Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Funnily enough, I actually see the reasoning that you, Belz et al are using. I also see how the evidence can readily suggest that AA would have to be religious.

However, there are a number of things that allow the end user to decide for themselves what they do with this one aspect of the program, these include:

- sufficient 'wriggle room' in the steps and literature for any member to make the decision on whether or not to apply the religious component to their own recovery.
- the steps are suggestions.
- the choice to mix and match what works for you.
- God can mean anything that might work for the individual (including the Christian god)
- the definition between spiritual and religious (not seen by those on your side)
- it is a spiritual program, not religious.

In other words, "these include: being able to redefine terms as you see fit."
 
That's an odd thing to say, since the question at issue is whether AA is religious. I would think that this requires a connection between AA and religion. :rolleyes:
Look for that connection, and if you as a suffering alcoholic need it, and you'll find it at AA.

If you are suffering alcoholic who needs AA without religion, you can find that too, even in the same meeting.
 
Look for that connection, and if you as a suffering alcoholic need it, and you'll find it at AA.

If you are suffering alcoholic who needs AA without religion, you can find that too, even in the same meeting.

So AA is all things to all men?
 
That's an odd thing to say, since the question at issue is whether AA is religious. I would think that this requires a connection between AA and religion.
Necessary, but not sufficient. Lots of things have "connections" to religion.

In other words, "these include: being able to redefine terms as you see fit."
In this place, what counts is not how one sees fit to define a thing, but how well a definition can be supported with logic and reason (and no, vacuous dictionary lookups don't meet that standard; try "consciousness" for an example). I have offered a definition for "religious" which still remains unchallenged here -- in fact, I don't recall one person having even "seen fit" to clarify whether they were rejecting that definition or accepting it but arguing that AA members DO adhere to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.
 
I have offered a definition for "religious" which still remains unchallenged here -- in fact, I don't recall one person having even "seen fit" to clarify whether they were rejecting that definition or accepting it but arguing that AA members DO adhere to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.

That's not true. Many, including myself, have stated that we reject your made up definitions and all the others used to put a positive spin on what is obviously a negative image.

Let's face it, if AA wasn't religious you wouldn't have to go to all the effort and resort to all the fallacies.
 
That's not true. Many, including myself, have stated that we reject your made up definitions...
No, it IS true that I don't recall you or anyone else explicitly rejecting my definition of the word "religious". If you do recall explicitly doing that, kindly point to the post or posts you have in mind, if you feel like searching them out (I don't, not the least reason being that I'm pretty sure they don't exist). An alternative might be to simply restate whether you accept or reject my definition -- but you might keep in mind that challenging it would require actually showing the logical basis for rejecting it.

If by any chance you happen to be including GB among the "many" you mention, feel free to also point to any of his posts (or anyone else's, for that matter) in which you feel he clarifies this. My guess is that GB would be inclined to accept my definition and cling to his position that AA does conform to a set of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs; specifically: the God of Protestant Christianity. But I could be wrong.

Let's face it, if AA wasn't religious you wouldn't have to go to all the effort and resort to all the fallacies.
I've encountered that argument before, only it sounded like this: "If the theory of evolution were true, you wouldn't have to work so hard to defend it". Let's face it: you wouldn't recognize a logical fallacy if it jumped up and bit you on the nose.
 
The power of choice, what a concept.
But seriously we are not talking about "redefinition" are we, simply understanding or interpretation.

The problem is, as this thread has demonstrated, that you and the other AA supporters are so willing to reinterpret that any discussion about the matter seems fruitless. The definitions you use are so fluid as to lose all consistency.
 
Necessary, but not sufficient. Lots of things have "connections" to religion.

I have offered a definition for "religious" which still remains unchallenged here -- in fact, I don't recall one person having even "seen fit" to clarify whether they were rejecting that definition or accepting it but arguing that AA members DO adhere to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.

Would you mind posting it again ? Somehow I doubt no one has any issues with it.

In this place, what counts is not how one sees fit to define a thing, but how well a definition can be supported with logic and reason

Considering that you guys have argued since page 1 that "whatever works, works" and that "you make your own reality" and that "anything can be a higher power"; and seeing as how people have been redefining terms in this thread since the beginning, I find it quite funny that you now claim that how people define things is irrelevant.
 
I've encountered that argument before, only it sounded like this: "If the theory of evolution were true, you wouldn't have to work so hard to defend it". Let's face it: you wouldn't recognize a logical fallacy if it jumped up and bit you on the nose.

Actually, Dymanic is right, here. Defense is no indication of guilt.
 
No, it IS true that I don't recall you or anyone else explicitly rejecting my definition of the word "religious". If you do recall explicitly doing that . . .

