Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
But is it not also true that the vast majority of our practical western laws are also based in Judeo/Christian theism i.e. the 10 commandments? Forget the fasle idols etc, but the last five (in short)
- will not murder
- will not commit adultery
- will not steal
- will not perjure
- will not covet

Does that in turn make western society religious? Or, as you say based in theism?

I dispute the premise on multiple grounds. First, the "vast majority" of laws today have little to do with murder, adultery, stealing, perjury, and coveting, unless you're willing to stretch the definitions of those terms beyond all recognition. Second, it's rather difficult to say that laws are "based on" the ten commandments when (a) only three of the ten commandments have current legal counterparts (I would strike coveting from your list -- it's practically the basis of our economic system, not a criminal offense! -- and adultery laws have either been repealed, ruled unconstitutional, or left to languish unenforced on the books in many jurisdictions); and (b) those three (murder, theft, perjury) are not unique to Judeo-Christian belief systems or societies, with legal prohibitions on such things dating back to around 2100 B.C.

You might as well say that since sheep and apples are mentioned in the Bible, it's somehow "religious" to eat them.

And of course, even if something originated in religious belief, it doesn't necessarily retain that nature.

To drag it back to AA: things like "taking a moral inventory" and "making amends to those you've wronged" aren't religious even though religions may endorse them as well. It's when you start bringing in God that you enter into religious territory, because there's really nothing secular about asking a god to remove your faults.
 
To drag it back to AA: things like "taking a moral inventory" and "making amends to those you've wronged" aren't religious even though religions may endorse them as well. It's when you start bringing in God that you enter into religious territory, because there's really nothing secular about asking a god to remove your faults.
Nicely glossing over the god-as-you-understand-him, and a higher power choice, which can remove the religious aspect. At least it does so for me.

I suspect any atheist could in good conscience make a similar choice, although drinking alcoholics are notoriously good at making choices and/or excuses to justify continued drinking.
 
I dispute the premise on multiple grounds. First, the "vast majority" of laws today have little to do with murder, adultery, stealing, perjury, and coveting, unless you're willing to stretch the definitions of those terms beyond all recognition.

So are you saying that western society has no basis in religious teachings?

And for the record, I agree I am being a little liberal with some interpretations here, but there are also social laws, that - I would venture - the bvast majority in society adhere to, in terms of simply trying to stay socially responsible.

And as for the "vast majority" having little to do with the commandments, I have a couple of observations:
- sure corporate fraud has nothing to do with murder, but murder is still illegal and you are right; the vast majority of laws do have little to do with this commandment; murder is just one area of (the) law.
- Possession being 9/10s of the law (as I've heard on US TV:)), is that not what the laws are based around? Respect for the property and freedom of others?
 
asking a god to remove your faults.

How does that actually work anyway?

I ask God to remove my faults, (after I've decided what those are)
Make sure it's humbly now,,,,,
God thinks "OK but this is the LAST TIME you smurf"
PRESTO your faults are removed, you can feel the weight lifted or something.
And you stop thinking about hacking your spouse up with a hatchet......

I just think it's fascinating how all this really works. THAT IS how it works isn't it?
 
Please read the thread, you are going over old ground.

I might also ask, are you just going to pose questions? Or will you occasionally respond or comment to people who have the courtesy to respond to you.

Just asking.
 
Nicely glossing over the god-as-you-understand-him, and a higher power choice, which can remove the religious aspect. At least it does so for me.

You are correct that I was glossing over that aspect, because I figured after fifty-some pages we've been through that repeatedly.

If you play with definitions enough and/or pick and choose the parts you like, you could turn anything from religious to non-religious, or at least pretend to. I celebrate Christmas in a non-religious, secular way: it's just an excuse to gather with friends or family and maybe exchange a few gifts. Of course, that's easy for me to do because my friends and family are either non-Christians or not actively practicing ones. If I found myself attending a midnight Mass and sitting through prayers at the Christmas dinner table and discussions about how we were celebrating the birth of "Our Lord," I don't think I'd be able to say in good conscience that I just celebrated a secular holiday, even if I came up with some rationalizations for all of it. ("Oh, 'Our Lord' just means 'human civilization,' and the 'birth' is just metaphorical," etc.)

I suspect any atheist could in good conscience make a similar choice, although drinking alcoholics are notoriously good at making choices and/or excuses to justify continued drinking.

This I disagree with. I'm willing to believe that you genuinely think that your "higher power" isn't just some euphemism for God. But I don't think that someone who says "I just can't rationalize it that way: it's pretty clear to me that phrases like Good Orderly Direction are just transparent ways of rationalizing a religious program, and I would feel dishonest if I pretended otherwise" is just making excuses to justify continued drinking. And since AA isn't the only option for alcoholics and doesn't claim to be -- as I've been repeatedly assured in this thread by its defenders -- then what's the problem with someone feeling that way?
 
- will not murder
- will not commit adultery
- will not steal
- will not perjure
- will not covet others belongings/rights

I wonder when's the last time someone was jailed for sleeping with someone else than their spouse, or for coveting someone's stuff, or for lying.

That leaves 2 out of 10, and those existed before the old testament was written, so it follows that they simply make sense in a social environment.
 
asking a god to remove your faults.

How does that actually work anyway?

I ask God to remove my faults, (after I've decided what those are)
Make sure it's humbly now,,,,,
God thinks "OK but this is the LAST TIME you smurf"
PRESTO your faults are removed, you can feel the weight lifted or something.
And you stop thinking about hacking your spouse up with a hatchet......

I just think it's fascinating how all this really works. THAT IS how it works isn't it?
It wouldn't have for me. If that was your attempt I suspect not for you either.
 
Last edited:
And since AA isn't the only option for alcoholics and doesn't claim to be -- as I've been repeatedly assured in this thread by its defenders

I only wish during my early struggles that this had been true "to my reach" but it just wasnt. All treatment was 12 step based, all therapist suggested using AA, all roads pointed to AA and they made no distinctions between the theistic and secular areas of the program.

I ask, went to professionals and ask, used my father's medical background to access the most prominent professionals in the psychological field in the state, the answer was always the same.

Thats why I love CBT, finally an alternative to theistic therapy. It's been around awhile but central Mississippi was not the place to find out about it in my youth or even a decade ago.

Alfie I didnt see you ask me anything that I did not answer sorry bout dat.
 
Would you settle for the AA average ?


By extension, because one lives in the USA, going on averages, The US is also religious?

I wonder when's the last time someone was jailed for sleeping with someone else than their spouse, or for coveting someone's stuff, or for lying.

That leaves 2 out of 10, and those existed before the old testament was written, so it follows that they simply make sense in a social environment.

As I conceded later and you seem to be confirming here - there are social laws also. You are also supporting our argument in earlier pages that that just because some social norms (for want of another expression) are adopted by a religion, that does not make them exclusively religious.

As I say, you seem to be supporting me here. I am sure it was not intentional, but thanks anyway. :)
 
It wouldn't have for me. If that was your attempt I suspect not for you either.

Oh thats just bad satire thats all. To people like me, God, or you higher power, isn't doing one thing in that endeavor, because he it whatever doesnt exist to do it.

So if some change does in fact occur, then YOU created it. So what exactly did you do to make that happen? I suspect being able to accurately describe what you actually did to achieve that without attributing it to the easter bunny may help some secular minded people, dont you?
 
Last edited:
You are correct that I was glossing over that aspect, because I figured after fifty-some pages we've been through that repeatedly.

If you play with definitions enough and/or pick and choose the parts you like, you could turn anything from religious to non-religious, or at least pretend to. I celebrate Christmas in a non-religious, secular way: it's just an excuse to gather with friends or family and maybe exchange a few gifts. Of course, that's easy for me to do because my friends and family are either non-Christians or not actively practicing ones. If I found myself attending a midnight Mass and sitting through prayers at the Christmas dinner table and discussions about how we were celebrating the birth of "Our Lord," I don't think I'd be able to say in good conscience that I just celebrated a secular holiday, even if I came up with some rationalizations for all of it. ("Oh, 'Our Lord' just means 'human civilization,' and the 'birth' is just metaphorical," etc.)
Luckily that doesn't sound like an AA meeting.


This I disagree with. I'm willing to believe that you genuinely think that your "higher power" isn't just some euphemism for God.
Thank you.

But I don't think that someone who says "I just can't rationalize it that way: it's pretty clear to me that phrases like Good Orderly Direction are just transparent ways of rationalizing a religious program, and I would feel dishonest if I pretended otherwise" is just making excuses to justify continued drinking.
You've never run across alcoholics who siezed any rationale to convince themselves no help was needed?


And since AA isn't the only option for alcoholics and doesn't claim to be -- as I've been repeatedly assured in this thread by its defenders -- then what's the problem with someone feeling that way?
No problem for me, yet several here seem to think AA should change even though other options they don't have a problem with are available.
 
So if some change does in fact occur, then YOU created it. So what exactly did you do to make that happen? I suspect being able to accurately describe what you actually did to achieve that without attributing it to the easter bunny may help some secular minded people, dont you?

FFS! Please, please, please, read the thread. This has all been discussed and we have moved on.

No problem for me, yet several here seem to think AA should change even though other options they don't have a problem with are available.

Me either, in fact this has been one of my points all along.
 
So are you saying that western society has no basis in religious teachings?

This is getting off-topic, but:

I'm saying that religious teachings and social values and laws share a lot of common ground, but that doesn't imply that the latter are based on the former. There are some laws (though most of them are no longer enforced or valid in many jurisdictions) that truly are based in religious teachings: anti-blasphemy laws, Sunday shopping restrictions, etc., but in general I think the causation works the other way around. I think religions have taken the common moral values that already existed (some of which are even evidenced in non-human animals), tried to codify them, tack on some new ones of their own that they thought were useful or beneficial either to the people or to the church or both, and then tried to provide some overarching rationale for them. Which I've always found unnecessary: who are these people who can't figure out why murder is wrong, but think 'because a very powerful entity says so' is a good answer? Keep them far away from me, please.

Frankly, it's a little hard to believe that any society could have survived long enough to form and pass on religious teachings if it didn't have any restrictions on murder or theft. (As Christopher Hitchens has remarked, even assuming the Exodus story was true, would you really think that when Moses announced 'sorry, no murder,' that this was some new concept for their society?)

You'd also have to explain how all sorts of different societies based on very different religions somehow managed to still develop these basic restrictions. I believe there's at least one tribe that anthropologists have discovered harbor no religious beliefs -- would you like to make a bet on whether or not they go around murdering and robbing each other?

And for the record, I agree I am being a little liberal with some interpretations here, but there are also social laws, that - I would venture - the bvast majority in society adhere to, in terms of simply trying to stay socially responsible.

And as for the "vast majority" having little to do with the commandments, I have a couple of observations:
- sure corporate fraud has nothing to do with murder, but murder is still illegal and you are right; the vast majority of laws do have little to do with this commandment; murder is just one area of (the) law.
- Possession being 9/10s of the law (as I've heard on US TV:)), is that not what the laws are based around? Respect for the property and freedom of others?

Well, first of all, "Possession being 9/10s of the law" is meaningless gibberish. If anything, it's backwards; possession of something matters a lot more outside of a courtroom, on a practical level.

Second, there's nothing about "respect for the freedom of others" in the Ten Commandments; indeed, the whole "freedom" idea doesn't really mesh with I AM THE LORD THY GOD and all those Thou Shalt Nots. So you're pulling a bit of a fast one tying "freedom of others" in with "property" -- remember, the commandment at issue is the one about stealing.

So exactly which laws are even covered by (putting aside the "based on" issue) the Ten Commandments? In the criminal laws, there's murder and the various forms of theft and robbery. The 10Cs don't say anything about assault and battery or sexual assault and rape or disturbing the peace or public intoxication or drinking and driving or drug possession or.... In civil law, there's nothing in the 10Cs about honoring your contractual obligations. Torts aren't covered other than wrongful death or conversion -- nothing about negligence or products liability. Nothing about bankruptcy, or nondiscrimination, or freedom of speech, and there isn't anything about freedom of religion other than that you don't have it (it's Yahweh or the highway). Nothing about antipollution or securities regulation or the regulation of industries like health care, insurance, nuclear power, etc.

Well, you get the point. "Don't lie, don't steal, and don't murder" is an ok start, but it's hardly a comprehensive foundation for a legal system, and there's no reason to believe that religion in general -- let alone one specific religion -- invented these concepts.
 
Well I guess I'll just bow out of this thread if it bothers you that much Alfie because I am not about to read 2,200 replies written in this verbose vernacular I can hardly get through some of the new posts.
 
AlBell said:
It wouldn't have for me. If that was your attempt I suspect not for you either.

Oh thats just bad satire thats all. To people like me, God, or you higher power, isn't doing one thing in that endeavor, because he it whatever doesnt exist to do it.

So if some change does in fact occur, then YOU created it. So what exactly did you do to make that happen? I suspect being able to accurately describe what you actually did to achieve that without attributing it to the easter bunny may help some secular minded people, dont you?
I've described it and it hasn't done any good: here, anyway.

PS: It would be helpful if you learn how to use Quote.
 
It would be more helpful if you learned to do without it hehehehe

I've described it and it hasn't done any good: here, anyway.

There, feel better now? hehehehe

I prefer bold at the break myself.

Well I thought you might share it, my travels through that quagmire actually took a long time and lots of walkabouts to get some idea of what my values really were where they came from and why they make sense......
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom