Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rural and Urban AA are completely different. Northern and southern AA completely different. US and Aussie AA very different. Same road lots of ways to travel it.

The OP's situation sounds more rural (and southern) than urban.

Is AA religious? Anybody mentioned that depends on where it's located?

You see, this is the problem with not bothering to at least skim through the thread and see which arguments are definitive, and which ones play right into AAers hands.

AA being religious has NOTHING, Nada, Zilch to do with its location.

It has to do with the religious language and tenets of AA's primary texts.

Just as Dymanic's sophistry regularly scores points for the "AA is religious" team, you just scored a goal for the "AA is not religious" team. :rolleyes:

GB
 
Thanks for often making my point for me that AA is religious under all definitions of the term.
And to you again for demonstrating consistency in declining to examine those myriad definitions on any but the most superficial level. Here I have fragments of Socrates and Hume and Kant and Wittgenstein and a whole host of other guys scowling at me from various little corners in my much-abused brain, while your entire worldview appears to be easily and quite conveniently contained in a single volume of Webster's Dictionary. I envy you that. There's a lot to be said for the ease and simplicity of an approach that says, "Here's the evidence, it speaks for itself, only one conclusion is possible, no logic required". Some of it isn't very nice, but still: a lot.
 
Correct (as usual) GB: Since this thread and it's by-now well demonstrated conclusion 'AA is a religious program' is speaking about the AA program, not particular meetings, I'm sure Ben would agree the following things are not the same.

1. An (or several) AA Meetings
2. The AA Program as contained within the core AA literature (primarily the Big Book, The 12x12, about 60 small pamphlets seen on the racks at AA meetings, and As Bill See's It). Most (but not all) of the other material seen or used at AA meetings are not Conference Approved, but as tactically allowed by AA through the supposedly separate yet completely intertwined Hazelton publishing house. As an aside, the difference between Hazelton Literature & Conference Approved literature is basically the same as between the words Spiritual and Religious - that is, for most on-the-ground practical reasons, there is no difference.
 
Last edited:
Well I guess you are making a distinction between is AA doctrine religious or is how it is practiced religious.

I just cant split hairs like you guys do nor do I see the need.

If it's theistic no matter how diversified the theism is, and all are using it to a common goal, then it's religious. call me simple.

Apparently the courts thought it's reference to God and Higher Power were enough to protect from it via the first amendment which says religion, not theism or spiritual.

It is really technically down to the molecule WHATEVER to win the argument religious?

Who gives a ***** ?
 
Last edited:
Hardcore atheists and/or those demonstrating Plait's definition of "being a dick"?
 
How about even if its not technically a religion, it's close enough that it functions as one.

So it's a religidyte not religion and not not religion....

whatever..

I just want yall to know that all this hair splitting has caused me to buy a 5th of vodka to cope with the stress.
Yes it IS your fault dont give me that blaming others garbage!
Oh no my life is falling apart again and its all yalls fault.
Hooray for Blue Goose MAN I feel GREAT!!!!!!
 
Last edited:
Thanks for a personal attack.

The category in question was "It is really technically down to the molecule WHATEVER to win the argument religious?

Who gives a ***** ? "

I wasn't actually included, technically.
 
Last edited:
And to you again for demonstrating consistency in declining to examine those myriad definitions on any but the most superficial level. Here I have fragments of Socrates and Hume and Kant and Wittgenstein and a whole host of other guys scowling at me from various little corners in my much-abused brain, while your entire worldview appears to be easily and quite conveniently contained in a single volume of Webster's Dictionary. I envy you that. There's a lot to be said for the ease and simplicity of an approach that says, "Here's the evidence, it speaks for itself, only one conclusion is possible, no logic required". Some of it isn't very nice, but still: a lot.

You know you've got your "opponent" on the ropes when they start name-dropping famous philosophers in an attempt to derail the thread. I mean who in their right mind is going to argue with Socrates, Hume, Kant, and Wittgenstein? :rolleyes:

Game over right? Oooo, the famous philosopher card!!! :eek:


Ancient Greece
Socrates

In this tradition, it is the Sophists who first challenged the certainty of human knowledge. Fundametal to the Sophistic way of thinking was the idea that "man is the measure of all things," as Protagoras put it. This meant that human knowledge, rather than conforming to some objective reality, in fact imposed itself and its own interpretations on the outside world. The Sophists were, however, less concerned with natural sciences than they were with ethics and politics; they would argue that there was no such thing as absolute or objective morality.

This tradition was carried on by Socrates, although neither he nor his pupils thought of him as a Sophist. However, Socrates carried the Sophistic concern with knowledge to a radical extreme. He claimed that he knew one and only one thing: that he knew nothing. So he set about questioning people who claimed to have knowledge, ostensibly for the purpose of learning from them. His method of questioning, called elenchus , imitated a cross-examination in a court of law. He would keep questioning his listener until he had forced him into a contradiction. As in a court of law, this contradiction proved that the speaker was lying in some way, in this case, did not really know what they claimed to know. Socrates, then, was the first in a line of skeptics, that questioned whether or not human beings can know anything at all.


Well, whaddya know? At the top of Dymanic's famous philosopher list is Socrates, the Master of Sophistry himself.

The dude that used epistemology to undermine ontological distinctions. That favourite pastime of Creationists that devalue Empirical Knowledge to put Creationism on the same ontological level as Natural Selection.

Dymanic's "winning" argument in a nutshell:

"Evidence, Schmevidence. Who needs it?" :p

"I can say what I want. It's all equally valid. I don't know anything, you don't know anything. I can make it all up as I go along. Yet I know I'm right and you're wrong."

GB
 
Of course it was an insult, directed at a group, which is allowed under the MA. If I had chosen to name you specifically as part of the group that would not be allowed.

Your personal attack is not allowed, and perhaps someone will report you.

I won't.
 
Of course it was an insult, directed at a group, which is allowed under the MA. If I had chosen to name you specifically as part of the group that would not be allowed.

Your personal attack is not allowed, and perhaps someone will report you.

I won't.


Thank you for the rules clarification -- I have edited my post accordingly.
 
Correct (as usual) GB: Since this thread and it's by-now well demonstrated conclusion 'AA is a religious program' is speaking about the AA program, not particular meetings, I'm sure Ben would agree the following things are not the same.

1. An (or several) AA Meetings
2. The AA Program as contained within the core AA literature (primarily the Big Book, The 12x12, about 60 small pamphlets seen on the racks at AA meetings, and As Bill See's It). Most (but not all) of the other material seen or used at AA meetings are not Conference Approved, but as tactically allowed by AA through the supposedly separate yet completely intertwined Hazelton publishing house. As an aside, the difference between Hazelton Literature & Conference Approved literature is basically the same as between the words Spiritual and Religious - that is, for most on-the-ground practical reasons, there is no difference.

Hmmm.

I am seriously starting to doubt your credentials (again), there is no publishing house name Hazelton. If you had written it once, I might have let is pass as a slip, but no - twice you wrote it.

For someone who has been around for 20 years in AA without a higher power, you have done a wonderful job of proving (anecdotally, for the benefit of Belz) that AA does work without God (I still don't know what your HP is however) and thus works without religion - ergo, it is not/doesn't have to be religious, and the decision on same falls with the individual.

But secondly, and here is my quandry your habit of submitting incorrect information makes any of this evidence weak to say the least.

Your credibility was in tatters before, now it is completely ruined.

And for the record, it is HAZELDEN publishing.

http://www.hazelden.org/web/public/publishing.page



Of course it was an insult, directed at a group, which is allowed under the MA. If I had chosen to name you specifically as part of the group that would not be allowed.

Your personal attack is not allowed, and perhaps someone will report you.

I won't.

Thank you for the rules clarification -- I have edited my post accordingly.

But no apology?
 
Hmmm.

I am seriously starting to doubt your credentials (again), there is no publishing house name Hazelton. If you had written it once, I might have let is pass as a slip, but no - twice you wrote it.

For someone who has been around for 20 years in AA without a higher power, you have done a wonderful job of proving (anecdotally, for the benefit of Belz) that AA does work without God (I still don't know what your HP is however) and thus works without religion - ergo, it is not/doesn't have to be religious, and the decision on same falls with the individual.

But secondly, and here is my quandry your habit of submitting incorrect information makes any of this evidence weak to say the least.

Your credibility was in tatters before, now it is completely ruined.

And for the record, it is HAZELDEN publishing.

http://www.hazelden.org/web/public/publishing.page







But no apology?

Another indication that your "opponent" is on the ropes: Attacking spelling mistakes and typos instead of the argument. :p

GB
 
Another indication that your "opponent" is on the ropes: Attacking spelling mistakes and typos instead of the argument. :p

GB

Exactly and as for credibility, how much credibility can we give to a christian counsellor defending the christian values of a christian based religious organization? Not to mention someone who has not one shred of evidence to back up a single claim but relies on his own anecdotes, how much credibility do they get?
 
Last edited:
Hardcore atheists and/or those demonstrating Plait's definition of "being a dick"?

As opposed to hardcore theists and/or those demonstrating what Dawkins defined as "The God Delusion" and others have defined as "pure idiocy?"
 
Hmmm.

I am seriously starting to doubt your credentials (again), there is no publishing house name Hazelton. If you had written it once, I might have let is pass as a slip, but no - twice you wrote it.


Oh my, I spelled a word wrong!!!! My my what AM I going to do, as due to my spelling mistake my entire argument is ka put!!! <sarcasm off>

And, since you keep asking what my HP is - I don't have one, don't need to invent one, didn't have one in 1983 (when I started going to meetings, also my original sobriety date fyi), don't have to invent one now - and neither does anyone else who wants to quit drinking.
Are you now going to keep asking why I still attend meetings (even though I've explained my reasons for that several times in this one thread)?

Any other examples you'd like to bring up where a spelling mistake invalidates the entirety of an argument?
 
Oh my, I spelled a word wrong!!!! My my what AM I going to do, as due to my spelling mistake my entire argument is ka put!!! <sarcasm off>

Funnily enough, just prior to pointing out your spelling mistake, Alfie wrote this:

But secondly, and here is my quandry your habit of submitting incorrect information makes any of this evidence weak to say the least.

He doesn't know that it is spelled quandary. When will he get anything right? Well, that nullifies any argument he has ever made, right there!
 
And, since you keep asking what my HP is - I don't have one, don't need to invent one, didn't have one in 1983 (when I started going to meetings, also my original sobriety date fyi), don't have to invent one now - and neither does anyone else who wants to quit drinking.
Are you now going to keep asking why I still attend meetings (even though I've explained my reasons for that several times in this one thread)?

Exactly - you are the walking epitome of why AA is not religious.
An HP is not needed, never was, never will be. It is but one tool that can be used in a framework of many many tools.
 
Exactly - you are the walking epitome of why AA is not religious.
An HP is not needed, never was, never will be. It is but one tool that can be used in a framework of many many tools.

Which is of course why AA literature says exactly the opposite. :rolleyes:

GB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom