Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I mean who in their right mind is going to argue with Socrates, Hume, Kant, and Wittgenstein?

Game over right? Oooo, the famous philosopher card!!!
Yeah, gee, what could I have been thinking? Like this is some kind of Philosophy forum, or what? It may be that I am not in my right mind, but it happens that of the points put forward by those four philosophers, the ones I feel that I fully understand I often find that I do not fully agree with. As I'm sure you would too, if you ever took the time to actually read any of the relevant material. But if there is one thing you've made glaringly obvious in 58 pages, it is that you've never done that.

Well, whaddya know? At the top of Dymanic's famous philosopher list is Socrates, the Master of Sophistry himself.
Before you decide to dismiss everything ever said by the father of western philosophy, consider this tip: the internet is a wealth of misinformation. Not that it matters much for you, I suppose. For a guy who would write Socrates off as a Sophist and offer evidence of that in the form of a pasted snippet that he cannot interpret accurately enough to recognize that it does not actually support that conclusion, one source of information is probably about as good as another.

Evidence, Schmevidence. Who needs it?
It's pretty comical that you still don't get this: we are both examining evidence. In fact, just as the opposing attorneys in a criminal trial do, we are examining the same evidence. We are reaching different conclusions because I add an important step you like to skip: examining the logic as well as the evidence.
 
But no apology?



*psssst* Hey, Al. I think he's talking to you...

Thanks for sharing your usual mis-understanding of the written word.
At least you believe she agrees with your biases.

You've fooled me until now thinking that you might have something worth contributing.
Thanks for straightening that out.

Any AA group that wanted to change to something you propose would be a confederacy of dunces.
You could always start you own organization.
Can I call the waaaaambulance for you?

Physician, heal thyself.

Edited by Locknar: 
Content removed, breach of Rule 12.
 
We are reaching different conclusions because I add an important step you like to skip: examining the logic as well as the evidence.


Wait, what? You're claiming that he's not applying logic to the evidence that has been presented to reach the conclusion that the AA organization has a religious nature?

How is his logic unsound exactly?
 
Well I guess you are making a distinction between is AA doctrine religious or is how it is practiced religious.

I just cant split hairs like you guys do nor do I see the need.

If it's theistic no matter how diversified the theism is, and all are using it to a common goal, then it's religious. call me simple.

Apparently the courts thought it's reference to God and Higher Power were enough to protect from it via the first amendment which says religion, not theism or spiritual.

It is really technically down to the molecule WHATEVER to win the argument religious?

Who gives a ***** ?

As Belz brought up long ago, if AA was non-religious atheists and agnostics wouldn't have to perform word magic to fit in.

Your point is well made. AA apologists use the same smoke and mirrors to convince people AA isn't religious as religious apologists use. One simply has to keep in mind that one simple fact: If AA wasn't religious, they wouldn't need the smoke and mirrors. The smoke and mirrors are evidence that AA is religious.
 
Exactly - you are the walking epitome of why AA is not religious.
An HP is not needed, never was, never will be. It is but one tool that can be used in a framework of many many tools.

So you really quit drinking on your own without any HP?
 
So you really quit drinking on your own without any HP?

No.
As I explained before, I adopted a kind of an amalgam of the laws of nature coupled with the fellowship itself.
My sponsor pointed out I needed to trust something or someone else apart from my own (bad) insticts.
 
So you really quit drinking on your own without any HP?

Nobody quits without changes but theistic powers to make them arent necessary IMHO.
Not drinking for 90 days is pretty powerful change
4th and 5th produce sometimes powerful change
Additional knowledge can change perspective obviously
Change in environment, people you associate with
A collection of changes

The alcoholic loop is tough to break but its all change isn't it?

People who truly want to quit, really want to change. They will find what they need when they start looking. Imaginary friends not necessary but some real ones certainly do help.

I too turned to the laws of nature and spent plenty time in it looking at them.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, gee, what could I have been thinking? Like this is some kind of Philosophy forum, or what? It may be that I am not in my right mind, but it happens that of the points put forward by those four philosophers, the ones I feel that I fully understand I often find that I do not fully agree with. As I'm sure you would too, if you ever took the time to actually read any of the relevant material. But if there is one thing you've made glaringly obvious in 58 pages, it is that you've never done that.

Before you decide to dismiss everything ever said by the father of western philosophy, consider this tip: the internet is a wealth of misinformation. Not that it matters much for you, I suppose. For a guy who would write Socrates off as a Sophist and offer evidence of that in the form of a pasted snippet that he cannot interpret accurately enough to recognize that it does not actually support that conclusion, one source of information is probably about as good as another.

It's pretty comical that you still don't get this: we are both examining evidence. In fact, just as the opposing attorneys in a criminal trial do, we are examining the same evidence. We are reaching different conclusions because I add an important step you like to skip: examining the logic as well as the evidence.

In my experience on internet debates, the first guy to start name-dropping Famous Philosophers without actually stating the relevance of the Famous Philosopher's ideas to his/her arguments is in an intellectual tail-spin, and clutching at straws to support their arguments.

And more often than not, the debater is hoping that simply name-dropping the Famous Philosopher is enough to stump his/her opponent. And if the name-dropper can drop enough names of famous Philosophers all at once, it should be enough to derail the topic into a completely irrelevant Red Herring. The Name-Dropper is also hoping to strut his/her intellectual superiority in a manner a Male Peacock would be proud of.

And I just LOVE that arrogant presumption that you and other Name-droppers display in spades, the presumption that your opponent is completely unfamiliar with the names being dropped and the ideas they espoused. Why do I love it so much? Because more often than not the Name-dropper reveals more about their own arguments than they care to openly admit.

It's very telling that Socrates was the first name you chose to drop. I don't at all dismiss Socrates out of hand. He was a brilliant philosopher, and YES, he was indeed a Master Sophist. I chose to cut and paste a brief off the internet because it was much easier than digging up my philosophy books, finding the relevant passages and typing them out.

Fortunately, I am more than familiar enough with Socrates and his methods that I was able to find a brief that accurately summed up the aspects of Socratic Method that were relevant to the topic at hand.

I am a big "fan" of Logic and Philosophy--though my preference is for the Eastern Schools of Philosophical Thought, as they are not so stuck on Rigid Rhetorical Rules as the Greeks were. The Eastern Philosophies in that sense seem far more pragmatic and focussed on philosophy's relevance to the human condition.

Socrates, and a few other Greek philosophers delighted with the Sophist Method, sometimes seem to convey a school of thought that suggests that Logic and Philosophy could be completely divorced from reality; that Logic Alone could solve the Mysteries of Reality, or at the very least demonstrate that the Philosopher's Rhetorical Opponent was an unworthy buffoon.

So, because you love to completely disregard the parts of your debating opponent's arguments that bely your deliberate misstatements of your opponent's points, I'll repeat myself for the benefit of those attempting to follow this thread:

Logic is a desired practice, but Logic without a solid basis in Existential Fact and Empirical Evidence is merely an exercise in RHETORIC that actually proves nothing but the rhetorical skill of the practitioner. And I must applaud your rather exceptional rhetorical skills.

It's just too bad that you choose not to provide a solid foundation of evidence to back up your rhetoric. The best you have managed to cough up is anecdote, analogies based on ONE fictional movie (an analogy which actually undermines your entire thesis), A line or two in AA's literature that is completely and utterly belied by AA's Paragraphs and Books full of Religious Language and Doctrine, and stuff you just make up on the spot.

You have yet to indicate that you are examining any evidence at all. You certainly haven't provided any evidence of significance. It's no wonder that more and more Courts are deciding that Judicial remanding of defendants to AA is a violation of the Establishment clause if Prosecution Lawyers are relying on the same Rhetorical Crap that you spew.

So excuse me if I'm not suitably impressed by you resorting to the Famous Philosopher Card. :p

GB
 
Last edited:
By extension, because one lives in the USA, going on averages, The US is also religious?

Yes.

Please answer my question.

As I conceded later and you seem to be confirming here - there are social laws also. You are also supporting our argument in earlier pages that that just because some social norms (for want of another expression) are adopted by a religion, that does not make them exclusively religious.

As I say, you seem to be supporting me here. I am sure it was not intentional, but thanks anyway. :)

It's just an impression.
 
With allowances for local variation, my observation is that the AA average is "spiritual but not religious", and I would have to assume that while individual members define "spiritual" in a myriad of different ways, they're all using roughly the same definition of "religious" -- a definition which describes a system of practices centered on beliefs with the three essential qualities I have listed: specific; shared; supernatural.

And the distinction with "spiritual" is, what, already ?

My initial question was simply meant to illustrate that, if you ask each AA member what their higher power is, I think you'll get more than double-majority "god"s. It'd be an interesting survey. But even if we got 90%, we'd still get folks here saying AA is not religious.
 
Well I see that philosophers just cannot escape their human trappings!

Do not do to others what angers you if done to you by others.
Socrates

Thou shouldst eat to live; not live to eat.
Socrates

Beware lest you lose the substance by grasping at the shadow.
Aesop

There's more to the truth than just the facts.
Author Unknown

When the student is ready, the master appears.
Buddhist Proverb

There are some remedies worse than the disease.
Publilius Syrus

It requires a great deal of faith for a man to be cured by his own placebos.
John L. McClenahan

You can't wake a person who is pretending to be asleep.
Navajo Proverb

One day, someone showed me a glass of water that was half full. And he said, "Is it half full or half empty?" So I drank the water. No more problem.
Alexander Jodorowsky

Reason and faith are both banks of the same river.
Doménico Cieri Estrada

This concludes a quick lesson in philosophy that doesn't seem to have much in common with benevolent bludgeoning.
 
Last edited:
Wait, what? You're claiming that he's not applying logic to the evidence that has been presented to reach the conclusion that the AA organization has a religious nature?

How is his logic unsound exactly?
To answer that in a brief and very general way, I'd say GB's argument reduces to something like:

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the jury, the defendant's fingerprints are all over the murder weapon, therefore you have no choice but to find him guilty".
 
In my experience on internet debates, the first guy to start name-dropping Famous Philosophers without actually stating the relevance of the Famous Philosopher's ideas to his/her arguments is in an intellectual tail-spin, and clutching at straws to support their arguments.
You may not have noticed that during the course of this debate I have, at various times when responding to you and other posters, referred to Plato, Descartes, Wittgenstein, Dennett, and probably two or three others I can't remember off the top of my head. Chalmers maybe. Each time, I did so either directly, as a specific part of an argument I was making, or indirectly, as a way of indicating that the landscape we're blundering about upon features some well established and clearly marked paths which nonetheless seem to manage to escape the attention of certain participants here. The above reference to "fragments of so-and-so" was an oblique reference to my having already introduced those arguments, but if I expected YOU to get that, well, once again: what could I have been thinking? I have not always been among the most prolific of posters on this forum, but I do have a history of extolling the virtues of Philosophy (in particular the Philosophy of Science) and this despite my making no claims to being anything but a dabbler in that field myself.

Yes, I will argue that despite all it has to offer, modern science does at some point hit a wall beyond which "I don't know anything, you don't know anything" is a fair description of the current state of human knowledge -- and I think it is important to recognize that this wall is encountered no matter which direction we're travelling in; the search for first causes ultimately bottoms out, and beyond that we are forced to rely on axioms which, by their very nature, cannot be tested empirically. Whether you like it or not (and I'm sure you don't), there still are some Mysteries of Reality which as yet cannot be examined with anything but Logic Alone.

It's very telling that Socrates was the first name you chose to drop. I don't at all dismiss Socrates out of hand. He was a brilliant philosopher, and YES, he was indeed a Master Sophist. I chose to cut and paste a brief off the internet because it was much easier than digging up my philosophy books, finding the relevant passages and typing them out.
I'm not surprised that you chose the easier course of action. Continue to make it easy on yourself and you can expect that the benefit you will obtain from participating in these discussions will be commensurate with that level of effort.

Because application of the word "Sophist" appears to be among your favorite ways of insulting other posters, and because it also appears that carefully selecting definitions broad enough as to include whatever you wish to include is among your favorite methods of argument, I think this matter of you including Socrates among "Sophists" may warrant closer examination.

The first of two definitions currently at the top of the Wikpipedia page on that has sophistry as "a specious argument used for deceiving someone", and whether or not that's where you got your understanding of what constitutes sophistry, this is clearly the way you use the word. The motive -- deception -- is a vital aspect of that definition. Your attempts to refute AA's explicit statement that it is not a religious organization (and the anecdotal evidence indicating that many AA members agree) begins with a conclusion: "AA is religious" -- and everything that follows is an exercise in affirming the consequent. Because AA is religious, it seeks converts, and to better accomplish that it lies about being religious, and anyone who disagrees and is able to do so persuasively is a sophist.

That's pretty airtight, but I think you'll have a much tougher time running that game on Socrates. His rhetorical skill alone is not enough to convict him of sophistry; once again, it goes to motive. Socrates surely possessed the skill to gain political or economic advantage from his ability to argue persuasively even when his was the weaker argument (the very essence of sophistry). Now all you need to do is find even one single instance of his having ever done that. I wonder if you're familiar with the dialogue with Protagoras in which Socrates ends up reversing his position on the question of whether virtue can be taught? Is that something that easily fits in with your definition of "Sophist"?
 
Last edited:
And the distinction with "spiritual" is, what, already ?
Pretty subjective, for one thing. Instead of reposting the significant chunk of this thread dedicated to that question (including arguments that "spirituality", for some, does not include either shared or supernatural elements), I'd rather refer you to the Wikipedia article on "spirituality", and if that raises any specific questions you feel are worth considering (or, more likely, reconsidering), put them up.

My initial question was simply meant to illustrate that, if you ask each AA member what their higher power is, I think you'll get more than double-majority "god"s.
Can we get a ruling on whether this observation can be entered as evidence, or is it a bit too speculative for that?
 
Pearls before swine, Dymanic. :(
Well, you know, I don't have cable, so the closest thing to entertainment I get sometimes is watching stuff pour out of my head onto a screen and then re-reading it to see if I can learn anything. I often close my contribution at an AA meeting with a (stolen) quip: "Thanks a lot for letting me share. I really enjoyed what I had to say". The truth in that is what makes it funny. After more that twenty years, I'm still my favorite speaker.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom