice (especially after dropping hammers on their toes) people belong to other Religious Organizations such as The Catholic Church, The Nation of Islam, Vedic sects of Tantric Hinduism, The Southern Baptist Church, The Anglican Communion/ The Unitarian Universalists and many others far too numerous to mention.

Your Honour, I cannot rely on the word of individual adherents, as their own personal views vary widely from those who merely attend to demonstrate propriety without actually believing in either the doctrines and/or the Deity of their chosen Religious Organization, to those that Fundamentally believe that every word of their sacred texts must be taken as Literal Truth.


Thus, as with any religious organization, I must rely on the words of their Sacred Texts, and the Historical Record of the Organization, the Biographies of the founders and the texts of the Founders Letters and Ancillary Writings, and Legal Precedence including the upholding of the Second Circuit's decision by the US Supreme Court establishing the the Religiosity of AA.

Maybe you were hoping no-one would remember that such a clear refutation of your tampered definitions was on the previous page. Or maybe you hoped that I was just resting on my laurels gloating, never to return to rub it in your face. But there it is, in black and white (actually red and white now, in a font large enough for you to see). :D

GB
 
Last edited:
*snip* I would think that this requires a connection between AA and religion. :rolleyes:

Look for that connection, and if you as a suffering alcoholic need it, and you'll find it at AA.

If you are suffering alcoholic who needs AA without religion, you can find that too, even in the same meeting.

I agree.

The fundamental underpinnings of AA may well be religious, but one need not adhere to any religious belief in order to benefit from what AA has to offer. You work your own program. Do what it takes to stay sober. If that means receiving support to live a sober life while dismissing superstition, dandy. Some may say, "You're not working the AA program!" So what? The objective is sobriety.
 
I agree.

The fundamental underpinnings of AA may well be religious, but one need not adhere to any religious belief in order to benefit from what AA has to offer. You work your own program. Do what it takes to stay sober. If that means receiving support to live a sober life while dismissing superstition, dandy. Some may say, "You're not working the AA program!" So what? The objective is sobriety.

So then, what does AA need all the god bothering for?
 
I agree.

The fundamental underpinnings of AA may well be religious, but one need not adhere to any religious belief in order to benefit from what AA has to offer. You work your own program. Do what it takes to stay sober. If that means receiving support to live a sober life while dismissing superstition, dandy. Some may say, "You're not working the AA program!" So what? The objective is sobriety.

So you agree that AA is a religious organization.

And that it's adherents, just like those who are members of any religious organization, vary in their beliefs in the Doctrines and the Deity(ies) espoused by the religious organization.

GB
 
Last edited:
So you agree that AA is a religious organization.

And that it's adherents, just like those who are members of any religious organization, vary in their beliefs in the Doctrines and the Deity(ies) espoused by the religious organization.

GB

No need to go bold on me--

Does AA have a religious aspect? Unquestionably, where those who are in need of such are concerned. Is an adherence to any given religion necessary? No. Does this mean that AA is non-religious? My personal opinion is that any religious component of AA is irrelevant, as I do not go to AA seeking validation of my beliefs or lack thereof. I go because I receive support in my decision to stay sober. Others may disagree, which suits me just fine.
 
not all christians adhere to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.
Hence, Christianity may be considered not merely a single religion but a family of separate religions -- each with it own specific set of supernatural beliefs shared within that religion, though not necessarily with the neighboring religions (for example, Jehovah's Witnesses reject the notion of the immortal soul, though they obviously accept Jehovah God).
 
Hence, Christianity may be considered not merely a single religion but a family of separate religions -- each with it own specific set of supernatural beliefs shared within that religion, though not necessarily with the neighboring religions (for example, Jehovah's Witnesses reject the notion of the immortal soul, though they obviously accept Jehovah God).

So, which ones aren't religious or are they all not religious? (You really aren't helping your own cause here.)
 
If people can and do define "religious" in different ways, then why do you only accuse one side in this discussion of "insist[ing] that theirs is the only correct definition possible"?
In noting that not everyone defines "religious" in the same way, one underlying assumption is left unspoken (mainly because it seems too obvious to require it): each person uses the definition he feels is most correct. In providing a definition for consideration by the assembled here, I am not presenting it as the only correct one possible (and you may notice that the compaints regarding "tampering" are all coming from the "other side"). Until there is some interest in weighing the relative merits of one definition over another (a step omitted in the references to vacuous dictionary definitions), mine will remain unchallenged -- but I do not automatically equate "unchallenged" with "best possible". I've asked a number of times whether the shared aspect (in particular) is indispensible, and got nothing but chirping crickets.
 
Hence, Christianity may be considered not merely a single religion but a family of separate religions -- each with it own specific set of supernatural beliefs shared within that religion, though not necessarily with the neighboring religions (for example, Jehovah's Witnesses reject the notion of the immortal soul, though they obviously accept Jehovah God).

Insofar as all the major denominations of Christianity adhere to a core set of doctrines and a belief in the same Deity, we can refer to Christianity as a whole. The key doctrines of Original Sin, being covered by the blood of Christ (Absolution/Grace), and the Trinity are the tenets that define the majority of Christianity as a whole. These are the central doctrines that Catholic, Reformation, and "Eastern" Orthodox churches all adhere too.

Are their minority sects with "heretical" views of Christianity? Of course.

But we don't determine what is Christianity simply by the views its minority sects, any more than we determine what is Christianity by the individual views of its practitioners.

We determine Christianity and its offshoots by their Sacred Texts and the ancillary writings of the founders of the splinter groups.

GB
 
So, which ones aren't religious or are they all not religious? (You really aren't helping your own cause here.)
By my definition, they're all religious, as each of them individually exhibits specific, shared, supernatural beliefs. (And you really aren't helping your own cause here by demonstrating an inability to follow this simple logic) .
 
In noting that not everyone defines "religious" in the same way, one underlying assumption is left unspoken (mainly because it seems too obvious to require it): each person uses the definition he feels is most correct. In providing a definition for consideration by the assembled here, I am not presenting it as the only correct one possible (and you may notice that the compaints regarding "tampering" are all coming from the "other side"). Until there is some interest in weighing the relative merits of one definition over another (a step omitted in the references to vacuous dictionary definitions), mine will remain unchallenged -- but I do not automatically equate "unchallenged" with "best possible". I've asked a number of times whether the shared aspect (in particular) is indispensible, and got nothing but chirping crickets.

I don't know why you continue to LIE about this. I have categorically demonstrated that the "shared" aspect is not something that is empirically demonstrable...except insofar as adherents actually belong to said religious organization.

I have made this point time and again as have others.

If you are a member of AA you belong to a religious organization. Your private beliefs have nothing to do with it.

GB
 
By my definition, they're all religious, as each of them individually exhibits specific, shared, supernatural beliefs. (And you really aren't helping your own cause here by demonstrating an inability to follow this simple logic) .

As Qayak says, you're just making OUR case for us.

GB
 
Insofar as all the major denominations of Christianity adhere to a core set of doctrines and a belief in the same Deity, we can refer to Christianity as a whole.
We can, but JW's insist that they are "no part of Christiandom". (BTW, they reject the Trinity, too).

But we don't determine what is Christianity simply by the views its minority sects, any more than we determine what is Christianity by the individual views of its practitioners.

We determine Christianity and its offshoots by their Sacred Texts and the ancillary writings of the founders of the splinter groups
Unlike Catholics and others, Jehovah's Witnesses do not use their own special version of the Sacred Texts, yet their beliefs place them well outside mainstream Christianity.
 
In noting that not everyone defines "religious" in the same way, one underlying assumption is left unspoken (mainly because it seems too obvious to require it): each person uses the definition he feels is most correct. In providing a definition for consideration by the assembled here, I am not presenting it as the only correct one possible (and you may notice that the compaints regarding "tampering" are all coming from the "other side"). Until there is some interest in weighing the relative merits of one definition over another (a step omitted in the references to vacuous dictionary definitions), mine will remain unchallenged -- but I do not automatically equate "unchallenged" with "best possible". I've asked a number of times whether the shared aspect (in particular) is indispensible, and got nothing but chirping crickets.

You completely dodged my point.

If not everyone defines "religious" the same way, then why is it ok for people to say "AA is not religious" because their personal definition says so, but if someone says "AA is religious" because their personal definition says it is, then according to you they are guilty of insisting that only their definition is the correct one?

Why aren't you chastising anyone who says "AA is not religious" for insisting that only their definition is correct?

You're applying a double standard.
 
We can, but JW's insist that they are "no part of Christiandom". (BTW, they reject the Trinity, too).

Unlike Catholics and others, Jehovah's Witnesses do not use their own special version of the Sacred Texts, yet their beliefs place them well outside mainstream Christianity.

Yes, that is why they are a minority splinter sect. I have lovely chats with them when they bring me their literature. And I have lovely chats with Mainstream Christians who consider Jehovah's Witnesses and Mormons as Heretical. Yet the members of all these religious organizations STILL BELONG TO A RELIGIOUS ORGANIZATION.

GB
 
I don't know why you continue to LIE about this. I have categorically demonstrated that the "shared" aspect is not something that is empirically demonstrable...except insofar as adherents actually belong to said religious organization.

I have made this point time and again as have others.

If you are a member of AA you belong to a religious organization. Your private beliefs have nothing to do with it.
You seem to be hung on mapping this to AA. We don't need a special definition of "religious" applicable solely to AA. Try it with regard to "religious" in general. I submit that if a person does not share the specific supernatural beliefs, that person is not religious; belief has everything to do with it -- and an organization made up of people who do not share the same specific supernatural beliefs is not a religious organization.

As Qayak says, you're just making OUR case for us.
So you keep saying. Now if only you could demonstrate it with logic.
 
You seem to be hung on mapping this to AA. We don't need a special definition of "religious" applicable solely to AA. Try it with regard to "religious" in general. I submit that if a person does not share the specific supernatural beliefs, that person is not religious; belief has everything to do with it -- and an organization made up of people who do not share the same specific supernatural beliefs is not a religious organization.

So you keep saying. Now if only you could demonstrate it with logic.

AA is a Religious Organization. The fact that you don't believe in its religious aspects (nearly all of it) doesn't make it any less a Religious Organization.

Now if you could only demonstrate YOUR assertions with Evidence and Logic.

GB
 
If not everyone defines "religious" the same way, then why is it ok for people to say "AA is not religious" because their personal definition says so, but if someone says "AA is religious" because their personal definition says it is, then according to you they are guilty of insisting that only their definition is the correct one?

Why aren't you chastising anyone who says "AA is not religious" for insisting that only their definition is correct?
First of all, because the unnamed "people" the OP mentions are not all here, so we have no way of knowing that they do in fact insist that theirs is the only possible correct definition. There has been so little attention paid to the matter that I don't know that anyone on this "side" is insisting that. And second of all, because those who are arguing that AA is religious are most adamant about that NOT being subject to personal definitions. It's the dictionary or the highway.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom