Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
By the way Alfie, I may be a resident of the US, but I was born and raised a Brit, and spent a couple of years in the Bahamas before being brought to the States by Mum. So nice try on the assumptions.

AA was founded in the US and has spread itself around the world through proselytizing. Just because AA's organization has spread around the globe doesn't make its language and doctrines any less religious.

You just happen to be fortunate enough to live in OZ, where (according to you at least) the Judicial System doesn't force people to attend AA (I'll try to confirm that with my Ozzie Cop internet pal).

And I DO give you credit for at least admitting that would be wrong.

However, that admission seems to me a tacit admission that AA is religious. Why else would it be wrong? Australia has it's own Establishment Clause in its Constitution, and I suspect the Government of Oz takes it more seriously than the US takes it.

GB
 
Last edited:
Got any evidence that AA is not religious?
Is the religiousity of AA a falsifiable proposition? What would accomplish that? Evidence of people not praying? How many would it take? And how could we know for sure that they weren't praying? A person whose lips weren't moving might be praying silently, and, conversely, a person might be mouthing words without actually meaning any of it -- is that still praying? If I happen to mention God once or twice immediately after having dropped a hammer on my toe, does that constitute adequate evidence that I am a theist?

I have little to no patience for this kind of crap.
I inferred as much; thanks for confirming.

I made a HUGE mistake by allowing Dymanic to goad me into a thread derail with HIS Pseudo-Philosophical Crap. Well screw that. It's back to Brass Tacks and Evidence for me.
So you're gonna hit the ol' implicit ignore button and start responding to everything by just jumping up and down repeating "Got any EVIDENCE, Got any EVIDENCE" over and over and reposting the 12 Steps for the Nth time and dismissing anyone who disagrees with you as disingenuous?

Now that's going to be a tough adjustment to make.

In the Case of AA, the Evidence truly does Speak for Itself.
Glad to also have confirmation that I have not misrepresented your position with the above analogy:

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the jury, the defendant's fingerprints are all over the murder weapon, therefore you have no choice but to find him guilty".
 
Nice try. I think people still reading the thread will see through your attempt at deception, however.
Those who speculate that AA is religious do see things not apparent to most.


You have succeeded, mind you, at erasing any doubt left in my mind about your dishonesty.
Doesn't take much to move you from speculation to a Belz Fact does it?
 
Is the religiousity of AA a falsifiable proposition?

YES!

What would accomplish that? Evidence of people not praying? How many would it take? And how could we know for sure that they weren't praying? A person whose lips weren't moving might be praying silently, and, conversely, a person might be mouthing words without actually meaning any of it -- is that still praying? If I happen to mention God once or twice immediately after having dropped a hammer on my toe, does that constitute adequate evidence that I am a theist?

Your Honour, I am NOT attempting to convict Dymanic of being a Theist. But I WILL prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he belongs to a Religious Organization known by the name of Alcoholics Anonymous.

How will I do that you ask? The same way I can prove beyond a Reasonable Doubt that many non-praying/praying silently/word-mouthing/God mentioning once or twice (especially after dropping hammers on their toes) people belong to other Religious Organizations such as The Catholic Church, The Nation of Islam, Vedic sects of Tantric Hinduism, The Southern Baptist Church, The Anglican Communion/ The Unitarian Universalists and many others far too numerous to mention.

Your Honour, I cannot rely on the word of individual adherents, as their own personal views vary widely from those who merely attend to demonstrate propriety without actually believing in either the doctrines and/or the Deity of their chosen Religious Organization, to those that Fundamentally believe that every word of their sacred texts must be taken as Literal Truth.

Thus, as with any religious organization, I must rely on the words of their Sacred Texts, and the Historical Record of the Organization, the Biographies of the founders and the texts of the Founders Letters and Ancillary Writings, and Legal Precedence including the upholding of the Second Circuit's decision by the US Supreme Court establishing the the Religiosity of AA.

Your Honour, I have submitted to you numerous briefs over the course of 61 pages of this thread containing this evidence, as has Tinyal and other members of our legal team.



In the Case of AA, the Evidence truly does Speak for Itself.
Glad to also have confirmation that I have not misrepresented your position with the above analogy:

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the jury, the defendant's fingerprints are all over the murder weapon, therefore you have no choice but to find him guilty".

Finally your Honour, the opposition attorney has deliberately misrepresented our case using specious analogies, and has deliberately discounted all the relevant evidence.

He claims that all we have are Fingerprints.

Yet as the submitted briefs have shown, our legal team also has DNA evidence, Ancillary Forensic Evidence, the Testimony of the Founders, the Historical Record, and Legal precedence.

GB
 
Forgive me for a slightly tangential post, but...

Magnus Huss coined the term 'alcoholism' in 1849. How did we get from that to the word 'alcoholic' to refer to a habitual inebriate?

'Alcoholic' should be reserved as a term describing the properties of a drink, not a person. We don't call a smoker a 'nicotinic', nor a junkie a 'heroinic'.
 
Forgive me for a slightly tangential post, but...

Magnus Huss coined the term 'alcoholism' in 1849. How did we get from that to the word 'alcoholic' to refer to a habitual inebriate?

'Alcoholic' should be reserved as a term describing the properties of a drink, not a person. We don't call a smoker a 'nicotinic', nor a junkie a 'heroinic'.

Welcome Lard2010!
 
Actually the question mark at the end should have been an indication that it was a question, not a "demand".

But I think there is a difference between a simple mistake and personal abuse. But that's just my opinion, I guess. If it had been just a "mistake", no doubt you would have left it in the thread - but I see it is gone. ;)

But like I said, apologising is what adults do. :rolleyes:


This is pathetic. Where's your public inquiry about AlBell's apologies to all those he directly attacked in this thread (which I quoted so there's no confusion)?

Or yours?

The hypocrisy astounds me sometimes.




Much of that was provided by those who are not alcoholics, and/or have not attended even one AA meeting.

What weight would you normally ascribe to this type of speculation?


This is a form of ad hominem attack; the merits of the argument are either valid or not. It is irrelevant who is proposing the argument. This also ignores the same (or similar) arguments made by those who are alcoholics/addicts and/or have attended one, a dozen, a hundred or thousands of AA meetings.



You have cited the big book as proof, yet wish not to look at other evidence that suggests otherwise - again, who is being dishonest? Moreover, the irony is not losyt on me that the big book proves your belief that AA is religious. The big book is one man's experience strength and hope. It is a nice historical document that documents the early recovery of the founders.

These statements are 100% true, and (unlike some) whilst I wish not to travel over old ground, it has already been shown that a HP does not need to be a deity, and spirituality has a variety of definitions.

AA has evolved since inception those early members are relative novices compared to those we have on offer today. AA is collective wisdom, not one man's experience.



The big book is far more than one man's experience, strength and hope. If that were true, there'd be only Chapter One. It's completely disingenuous to claim that AA has evolved since inception -- I've quoted the preface which explicitly states that the first 154 pages are not to be edited or changed and why they have not been changed.
 
This is pathetic. Where's your public inquiry about AlBell's apologies to all those he directly attacked in this thread (which I quoted so there's no confusion)?

Which one have you quoted?

Or yours?

For what exactly?

This is a form of ad hominem attack; the merits of the argument are either valid or not. It is irrelevant who is proposing the argument. This also ignores the same (or similar) arguments made by those who are alcoholics/addicts and/or have attended one, a dozen, a hundred or thousands of AA meetings.

If you consider that ad hom, I suggest you toughen up a bit. :boggled:

The big book is far more than one man's experience, strength and hope. If that were true, there'd be only Chapter One. It's completely disingenuous to claim that AA has evolved since inception -- I've quoted the preface which explicitly states that the first 154 pages are not to be edited or changed and why they have not been changed.

Are you saying AA hasn't evolved?
Or that Bill thought his way and word was the only one?

The 154 pages have not been changed in much the same way that the original text of (say) Darwins theory of evolution has not been changed. The book itslef is of historical and practical value, sure, but it is far from being some holy orders that you seem to imply it is.
 
The misconception that a life without a clear theme is not just as important as someone who decided to live their life around a theme is a frustrating thing to me, and even more sad to me than someone with no importance in their life. Choosing an arbitrary delusion isn't more meaningful than choosing to be liberated from arbitrary delusion, all that really seems important is if your life is important to you or not. A god or spiritual theme is not automatically important, and the only thing can make meaning meaningful is how important you find it to be.
 
Last edited:
Which one have you quoted?

Post 2322.



For what exactly?

For your poor behavior and sarcastic remarks that you later defended by claiming that you only give back what you receive. Not very adult like, IMO.



If you consider that ad hom, I suggest you toughen up a bit. :boggled:


It wasn't aimed at me -- or at least, I never read it as being aimed at me. It is a logical fallacy in trying to discredit an argument (that AA is religious) by stating that the person putting forth the argument isn't qualified to put forth that argument (because they aren't in AA nor are an alcoholic).



Are you saying AA hasn't evolved?
Or that Bill thought his way and word was the only one?

The 154 pages have not been changed in much the same way that the original text of (say) Darwins theory of evolution has not been changed. The book itslef is of historical and practical value, sure, but it is far from being some holy orders that you seem to imply it is.


You've pointed out many times that you find it hard to believe that in the United States, there are people who believe just that -- that the big book is a book of holy orders. Nevertheless, there isn't a monolithic World Organization regarding Darwin and his book which has steadfastly refused to change anything about the first 154 pages even though the statements that have been made about "changing the big book to more accurately represent the membership" is seemingly factually incorrect. (There are no stories of atheists for example and I've never read one story about a so-called agnostic who didn't convert to a belief in God. And by "stories" I'm referring to the AA Grapevine as well as the big book itself, printed by the AA World Organization.)
 
So we should change Darwin's book now because the theory has evolved and grown? Because people have piggy-backed their own ideas on the original. Or does Darwin set down a set of beliefs that can be expanded?

On the grapevive issue, I would suggest you aren't looking hard enough nor in enough places, if nothing ever showed an atheist or agnostic perspective. Indeed, there are stories right in this thread.

And on giving what I get. Too bad.
That said, if someone takes offence and I did not intend it, you may have noted I make an apology - I seem to recall giving you one too (I may be wrong). As I say, that's what adults do when they are wrong and admit it. I feel no need to apologise to someone for giving them a bit if lip when I respond in kind, that may not be adult, but I am certainly not sorry about it.
You seem to be mistaking me for a xstian that happily turns the other cheek; that is not me mate.
 
Last edited:
Are there some people who actually quote from Darwin's book anymore, and use it in arguments for evolution ?

You tell me; I tend not to get involved with evolution discussions. The use of the book was simply an example. Can I get you a net?
 
So we should change Darwin's book now because the theory has evolved and grown? Because people have piggy-backed their own ideas on the original. Or does Darwin set down a set of beliefs that can be expanded?


I don't know much of his book at all; certainly I know less about Darwin's book than I do Bill W's.



On the grapevive issue, I would suggest you aren't looking hard enough nor in enough places, if nothing ever showed an atheist or agnostic perspective. Indeed, there are stories right in this thread.


Do you read or have you ever thoroughly read the AA Grapevine? That's specifically what I'm referring to, not posters in this thread. I'm specifying the AA Grapevine as it is an Official AA World Organization monthly publication which, so far to my knowledge, has never printed a story by a successful (i.e., in sobriety) atheist nor an agnostic who did not also go onto rediscovering God as his/her higher power.




And on giving what I get. Too bad.
That said, if someone takes offence and I did not intend it, you may have noted I make an apology - I seem to recall giving you one too (I may be wrong). As I say, that's what adults do when they are wrong and admit it. I feel no need to apologise to someone for giving them a bit if lip when I respond in kind, that may not be adult, but I am certainly not sorry about it.
You seem to be mistaking me for a xstian that happily turns the other cheek; that is not me mate.


This is the second time you've done the old "I'm not what you think I am" line on me when I have never claimed nor thought that you were a Xian. In most respects, I really couldn't care less that you attack others -- what I do care about is when you hypocritically expect me to apologize for something which you clearly are not willing to do and then imply that I'm not being adultlike in not apologizing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom