Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Luckily that doesn't sound like an AA meeting.

I wasn't trying to say it did. (Although I gather from some other posters that at least some meetings have been like that.) I was simply trying to explore the analogy: that it's possible to turn something religious into something secular, but it requires more than just mentally crossing one's fingers, so to speak.

You've never run across alcoholics who siezed any rationale to convince themselves no help was needed?

Actually, no, but that's only because I luckily have little experience with alcoholics.

I don't doubt that some alcoholics seize any excuse to avoid seeking help. What I take issue with was what I saw as your implication that any atheist who can't accept the same rationalizations that you do must be trying to avoid seeking help because there's no other reason why they wouldn't think like you do on that issue. If that's not what you meant to say, great.

No problem for me, yet several here seem to think AA should change even though other options they don't have a problem with are available.

I don't really have an opinion on whether AA should change. AA is free to say (collectively), "hey, we have something that we think works for (some/most/all of) the 90% of the population that is religious, and for many of the 10% that isn't. If the allegedly religious content turns off some of that 10%, well, nothing works for everyone, and we wish you well." I also think AA is free to say "you know what, we really aren't and don't want to be a religious program, so if some of this language is driving away people who could use our help, since it's not essential to the program anyway, we'll change it in the interest of being more inclusive and trying to help more people." I admit I find it a little odd that the attitude seems to be "oh, that stuff isn't really religious, and doesn't really matter because the program is only about having a desire to stop drinking -- but we're still not going to change it. Why not? Because we don't want to, that's why."
 
They've tried to make it more open, but insist that you have a "higher power"

AA does not insist anything except that you have a sincere desire to stop drinking. Everything else is suggestive, you can take it or leave it on the table. What people say at meetings is up to them as individuals. No one speaks for AA. Most of the comments made here against AA are based on a misunderstanding of what AA is. I won't try to answer all of them.

More to the point. There are many atheists/agnostics/secularists/whatever in AA. I am one. If you are in need of help, please visit the Atheist-AA Google group. I can't list the URL here because I haven't posted enough. But you can find it easy enough by searching Google for atheist-aa.

You will find a friendly helpful crowd there that will be happy to hear from you.
 
Would you settle for the AA average ?
With allowances for local variation, my observation is that the AA average is "spiritual but not religious", and I would have to assume that while individual members define "spiritual" in a myriad of different ways, they're all using roughly the same definition of "religious" -- a definition which describes a system of practices centered on beliefs with the three essential qualities I have listed: specific; shared; supernatural.

I would also allow that there may be some significant number of AA members who, despite invoking the SBNR meme to describe their own beliefs, would turn out on close examination to be holding beliefs that actually do meet those requirements. Some posters here would be quick to conclude that those AA members would simply be lying about their beliefs, presumably motivated by a desire to make AA seem more acceptable to agnostics and whatnot, and while I cannot dismiss that possibility outright, I still don't see what those individual members would see themselves having to gain from such a deception.

It might also be that some of them are just mistaken, having simply never given much thought to exactly how to distinguish between the "spiritual" and the "religious" (which, to be fair, is somewhat more difficult that it might appear on a first glance). Yet another possibility is that they might be attempting to describe a difference they perceive in the role their religious beliefs play in their lives by comparison with others who share the beliefs but not the experience of recovery.

A lot of conjecture in all of that, but then, I don't know what else we've really got. Grilling an entire AA group on these details would be mind-numbing work, let alone the entire membership of AA.

Of course, there certainly are those whose reject the SBNR meme altogether and openly espouse beliefs straight from mainstream religion. These members are often happy to treat AA as if it were little more than a recruitment center for the church of their preference, and the degree to which their proseletyzing is tolerated will depend a lot on the prevailing culture of the community from which the members are drawn. But we're not much interested in them, because they aren't the ones questioning AA's religiousity anyway.
 
Last edited:
I admit I find it a little odd that the attitude seems to be "oh, that stuff isn't really religious, and doesn't really matter because the program is only about having a desire to stop drinking -- but we're still not going to change it. Why not? Because we don't want to, that's why."
That you find this an odd attitude among alcoholics may easily be explained by this:
I luckily have little experience with alcoholics.
 
I dont think that too many AA groups talk about this subject to this level. I think most participants may not understand the differences being discussed here. The level of discussion isnt serving to better illuminate the circumstances in AA when it is beyond the realm of understanding of most of AA participants and their contributions in meetings.
 
Well I guess I'll just bow out of this thread if it bothers you that much Alfie because I am not about to read 2,200 replies written in this verbose vernacular I can hardly get through some of the new posts.

See you, then.

I dont think that too many AA groups talk about this subject to this level. I think most participants may not understand the differences being discussed here. The level of discussion isnt serving to better illuminate the circumstances in AA when it is beyond the realm of understanding of most of AA participants and their contributions in meetings.

Ohhh. Disappointed.
But, never mind.

What you are suggesting here is that members of AA are incapable of understanding the difference and/or nuances between (say) spiritual and religious?

Wow!... Just wow.

Can I ask just how many meetings you actually went to?
 
Last edited:
Not incapable, it just isn't part of the material that Ive ever heard. Thinking of new comers in saying it, but most old timers dont think about this on this level either I dont think.

WOW! hehehehe

Heard a guy claim a palm tree was his higher power once but most of the time it's good old God and I just assumed that to mean the christian version.

I dont know a total count of meetings but do know of 1001 in one year in the largest AA chapter in the USA which at that time was South Dade Miami.

DId I ever hear one time anyone talking about the difference between religion and spirituality?
Nope......

Why? Probably because most people dont really know the difference very well and it isnt important to them in their program.

Not being condescending at all as you imply.

Just saying that in a conversation like this if you want to know if its religious or not you need to stay on the level of thinking that dictates that and that is the level of understanding that is prominent in AA meetings not a place like this where it can clearly be over thought.
 
Last edited:
I dont know a total count of meetings but do know of 1001 in one year in the largest AA chapter in the USA which at that time was South Dade Miami.

I'm not sure I understand you. Are you saying you went to three meetings per day for a year? Just how many meeting (roughly) did you attend.

BTW. I actually agree with you when you say that most of the time people do not discuss these differences at a meeting. But in private or smaller (informal) groups this is discussed a great deal. It is also discussed and explored at great depth when actually doing the steps with a sponsor.

In fact I spent three hours last week with a member and the larger part of our discussion was on just this topic. The truth is people get too hung up on the god stuff, it's just one facet of the many within AA that you can take or leave.
 
Last edited:
Three meetings a day is an understatement I practically lived at the place. I know of 1001 meetings because that's how many hash marks I had in my big book when I counted them.
They elected me to the board at 9 months so apparently they thought I was doing at least something right.

My sponsor never discussed religion/spirituality one time with me, nor in the many round table discussions I attended between meetings was it ever discussed that I remember.

Perhaps that is something colloquial in nature as the subject matter in AA is certainly colloquial in many ways.

One of the benefits of South Dade was that it was so big - 715 or so members.
Every problem from every angle that you could imagine. GREAT place to learn how to live sober.

And thats what the meetings I have attended are about, not splitting hairs about theistic vs religious beliefs and so forth that has dominated what Ive read in this thread.
 
Last edited:
No, actually mostly without. I found that most people who talked about their higher power were at some crossroads or facing some problem that they werent sure how to cope with. However most of the answers or stories I heard as solutions to problems offered had nothing to do with higher powers.

I can remember watching as in a room of 75 or so, someone would begin talking about a problem and wanting their higher power to help them out. 40 or 50 of the 75 would begin showing signs of discomfort moving in their chairs scratching their heads and various indicators that this person was barking up the wrong tree and they knew it.

Really interesting stuff at times. I myself did the 1st 458910 and left the steps with magical business out of the picture.

I should point out that I think both the size of this chapter and its proximity to a large community of urban dwellers had plenty to do with the quality of help available there. After a year I moved back to small town Mississippi and AA was a horse of a completely different color there, in fact it wasnt even a horse. More like a pig. God this God that Big Book thumpers judgement at every comment just pretty damn dismal. Dont know how anyone could sober up in that atmosphere and be happy, which few of them were.
 
Last edited:
I dont think that too many AA groups talk about this subject to this level.
I agree.

I think most participants may not understand the differences being discussed here. The level of discussion isnt serving to better illuminate the circumstances in AA when it is beyond the realm of understanding of most of AA participants and their contributions in meetings.
I know the "participants" you're referring to are AA members (as a whole, which is always a tricky thing to generalize about), and I cannot help but agree that nothing we might ever have hoped to accomplish here would be likely to impact AA in any way. I see that as too obvious to even be worth noting.

But both the nature and the purpose of the dialogue that takes place in AA is very different from what takes place here at the JREF forum. If some of the participants here do not understand the differences being discussed here, that IS something we may be able to do something about. That will occasionally involve splitting a few hairs, but the study of fundamental problems often does require unpacking concepts so as to examine them at a more fundamental level. This process is often referred to broadly as "Philosophy" -- and if you think what you're seeing here is hair-splitting, I can recommend some reading that will provide a whole new perspective on that.
 
Thanks for the offer this is enough hair splitting for me as I did say they are already split too far to make an AA movie with them.

Also I agree that broadly categorizing AA as such isn't splitting any real hairs anyway.

Rural and Urban AA are completely different. Northern and southern AA completely different. US and Aussie AA very different. Same road lots of ways to travel it.

The OP's situation sounds more rural (and southern) than urban.

Is AA religious? Anybody mentioned that depends on where it's located?
 
I admit I find it a little odd that the attitude seems to be "oh, that stuff isn't really religious, and doesn't really matter because the program is only about having a desire to stop drinking -- but we're still not going to change it. Why not? Because we don't want to, that's why."



I'm certain that hundreds or thousands of people, both inside and outside AA, have thought the exact same thing.

The thing is, is that it's very clearly spelled out in the preface (paraphrased) "we won't change it because it's been so very very effective for zillions of people and you just don't go around changing what works."
 
Somebody has their fiction actualized. Since 1935 an 80% failure rate has only helped several billion people, not a zillion. ;)
It has however, failed for over a Zillion......

Actually I exaggerate, 98 times. :)

WELL, I'm glad to see SUMbody here knows what they are talking about!
 
You know what really burns me up about AA meetings? They always waste the first 18 minutes making people listen to others read crap that everybody has heard the exact number of times they have attended a meeting. :)

When everybody knows everybody, each have seen each other a zillion times, each has heard the preamble a billion times, shouldn't they talk about better utilizing that 26% of the meeting time? :)

I solved that problem by taking one more drink and arriving fashionably late. :boggled:
 
You know what really burns me up about AA meetings? They always waste the first 18 minutes making people listen to others read crap that everybody has heard the exact number of times they have attended a meeting. :)

I solved that problem by taking one more drink and arriving fashionably late. :boggled:

Kind burns me up that you must not have not been to many different meetings. It is just not true that the readings occur at every meeting. If you don't like it, keep trying until you find a meeting where they don't read.

Or maybe you could do us all a favor, have two extra drinks and stay away from the meeting altogether.
 
The simplest answer to the OP's question, of course, still is that not everyone defines "religious" the same way. It logically follows that not everyone defines "God" the same way. Thanks to GB for his tireless efforts at reposting, over and over again, samples of the textual evidence which supports this conclusion.

Thanks for reposting evidence of your sophistry that in no way defines away the meaning of religious, over and over again. Thanks for never having the evidence to back up your assertions. Thanks for often making my point for me that AA is religious under all definitions of the term.

GB
 
Or maybe you could do us all a favor, have two extra drinks and stay away from the meeting altogether.


Now thats just plain old mean! You bruiser you hehehehe
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom