Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is that just 'speculation' or is it being presented as a 'Belz Fact'?

You think me telling Alfie to present proper analogies could be a "fact" ? No. I think you're just in assault mode, right now, and nothing you say has any value so long as you don't step out of it.
 
Any chance of you toughening up yet, Belz? Or are you still sooking about being asked to apologise?

Anyhow, back on topic.... do you think that we should change all of humankinds history books? Should we simply change what happened to Bill W (et al), as they reported it? What about some of Freuds books, perhaps we could change them? What about just rewriting history alltogether, no more slavery, no wars, no religions, no genocide, no science, no education, no anything.
That way we could accommodate all your sensibilities.

Actually, why not forget history all together, and pretend that everything today, was always like that?

And while you are wanting to change the history of AA and the big book, perhaps you could tell us exactly why we should.
 
Last edited:
Anyhow, back on topic.... do you think that we should change all of humankinds history books? Should we simply change what happened to Bill W (et al), as they reported it? What about some of Freuds books, perhaps we could change them? What about just rewriting history alltogether, no more slavery, no wars, no religions, no genocide, no science, no education, no anything.
That way we could accommodate all your sensibilities.

Actually, why not forget history all together, and pretend that everything today, was always like that?

Strawman. No one has asked you to do any such thing. We don't care that the history hasn't changed. We only care that the organization AA hasn't changed and thus, is just as religious as when it first started.

Actually, why not forget history all together, and pretend that everything today, was always like that?

And while you are wanting to change the history of AA and the big book, perhaps you could tell us exactly why we should.

You should change simply to prevent being a liar. Of professing one thing while practicing another. Even a organization working with children understands such a simple concept and changed but AA, working with adults, can't figure that out.

Is there something about adults, alcoholics, or AA that makes them unable to understand simple concepts?
 
And while you are wanting to change the history of AA and the big book, perhaps you could tell us exactly why we should.
I believe we're hearing a request to replace the word 'god' with 'The Trinity of GB-BZ-QK'.

Why? Because it's more fun to play in someone else's business than tend to one's own. ;)
 
168034cd45a83f2d06.jpg


So remind me again how exactly this doesn't qualify as "religious"?
 
For you, and a few others who seem worried about it, it's Religious.

For me, and others, it isn't.

We can agree to disagree.
 
For you, and a few others who seem worried about it, it's Religious.

For me, and others, it isn't.

We can agree to disagree.

Whether or not one agrees to disagree, the language and the doctrines of your Sacred Texts are clearly religious. What you're doing is like claiming that the distinction between Creationism/Intelligent Design and Natural Selection is merely a matter of opinion rather than fact (it's not by the way ;) ).

Claiming that those who disagree with you are "worried" about it is likewise just as Specious on a forum which is intended for arguing points of fact.

GB
 
For you, and a few others who seem worried about it, it's Religious.

For me, and others, it isn't.

We can agree to disagree.

No, we can only agree to let you go on with your mistaken beliefs. This isn't a disagreement, it is a case of your being wrong.
 
For you, and a few others who seem worried about it, it's Religious.

For me, and others, it isn't.

We can agree to disagree.
It's not so much different from asking: "Can participants in JREF forum discussions be assumed to be practitioners of critical thinking?"

(Answer: not necessarily).
 
It's not so much different from asking: "Can participants in JREF forum discussions be assumed to be practitioners of critical thinking?"

(Answer: not necessarily).

So, you ask if members of the JREF think in a particular way as an analogy. What are you trying to say about the way AA members think? That they all make the same mistakes of logic and change the meaning of words to suit their purpose?

We know that isn't true as many members of AA in this thread admit it is religious. It is only a select few who deny against all evidence that it is.

I think a better analogy is to ask: If a JREF member says they think critically but then, through non-critical examples, demonstrates otherwise is it the same as a AA member who claims to be atheist/agnostic but then, through expressed religious beliefs, demonstrates otherwise?

Answer: Absolutely.

Not only that but a select group of JREF members who are also members of AA demonstrate both non-critical thinking and religious belief, even though they profess to think critically and be agnostics/atheists.
 
For you, and a few others who seem worried about it, it's Religious.

Worried?? I can hardly maintain sufficient interest to participate in this thread. The reason I originally started posting was because I found it completely unbelievable that anyone would deny the obvious connection between AA and religion. Why some would deny this connection...I have no idea. Since those who maintain no connection between AA and religion DID NOT arrive at that conclusion by reason, no amount of reasoning will change their minds...making this thread a pointless endeavour.
 
The reason I originally started posting was because I found it completely unbelievable that anyone would deny the obvious connection between AA and religion.
The question at issue is not whether there is a connection between AA and religion.
 
Worried?? I can hardly maintain sufficient interest to participate in this thread. The reason I originally started posting was because I found it completely unbelievable that anyone would deny the obvious connection between AA and religion. Why some would deny this connection...I have no idea. Since those who maintain no connection between AA and religion DID NOT arrive at that conclusion by reason, no amount of reasoning will change their minds...making this thread a pointless endeavour.

Funnily enough, I actually see the reasoning that you, Belz et al are using. I also see how the evidence can readily suggest that AA would have to be religious.

However, there are a number of things that allow the end user to decide for themselves what they do with this one aspect of the program, these include:

- sufficient 'wriggle room' in the steps and literature for any member to make the decision on whether or not to apply the religious component to their own recovery.
- the steps are suggestions.
- the choice to mix and match what works for you.
- God can mean anything that might work for the individual (including the Christian god)
- the definition between spiritual and religious (not seen by those on your side)
- it is a spiritual program, not religious.

There are many more that actually answer the OP's question and show that while AA can certainly be religious, that does not meant that it is.


Now, on another matter, how's my respect coming? :)
 
Last edited:
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/168034cd45a83f2d06.jpg[/qimg]

So remind me again how exactly this doesn't qualify as "religious"?

For you, and a few others who seem worried about it, it's Religious.

For me, and others, it isn't.

We can agree to disagree.

The question is: does it fit the definition or not ?

Personally defining "red" to mean "blue" doesn't suddenly mean that a person's claim that "this apple is red" is false.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom