I began composing this post before
Dymanic admitted that he has no argument, and that his last 20 pages of debate are worthless. But there are still a couple of points worth challenging.
Quite frankly
Dymanic, your abandonment of all pretense of actually defending your position (that AA is not Religious) with evidence means your arguments are nothing short of worthless, and there is little or no point in responding to them. It has become so clear (even to you) that you have utterly lost the debate, that you have nothing left to offer but the tactics employed by some of the more sophisticated Christian Fundamentalist Apologists.
Science is reduced by you to being nothing more than “axiomatic”, with no objective empirical evidence (as it must be “interpreted” by people with “unexamined assumptions”—presuppositions in Apologist-Speak) to support its claims. Again, this baseless argument is a tactic time-honored by Christian Apologists.
You disingenuously quote Daniel Dennet, a proponent of the idea that some aspects of religion CAN be examined empirically. While the quote you use has a measure of truth to it (if you haven’t taken it out of context), Dennet himself appears to be engaging in an unexamined assumption that scientists don’t examine their philosophical assumptions, and a conflation of Science with the scientists doing the science. And it (the quote) doesn’t take into consideration that the empirical data gathered by scientists stands regardless of the scientists’ original hypotheses and assumptions.
In
Breaking the Spell, the book in which Dennet suggests that some aspects of Religion can be empirically examined, he begins with a rather weaselly “out”, should anyone call him on his ideas (much like your own disingenuous claims that you didn't defend the argument that AA wasn’t Religious, but not as bad):
How do I define religion? It doesn’t matter just how I define it, since I plan to discuss the neighboring phenomena that (probably) aren’t religious—spirituality, commitment to secular organizations, fanatical devotion to ethnic groups (or sport teams), superstitions…So, wherever I “draw the line,” I’ll be going over the line in any case.
Still—as tepid as his qualifications are—Dennet at least has the balls to admit that the “neighboring phenomena (probably) aren’t religious,” which is a step or two better than you. A few paragraphs later Dennet timidly proffers his definition of Religion:
Tentatively, I propose to define religions as social systems whose participants avow belief in a supernatural agent or agents whose approval is to be sought. This is of course, a circuitous way of articulating the idea that a religion without a God or gods is like a vertebrate without a backbone. Some of the reasons for this roundabout language are fairly obvious; others will emerge over time—and the definition is subject to revision, a place to start, not something carved in stone to be defended to the death.
All timidity aside, there is actually NOTHING circuitous about his definition of Religion. It is the primary definition of Religion, and it is the operative definition for the purposes of this thread. And despite bending over backwards to demonstrate a “nuanced” approach, Dennet undercuts the foundation of your arguments.
And despite your attempts to use a “broader” definition of Religious, AA continues to be Religious in BOTH the Broadest AND the Narrowest definitions of Religion. There is no definition that you can employ which will define it away, except one which you make up out of whole cloth.
Dennet at least has the ‘nads to begin with a quote that lets the reader know that his position is stronger than he initially asserts. And this quote applies to your arguments in spades:
Philosophers stretch the meaning of the words until they retain scarcely anything of their original sense; by calling “God” some vague abstraction which they have created for themselves, they pose as deists, as believers before the world; they may even pride themselves on having attained a higher and purer idea of God, although their God is nothing but an insubstantial shadow and no longer the mighty personality of religious doctrine. –Sigmund Freud, The Future of an Illusion
The irony of Freud, of all people, puncturing your philosophical bubble isn’t lost on me.
And no doubt on other threads you and I could have lovely agreeable discussions regarding speculations on “Consciousness” as it relates to Quantum Physics and Chaos Theory and the intersection of such thought with Hindu and Buddhist philosophies and the Mystery Schools of Western religious thought, Jung, Campbell, Alan Watts, Fred Alan Wolff and Fritjof Capra; devoid of the rigors of having to defend our ideas with empirical data (until other JREFers laugh us of the forum).
But this thread is about a specific organization, a specific religion (and the relationship between the two), a specific definition of religion, and the empirical evidence that either supports or refutes our respective cases.
You sir, have categorically LOST the debate; and your arguments shown to be a sham, a shameless exercise in disingenuous philosophizing and the presumptive arrogance of your “superior” ability to discern nuance as compared to our “simplistic” and “trivial” notions.
GB