On several occasions I have rejected all the definition changes you and others have made. I have also posted the standard dictionary definitions of "religion," "religious," and "spiritual" and not had anyone show how AA was exempt for any reason.

If by any chance you happen to be including GB among the "many" you mention . . .

I do, and Belz and Tinyal as well. They have all at one time or another rejected the tampered definitions being used by their opponents. Those opponents couldn't even rely on an argument of semantics until after they distorted the meanings of the words.

I've encountered that argument before, only it sounded like this: "If the theory of evolution were true, you wouldn't have to work so hard to defend it". Let's face it: you wouldn't recognize a logical fallacy if it jumped up and bit you on the nose.

That is true but that isn't the argument I made. The argument I made was that if your what you say was true, you could make the argument and demonstrate it in the AA literature. But AA supporters can't. They have to change words, ignore the vast majority of AA literature, cherry pick anecdotal evidence from individuals, lie, etc., to come up with anything.

That's a lot of work considering the reverse was shown to be true in the first post and all the way through the thread. Occam's Razor comes to mind here.
 
Actually, Dymanic is right, here. Defense is no indication of guilt.

Absolutely, but with people here seeming to have, at least, normal intelligence and this thread going on for 60+ pages, one would think the non-religious AA side would have made some inroads by now. They haven't because even normally intelligent people can see that what they claim is just wrong.

[Also see my previous post to Dynamic.]
 
My comment specifically addressed suffering alcoholics who were looking for help, so no.

It seems to me you haven't clarified anything. It would seem to me that alcoholics represent the diversity of the population. So, although re-worded, the question is exactly the same.

Is AA all things to all suffering alcoholics?
 
Would you mind posting it again ?
Just did. Take your time, you'll find it. It's right there in the snippet you just quoted.

Considering that you guys have argued since page 1 that "whatever works, works" and that "you make your own reality" and that "anything can be a higher power"; and seeing as how people have been redefining terms in this thread since the beginning, I find it quite funny that you now claim that how people define things is irrelevant.
That you now have me saying it's irrelevant indicates either that I am still having a very great deal of trouble making myself understood or you aren't making much effort to understand me. This has been all about defining terms since the beginning, and I've said so in every way I can think of. Why do people insist AA is not religious? Because not everyone defines "religious" in the same way. Why do some here insist that AA is religious? Because they insist that theirs is the only correct definition possible.

You're making the same mistake GB made above when he failed to appreciate the difference between broadening the definition of "God" and broadening the definition of "religious". I cannot imagine a simpler exercise in logic: broaden the definition of "God" (say, by using phrases like "higher power") and you may end up outside the boundaries of "religious".
 
On several occasions I have rejected all the definition changes you and others have made.
Right. The challenge before you is to show your reasons for doing so.

I have also posted the standard dictionary definitions of "religion," "religious," and "spiritual" and not had anyone show how AA was exempt for any reason.
Argument from practical lexicography: Throw out all but the dictionaries, because the deepest insights are reflected in common usage. Think of all the time and bandwidth wasted over the years on discussing "consciousness", when it never deserved more than a quick peek in the dictionary: "The state of being conscious". Now that's what I call keeping it simple!
 
Argument from practical lexicography: Throw out all but the dictionaries, because the deepest insights are reflected in common usage. Think of all the time and bandwidth wasted over the years on discussing "consciousness", when it never deserved more than a quick peek in the dictionary: "The state of being conscious". Now that's what I call keeping it simple!

So, what you are trying to say is that no word has a definition and anything can mean anything you want it to? Okay then.

That alcoholism mount navigates and performance full series, therefore, AA compensated helix including sunlight is atmospheric and thus, religious.

Game, set, and match, Qayak! :monkeyr:
 
. . . in fact, I don't recall one person having even "seen fit" to clarify whether they were rejecting that definition or accepting it but arguing that AA members DO adhere to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.

And I remember specifically stating that the problem is that you are looking at AA members and not at the organization. I stated then, and I state it again, that not all christians adhere to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.

In order for your definition to fit, you would have to admit that no christian church is religious because not all christians believe the exact same thing. The same for muslims and jews and hindus and . . .

AA the (organization) does indeed adhere to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.[/B] That individuals choose to do things differently is irrelevent.

So, you were mistaken both in that this definition proves AA is not religious and that your definition is accurate of what the word "religious" means . . . you are also mistaken that this hasn't been addressed before.
 
Why do people insist AA is not religious? Because not everyone defines "religious" in the same way. Why do some here insist that AA is religious? Because they insist that theirs is the only correct definition possible.

If people can and do define "religious" in different ways, then why do you only accuse one side in this discussion of "insist[ing] that theirs is the only correct definition possible"? Is that not equally true of -- using your own words -- "people [who] insist AA is not religious"?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom