Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are talking about the "exit maintenance" phase within the stages of change. I have seen that work for many alcoholics, whereby they do stop using AA altogether and stay sober.

No that's not what I'm talking about. I am talking about people who take the whole premise too seriously for too long and start exhibiting some rather bizarre thoughts and behavior because of it, including an addiction to AA meetings themselves.

It is generally accepted that once and alky, always an alky.

Perhaps by AA but certainly not by the Cognitive Behavioral community. Alcoholism is behavior, and like all behaviors, it can be changed.

Why do some exit AA never to drink again and some don't? I have no clue except to say they continue to apply their personal maintenance program which simply no longer includes AA.

That is interesting that you see it that way, obviously from the inside looking out. How else could they do it, right?
 
I want to mention that to me it seems that an underlying belief never really verbalized in AA is that a good person is a sober person.

Or to say that if you follow these rules, do your best to do what you think God wants you to do, then your sobriety will be strong, long lived, and successful.

I suppose it's a noble notion, but the fact is that the most heinous and outright evil people that I personally know in life, both are complete teetotalers and don't use any type of drugs at all.

Being a "good person" will keep you sober? Apparently emulating Satan himself will TOO....
 
No that's not what I'm talking about. I am talking about people who take the whole premise too seriously for too long and start exhibiting some rather bizarre thoughts and behavior because of it, including an addiction to AA meetings themselves.

That's funny. I thought you were talking about people leaving AA (or any part of their maintenance) because they no longer had a need for it

Perhaps by AA but certainly not by the Cognitive Behavioral community. Alcoholism is behavior, and like all behaviors, it can be changed.

I did say generally. That would include the medical profession, AA AND the CBT community including psychiatrists, psychologists, counsellors etc.
And I agree that the bahaviour can be changed, that is exactly what AA does btw; help facilitate that change. But if one were to pick up a drink again, would or would not (in most instances) the mental obsession and physical allergy reappear?

That is interesting that you see it that way, obviously from the inside looking out. How else could they do it, right?

Actually I have a rather unique perspective here: I am a professional in the field of Addiction as a Drug and Alcohol Counsellor (along with other disciplines) as well as a long time sober alcoholic and drug addict. I look from the outside in as well as the inside out.

So what was "obvious" to you was in fact totally incorrect. I see many forms of recovery work for many individuals

I want to mention that to me it seems that an underlying belief never really verbalized in AA is that a good person is a sober person.

Or to say that if you follow these rules, do your best to do what you think God wants you to do, then your sobriety will be strong, long lived, and successful.

I suppose it's a noble notion, but the fact is that the most heinous and outright evil people that I personally know in life, both are complete teetotalers and don't use any type of drugs at all.

Being a "good person" will keep you sober? Apparently emulating Satan himself will TOO....

Wow!...., just wow!

You clearly didn't hear the saying "people in AA are not bad people trying to become good, but sick people trying to get well"?
 
Last edited:
I talked to a CBT counselor and asked him to repeat to me the fact that CBT doesnt say once/always. CBT doesnt think once/always around here & the only reason medical pros say that is because it's classified as a disease and thus insurance covered. They may say it, but I dont know many that believe it, a common occurrence around AA. Even people who dont believe a word OF it recommend it. Time will bring reasonable alternatives.

Your position as a counselor puts you dead center inside looking out.
Objectivity on the matter long since gone, isn't it?
You are pretty sure that I'm wrong arent you?

As I said before, what people say in AA and what they do are a great deal two different things. They say they are sick but they talk and change like they are bad. They say they want to get well but they do so by trying to become good.

And after all, the very start of this thread, they say it isn't a religion either.
 
You clearly didn't hear the saying "people in AA are not bad people trying to become good, but sick people trying to get well"?

This is another example of something you are saying which is not part of the AA program, but began to be heard at meetings several decades ago as courts and the multi-billion dollar treatment centers started acting as recruitment agencies for AA. (By the way, another phrase 'Take what you need and leave the rest' is also not a part of the AA program, but my anecdotal research seems to suggest started when people with non-alcohol problems started to show up at AA meetings (people with drug, sex, gambling, and other behavioral issues) from treatment centers and the courts - that phrase is used in treatment centers due to the fact that non-alcoholic people are pretty much forced into AA, and the phrase lets them know that as far as the centers are concerned, taking what works and discarding the rest attempts to ameliorate the 'one size fits all' AA program model.

In reality, the AA program lay's straight out that alcoholism is a sin-based disease, best treated by a religious program of action (sometimes referred to as a spiritual program of action) summarized by:

1. Admitting that 'probably no human power could relieve our suffering'.
2. Establishing contact with God
3. Turning one's entire life (specifically not just one's drinking problem)over to God
4. Admitting to God one's 'defect's of character' - otherwise known as sins
5. Seek through Prayer & Meditation continuing contact with God - at this point the bait & switch so common in AA is in full swing, as God is now fully described by phrases such as 'He is the Father, We are His Children', 'He who is Above Us All', etc and similar christian phrasing.
6. Spread the good news (note: sarcasm) about this God to others, as well as suggesting the AA program to non-alcoholics (as noted in the chapter 'To Wives' as well as elsewhere.

I repeat my contention, which is anyone - new, old, young, sober, non-sober, anyone at all - who goes into any AA meeting, regardless of country, who full out makes the following statement, will not be met with kindness, love & tolerance (but will instead be met with derision, laughter, isolation, etc) - that phrase being:

"God - nor any Higher Power - is not required to get, nor maintain, sobriety" - there are several stories in AA literature that speak of people who stated just that, and describe the way AA members treated such individuals -- none of which could be called at all loving or kind.

As an aside, the statement above about God not being required is now the sole reason I continue to remain involved in AA - that is, so that members (both new and old) can clearly see that I - and many people I know, including very high ranking corporate AA people (right up to Trustee), are atheists and are able to live full, sober lives without any need for a 'higher power of our understanding'. Our living examples show people in need that getting together with others who have the same problem can be helpful to getting and staying sober - that meeting with similar people can have a strong positive psychological effect that seems to assist people with substance abuse issues - and AA meetings (without God) meet that goal.

No God Necessary (contrary to the core of AA's religious & spiritual program).
 
My favorite step has always been 13 :rolleyes:

I went to 1001 meetings in one year at Miami South Dade a long time ago.

I never went back. That's many years now but honestly I don't count anymore who cares.

AA gave me a place to go where there was no alcohol and a place to listen to how other people have dealt with issues and problems. I made some friends who also thought all the God business was bologna, but that was a hush hush group because we knew better than to talk about it.

It might be by total accident, or by cause/effect, but AA people do the same thing that all other religions do - they ostracize those who don't agree with them.
 
I have no problem with that. Of course I don't recall either version in AA literature.

The real question is in "Today I ( imo the conscious "me" ) have the serenity..." is 'Do you?'. Most drunks don't seem to manage it.

Neither version was in AA literature. Apparently, it was discovered and shown to Bill W. in 1942. He liked it so much that he had it printed on all outgoing correspondence (so I've read) and it caught on like wildfire.

"With amazing speed," writes Bill, "the Serenity Prayer came into general use and took its place alongside our two other favorites, the Lord's Prayer and the Prayer of St. Francis."

As for me personally, yes, I do have the serenity and ability to change the things I can and certainly I work very hard at acceptance. Sometimes I shudder at thinking that "serenity" is a hackneyed term these days, but it is truly fitting for me.
 
I believe the story goes like this:

Early in 1942, writes Bill W., in A.A. Comes of Age, a New York member, Jack, brought to everyone's attention a caption in a routine New York Herald Tribune obituary that read:

"God grant us the serenity to accept the things we cannot change,
courage to change the things we can,
and wisdom to know the difference."


Everyone in A.A.'s burgeoning office on Manhattan's Vesey Street was struck by the power and wisdom contained in the prayer's thoughts. "Never had we seen so much A.A. in so few words," Bill writes. Someone suggested that the prayer be printed on a small, wallet-sized card, to be included in every piece of outgoing mail. Ruth Hock, the Fellowship's first (and nonalcoholic) secretary, contacted Henry S., a Washington D.C. member, and a professional printer, asking him what it would cost to order a bulk printing.

Henry's enthusiastic response was to print 500 copies of the prayer, with the remark: "Incidentally, I am only a heel when I'm drunk .. . so naturally, there could be no charge for anything of this nature."

"With amazing speed," writes Bill, "the Serenity Prayer came into general use and took its place alongside our two other favorites, the Lord's Prayer and the Prayer of St. Francis.

The original "Serenity Prayer" was conceived
in a little stone cottage in Heath, Massachusetts
by Reinhold Niebuhr and, per his daughter, was written like this:

"God, Give us the grace to accept with serenity
the things that cannot be changed, Courage
to change the things which should be changed,
And the wisdom to distinguish the one from the other."

God's grace, or pardon for our sins at the gates of heaven, was left out of the version AA uses. In the original prayer it implies that to achieve that serenity some magical Jesus stuff sure helps.

I think serenity and courage come from the same place paraphrased simply with two statements!

Don't sweat the small stuff.
It's all small stuff.
 
Last edited:
I think serenity and courage come from the same place paraphrased simply with two statements!

Don't sweat the small stuff.
It's all small stuff.



Yeah, that or one of my favorite movie lines from the Skipper in Madagascar: "Just smile and wave, boys! Smile and wave!"
 
I talked to a CBT counselor and asked him to repeat to me the fact that CBT doesnt say once/always. CBT doesnt think once/always around here & the only reason medical pros say that is because it's classified as a disease and thus insurance covered. They may say it, but I dont know many that believe it, a common occurrence around AA. Even people who dont believe a word OF it recommend it. Time will bring reasonable alternatives.

Anyone can cite anecdotal evidence. It really doesn't hold much water around here.

Your position as a counselor puts you dead center inside looking out.
Objectivity on the matter long since gone, isn't it?
You are pretty sure that I'm wrong arent you?

Actually the opposite is true, it allows me to mix with medical professionals, psychiatrists, psychologists, counsellors, AA members, and the list goes on. I also teach some CBT (but I do not claim to be an expert). It seems to me I am in a fairly unique postion.
You might need to consider and fully explain why I have no objectivity.

So yes, I am pretty sure you are wrong.

As I said before, what people say in AA and what they do are a great deal two different things. They say they are sick but they talk and change like they are bad. They say they want to get well but they do so by trying to become good.

Are you saying that alcoholism is or isn't a moral issue? I am a little confused.

My AA meetings are not ones in which we pour petrol on ourselves with a view to ignition.
If you are going to make claims like this, you really ought to back it up with something - the onus is on you.

And after all, the very start of this thread, they say it isn't a religion either.

Which it isn't.
The question is whether it is religious, not whether it is a religion.
 
Last edited:
How religious does it need to be before its religion? :)

Drunkery is behavioral and only sometimes a problem.
It produces behavior that may bring morality into question but isn't a moral issue.
I have a neighbor that is so eat up with being the good son of AA that he is just plain sickening to be around. Out to lunch, flew the coup, got four sponsees all in relapse. But he's normal, it's them that are troubled :confused:

I got over 18 years of sobriety that says I am not wrong but you call a right a right however you might see it. I suspect your clients fall into the dismal figures that AA and others produce for success, somehow I beat those numbers into the dust, but I'm just wrong anyway I suppose. :cool:
 
Religion has borrowed everything they claim to own from life, how could it be any other way?
I don't think that's quite true. If it were, it would be even harder to identify just exactly what it is that distinguishes the "religious" from the "not religious", because that would essentially amount to signing a quitclaim deed on concepts that otherwise might have just been considered to be some pretty good and mostly universal ideas.

I am glad to see that we do appear to agree (subject to your review) that much of what is now recognized as religious in origin actually has origins in, as you say, life. The purely religious concepts then must surely be the ones that were invented rather than simply borrowed. No?

What is interesting about AA in this regard is that it at least appears that they borrowed an awful lot of their doctrine from the religions that borrowed it from life and followed suit by adding God to it for sticking power.
Let's address the "borrowed ideas" thing separately. As to the God concept, it seems to me that if that was already part of those religions, then "following suit" and "adding God" are alternative (as in mutually exclusive) explanations. That's not just a play on words, as much of the debate here has centered on the extent to which AA does in fact "follow suit", with vehement arguments having been presented that AA embraces the Protestant Christian model of "God". The opposing argument, of course, is that AA takes great care to clarify that does not obligate its members to accept any concept of "higher power" but their own -- a degree of freedom which makes it the very antithesis of religion, if that is defined as adherence to a specific set of shared supernatural beliefs.

If that isn't religion, what is it then?
Is that important? If we can't agree on something else to call it, are we then forced to call it religion?

My favorite step has always been 13
You and everybody else. I've always found the challenge to be the same as with Step Five: it's finding that special person to work with.

How religious does it need to be before its religion?
As I see it, that really is the question here. What I would regard as necessary are beliefs with the three qualities I listed above: specific; shared; supernatural. It certainly is possible to define "religious" in a way that does not include all three, but if we acknowledge that we don't all define "religious" the same way, have we not just answered the OP's question?
 
The purely religious concepts then must surely be the ones that were invented rather than simply borrowed. No?

Yes I didn't say that well and am not the wordsmith most appear to be here but good observation. What I meant was "everything rational and logical" or something close to that. "The sun comes and goes every day, which IS a day". Answering WHY is where they made it up as they went along....

a degree of freedom which makes it the very antithesis of religion, if that is defined as adherence to a specific set of shared supernatural beliefs.

Well not really, it's actually brilliant. "Keep your Voodoo, just use it this way to do this particular job." A true "community" religion that transcends traditional boundaries and embraces Theism to solve a common problem among its members.

If we can't agree on something else to call it, are we then forced to call it religion

Well allowing all the established religions to be thrown into one pot to cook a new batch of something certainly is something "new" as religion goes, perhaps even a very good idea. (perhaps they wont kill each other) But it's still religion. Or perhaps "Behavior based in Theism"

but if we acknowledge that we don't all define "religious" the same way, have we not just answered the OP's question?

Well the answer to the original question is simple: They don't callit religion because doing so would turn a lot of needy people at the door, and create a new order that would immediately offend members who have their own ideas. But of course, that's anecdotal evidence if evidence at all as Alfie likes to point out, so the whole thing doesn't exist now does it hehehehehe.

I think most people who have a problem with AA being "religious" as the original poster put it actually have a problem with it being Theistic. Religion is just organized Theism isnt it? Is AA Theistic? 100% Is it religion? Makes little difference. It calls on magical superpowers to solve problems, that I think is what people dont like about it.

The posters who say they are ardent AA participants and also Atheist intrigue me. I wonder why the need to be a part of AA. Surely community is a big part of their drive. I do hope that soon CBT will emerge with it's own version of community geared at dealing with addiction problems. I think those would be some truly interesting meetings that arrive at solid ideas and decisions that most anyone can swallow without a spoonful of magic elixir.
 
Last edited:

Yeah, read that. Perhaps Alfie has figured out that we don't accept anything he says as being gospel.

Probably not though. He probably thinks his stories are real evidence and everyone else's are just anecdotes. :rolleyes:
 
No, I don't think that. I am simply quite used to "professionals" standing on bags of rubbage (like an 8% success rate) and claiming they have all the answers.
That behavior hurts people, it hurt me when I was young. I'm pretty sure it wasn't anecdotal.
I might have sobered up young at perhaps 20 if the treatment I entered hadn't turned me around bent me over and tried to stuff God up my azz. They are still doing it today, it is still wrong to do it and to stand and defend it is grossly inept.
If I had the resources I would gladly spend them to do a definitive study on what the professional world "really" thinks about AA, but it would fall on deaf ears that must pay car and house notes in an industry that is pathetically impotent.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps we should start a thread discussing ideas for how to go about sobering up a loaded percentage of the population.
 
I might have sobered up young at perhaps 20 if the treatment I entered hadn't turned me around bent me over and tried to stuff God up my azz.

No doubt about it. That must have been your only problem.

ps. Ahhh, the memories; drunks and dry drunks explaining their problems and the reasons for them -- usually people, places, and things -- god up the azz is a new one.
 
Well allowing all the established religions to be thrown into one pot to cook a new batch of something certainly is something "new" as religion goes, perhaps even a very good idea. (perhaps they wont kill each other)
Not limited to "all the established religions", though. Over time, one person's imaginary friend might somehow evolve into an established belief system, but until it aquires the important shared aspect, I don't think most people would accept it as meeting the definition of "religion".

But it's still religion. Or perhaps "Behavior based in Theism"
If theists were more consistent in demonstrating that their belief systems are actually effective at producing the significant changes in behavior their doctrines are always going on about instead of, if anything, intensifying certain behaviors the rest of society often sees as rather repulsive, I doubt if there would be the strong objections we see to the influence those belief systems have. What I like about you've said there is that it places the emphasis where I feel it does belong: on improved quality of life through adjustments in inner states and the resulting changes in behavior -- in this life -- rather than on any of the usual promised benefits of improved quality of a proposed afterlife (a goal toward which the behavior modification tends to be treated by bona fide religion as more as a means to an end than an end in itself). I did earlier offer the proposition that AA might be referred to as "metareligious" -- acknowledging that while the specific supernatural beliefs are not shared, religious elements are present -- but that idea never got any traction here.

Well the answer to the original question is simple: They don't callit religion because doing so would turn a lot of needy people at the door, and create a new order that would immediately offend members who have their own ideas.
In other words, as Perry Mason might have said, it goes to motive. That argument has been presented here, but it seems to rely entirely on assertion for its support.

It calls on magical superpowers to solve problems, that I think is what people dont like about it.
It certainly does at least tolerate that, and a lot of people these days seem to have a strong dislike of anything that even tolerates such ideas.

I wonder why the need to be a part of AA. Surely community is a big part of their drive.
Why the need to be a part of any community? I've always been intrigued by the degree of emotional investment some people are willing to make in identifying themselves as, say, fans of a particular sports team -- but I don't need to wonder about that sort of thing for very long. All I have to do to explain it is to consider what kind of survival chances (let alone reproductive opportunities) a solitary proto-human would have had on the African savannah.
 
Ahhhhhh - Dry Drunks --- Sober unhappy people who wont buy the bull to reach sobrietal Nirvana ....

hehehehe

It's more like people IN places poking THINGS up your azz.....

"Oh this person has behavioral problems, I KNOW, let's poke GOD up his azz!"

hehehehe

"He doesn't have a full plate yet, let's introduce a theist slant to his misgivings that will surely straighten him on out!"

Solving insanity - WITH insanity........
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom