In my experience on internet debates, the first guy to start name-dropping Famous Philosophers without actually stating the relevance of the Famous Philosopher's ideas to his/her arguments is in an intellectual tail-spin, and clutching at straws to support their arguments.
You may not have noticed that during the course of this debate I have, at various times when responding to you and other posters, referred to Plato, Descartes, Wittgenstein, Dennett, and probably two or three others I can't remember off the top of my head. Chalmers maybe. Each time, I did so either directly, as a specific part of an argument I was making, or indirectly, as a way of indicating that the landscape we're blundering about upon features some well established and clearly marked paths which nonetheless seem to manage to escape the attention of certain participants here. The above reference to "fragments of so-and-so" was an oblique reference to my having already introduced those arguments, but if I expected YOU to get that, well, once again: what
could I have been thinking? I have not always been among the most prolific of posters on this forum, but I do have a history of extolling the virtues of Philosophy (in particular the Philosophy of Science) and this despite my making no claims to being anything but a dabbler in that field myself.
Yes, I
will argue that despite all it has to offer, modern science does at some point hit a wall beyond which "I don't know anything, you don't know anything" is a fair description of the current state of human knowledge -- and I think it is important to recognize that this wall is encountered no matter which direction we're travelling in; the search for first causes ultimately bottoms out, and beyond that we are forced to rely on axioms
which, by their very nature, cannot be tested empirically. Whether you like it or not (and I'm sure you don't), there still are some Mysteries of Reality which as yet cannot be examined with
anything but Logic Alone.
It's very telling that Socrates was the first name you chose to drop. I don't at all dismiss Socrates out of hand. He was a brilliant philosopher, and YES, he was indeed a Master Sophist. I chose to cut and paste a brief off the internet because it was much easier than digging up my philosophy books, finding the relevant passages and typing them out.
I'm not surprised that you chose the easier course of action. Continue to make it easy on yourself and you can expect that the benefit you will obtain from participating in these discussions will be commensurate with that level of effort.
Because application of the word "Sophist" appears to be among your favorite ways of insulting other posters, and because it also appears that
carefully selecting definitions broad enough as to include whatever you wish to include is among your favorite methods of argument, I think this matter of you including Socrates among "Sophists" may warrant closer examination.
The first of two definitions currently at the top of the Wikpipedia page on that has sophistry as "a specious argument used for deceiving someone", and whether or not that's where you got your understanding of what constitutes
sophistry, this is clearly the way you use the word. The motive --
deception -- is a vital aspect of that definition. Your attempts to refute AA's explicit statement that it is not a religious organization (and the anecdotal evidence indicating that many AA members agree)
begins with a conclusion: "AA
is religious" -- and everything that follows is an exercise in affirming the consequent. Because AA is religious, it seeks converts, and to better accomplish that it lies about being religious, and anyone who disagrees and is able to do so persuasively is a
sophist.
That's pretty airtight, but I think you'll have a much tougher time running that game on Socrates. His rhetorical skill alone is not enough to convict him of sophistry; once again,
it goes to motive. Socrates surely possessed the skill to gain political or economic advantage from his ability to argue persuasively even when his was the weaker argument (the very essence of sophistry). Now all you need to do is find even one single instance of his having ever done that. I wonder if you're familiar with the dialogue with Protagoras in which Socrates ends up
reversing his position on the question of whether virtue can be taught? Is
that something that easily fits in with your definition of "Sophist"?