Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Physician, heal thyself.

Edited by Locknar: 
Content removed, breach of Rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
a solitary proto-human would have had on the African savannah.

Yes of course but if you are a zebra you don't put pin stripes on the world by hanging out with gazelles. :eek:
 
Oh, someone already has had a few drinks.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Oh I did heal myself, trust me. After looking at asking God for everything I decided to just do it myself and by golly it worked pretty good! I just wish I wasn't stupid enough to waste my life away a few more years after being exposed to treatment programs.

They actually told me repeatedly that if I didn't didn't turn my will over to God that I would die of alcoholism. Not a very good prognosis for an atheist or agnostic. I left those halls feeling truly hopeless. It should be a crime to do that to people.

You know who gets sober? People who want to. DUH
 
Last edited:
No doubt about it. That must have been your only problem.

ps. Ahhh, the memories; drunks and dry drunks explaining their problems and the reasons for them -- usually people, places, and things -- god up the azz is a new one.

Well if some people say God is the only solution, some are bound to say God is the problem, eh. What goes around...
 
Rock bottom certainly is a good catalyst for arriving at that desire isn't it?

In fact I think the whole notion of what rock bottom actually is should be studied until every aspect of the perspective is thoroughly understood. I think cultivating that perspective should be the central focus of any 28 day program as that isn't enough time to scratch the surface of much else.

Why do some people end up sleeping in ditches before they reach their bottom and others break a pinky nail and have a catharsis? Why do some people seemingly have no bottom at all?

I think the quest for sobriety is about the quest for knowledge. Treatment programs approach this the same way that American schools approach it - everybody in one room teach everybody the same thing come out with generic luke warm results.

If a person is not theistic, then don't offer them theism as a solution... Maybe?

I would be afraid to count the number of people who have gone through treatment and then died from one thing or another because this simple idea is totally ignored.

I have said for many years, that faith is a frame of mind that is highly mercurial, and can wane on a moments notice. I just do not see this as a stable platform to build sobriety on.
 
I have said for many years, that faith is a frame of mind that is highly mercurial, and can wane on a moments notice. I just do not see this as a stable platform to build sobriety on.

What do you think any counselor or program, including CBT, offers other than coping mechanisms? Not counting that most do offer to relieve you of $$$, and do so.

For example actually meaning and accepting "Today I have the serenity to accept ...etc" when you think it, and finally realizing 'you' are the only thing you can change.
 
And some people get odd ideas of what AA offers.

I wonder where they get those "odd" ideas from!

Service Material from the General Service Office
THE TWELVE STEPS OF ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS

1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become
unmanageable.
2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to
sanity.
3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.
4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.
5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.
6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.
8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make
amends to them all.
9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do
so would injure them or others.
10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly
admitted it.
11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.
12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to
carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our
affairs.
 
#1 AA Recommended Sobriety Enhancer - Theistipromol
 

Attachments

  • aamol.jpg
    aamol.jpg
    51.2 KB · Views: 5
Last edited:
GB: I've explained several times my higher power, god as I understand him, and where my prayers are directed.

You can do as you wish.
 
Last edited:
GB: I've explained several times my higher power, god as I understand him, and where my prayers are directed.

You can do as you wish.

Funny, I thought I just heard you wonder where some people got their "odd" ideas from.

Your response is relevant to my response how exactly? ;)

(I think it might be called a non-sequitur)

GB
 
I've explained several times my higher power, god as I understand him, and where my prayers are directed.

Please direct to this info I'd like to read it without sifting through 56 pages of this stuff.
 
I've explained several times my higher power, god as I understand him, and where my prayers are directed.

Please direct to this info I'd like to read it without sifting through 56 pages of this stuff.

Just skim through the thread. Believe me, it's worth it.

GB
 
The simplest answer to the OP's question, of course, still is that not everyone defines "religious" the same way. It logically follows that not everyone defines "God" the same way. Thanks to GB for his tireless efforts at reposting, over and over again, samples of the textual evidence which supports this conclusion.
 
I've explained several times my higher power, god as I understand him, and where my prayers are directed.

Please direct to this info I'd like to read it without sifting through 56 pages of this stuff.
Search, my id, keywords higher power, last week, show posts.
 
Well allowing all the established religions to be thrown into one pot to cook a new batch of something certainly is something "new" as religion goes, perhaps even a very good idea. (perhaps they wont kill each other) But it's still religion. Or perhaps "Behavior based in Theism"

This is very interesting to me.
Firstly I agree with what I imagine you are saying, that AA is based in some theism - there is no argument in there from me. But is it not also true that the vast majority of our practical western laws are also based in Judeo/Christian theism i.e. the 10 commandments? Forget the false idols etc, but the last five (in short)
- will not murder
- will not commit adultery
- will not steal
- will not perjure
- will not covet others belongings/rights

Does that in turn make western society religious? Or, as you say based in theism?
I tend to think the latter on both, but that does not make them religious.

Rock bottom certainly is a good catalyst for arriving at that desire isn't it?

In fact I think the whole notion of what rock bottom actually is should be studied until every aspect of the perspective is thoroughly understood. I think cultivating that perspective should be the central focus of any 28 day program as that isn't enough time to scratch the surface of much else.

I gave my definition of rock bottom much earlier in the piece. Rock Bottom has been studied, but given human beings and our propensity to do things individually means that there is no one point; it is different for everyone.
I teach this in Addiction Awareness classes and rehabs (yes 28 day programs):

Pain > Fear = Rock Bottom

In other words, Rock bottom is when the pain we are in becomes greater than the fear of doing something about it.

Let's look at pain: what is it?
I muck around with the four Ls and the things that go wrong within each of them.

Lovelife - relationships, partners, parents children, colleagues, friends, spirituality, respect etc. Also importantly: self, including self-esteem, self-respect, guilt, remorse, self-loathing etc.
Legal - DUIs, violence, police and courts, lock ups, gaol, dept human services, divorce, criminal activity etc
Livelihood - loss of jobs, unemployable, spending inappropriately (eg. feed the habit before the kids or ourselves), financial troubles etc
Liver - which means health: major organs are damaged or compromised, heart, lungs, liver, pancreas, reproductive system, central nervous system, brain damage, mental heath (depression, anxiety) etc
And you can include any other personal pain here .....

What rock bottom means for one wioll not mean the same for another: there are high bottoms and low bottoms.

I might describe a high bottom alcoholic for example, as a housewife with three kids. She gets the kids off to school each morning, lunches packed, clean clothes etc. Husband goes off to work also with luch and a pressed shirt. She does her day working part time, perhaps a game of tennis once a week - you get the idea. The kids come home and are given a snack, have a play and settle in for some homework. Mum steps into the kitchen and starts preparing the meal, she also opens a bottle of wine. Hubby comes home, the family have dinner. The kids toddle off to bed, hubby sits down for a beer and some telly and mum finishes the bottle.
It doesn't sound like a bad scenario really does it. Except, he marriage is in tatters, they are arguing all the time, they sleep in separate rooms. She is fighting with her family and friends more and more, doing embarrassing things at public functions, she feels she is losing control.
She makes a decision to change things and steps into action.
For her, this is rock bottom.

I might describe a low bottom alcoholic as a man, long matted hair, unkempt beard. He lives in the parks and gardens, sleeping rough and carries his belongings in a plastic bag. He drinks two bottles of metho a day.
One day he says to himself. How the hell did I get here? I once had a wife, kids, a house! I have qualifications! He has just been beaten up again for no apparent reason apart from a half a cigarette. "No more!" He says and he starts to climb up and out.
This is his rock bottom.

Now what is the fear?
In short order: the loss of one's best friend, the loss of a coping tool (perhaps their only tool), withdrawal, fear of the future, fear of change, the judgement of others (and self - imagine having to admit we are an alcoholic?), insert other personal fears here .....

In actual fact BA, there has been much study done and more being done all the time. You might also look at the stages of change for some answers, as well as the cycle of addiction. Pretty basic stuff but a good place for you to start.

The simplest answer to the OP's question, of course, still is that not everyone defines "religious" the same way. It logically follows that not everyone defines "God" the same way. Thanks to GB for his tireless efforts at reposting, over and over again, samples of the textual evidence which supports this conclusion.

He is consistent isn't he.;)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom