Luckily that doesn't sound like an AA meeting.
I wasn't trying to say it did. (Although I gather from some other posters that at least some meetings have been like that.) I was simply trying to explore the analogy: that it's possible to turn something religious into something secular, but it requires more than just mentally crossing one's fingers, so to speak.
You've never run across alcoholics who siezed any rationale to convince themselves no help was needed?
Actually, no, but that's only because I luckily have little experience with alcoholics.
I don't doubt that some alcoholics seize any excuse to avoid seeking help. What I take issue with was what I saw as your implication that any atheist who can't accept the same rationalizations that you do must be trying to avoid seeking help because there's no other reason why they wouldn't think like you do on that issue. If that's not what you meant to say, great.
No problem for me, yet several here seem to think AA should change even though other options they don't have a problem with are available.
I don't really have an opinion on whether AA should change. AA is free to say (collectively), "hey, we have something that we think works for (some/most/all of) the 90% of the population that is religious, and for many of the 10% that isn't. If the allegedly religious content turns off some of that 10%, well, nothing works for everyone, and we wish you well." I also think AA is free to say "you know what, we really aren't and don't want to be a religious program, so if some of this language is driving away people who could use our help, since it's not essential to the program anyway, we'll change it in the interest of being more inclusive and trying to help more people." I admit I find it a little odd that the attitude seems to be "oh, that stuff isn't really religious, and doesn't really matter because the program is only about having a desire to stop drinking -- but we're still not going to change it. Why not? Because we don't want to, that's why."
