Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
For me, 18 years sobriety didn't require 55 pages of debating hehehe

Carl Jung wrote the 12 steps not bill or bob. If believing in entities or objects with supernatural powers that can influence your life is what is being called "religious" in this discussion, then AA is certainly religious. It can be tweaked into many things but in it's pristine state as the BB states it is universal religion with a homogeneous mission.

"God as you understand him" from the BB isn't some deep anything, it just means "God of your religion-or not" that's all. Designed to not alienate, not to create a new axiom for universal supernatural design. "Keep it simple stupid" has been heard more than once in AA.

My humble opinion is the only Higher Power, (or Additional Power would be good) that actually exists is Knowledge. Whether that falls from the sky or pops into your head while you spend three days in the belly of a fish is up to you, as long as you find it.
The second and third steps are formatted so that an individual "gives" his will over to the care of another entity simply because in doing this they overcome their lack of trust for anyone or anything and become receptive to new knowledge. Think outside of the little box they have thought themselves into, which people do about all kinds of things. The worse things are, the less likely you are to listen to anyone, it's a self defense mechanism that will kill you when using unnatural powerful chemicals like alcohol. It's just not that complicated.
People who are offended by the whole idea of some Genie in a bottle (as I was) scoff at the delivery system rather than the goods.
Face it, a lot of people in the world will listen to things if it's delivered from a magical powerful super hero. Those that are smart enough to absorb above this level are also hopefully smart enough to focus on the content rather than the delivery. The key is to understand and accept that I don't have the answers and I need to listen to learn them.
If I have to see a finger sticking through the clouds pointing at me to listen then whatever, if I listen I listen. Is that religion?

With tongue in cheek just about anybody with a brain can sit down in AA and hear some pretty good problem solving stories and solutions to the everyday problems that torment newly sober individuals. To me those stories are where the real benefits of AA really are. You can learn how to live sober there and that is what the people there don't know how to do anymore. Take what you need and leave the rest is in order, it's not very efficient but it is a place for people to go and listen to alternatives to their own way of thinking no matter where the sharing person thinks it came from.

Something that really surprises me is that AA hasn't put together a book, a BIG book, of all the problems of life that are discussed in meetings accompanied by the MANY MANY different solutions to them that people offer up in meetings. Spending time in meetings and just the act of going to them regularly helps many people, but the pace of spoon feeding the knowledge people need in meetings is dismally slow in my opinion. People who take a year to work the 12 steps are just playing with it, a trend that has become fashionable in AA, as if to take more time is to work them more efficiently.

I’m a monkey’s uncle if Dr. Jung didn’t pull the 4th and 5th steps straight out of Catholicism. Confession has strong emotional healing properties especially when the bag of guilt somebody is carrying around is too large to carry. It’s also interesting that Jung made one of the requirements for the 5th step to not only tell your God about all this garbage, but to tell another human being. The other human being, not God, is what makes the admittance real. It certainly does produce a state of emotion that has been likened to being “born again”, a catharsis or sorts, a feeling of immense burdens being lifted.
To this day I will swear that the 6th 7th 8th and 9th steps are what is sorely lacking in the Christian process of being “born again” which is very much the same kind of process. I think that Dr. Jung got the sequence of these steps a little mixed up as the 8th and 9th should be done thus “paying the price” before a person asks “whoever” to help them not do that crap again.
Anyone who reads the 11th and then says there is nothing religious about AA has missed the boat ride.
“Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with
God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.”
It’s proven that AA is no more effective than any other effort including no effort in achieving sobriety. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, whose founder Albert Ellis immediately found himself on AA’s **** list for claiming that you don’t need a higher power to achieve sobriety, is now coming of age finally. I believe that this approach will eventually replace AA’s place with the court systems because of it’s lack of dependence on higher powers and “religious-like” implications.
 
Ben, you're entire post is based on a false statement - that is, Jung had basically Zero - nada, zip, nothing whatever - to do with the 12 steps.
None at all.
Read up a bit on the oxford group (or moral rearmament, or Up With People even) - there are many informative links throughout this thread referring back to orginal sources that can help you understand how bill got to the steps from the teachings of Buchanan, Shoemaker, etc.
Jung's part in the development of AA was very very small.
 
Well thats what I read at some point and actually dont care about "the" source because it has little to do with examining the actual nature of AA and it's religious practices. I don't need to know the evolutionary history of an amoeba to examine its current nature.

The point is that religion can be a delivery system for just about any kind of knowledge including how to stay sober.

Though AA itself was not deemed a religion, it was ruled that it contained enough religious components to make coerced attendance at AA meetings a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment of the constitution. In September 2007, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit stated that a parole office can be sued for ordering a parolee to attend AA."

"A fair reading of the fundamental AA doctrinal writings discloses that their dominant theme is unequivocally religious," the court said. "Adherence to the AA fellowship entails engagement in religious activity and religious proselytization."
 
Last edited:
For me, 18 years sobriety didn't require 55 pages of debating hehehe
Me either. It may, however, have helped to make it possible (may have, mind you; not making any specific claim here; hypothetical alternate time lines may be fraught with perils of their own, with no guarantees regarding any particular outcome). At the very least, I'm pretty sure it has had a favorable effect on the quality of these diversions, at least on my end.

I’m a monkey’s uncle if Dr. Jung didn’t pull the 4th and 5th steps straight out of Catholicism.
Would you settle for cousin? I mean, suppose it turns out that the subject may have been touched on once or twice by thinkers predating Catholicism by a number of centuries. Do we conclude that they were drawing from the same source, or that certain ideas are just more likely than others to be sort of stumbled upon?
 
Would you settle for cousin?

It wouldn't surprise me if the first Homo sapiens did this after bludgeoning numerous Neanderthals to death and taking their territory but monkey see monkey do seems in order here.
 
Do you suggest that an AA group comprised of, say, fundamentalist YEC's will suddenly chose AA as their means of being religious?

I think that's unlikely; they'll remain YECs.

I'm not suggesting that they'll abandon their churches and formal religious affiliations and express their religiosity solely through AA, no.

What I'm suggesting is that an AA group comprised of fundamentalist YECs is highly likely to inject their religious beliefs into their AA group. Such people tend to inject their religious beliefs into practically everything, and since AA specifically invites people to bring their religious beliefs into the program (I think even you would have to admit that "God as you understand Him" means -- if nothing else -- that if you already pray to the Christian god, then that's the chap you should be asking for help with your sobriety).

And I'm suggesting that an AA group that begins and ends its meetings with prayers, and where much of the discussion involves how God has enriched their lives, etc., can fairly be called "religious." Do you disagree?
 
Apologies for the offending smiley; I actually meant nothing by it except to show confusion.

Ok, I'll accept that that was your intent. To me, it came across as "what kind of idiot are you?" In my experience, a lot of people use smilies in a passive-aggressive way. E.g. saying something insulting and then sticking on a happy face or wink so they can claim they were kidding.

I see where you are coming from and my best response (without looking up all the individual examples you gave) would be "context".

I think you will find I am usually responding to some 'black and white' opinion of a poster, with a 'black or white' counter comment. In other words, my comment does not necessarily mean that is where my opinion on the matter falls, it is simply to challenge their opinion with a request for evidence, context, further clarification etc.

Well, I tried to be as fair as I could regarding context. When I see you repeatedly responding to statements that AA is religious with demands to know "what religion is being taught/required," it implies to me that you think that those are necessary conditions for AA to be religious. Otherwise it's not part of the claimant's burden of proof.

But I know there have been a few statements in this thread about AA being a "cult" or a "religion," so at times the discussion will get confused.

My opinion is far less black or white and falls into the wonderful world of gray; I see that it is (religious) by certain definitions and it isn't by others.
I also see that some members are religious and others arent.
Additionally I see some members get better with the steps and a higher power, and some with the steps but without. Or without the steps but with a hp (I could go on).

The overall thrust of AA as I have seen it practiced, and as I have interpreted my many years of membership is around total religious freedom, including that of no religion.

Ultimately the decision as to whether the program is or isn't religious boils down to the opinion of one person alone; that of the individual member.

Again, my apologies, I have no personal gripe with you. :cool:

I appreciate that, and thanks for the response.
 
Thanks I needed that got any bananas?
I'll rephrase.

It looked for a minute there like you might be the first one in 56 pages (it is now) who might regard the sort of question I was asking there as worthy of a serious attempt at an answer, but when you went off into the bit about bludgeoning and monkeys and all, it occurred to me that I might have been mistaken. If it doesn't interest you, then cool, let the snackfest continue. I find it fun to inquire as to just exactly what it is that distinguishes the "religious" from the "not religious" (arguing, for instance, that the former must include a certain public aspect), but some of the posters here have made it clear that their bases for making that distinction are good enough for them and should be good enough for anyone; the matter may be quickly be put to rest on a dictionary lookup, and anything beyond that is sophistry.

Another possibility I considered was that your response was intended as a serious answer to my question, but that I am just too simple to grasp it. By exploiting the lovely opening you gave me there, I figured I'd have it covered either way, because if it turned out to be this latter, you'd realize that I was just covering up my embarassment at finding myself having to ask you to dumb it down for me.
 
Sorry I think I misunderstood you and still do to some degree.
What I meant with the sapien monkey thing was at some point in history humans realized that admitting their woes/crimes was emotionally beneficial, (4th & 5th) no telling when that happened, but the birthers of AA or the steps had Catholicism to look at, thus monkey see monkey do in a friendly jab at established religion.

I am not sure what the subject pondered prior to Catholicism is if you aren't talking about this.

Religion to me is any behavior or group of behaviors which are designed to worship or to use the power of a supernatural being for ones own benefit. Organized religion is when more than one person is using the same approach to that end.

Spiritual to me means believing in supernatural powers but not agreeing with any organized form of using them that you know of.

I suppose I am an agnostic and Naturalistic Pantheist or at least those two definitions seems to fit my ideas at the moment.

AA clearly suggests the use of powers of some supernatural entity or thing and clearly suggests exactly how to go about that. This to me qualifies it to be organized religion.

Apparently the courts saw enough similarities to site the need for protection of separation of church and state.

A drunk rarely admits that he's a drunk either ya know. :-)
 
Last edited:
I might add that I love the serenity prayer except for the fact that it's a prayer.

God grant me this and God grant me that. Entity dependent people always seem to be asking for something. My logic says everything is already "given" and now they want help with perceiving it to their benefit.

You would think that if God would actually do this for you, he would go ahead and do it just once and make it stick, so you wouldn't be bothering him every 8 hours asking for it again. :)
 
Last edited:
I might add that I love the serenity prayer except for the fact that it's a prayer.

God grant me this and God grant me that. Entity dependent people always seem to be asking for something. My logic says everything is already "given" and now they want help with perceiving it to their benefit.

You would think that if God would actually do this for you, he would go ahead and do it just once and make it stick, so you wouldn't be bothering him every 8 hours asking for it again. :)


Frankly, I do too.

Which is why, a thousand or so posts ago, I suggested to Alfie a change to the Serenity Prayer to more like the Serenity Affirmation:

Instead of "God grant me the serenity..." it was "Today I have the serenity..."
 
And I'm suggesting that an AA group that begins and ends its meetings with prayers, and where much of the discussion involves how God has enriched their lives, etc., can fairly be called "religious." Do you disagree?

Where I come from we do not start the meeting with a prayer, but we finish with the serenity prayer.

At the risk of being in poor taste, I'm going to post a link to this video from The Onion

I thought that was hilarious. Thanks, I am forwarding it to my AA mates.

Which is why, a thousand or so posts ago, I suggested to Alfie a change to the Serenity Prayer to more like the Serenity Affirmation:

Instead of "God grant me the serenity..." it was "Today I have the serenity..."

Funnily enough, when doing presentations on Addiction Awareness, self-esteem etc I often use the prayer simply without the word "God", as an affirmation (i.e. message to self).
"..Grant me the serenity....."


According to Wiki the serenity prayer possibly has its roots in a mother goose nursery rhyme from 1695.

For every ailment under the sun
There is a remedy, or there is none;
If there be one, try to find it;
If there be none, never mind it.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serenity_Prayer

Perhaps nursery rhymes are religious too.:)
 
What I meant with the sapien monkey thing was at some point in history humans realized that admitting their woes/crimes was emotionally beneficial, (4th & 5th) no telling when that happened, but the birthers of AA or the steps had Catholicism to look at, thus monkey see monkey do in a friendly jab at established religion.
Excellent. I must apologize for the sarcasm then. Please take it as just my special way of welcoming you to the forum. Your response was indeed cryptic, and that can be enjoyable sometimes (as I will now demonstrate by providing a plethora of verbosity for comparison).

The first has to do with the origins of "confession" itself. I think we need to start with a little unpacking. It may be that admitting one's woes/crimes can have emotional benefits, but we must acknowledge the possibility of other benefits and their corresponding motives as well. I will postulate (admitting up front that some of these ideas I am merely passing along) that the ability to outsmart and out-think other humans can pay handsomely in the currency of reproductive fitness, that part of that often involves the ability to deceive other humans (or monkeys, if you're a monkey; most of us here are probably aware of the studies showing deception among chimpanzees and all that).

With humans, the recipients of these deceptions are more likely to have insight into the ways in which they themselves practice deception, and to therefore be wary of this on the part of others -- hence, deception is most likely to succeed when the deceiver is able to buy into the deception himself. This is a feat which requires some rearranging of the mental furniture. Some compartmentalization. Some cognitive dissonance. Whatever. It may not always be as harmful or as fundamentally immoral as it sounds. What is regarded as common curtesy in polite society typically involves emphasizing certain aspects of one's makeup while de-emphasizing others. We all want (and need) to be respected, and in order to make a good impression we may need to fudge a little here and there. Put our best foot forward. Leave the skeletons in the closet. Refrain from airing our dirty laundry in public. Keep smiling. (Our "social smile" is not our real smile, but we don't necessarily use it to trick others, just to let them know we do not have hostile intentions -- unless of course we do, in which case it can be used deceptively).

The biggest problem may be encountered not when we have been caught in a deception, but when we have been too successful. Successfully exaggerate your qualifications on a resume (or a computer dating profile), and you may well end up with a job (or a mate) you are not suited for. If you are one of those very successful deceivers who have become so lost in the web that you don't know where the real you leaves off and the fictitious character begins, then you may easily be inclined to blame all of your failures on others, or on just plain rotten luck, or bad weather -- how could it be otherwise, you being so perfectly suited to this thing and all?

The expectations of others loom ever large in our minds, and we may embark on a path of lies for the noblest of reasons. The loving son of the proud mining engineer might actually be able to convince himself that flying rockets never was his passion but only a passing fancy, and that being a coal miner just like his dad was all he ever truly wanted to do. Our brains appear to be structured in such a way as to permit this degree of compartmentalization. To indulge a bit of pop-psyche cliche, there may actually be something to this business about "coming out of hiding" and "rediscovering one's authentic self" and all that. It may well be that identifying self-deception may be inherently a difficult thing to achieve in isolation for the same reasons that make it possible in the first place.

I can't think of any logical (or empirical!) reason to suppose that any of this is unique to modern humans -- but then that brings up the second part: where it is that AA obtains these insights (if insights they are, rather than just so much psychobabble). My take on this is that the very thing that makes religious memes so successful is their ability to attach themselves to fundamental aspects of human nature, and to subvert these to their own ends. I stated, far above, that I do think there can be something powerful and very healing in letting another human being see into those places we usually keep hidden, and talking about those things we usually don't like to talk about.

I don't believe that involves anything particularly mysterious or magical -- but that idea has been co-opted by religion (it is my understanding that Catholicism in particular places very great emphasis on this). I submit that the "God" concept was artifically inserted into this process (among others), and once the refined meme had become dominant in the minds of many people, its origins were forgotten. As I see you have just noted, the main objection to the serenity prayer is that it is a prayer, i.e., that it is inherently religious in nature, but I see it as more fundamental than that. It's simply a tool that may be applied toward accomplishing an adjustment in one's inner states. It is NOT inherently religious (supernatural, magical) in nature. The founders of AA rediscovered something powerful and fundamental, and given their cultural frame of reference it is not surprising that some of them couched it in religious terms, making the now time-honored error of attributing to religion something that never did rightfully belong to it. There are those (plenty, in fact) who follow them in the commission of this error, but there are plenty more who deny that the benefits they obtain from implementing some of these fundamental concepts come from practicing "religion".

Hence this thread.
 
Instead of "God grant me the serenity..." it was "Today I have the serenity..."
I have no problem with that. Of course I don't recall either version in AA literature.

The real question is in "Today I ( imo the conscious "me" ) have the serenity..." is 'Do you?'. Most drunks don't seem to manage it.
 
My higher power has done so much for me.

That was the topic in the last meeting I ever attended during which I got up and walked out never to return.

It was right after a woman recalled the story of what had just happened to her on the way to the meeting. She had gotten tied up and was worried that she would not make it on time to the meeting. To her astonishment, every traffic signal she came to turned green as she approached allowing her to get to the meeting on time, showing just how much her higher power was looking out for her.

There is a lot that can be had at AA but there is also a point at which enough is enough and it's time to move on with your life.
 
To indulge a bit of pop-psyche cliche, there may actually be something to this business about "coming out of hiding" and "rediscovering one's authentic self" and all that. It may well be that identifying self-deception may be inherently a difficult thing to achieve in isolation for the same reasons that make it possible in the first place.

I don't think its self deception, it's confusion about person and action. Its an unrealistic belief that these things they have done are who they are, rather than what they did. Drugs often produce behavior that almost immediately is regretted. A collection of those deeds over time leads to the false assumption that these are an indication of who the person actually is. The person is fully aware of what they have done and painfully so. "Coming out" strikes an important difference between behavior and person which can and does cause a catharsis in many cases.

where it is that AA obtains these insights

I would offer that they got them from the same place that Jews and Christians got the 10 commandments. I think you are right, yes they are drawn from human life and then claimed as their own.
"Moses got them from God"

Well THAT settles THAT! :D

Religion has borrowed everything they claim to own from life, how could it be any other way?

What is interesting about AA in this regard is that it at least appears that they borrowed an awful lot of their doctrine from the religions that borrowed it from life and followed suit by adding God to it for sticking power.

If that isn't religion, what is it then?
 
Last edited:
There is a lot that can be had at AA but there is also a point at which enough is enough and it's time to move on with your life.

You are talking about the "exit maintenance" phase within the stages of change. I have seen that work for many alcoholics, whereby they do stop using AA altogether and stay sober.

As a reminder, simply and briefly the stages are:
Precontemplative - where there is no problem or one is in denial
Contemplative - Hmmm? Maybe I do have a problem
Decision - Yes, I do have a problem
Action - education, experimentation etc
Maintenance - continue the use of the tools
Exit - I no longer need to apply maintenance

There is "quandry" and "ambivalence" within these stages by the way, as well as relapses.

This exit stage is not always an option (e.g. for weight management, one would need to keep to their diet). In other situations (e.g. moving house) there would be no requirement for maintenance - once you are unpacked and settled one exits the stages of change.

It is generally accepted that once and alky, always an alky. The fear of relapse, the enjoyment of the meetings, their friends etc etc keep people coming back decades into recovery.

Why do some exit AA never to drink again and some don't? I have no clue except to say they continue to apply their personal maintenance program which simply no longer includes AA.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom