Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Whether you like it or not (and I'm sure you don't), there still are some Mysteries of Reality which as yet cannot be examined with anything but Logic Alone.

We're getting off topic, but: Such as ?

Pretty subjective, for one thing.

That was my impression as well. I, for one, see religion as a mere extension of spirituality. Both are woo, mind you.

Can we get a ruling on whether this observation can be entered as evidence, or is it a bit too speculative for that?

Speculation, but I think it's a reasonable one. I doubt any actual survey was made about this.
 
So nothing anecdotal is OK. But pure unadulterated speculation is.

Call it an educated guess.

That's what adults do when they make a mistake.

It's not something you do but something you demand. Demanding an apology for simple mistakes is more the domain of adolescents.

I think we could accept that if Hazelton ever, anywhere, at any time had literature placed in AA meetings, but guess what? They don't. :)

 
That was my impression as well. I, for one, see religion as a mere extension of spirituality. Both are woo, mind you.

So in terms of the spiritual definition in wiki, these are all woo?

[1] an inner path enabling a person to discover the essence of their being; or the “deepest values and meanings by which people live.”

So your personal essense, value, or meaning to your life are all woo?

[2] Spiritual practices, including meditation, prayer and contemplation, are intended to develop an individual's inner life; such practices often lead to an experience of connectedness with a larger reality, yielding a more comprehensive self; with other individuals or the human community; with nature or the cosmos; or with the divine realm.

You never meditate nor contemplate. Never explore yourself nor the human community around you as it is all woo?

[3] Spirituality is often experienced as a source of inspiration or orientation in life.

You have no orientation or inspiration in life as any personal gathering of same you might have would be woo?

[4] It can encompass belief in immaterial realities or experiences of the immanent or transcendent nature of the world.

I imagine this is the one you really object to.

Call it an educated guess.

No, I think I will call it an uneducated, blind stab in the dark.
Unless of course you can give us the calculations for your 90% for us to scrutinise.

Did you know that 74.3% of all statistics are made up on the spot? ;)

It's not something you do but something you demand. Demanding an apology for simple mistakes is more the domain of adolescents.

Actually the question mark at the end should have been an indication that it was a question, not a "demand".

But I think there is a difference between a simple mistake and personal abuse. But that's just my opinion, I guess. If it had been just a "mistake", no doubt you would have left it in the thread - but I see it is gone. ;)

But like I said, apologising is what adults do. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Keep it civil, folks, and discuss the topic, not each other.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
It's only an insult if it's not true.
So (speaking strictly hypothetically you understand) if I were to say, "You're an idiot", that wouldn't be an insult -- or at least I might not think so, but you probably would -- and the mods would almost surely see it as having enough of the appearances of a genuine insult to justify ruling it a violation of rule 0, and in reaching that decision they probably wouldn't even bother trying to tease out all of the possible nuances, either. (In very much the same way that a judge might arrive at a decision on, say, the religiousity of AA). But I'm still a little uncertain as to whether these predictions help to resolve the question of whether it has been objectively established that all insults are false (/no insults are true).

And I'm very uncertain whether it helps to support your contention that labelling my arguments "sophistry" is not an insult. In making that judgement for myself, do I need insight into your motives? I mean, I'm sitting here thinking that I really do mean the things I've said here, but I also realize that a lot of your argument rests on your ability to make penetrating observations regarding what's really going on inside the heads of a bunch of other people (specifically, AA members), even when it does not match what they may have to say about that (especially then). I do not claim to possess any special skill at this myself, however, so I have no good way of determining whether you really believe that I'm being disingenuous or not. The plethora of possible layers makes this tricky, doesn't it? For all I know, you may think that I think I'm being sincere, but that you know more about that than I do, in which case the "sophistry" charge would stick. I have a couple of ex-wives who claimed to be able to perform this trick, and I'd have to allow that from time to time they might even have been right. But I have a hard time seeing you as knowing me well enough for that. Can we make this determination without peeling back all of those layers? Can you point to a specific post of mine as evidence of my disingenuous motives, or do you consider that to be something that just logically follows from the fact that I consistently question the methodology you use in reaching your conclusions?

Besides I was only attacking your argument
To be sure, you've attacked my arguments. But an attack on an argument is really not necessarily quite the same thing as a refutation of an argument, is it? Maybe your best bet would be to quit saying that my arguments are sophistry and to begin demonstrating why that is the case.

No, actually it demonstrated that you poorly analyzed a Dennet quote most likely taken out of context.
Amazing how you can know that my analysis was poor even without knowing for sure whether I took it out of context.
 
Yes, but until the premises are verified it all amounts to nothing.
Uh... wait:

Speculation, but I think it's a reasonable one. I doubt any actual survey was made about this.
Reasonable, but amounting to nothing because the premises are unverified? Is there a general policy we can agree on?
 
So (speaking strictly hypothetically you understand) if I were to say, "You're an idiot", that wouldn't be an insult -- or at least I might not think so, but you probably would -- and the mods would almost surely see it as having enough of the appearances of a genuine insult to justify ruling it a violation of rule 0, and in reaching that decision they probably wouldn't even bother trying to tease out all of the possible nuances, either. (In very much the same way that a judge might arrive at a decision on, say, the religiousity of AA). But I'm still a little uncertain as to whether these predictions help to resolve the question of whether it has been objectively established that all insults are false (/no insults are true).

And I'm very uncertain whether it helps to support your contention that labelling my arguments "sophistry" is not an insult. In making that judgement for myself, do I need insight into your motives? I mean, I'm sitting here thinking that I really do mean the things I've said here, but I also realize that a lot of your argument rests on your ability to make penetrating observations regarding what's really going on inside the heads of a bunch of other people (specifically, AA members), even when it does not match what they may have to say about that (especially then). I do not claim to possess any special skill at this myself, however, so I have no good way of determining whether you really believe that I'm being disingenuous or not. The plethora of possible layers makes this tricky, doesn't it? For all I know, you may think that I think I'm being sincere, but that you know more about that than I do, in which case the "sophistry" charge would stick. I have a couple of ex-wives who claimed to be able to perform this trick, and I'd have to allow that from time to time they might even have been right. But I have a hard time seeing you as knowing me well enough for that. Can we make this determination without peeling back all of those layers? Can you point to a specific post of mine as evidence of my disingenuous motives, or do you consider that to be something that just logically follows from the fact that I consistently question the methodology you use in reaching your conclusions?[

To be sure, you've attacked my arguments. But an attack on an argument is really not necessarily quite the same thing as a refutation of an argument, is it? Maybe your best bet would be to quit saying that my arguments are sophistry and to begin demonstrating why that is the case.

Every time I call your arguments sophistry, I present the analysis of why they are so. You, on the other hand, make assertions without providing evidence, which leads me to question your analysis.

I don't like saying that people are lying, but the fact that you continually misrepresent my arguments leads me to conclude that your arguments are disingenuous.

Amazing how you can know that my analysis was poor even without knowing for sure whether I took it out of context.

I do not own a copy of the particular Dennet book you quoted from. And I made it clear that my analysis of the quote was based on taking it at face value in and of itself.

I think this derail has gone on long enough. Please explain how your post demonstrates that AA is not religious. And please provide some evidence.

GB
 
Last edited:
So your personal essense, value, or meaning to your life are all woo?

I'd actually call that definition word salad, instead. "an inner path enabling a person to discover the essence of their being; or the “deepest values and meanings by which people live.” " What in the blue hell does that mean ?

You never meditate nor contemplate. Never explore yourself nor the human community around you as it is all woo?

Again, what does "explore yourself" mean ? I never meditate because I see it as a waste of time. I don't pray because I don't believe in spirits or gods. I analyse. That seems much more productive. I don't know from where you pulled those definitions but they sure sound new-agey to me.

You have no orientation or inspiration in life as any personal gathering of same you might have would be woo?

Nice try. Read that definition again: "Spirituality is often experienced as a source of inspiration or orientation in life." It took me a fraction of a second to understand that your comment had nothing to do with it. Spirituality is a source of inspiration. Lack of spirituality doesn't mean lack of inspiration. Or, if you want an analogy, a car is a means of transportation, but not using a car doesn't mean you can't get from point A to point B.

I imagine this is the one you really object to.

That's the classical one, but all of the definitions you gave are related: belief in things nonexistent.

No, I think I will call it an uneducated, blind stab in the dark.
Unless of course you can give us the calculations for your 90% for us to scrutinise.

Didn't I say double-majority ? I always understood it to mean 75%+1, but I could be wrong.

Actually the question mark at the end should have been an indication that it was a question, not a "demand".

So if you tell someone "so you're an idiot ?", the question mark makes it not an insult ?

But I think there is a difference between a simple mistake and personal abuse. But that's just my opinion, I guess. If it had been just a "mistake", no doubt you would have left it in the thread - but I see it is gone. ;)

Huh ?

But like I said, apologising is what adults do. :rolleyes:

Yes, but when it's expected it becomes silly.
 
Yes. Both were speculatory.
We can agree the speculation that AA is religious remains just that: speculation.

Much of that was provided by those who are not alcoholics, and/or have not attended even one AA meeting.

What weight would you normally ascribe to this type of speculation?
 
Last edited:
Every time I call your arguments sophistry, I present the analysis of why they are so.
Give one example.

I don't like saying that people are lying, but the fact that you continually misrepresent my arguments leads me to conclude that your arguments are disingenuous.
And the fact that you so seldom attempt to address my arguments directly by stating in clear and explicit terms exactly where and how I have "misrepresented" your arguments (or showing how my arguments are contradictory, or circular, or based on any one of a number of logical fallacies) -- choosing instead to respond in very general terms exactly as you have done here leads me to the conclusion that you simply cannot argue your case on any other basis but to attempt to cast broad aspersions upon the integrity and sincerity of the opponent.

I think this derail has gone on long enough.
Oh, so the sophistry thing is a derail now? After all the energy you've put into it? As if it were not at this point essentially your main objection to my counterarguments? Fine. Glad to hear it.

Please explain how your post demonstrates that AA is not religious.
It calls into question a key basis for your claim that AA is religious: the ability to know what others are thinking.

I do not own a copy of the particular Dennet book you quoted from. And I made it clear that my analysis of the quote was based on taking it at face value in and of itself.
Oh, the Dennett book I quoted from? Unbelievable. You know, GB, the actual history of that exchange IS still up there in black and white, TEXTUAL EVIDENCE of the standard to which you hold yourself. Responding to another poster, I provided a very well know quote by Daniel Dennett, one which can easily stand on its own, sans context. I'm reposting that partly because I feel that it bears on much of what we've been discussing over the last few pages:

"Scientists sometimes deceive themselves into thinking that philosophical ideas are only, at best, decorations or parasitic commentaries on the hard, objective triumphs of science, and that they themselves are immune to the confusions that philosophers devote their lives to dissolving. But there is no such thing as philosophy-free science, there is only science whose philosophical baggage is taken on board without examination."

You jumped on that, saying "You disingenuously quote Daniel Dennet...", (offering no support beyond bald assertion for this attack on my character) and then -- after first acknowledging, "the quote you use has a measure of truth to it" -- YOU proceded to provide some quotes you snatched from an online review of a Dennett book which was not even the one my quote came from: "In Breaking the Spell, the book in which Dennet suggests...". You added some brief commentary which, beyond some feeble attempts at condescention regarding Dennett's "tepid qualifications" and his "timidity", was largely content-free. Now you're selling that as an "analysis"? An anal cyst would have as much value to me.
 
Now you're selling that as an "analysis"? An anal cyst would have as much value to me.

Funniest thing in this thread. :D

Just cruising through that post and having the benefit of seeing one of GBs posts, it seems to me he is still trying to prove whether or not AA is religious. The OP does not ask that question. In actual fact, the OP has been answered time and again in the words of members "it is a spiritual program, not religious", or similar.

How it works also outlines:

The point is, that we are willing to grow along spiritual lines. The principles we have set down are guides to progress. We claim spiritual progress rather than spiritual perfection.
 
Give one example.

Nearly every post that is a response to yours has an example.

And the fact that you so seldom attempt to address my arguments directly by stating in clear and explicit terms exactly where and how I have "misrepresented" your arguments (or showing how my arguments are contradictory, or circular, or based on any one of a number of logical fallacies) -- choosing instead to respond in very general terms exactly as you have done here leads me to the conclusion that you simply cannot argue your case on any other basis but to attempt to cast broad aspersions upon the integrity and sincerity of the opponent.

Actually I have, in nearly every post which I have claimed you've misrepresented my points, I have demonstrated how you have misrepresented them. it's exactly this kind of crap that you pull that leads me to conclude that you are lying.

And no, I'm not going to repost all my posts to prove my point. You know as well as I do that I have made my points clear.

Oh, so the sophistry thing is a derail now? After all the energy you've put into it? As if it were not at this point essentially your main objection to my counterarguments? Fine. Glad to hear it.

It is when after a couple of exchanges it offers no more value to the thread. You've made your points, I've made mine. Anyone following our arguments can judge for themselves who has the better argument.

It calls into question a key basis for your claim that AA is religious: the ability to know what others are thinking.

See...that right there is a lie. I have NEVER based my claim that AA is religious on being psychic. My claim is based on Textual Analysis, and evidence of the founders' intent sometimes in their own words and sometimes as provided by other AA historians. You yourself have pointed out that I am nothing if not consistent in sticking to the Textual Evidence.

Oh, the Dennett book I quoted from? Unbelievable. You know, GB, the actual history of that exchange IS still up there in black and white, TEXTUAL EVIDENCE of the standard to which you hold yourself. Responding to another poster, I provided a very well know quote by Daniel Dennett, one which can easily stand on its own, sans context. I'm reposting that partly because I feel that it bears on much of what we've been discussing over the last few pages:

"Scientists sometimes deceive themselves into thinking that philosophical ideas are only, at best, decorations or parasitic commentaries on the hard, objective triumphs of science, and that they themselves are immune to the confusions that philosophers devote their lives to dissolving. But there is no such thing as philosophy-free science, there is only science whose philosophical baggage is taken on board without examination."

You jumped on that, saying "You disingenuously quote Daniel Dennet...", (offering no support beyond bald assertion for this attack on my character) and then -- after first acknowledging, "the quote you use has a measure of truth to it" -- YOU proceded to provide some quotes you snatched from an online review of a Dennett book which was not even the one my quote came from: "In Breaking the Spell, the book in which Dennet suggests...". You added some brief commentary which, beyond some feeble attempts at condescention regarding Dennett's "tepid qualifications" and his "timidity", was largely content-free. Now you're selling that as an "analysis"? An anal cyst would have as much value to me.

Yes, it is still there. That's why I thought it worth reposting that one particular exchange, because it illustrates my points very well.

I don't have the particular book you quoted from, so I performed a brief textual analysis of the quote as it stood (just like you say I should).

I suggested it was disingenuous for you to quote Dennett as an Authority, because the book I DO HAVE has several quotes that directly contradict your claims that were actually relevant to this thread:

Namely, his clear definition of religion which completely contradicts your attempts to define it out of existence, and his quote from Freud which illustrates precisely the attempt of "philosophers" such as yourself who try to define words out of existence.

Now shall we continue to bore people with our tit for tat, or are you ever going to provide evidence that AA is not religious.

GB
 
Now shall we continue to bore people with our tit for tat, or are you ever going to provide evidence that AA is not religious.

That is not what the OP requests now is it?:rolleyes:
AAers are under no obligation to prove AA is or is not religious, this is a tangent you have decided to run down in some type of evangelistic pursuit.

The OP asks why people insist AA is not religious.

This has again been answered time and again, and simply said most of us consider it to be "spiritual, not religious". But you seem to refuse to accept this simple fact (definitions aside).

I have provided some definitions of spirituality that has been disregarded out of hand by some. It matters not that they have or do. What does matter is that AA members do not, they see the differences and nuances within the word that escapes the bigoted and/or hate filled.

But I see that your line of argument has not changed in some 50 pages, so back to ignore you go. :)
 
Last edited:
That is not what the OP requests now is it?:rolleyes:
AAers are under no obligation to prove AA is or is not religious, this is a tangent you have decided to run down in some type of evangelistic pursuit.

The OP asks why people insist AA is not religious.

This has again been answered time and again, and simply said most of us consider it to be "spiritual, not religious". But you seem to refuse to accept this simple fact (definitions aside).

I have provided some definitions of spirituality that has been disregarded out of hand by some. It matters not that they have or do. What does matter is that AA members do not, they see the differences and nuances within the word that escapes the bigoted and/or hate filled.

But I see that your line of argument has not changed in some 50 pages, so back to ignore you go. :)

Yes the OP asks why people insist AA is not religious. Your answer in a nutshell is: "Because we say so." and "We believe it is 'spiritual' but not religious."

And all you have to back that up are your anecdotes and fuzzy definitions.

It is ENTIRELY within the purview of the OP for me to demonstrate that AA is indeed religious, as the original poster didn't just come up with a title, but a post which essentially asks "why do people insist AA is not religious when there is evidence that it is?"

Now I'm not certain why you have to sling accusations of bigotry/hatred. Maybe you should look in the mirror. And it's quite galling to have an AA Evangelist accuse ME of evangelizing.

Apparently a number of Theists arguing here at JREF have the same problem as you. They see the demands for evidence as an attack on their belief systems. You don't like the fact that you can't provide evidence to back your assertions, therefore you put me on your ignore list .

What I DO hate (with a passion) is dishonest debate tactics.

I have Evidence that categorically demonstrates that AA is religious. Where's yours to demonstrate the converse?

GB
 
Last edited:
Nearly every post that is a response to yours has an example.
Should make it easy to point to just one then.

Actually I have, in nearly every post which I have claimed you've misrepresented my points, I have demonstrated how you have misrepresented them.
Yet another very general example illustrating how your responses tend to be very general.

And no, I'm not going to repost all my posts to prove my point.
I asked for ONE example.

Yes, it is still there. That's why I thought it worth reposting that one particular exchange, because it illustrates my points very well.
It certainly illustrates something, just not what you think it does.

I suggested it was disingenuous for you to quote Dennett as an Authority
Regardless of whether everyone agrees with his ideas, Dennett IS an authority on matters philosophical, and the quote I provided was quite relevant to the post I was responding to. I later went on to say that I agreed with Dennett that some aspects of religion CAN be examined empirically, and asked whether YOU agreed as well, and you answered in the affirmative; adding "One needs a clear definition of what one hopes to explore empirically.", with which I also agree completely. Then -- in the very next sentence -- you proclaimed: "Thus I can empirically determine that AA is religious." Now, I'll give you this: my response to that was an excess of verbosity that would take ME an hour to decipher now (illustrating a point I made above). In retrospect, it probably could have been shortened to: "I think you skipped a step there. GB".

Namely, his clear definition of religion which completely contradicts your attempts to define it out of existence, and his quote from Freud which illustrates precisely the attempt of "philosophers" such as yourself who try to define words out of existence.
Yes, let's do revisit that quote as well:

"Philosophers stretch the meaning of the words until they retain scarcely anything of their original sense; by calling “God” some vague abstraction which they have created for themselves, they pose as deists, as believers before the world; they may even pride themselves on having attained a higher and purer idea of God, although their God is nothing but an insubstantial shadow and no longer the mighty personality of religious doctrine."

The last line I have bolded because I find it particularly significant in the context of this discussion. Do you see how a broadening of the definition of "God" similar to the sort Freud was talking about might place it outside the boundaries of "religious" (by any definition)? Do you not see Freud saying that very thing in the snippet YOU provided? If not, why not? Do you really fail to appreciate the difference between broadening the definition of "God" and broadening the definition of "religious"?

Even then, you were attributing to me an argument that is precisely the opposite of the one I've been making: "And despite your attempts to use a “broader” definition of Religious...."

Check it out: I am arguing for a narrower definition of "religious", GB. After all these pages, do you really not get that yet? I've postulated that beliefs are not "religious" if they lack any of three qualities: specific, shared, supernatural. Before this is all over, will you ever once attempt to address that directly? Do you agree that all of these qualities are indispensible? Why or why not? Do you see this as an attempt to define "religious" out of existence? If so, can you explain exactly how it does that?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom