Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, you know, I don't have cable, so the closest thing to entertainment I get sometimes is watching stuff pour out of my head onto a screen and then re-reading it to see if I can learn anything. I often close my contribution at an AA meeting with a (stolen) quip: "Thanks a lot for letting me share. I really enjoyed what I had to say". The truth in that is what makes it funny. After more that twenty years, I'm still my favorite speaker.

That's probably funny sad because it's probably true.

And it also underlines the point I made ages ago in this thread. A sober pimhole is still a pimhole. Just being sober is not enough sometimes. Not being a pimhole is also important. Resorting to pimholeness, posturing and name dropping when wrong is another way of proving that point. That some pimhole lauds that doesn't mean that the pimholeness goes away. It just proves that it's easier to remain a pimhole when there is another pimhole to agree with you.
 
Last edited:
"Just being sober is not enough sometimes."

There's more to the truth than just the facts?

pimholeness: [PIM-hole-ness]

— noun
1. a. The quality of being a Pimhole.
b. Pimhole conduct
2. a. Justifiable or right, esp from one's own point of view:
b.the quality or state of being a pimhole or pimdent: He came to realize the pimholeness of his position on the matter.

— adj
1. a. characterized by, proceeding from, or in accordance with accepted standards of pimholeness, pimdentness, or justified.
b. ( as collective noun ; preceded by the ): the pimholous

origin - Kent, UK 2010
 
Last edited:
That's probably funny sad because it's probably true.

And it also underlines the point I made ages ago in this thread. A sober pimhole is still a pimhole. Just being sober is not enough sometimes. Not being a pimhole is also important. Resorting to pimholeness, posturing and name dropping when wrong is another way of proving that point. That some pimhole lauds that doesn't mean that the pimholeness goes away. It just proves that it's easier to remain a pimhole when there is another pimhole to agree with you.
Did you actually think that pap would come across as a reasoned, well-thought-out rebuttal of anything? No? I didn't think so.

May I ask if you actually attend AA meetings? Or think you are an alcoholic? Or are you just another here who has no idea what AA is other than what you read someone?
 
Did you actually think that pap would come across as a reasoned, well-thought-out rebuttal of anything?
Aw now, nothing says we can't have a little fun here. I don't recall ever being called a "pimhole" before, and in fact I have to admit to never having encountered the word before, so I stand to learn something here. Not sure if Ben's represents the best possible definition, but if pimholeness does indeed involve a willingness to argue a position one considers right or justified, I must plead guilty and throw myself on the mercy of those whose virtue extends to a willingness to argue a position they feel is wrong or unjustified.
 
Does "pim" have some meaning in the UK like "ass" or something? Or is she just assuming that the "hole" on the end of it has sufficient colloquiality to carry most any ole companion?
 
I think it is indeed a she based on pim's lack of tawny pigmentation, much like American women's admission that they have committed a poot rather than a fart.
 
images
 
Well, you know, I don't have cable, so the closest thing to entertainment I get sometimes is watching stuff pour out of my head onto a screen and then re-reading it to see if I can learn anything. I often close my contribution at an AA meeting with a (stolen) quip: "Thanks a lot for letting me share. I really enjoyed what I had to say". The truth in that is what makes it funny. After more that twenty years, I'm still my favorite speaker.

"...Stuff pour out of your head..." ???? The phrase verbal diarrhea comes to mind. :p

You know, I'm really glad you just finally came out and admitted that your arguments are full of Crap and that you behave in a Narcissistic manner. This is the First Step in Recovery of your Addiction to Sophistry.

You may not have noticed that during the course of this debate I have, at various times when responding to you and other posters, referred to Plato, Descartes, Wittgenstein, Dennett, and probably two or three others I can't remember off the top of my head. Chalmers maybe. Each time, I did so either directly, as a specific part of an argument I was making, or indirectly, as a way of indicating that the landscape we're blundering about upon features some well established and clearly marked paths which nonetheless seem to manage to escape the attention of certain participants here. The above reference to "fragments of so-and-so" was an oblique reference to my having already introduced those arguments, but if I expected YOU to get that, well, once again: what could I have been thinking? I have not always been among the most prolific of posters on this forum, but I do have a history of extolling the virtues of Philosophy (in particular the Philosophy of Science) and this despite my making no claims to being anything but a dabbler in that field myself.

Dennet is the only one on your list that I recall you actually attempting to draw some relevant information from.:

I'll let Daniel Dennett take that one:

"Scientists sometimes deceive themselves into thinking that philosophical ideas are only, at best, decorations or parasitic commentaries on the hard, objective triumphs of science, and that they themselves are immune to the confusions that philosophers devote their lives to dissolving. But there is no such thing as philosophy-free science, there is only science whose philosophical baggage is taken on board without examination."

And we all know how well THAT went for you:

I began composing this post before Dymanic admitted that he has no argument, and that his last 20 pages of debate are worthless. But there are still a couple of points worth challenging.

Quite frankly Dymanic, your abandonment of all pretense of actually defending your position (that AA is not Religious) with evidence means your arguments are nothing short of worthless, and there is little or no point in responding to them. It has become so clear (even to you) that you have utterly lost the debate, that you have nothing left to offer but the tactics employed by some of the more sophisticated Christian Fundamentalist Apologists.

Science is reduced by you to being nothing more than “axiomatic”, with no objective empirical evidence (as it must be “interpreted” by people with “unexamined assumptions”—presuppositions in Apologist-Speak) to support its claims. Again, this baseless argument is a tactic time-honored by Christian Apologists.

You disingenuously quote Daniel Dennet, a proponent of the idea that some aspects of religion CAN be examined empirically. While the quote you use has a measure of truth to it (if you haven’t taken it out of context), Dennet himself appears to be engaging in an unexamined assumption that scientists don’t examine their philosophical assumptions, and a conflation of Science with the scientists doing the science. And it (the quote) doesn’t take into consideration that the empirical data gathered by scientists stands regardless of the scientists’ original hypotheses and assumptions.

In Breaking the Spell, the book in which Dennet suggests that some aspects of Religion can be empirically examined, he begins with a rather weaselly “out”, should anyone call him on his ideas (much like your own disingenuous claims that you didn't defend the argument that AA wasn’t Religious, but not as bad):

How do I define religion? It doesn’t matter just how I define it, since I plan to discuss the neighboring phenomena that (probably) aren’t religious—spirituality, commitment to secular organizations, fanatical devotion to ethnic groups (or sport teams), superstitions…So, wherever I “draw the line,” I’ll be going over the line in any case.

Still—as tepid as his qualifications are—Dennet at least has the balls to admit that the “neighboring phenomena (probably) aren’t religious,” which is a step or two better than you. A few paragraphs later Dennet timidly proffers his definition of Religion:

Tentatively, I propose to define religions as social systems whose participants avow belief in a supernatural agent or agents whose approval is to be sought. This is of course, a circuitous way of articulating the idea that a religion without a God or gods is like a vertebrate without a backbone. Some of the reasons for this roundabout language are fairly obvious; others will emerge over time—and the definition is subject to revision, a place to start, not something carved in stone to be defended to the death.

All timidity aside, there is actually NOTHING circuitous about his definition of Religion. It is the primary definition of Religion, and it is the operative definition for the purposes of this thread. And despite bending over backwards to demonstrate a “nuanced” approach, Dennet undercuts the foundation of your arguments.

And despite your attempts to use a “broader” definition of Religious, AA continues to be Religious in BOTH the Broadest AND the Narrowest definitions of Religion. There is no definition that you can employ which will define it away, except one which you make up out of whole cloth.

Dennet at least has the ‘nads to begin with a quote that lets the reader know that his position is stronger than he initially asserts. And this quote applies to your arguments in spades:

Philosophers stretch the meaning of the words until they retain scarcely anything of their original sense; by calling “God” some vague abstraction which they have created for themselves, they pose as deists, as believers before the world; they may even pride themselves on having attained a higher and purer idea of God, although their God is nothing but an insubstantial shadow and no longer the mighty personality of religious doctrine. –Sigmund Freud, The Future of an Illusion

The irony of Freud, of all people, puncturing your philosophical bubble isn’t lost on me.

And no doubt on other threads you and I could have lovely agreeable discussions regarding speculations on “Consciousness” as it relates to Quantum Physics and Chaos Theory and the intersection of such thought with Hindu and Buddhist philosophies and the Mystery Schools of Western religious thought, Jung, Campbell, Alan Watts, Fred Alan Wolff and Fritjof Capra; devoid of the rigors of having to defend our ideas with empirical data (until other JREFers laugh us of the forum).

But this thread is about a specific organization, a specific religion (and the relationship between the two), a specific definition of religion, and the empirical evidence that either supports or refutes our respective cases.

You sir, have categorically LOST the debate; and your arguments shown to be a sham, a shameless exercise in disingenuous philosophizing and the presumptive arrogance of your “superior” ability to discern nuance as compared to our “simplistic” and “trivial” notions.


GB

Yes, I will argue that despite all it has to offer, modern science does at some point hit a wall beyond which "I don't know anything, you don't know anything" is a fair description of the current state of human knowledge -- and I think it is important to recognize that this wall is encountered no matter which direction we're travelling in; the search for first causes ultimately bottoms out, and beyond that we are forced to rely on axioms which, by their very nature, cannot be tested empirically. Whether you like it or not (and I'm sure you don't), there still are some Mysteries of Reality which as yet cannot be examined with anything but Logic Alone.

True. But we aren't examining those Mysteries here; we're examining Evidence that conclusively demonstrates that AA is Religious. And in any case, examining said "Mysteries of Reality" through Logic Alone is nothing but Speculation.

Because application of the word "Sophist" appears to be among your favorite ways of insulting other posters, and because it also appears that carefully selecting definitions broad enough as to include whatever you wish to include is among your favorite methods of argument, I think this matter of you including Socrates among "Sophists" may warrant closer examination.

The first of two definitions currently at the top of the Wikpipedia page on that has sophistry as "a specious argument used for deceiving someone", and whether or not that's where you got your understanding of what constitutes sophistry, this is clearly the way you use the word. The motive -- deception -- is a vital aspect of that definition. Your attempts to refute AA's explicit statement that it is not a religious organization (and the anecdotal evidence indicating that many AA members agree) begins with a conclusion: "AA is religious" -- and everything that follows is an exercise in affirming the consequent. Because AA is religious, it seeks converts, and to better accomplish that it lies about being religious, and anyone who disagrees and is able to do so persuasively is a sophist.

1) You are the only one deliberately "broadening" definitions (though you can't broaden the definition of religious enough to define it away as it pertains to AA). You are the only one deliberately distorting, conflating, and doing everything possible to erase ontological distinctions.

2) I have never used Sophist as an Insult. I have however; called your arguments Sophistry, which is a very accurate description of them.

3) As has been pointed out ad infinitum: AA's "explicit statement" that it is not a Religious Organization is a lie, demonstrated by reams of Explicitly Religious Language and Doctrines.

4) My arguments that AA is Religious do not begin as a Premise. I built a case and reached conclusions based on Evidence. Something which you have yet to significantly attempt.

That's pretty airtight, but I think you'll have a much tougher time running that game on Socrates. His rhetorical skill alone is not enough to convict him of sophistry; once again, it goes to motive. Socrates surely possessed the skill to gain political or economic advantage from his ability to argue persuasively even when his was the weaker argument (the very essence of sophistry). Now all you need to do is find even one single instance of his having ever done that. I wonder if you're familiar with the dialogue with Protagoras in which Socrates ends up reversing his position on the question of whether virtue can be taught? Is that something that easily fits in with your definition of "Sophist"?

Yes, I'm sure you'd love to derail the thread with the Red Herring of discussing Socrates in-depth. What is relevant to this debate is the extent to which he did use Sophistry. I never claimed that he only relied on Sophistry.

Again, all you have (for the most part) is Empty Rhetoric and Anecdotes. That may work on some debaters who aren't experienced enough to recognize your kind of Sophisticated BS, but it won't work on me.

I'll give you this though, you did at least manage to convince me that it was worth taking the time to respond to your latest round of BS. ;)

GB
 
Last edited:
You may not have noticed that during the course of this debate I have, at various times when responding to you and other posters, referred to Plato, Descartes, Wittgenstein, Dennett, and probably two or three others I can't remember off the top of my head. Chalmers maybe. Each time, I did so either directly, as a specific part of an argument I was making, or indirectly, as a way of indicating that the landscape we're blundering about upon features some well established and clearly marked paths which nonetheless seem to manage to escape the attention of certain participants here. The above reference to "fragments of so-and-so" was an oblique reference to my having already introduced those arguments, but if I expected YOU to get that, well, once again: what could I have been thinking? I have not always been among the most prolific of posters on this forum, but I do have a history of extolling the virtues of Philosophy (in particular the Philosophy of Science) and this despite my making no claims to being anything but a dabbler in that field myself.

Yes, I will argue that despite all it has to offer, modern science does at some point hit a wall beyond which "I don't know anything, you don't know anything" is a fair description of the current state of human knowledge -- and I think it is important to recognize that this wall is encountered no matter which direction we're travelling in; the search for first causes ultimately bottoms out, and beyond that we are forced to rely on axioms which, by their very nature, cannot be tested empirically. Whether you like it or not (and I'm sure you don't), there still are some Mysteries of Reality which as yet cannot be examined with anything but Logic Alone.
I'm not surprised that you chose the easier course of action. Continue to make it easy on yourself and you can expect that the benefit you will obtain from participating in these discussions will be commensurate with that level of effort.

Because application of the word "Sophist" appears to be among your favorite ways of insulting other posters, and because it also appears that carefully selecting definitions broad enough as to include whatever you wish to include is among your favorite methods of argument, I think this matter of you including Socrates among "Sophists" may warrant closer examination.

The first of two definitions currently at the top of the Wikpipedia page on that has sophistry as "a specious argument used for deceiving someone", and whether or not that's where you got your understanding of what constitutes sophistry, this is clearly the way you use the word. The motive -- deception -- is a vital aspect of that definition. Your attempts to refute AA's explicit statement that it is not a religious organization (and the anecdotal evidence indicating that many AA members agree) begins with a conclusion: "AA is religious" -- and everything that follows is an exercise in affirming the consequent. Because AA is religious, it seeks converts, and to better accomplish that it lies about being religious, and anyone who disagrees and is able to do so persuasively is a sophist.

That's pretty airtight, but I think you'll have a much tougher time running that game on Socrates. His rhetorical skill alone is not enough to convict him of sophistry; once again, it goes to motive. Socrates surely possessed the skill to gain political or economic advantage from his ability to argue persuasively even when his was the weaker argument (the very essence of sophistry). Now all you need to do is find even one single instance of his having ever done that. I wonder if you're familiar with the dialogue with Protagoras in which Socrates ends up reversing his position on the question of whether virtue can be taught? Is that something that easily fits in with your definition of "Sophist"?

Logic without facts is mere rationalization.
 
Well, you know, I don't have cable, so the closest thing to entertainment I get sometimes is watching stuff pour out of my head onto a screen and then re-reading it to see if I can learn anything. I often close my contribution at an AA meeting with a (stolen) quip: "Thanks a lot for letting me share. I really enjoyed what I had to say". The truth in that is what makes it funny. After more that twenty years, I'm still my favorite speaker.

You might try also reading what others post.
 
"...Stuff pour out of your head..." ???? The phrase verbal diarrhea comes to mind.
I'll plead guilty to that one as well. In fact, it may even be worse than you realize, as I typically do quite a bit of editing for brevity before putting a post up (believe it or not), so you can just imagine the sort of mess I start out with. Mental incontinence is, it would appear, simply another aspect of my character. If this constitutes a defect of character, then I have plenty of company here, but since I don't see it as such, I guess I'm just not ready to have it removed. I appreciate you trying to help with that, though.

You know, I'm really glad you just finally came out and admitted that your arguments are full of Crap and that you behave in a Narcissistic manner.
I don't believe I've ever denied being narcisstic, but I like the crafty way you tied that to an admission that my arguments are full of crap. I assure you GB, I would not take the time to present my arguments if I thought that. Who would?

Dennet is the only one on your list that I recall you actually attempting to draw some relevant information from.:
I referenced Plato in post #681, Descartes in post #2138, and references to Searle, Nagel, and Chalmers in my post #865, which also contains a reference to Wittgenstein, though only indirectly; I linked to a Wiki article on natural language philosophy, of which Wittgenstein is the most notable proponent. I believe there are other examples scattered elsewhere in the thread, but I feel I've made my point: so much for your powers of recollection over mine.

And we all know how well THAT went for you:
Actually, I thought it went quite well for me. It was demonstrated that your grasp of Dennett's take on the specific ponts we were addressing was limited to a quick glance at some online book reviews, a deficit which surely compromised your ability to grasp how my Dennett references supported my position rather than yours. This, of course, did not prevent you from continuing to crow about how you'd won the debate and all that.

True. But we aren't examining those Mysteries here; we're examining Evidence that conclusively demonstrates that AA is Religious.
And what are we using to examine that evidence again?

And in any case, examining said "Mysteries of Reality" through Logic Alone is nothing but Speculation.
A common lament. Still, there's speculation and then there's logically defensible speculation -- just as there is examination of evidence and logically defensible examination of evidence. As much as this is an attempt to answer a specific question, this discussion is an exercise in logic.

You are the only one deliberately "broadening" definitions (though you can't broaden the definition of religious enough to define it away as it pertains to AA).
Hmm... I hate to say it, but if your best effort at a logical interpretation of my arguments leads you to that conclusion, maybe you would be better off sticking to just presenting the evidence and standing on your claim that it speaks for itself. I have quite explicitly narrowed the definition of "religious" to beliefs with three qualities: specific; shared; supernatural. Your argument that I would take the opposite tack does not even seem internally consistent to me.

I have never used Sophist as an Insult. I have however; called your arguments Sophistry, which is a very accurate description of them.
Perhaps you did not even realize that the term strongly implies disingenuous intent? Or is it that you do not consider it an insult to accuse another poster of disingenuous intent?

Yes, I'm sure you'd love to derail the thread with the Red Herring of discussing Socrates in-depth.
I'll admit, I wouldn't mind discussing Socrates, but I'd be happy to settle for an in-depth discussion of a question somewhat reminiscent of some he addressed, and one I find an indispensible prerequisite to answering the OP's question: what exactly is it that distinguishes the purely religious in nature from the not purely religious in nature? I have repeatedly issued invitations to that discussion since very early in the thread, and you have consistently declined, preferring instead to keep things on the most superficial level -- as I alluded to in the sentence I used to provide the context for my mention of Socrates and the rest. (You know: the one you gleefully seized on as me "playing the famous philosopher card"?)
 
You might try also reading what others post.
Thanks for the tip. Yeah, I really should have added something like "...re-reading it to see if I can learn anything, with a little help from some lively but friendly criticism by others". I won't deny that I've sometimes found myself re-reading something I had posted previously and which someone had re-posted, and seeing it in a whole new way. All part of the service here at JREF.
 
Thanks for the tip. Yeah, I really should have added something like "...re-reading it to see if I can learn anything, with a little help from some lively but friendly criticism by others". I won't deny that I've sometimes found myself re-reading something I had posted previously and which someone had re-posted, and seeing it in a whole new way. All part of the service here at JREF.

I've learned a lot here whether I wanted to or not.:)
 
And the distinction with "spiritual" is, what, already ?

My initial question was simply meant to illustrate that, if you ask each AA member what their higher power is, I think you'll get more than double-majority "god"s. It'd be an interesting survey. But even if we got 90%, we'd still get folks here saying AA is not religious.

So nothing anecdotal is OK. But pure unadulterated speculation is. :rolleyes::D
(see below)

What is it with some people and apologies ?

That's what adults do when they make a mistake.

No ? Well apparently he's not the only one to make that typo:

I think we could accept that if Hazelton ever, anywhere, at any time had literature placed in AA meetings, but guess what? They don't. :)

Pretty subjective, for one thing. Instead of reposting the significant chunk of this thread dedicated to that question (including arguments that "spirituality", for some, does not include either shared or supernatural elements), I'd rather refer you to the Wikipedia article on "spirituality", and if that raises any specific questions you feel are worth considering (or, more likely, reconsidering), put them up.

Can we get a ruling on whether this observation can be entered as evidence, or is it a bit too speculative for that?

For those who would refuse to search, I will post it (again), I believe I did so earlier.

This goes to the heart of the question in the OP as to why people in AA say "it isn't religious". Most of us, I would venture say it is spiritual - there is no requirement for a god. There is certainly a search for self and inner meaning, there is certainly a search for values and self improvement, and there is certainly a search for ways to better live in community.

Spirituality can refer to an ultimate or immaterial reality;[1] an inner path enabling a person to discover the essence of their being; or the “deepest values and meanings by which people live.

”[2] Spiritual practices, including meditation, prayer and contemplation, are intended to develop an individual's inner life; such practices often lead to an experience of connectedness with a larger reality, yielding a more comprehensive self; with other individuals or the human community; with nature or the cosmos; or with the divine realm.

[3] Spirituality is often experienced as a source of inspiration or orientation in life.

[4] It can encompass belief in immaterial realities or experiences of the immanent or transcendent nature of the world.

AA is a spiritual program, not a religious program (that said, if one chooses for it to be religious, go right ahead).
 
Perhaps you did not even realize that the term strongly implies disingenuous intent? Or is it that you do not consider it an insult to accuse another poster of disingenuous intent?

It's only an insult if it's not true. ;) (And it's a backhanded compliment actually; you're quite good at it, and it's the root of the word sophisticate).

Besides I was only attacking your argument, I didn't actually call you a Sophist (which was actually an ancient Greek school of philosophy, so it doesn't always carry a negative connotation :D ). If you feel bad about posting disingenuous arguments that's your problem (I implicitly suggested you might try a 12 Step programme for your Sophistry Addiction).

GB
 
.

Actually, I thought it went quite well for me. It was demonstrated that your grasp of Dennett's take on the specific ponts we were addressing was limited to a quick glance at some online book reviews, a deficit which surely compromised your ability to grasp how my Dennett references supported my position rather than yours. This, of course, did not prevent you from continuing to crow about how you'd won the debate and all that.

No, actually it demonstrated that you poorly analyzed a Dennet quote most likely taken out of context. I then countered by quoting Dennet--not from an online book review-- but by painstakingly two finger typing the quotes directly from my copy of his book.

His clear definition of religion/religious (timid though it appeared) was a mortal blow to your attempts to redefine religion. And his opening quotation of Freud read as if Dennet had anticipated precisely the sort of BS you peddle as "philosophy."

If you could actually demonstrate that my analysis was incorrect, you would have already done so instead of making your standard wholly unsupported assertions.

Given that you have freely admitted that you are given to making unsupported assertions, your arguments have lost all semblance of credibility which you hope to camouflage with your name-dropping.

GB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom