For me, 18 years sobriety didn't require 55 pages of debating hehehe
Carl Jung wrote the 12 steps not bill or bob. If believing in entities or objects with supernatural powers that can influence your life is what is being called "religious" in this discussion, then AA is certainly religious. It can be tweaked into many things but in it's pristine state as the BB states it is universal religion with a homogeneous mission.
"God as you understand him" from the BB isn't some deep anything, it just means "God of your religion-or not" that's all. Designed to not alienate, not to create a new axiom for universal supernatural design. "Keep it simple stupid" has been heard more than once in AA.
My humble opinion is the only Higher Power, (or Additional Power would be good) that actually exists is Knowledge. Whether that falls from the sky or pops into your head while you spend three days in the belly of a fish is up to you, as long as you find it.
The second and third steps are formatted so that an individual "gives" his will over to the care of another entity simply because in doing this they overcome their lack of trust for anyone or anything and become receptive to new knowledge. Think outside of the little box they have thought themselves into, which people do about all kinds of things. The worse things are, the less likely you are to listen to anyone, it's a self defense mechanism that will kill you when using unnatural powerful chemicals like alcohol. It's just not that complicated.
People who are offended by the whole idea of some Genie in a bottle (as I was) scoff at the delivery system rather than the goods.
Face it, a lot of people in the world will listen to things if it's delivered from a magical powerful super hero. Those that are smart enough to absorb above this level are also hopefully smart enough to focus on the content rather than the delivery. The key is to understand and accept that I don't have the answers and I need to listen to learn them.
If I have to see a finger sticking through the clouds pointing at me to listen then whatever, if I listen I listen. Is that religion?
With tongue in cheek just about anybody with a brain can sit down in AA and hear some pretty good problem solving stories and solutions to the everyday problems that torment newly sober individuals. To me those stories are where the real benefits of AA really are. You can learn how to live sober there and that is what the people there don't know how to do anymore. Take what you need and leave the rest is in order, it's not very efficient but it is a place for people to go and listen to alternatives to their own way of thinking no matter where the sharing person thinks it came from.
Something that really surprises me is that AA hasn't put together a book, a BIG book, of all the problems of life that are discussed in meetings accompanied by the MANY MANY different solutions to them that people offer up in meetings. Spending time in meetings and just the act of going to them regularly helps many people, but the pace of spoon feeding the knowledge people need in meetings is dismally slow in my opinion. People who take a year to work the 12 steps are just playing with it, a trend that has become fashionable in AA, as if to take more time is to work them more efficiently.
I’m a monkey’s uncle if Dr. Jung didn’t pull the 4th and 5th steps straight out of Catholicism. Confession has strong emotional healing properties especially when the bag of guilt somebody is carrying around is too large to carry. It’s also interesting that Jung made one of the requirements for the 5th step to not only tell your God about all this garbage, but to tell another human being. The other human being, not God, is what makes the admittance real. It certainly does produce a state of emotion that has been likened to being “born again”, a catharsis or sorts, a feeling of immense burdens being lifted.
To this day I will swear that the 6th 7th 8th and 9th steps are what is sorely lacking in the Christian process of being “born again” which is very much the same kind of process. I think that Dr. Jung got the sequence of these steps a little mixed up as the 8th and 9th should be done thus “paying the price” before a person asks “whoever” to help them not do that crap again.
Anyone who reads the 11th and then says there is nothing religious about AA has missed the boat ride.
“Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with
God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.”
It’s proven that AA is no more effective than any other effort including no effort in achieving sobriety. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, whose founder Albert Ellis immediately found himself on AA’s **** list for claiming that you don’t need a higher power to achieve sobriety, is now coming of age finally. I believe that this approach will eventually replace AA’s place with the court systems because of it’s lack of dependence on higher powers and “religious-like” implications.
Carl Jung wrote the 12 steps not bill or bob. If believing in entities or objects with supernatural powers that can influence your life is what is being called "religious" in this discussion, then AA is certainly religious. It can be tweaked into many things but in it's pristine state as the BB states it is universal religion with a homogeneous mission.
"God as you understand him" from the BB isn't some deep anything, it just means "God of your religion-or not" that's all. Designed to not alienate, not to create a new axiom for universal supernatural design. "Keep it simple stupid" has been heard more than once in AA.
My humble opinion is the only Higher Power, (or Additional Power would be good) that actually exists is Knowledge. Whether that falls from the sky or pops into your head while you spend three days in the belly of a fish is up to you, as long as you find it.
The second and third steps are formatted so that an individual "gives" his will over to the care of another entity simply because in doing this they overcome their lack of trust for anyone or anything and become receptive to new knowledge. Think outside of the little box they have thought themselves into, which people do about all kinds of things. The worse things are, the less likely you are to listen to anyone, it's a self defense mechanism that will kill you when using unnatural powerful chemicals like alcohol. It's just not that complicated.
People who are offended by the whole idea of some Genie in a bottle (as I was) scoff at the delivery system rather than the goods.
Face it, a lot of people in the world will listen to things if it's delivered from a magical powerful super hero. Those that are smart enough to absorb above this level are also hopefully smart enough to focus on the content rather than the delivery. The key is to understand and accept that I don't have the answers and I need to listen to learn them.
If I have to see a finger sticking through the clouds pointing at me to listen then whatever, if I listen I listen. Is that religion?
With tongue in cheek just about anybody with a brain can sit down in AA and hear some pretty good problem solving stories and solutions to the everyday problems that torment newly sober individuals. To me those stories are where the real benefits of AA really are. You can learn how to live sober there and that is what the people there don't know how to do anymore. Take what you need and leave the rest is in order, it's not very efficient but it is a place for people to go and listen to alternatives to their own way of thinking no matter where the sharing person thinks it came from.
Something that really surprises me is that AA hasn't put together a book, a BIG book, of all the problems of life that are discussed in meetings accompanied by the MANY MANY different solutions to them that people offer up in meetings. Spending time in meetings and just the act of going to them regularly helps many people, but the pace of spoon feeding the knowledge people need in meetings is dismally slow in my opinion. People who take a year to work the 12 steps are just playing with it, a trend that has become fashionable in AA, as if to take more time is to work them more efficiently.
I’m a monkey’s uncle if Dr. Jung didn’t pull the 4th and 5th steps straight out of Catholicism. Confession has strong emotional healing properties especially when the bag of guilt somebody is carrying around is too large to carry. It’s also interesting that Jung made one of the requirements for the 5th step to not only tell your God about all this garbage, but to tell another human being. The other human being, not God, is what makes the admittance real. It certainly does produce a state of emotion that has been likened to being “born again”, a catharsis or sorts, a feeling of immense burdens being lifted.
To this day I will swear that the 6th 7th 8th and 9th steps are what is sorely lacking in the Christian process of being “born again” which is very much the same kind of process. I think that Dr. Jung got the sequence of these steps a little mixed up as the 8th and 9th should be done thus “paying the price” before a person asks “whoever” to help them not do that crap again.
Anyone who reads the 11th and then says there is nothing religious about AA has missed the boat ride.
“Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with
God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.”
It’s proven that AA is no more effective than any other effort including no effort in achieving sobriety. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, whose founder Albert Ellis immediately found himself on AA’s **** list for claiming that you don’t need a higher power to achieve sobriety, is now coming of age finally. I believe that this approach will eventually replace AA’s place with the court systems because of it’s lack of dependence on higher powers and “religious-like” implications.