Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I cannot agree with that interpretation. At the time, Nolan was engaged in a desperate struggle for survival, which hinged on his success or failure at creating fire.

Just went and watched the scene under discussion and you have it wrong. he did not create Wilson because he was engaged in a desperate stuggle where his survival hinged on creating fire. He created Wilson because he was very frustrated that he hadn't been able to create fire. His frustration boiled over when his stick slipped and he cut his hand. He went into a rage and threw things about the camp, including a volleyball. The blood from his hand left a mark on the volleyball that he then turned into Wilson.

Wilson was not a HP in any way shape or form, he was simply a companion replacement.

There is a particular quote that comes to mind upon my reading that:

"When people thought the earth was flat, they were wrong. When people thought the earth was spherical, they were wrong. But if you think that thinking the earth is spherical is just as wrong as thinking the earth is flat, then your view is wronger than both of them put together."

Bad quote because it is fundamentally flawed. The Earth is spherical.

spher·i·cal

–adjective
1.having the form of a sphere; globular.
2.formed in or on a sphere, as a figure.
3.of or pertaining to a sphere or spheres.
4.pertaining to the heavenly bodies, or to their supposed revolving spheres or shells.
5.pertaining to the heavenly bodies regarded astrologically as exerting influence on humankind and events.

sphere

–noun
1.Geometry.
a.a solid geometric figure generated by the revolution of a semicircle about its diameter; a round body whose surface is at all points equidistant from the center. equation: x2 + y2 + z2 = r2.
b.the surface of such a figure; a spherical surface.
2.any rounded body approximately of this form; a globular mass, shell, etc.
3.Astronomy.
a.a planet or star; heavenly body.
b.celestial sphere.
c.any of the transparent, concentric, spherical shells, or layers, in which, according to ancient belief, the planets, stars, and other heavenly bodies were set.
4.the place or environment within which a person or thing exists; a field of activity or operation: to be out of one's professional sphere.
5.a particular social world, stratum of society, or walk of life: His social sphere is small.
6.a field of something specified: a sphere of knowledge.
 
Last edited:
he did not create Wilson because he was engaged in a desperate stuggle where his survival hinged on creating fire
If you read my post again more carefully, you may see that I didn't use the word "because".

The blood from his hand left a mark on the volleyball that he then turned into Wilson.
Right. And then...?

Well, GB is correct.
Ah. So logic cannot exist independent of empirical evidence? This may be an interesting new avenue of investigation.

Bad quote because it is fundamentally flawed. The Earth is spherical.
Heh. Well, I'll let you take that up with Asimov. Those details have very little to do with the association I was making between that quote and your post, and while I'm slightly disappointed that you missed the point entirely, I can't say that I'm particularly surprised.

Wilson was not a HP in any way shape or form, he was simply a companion replacement.
Already stipulated to above. Are you bothering to read the posts you're responding to at all?
 
Last edited:
If you read my post again more carefully, you may see that I didn't use the word "because".

Regardless, the point is, you got it wrong.

Right. And then...?

He went back to making fire, it worked. he looked at Wilson and then the fire went out. He figured out what he did wrong, adjusted things and successfully made fire.

Ah. So logic cannot exist independent of empirical evidence? This may be an interesting new avenue of investigation.

Sure, it can also exist without evidence of god but without evidence, you can't prove god exists.

Heh. Well, I'll let you take that up with Asimov.

You made a claim that was wrong, why not just admit to it?

Those details have very little to do with the association I was making between that quote and your post, and while I'm slightly disappointed that you missed the point entirely, I can't say that I'm particularly surprised.

I didn't ignore it. The point you made, intentionally or not, is that both were wrong but one is less wrong. Applying that to the christian and AA perspectives on god seems to make my point . . . both are wrong but christians and AA members insist on having their perspective.

You seem to think that it is important that one is more wrong than the other, that this in some way helps your cause.

Already stipulated to above. Are you bothering to read the posts you're responding to at all?

You stipulate it but you keep trying to draw parallels. You are saying HP is to an AA member what Wilson was to Nolan. That isn't true at all and it isn't the way AA says an HP works.

I think failure to read is your issue, not mine.
 
It was a general "you". Care to answer, rather than dodge ?

Silly me, imagine taking you literally.

So, presumably, once you're done with AA and are sober you can kick that ugly God As You Understand Him out of your life ?

When I stopped playing sport, my exercise ceased but my calories didn't. As a consequence I put on a bit of weight. What did I do? I went on a diet, I learned about nutrition, carbohydrates, protein, metabolism, food groups etc etc. I implemented a moderate exercise regime, I ate balanced meals, smaller portions, and numerous other things to help me.
(It just struck me that my higher power for this weight loss was education!)

Once I had achieved my weight reduction goals, did I throw out all the tools I had gathered together? Or do I retain them continue to use them as part of my maintenance in managing my weight in an ongoing basis?

Obviously I continue to use them.

The same with AA and a higher power. Why would I discard what has worked so well to assist me in obtaining my hard won sobriety? Obviously I wouldn't: AA continues to form part of my personal maintenance program.

So, I (as in the specific me, not a general I :rolleyes:) don't finish with AA, my HP, or anything else that works for me. I take what I need, leave the rest and keep going back.
 
Regardless, the point is, you got it wrong.
You and I may differ in our interpretations of what is happening in that scene, just as we may disagree on how best to interpret a passage from AA literature. If the dispute is over the actual content of the material under consideration, that's a problem of an entirely different nature. I do own a copy of the movie, so if we need to nail down just what is and what is not portrayed, well, that's a bit unfortunate, but I suppose (with apologies to those for whom the analogy has grown stale) it has to be done.

Sure, it can also exist without evidence of god but without evidence, you can't prove god exists.
The only word in that marginally coherent sentence that I'm really interested in is the first one. May I then paraphrase you thusly?: "Sure, logic can exist independent of evidence."

And may I take this as a retraction of your endorsement of GB's statement: "You haven't provided any evidence for your assertions, therefore you have no logic."?

You made a claim that was wrong, why not just admit to it?
You have chosen the wrong conceptual level at which to approach this. I was not presenting it as a claim (one having to do with the shape of the Earth) but as an illustration: two different views of a thing, held by two different groups of people, may be referred to in such a way as to imply that they are quite similar when in fact they are different in a very important way. That quote does constitute a claim, however, and I only wish it were my name rather than Isaac Asimov's that is associated with it -- but as it is, I can only repeat my suggestion that you take it up with him. Sadly, he is no longer with us, but if you would like to conduct that debate here, I don't see why we shouldn't be able to squeeze that in; shouldn't take up too much space (as if we weren't so far past worrying about that anyway). While you're at it, I do hope you will read the entire essay on The Relativity of Wrong, because a lot of the problem I see you having is that you are exactly the sort of person Asimov had in mind here:

"The basic trouble, you see, is that people think that "right" and "wrong" are absolute; that everything that isn't perfectly and completely right is totally and equally wrong."

As to this question of the sphericity of the earth, I'd say the passage you are attempting to refute (with dictionary lookups!) is this one:

And yet is the earth a sphere?

No, it is not a sphere; not in the strict mathematical sense. A sphere has certain mathematical properties; for instance, all diameters (that is, all straight lines that pass from one point on its surface, through the center, to another point on its surface) have the same length.

That, however, is not true of the earth. Various diameters of the earth differ in length.
http://chem.tufts.edu/answersinscience/relativityofwrong.htm


You stipulate it but you keep trying to draw parallels.You are saying HP is to an AA member what Wilson was to Nolan.
I do see parallels. I doubt if many AA members would quickly agree that their HP is to them what Wilson was to Nolan (though if the doorknob group turns out not to be an empty set after all, those are the first ones I'd go to in search of supporters for that idea), and I expect most Christians would be even more reluctant to accept my postulate that their God is nothing more than an externalization of some aspects of themselves, but that's really not what I'm getting at anyway. Much of the dispute earlier on had to do with AA's "requirement" for a higher power, and included some quotes from AA literature to the effect that this is not nearly as stringent or as difficult to achieve as one might expect. I submit that the reason for this is that the human brain is hardwired with a strong predisposition for naive panpsychism, and that it manifests across a wide range from the trivial and benign to the extreme and pathological, and that the average person practices this all the time to one degree or another.

And with that, I'm out, for the next 24 hours at least.
 
If I have resiled from my comments, please show me where.

My point is that speculating on what might happen in a movie compared to what happens in the life of an AAer are two different things. The comparison on that level is dubious at best, thus my comment regarding it being "quite a stretch.

It also shows that you are having a difficult time interpreting Dynamic's well considered, well constructed arguments (I wish I had that knowledge and skill), which is a pity for you - there is a lot of great stuff in there. :)
 
If I have resiled from my comments, please show me where.

My point is that speculating on what might happen in a movie compared to what happens in the life of an AAer are two different things. The comparison on that level is dubious at best, thus my comment regarding it being "quite a stretch.


That's exactly why I pointed it out, Alfie. What I was doing with the movie and what you're doing with AA are the same thing -- you're making it up as you go. You've latched onto the "God as I understand Him" and "anything can be your Higher Power" phrases as a way to reconcile the blatant religious religious nature of Bill Wilson and AA. That's fine, knock yourself out, have a great and successful life. But to take it one step further and proclaim that because of these few and minor phrases that AA as a whole and as an organization are not religious is rather absurd.



It also shows that you are having a difficult time interpreting Dynamic's well considered, well constructed arguments (I wish I had that knowledge and skill), which is a pity for you - there is a lot of great stuff in there. :)


See? Perfect example of you just making stuff up! :p







(I am just kidding Dymanic.)
 
But to take it one step further and proclaim that because of these few and minor phrases that AA as a whole and as an organization are not religious is rather absurd.

I agree.

I have also conceded time and again that Bill W was religious and so were his writings. But he was the founder, not a divinity, he was the writer of his story, no-one elses, he shared his experience strength and hope. And with the assistance of many created some "suggestions" for recovery (the steps) and the traditions to protect the fellowship.

He never intended his book to be the last word; hence his "as Bill sees it" statements. Perhaps people should familiarise themselves with more of his thoughts.

Now along the lines of your post here, because his experience was a "religious" one, that does not mean AA as a whole is religious - remember this is a worldwide movement: America is not the centre of the universe and if it is religious in parts of the US, that does not mean it is religious everywhere.

And I point out again that Tinyal - with apparently 20 years sobriety in AA is HPless proves the point - he is not a small exception.
 
And I point out again that Tinyal - with apparently 20 years sobriety in AA is HPless proves the point - he is not a small exception.

Do you not see how this makes AA a load of BS? All that "you can't do it alone, you need god, you need a higher power, turn your life over to god, you are powerless, your ego won't let you . . . blah, blah, freaking blah."

It's all wrong. AA is a pile of religious BS.
 
America is not the centre of the universe and if it is religious in parts of the US, that does not mean it is religious everywhere.

Does this mean that you agree that it is possible that AA is religious in parts of the U.S., or are you still insisting that no subgroup of AA can be religious unless it constitutes a specific religion and/or demands that members convert?
 
Does this mean that you agree that it is possible that AA is religious in parts of the U.S.

That is what I have said all along and many times over. :boggled:

, or are you still insisting that no subgroup of AA can be religious unless it constitutes a specific religion and/or demands that members convert?

It is possible perhaps, that I responded along those lines with a comment on "conversion" when/if another poster had suggested "that all AA members had to convert to a specific such and such".
 
That is what I have said all along and many times over. :boggled:

You have indeed said that. However, you have also said all of the following:

My understanding of "religious" relates to a specific religion with tenets, dogma, teachings, belief etc within the framework of same.

You need to prove to us AA is religious, not by using one man's opinions but by showing what religion, what god, what tenets etc are required.

If it is indeed religious, what religion is it teaching when all these other believers and non-believers are equally included, welcomed and loved?

So, what religion is it?
And when answering that, tell me what religion in India, Pakistan, Nepal, South Africa, Morocco, Mozambique, Namibia, Singapore, Vietnam, Solomon Islands? and on and on I could go.

What religion is it?

Which religion?
How is it taught, precisely?

I would too if it were in fact religious.
Please explain which religion is being taught and how atheists agnostics and everyone else can get sober together?

Which religion is being taught?

Which God?
Which religion?
Which church?
Which practices?

If AA is truly a religion, can someone explain the religious service that is practiced?

Fair enough I supopose.
I'll ask it this way then:

If AA is religious:-
what are its' religious teachings?
what are the religious services that are given & by whom?
and what is the purpose behind these religious teachings?
and (presumably) religious conversions?

When asked why you cared whether people said AA was religious:

Simple.
I would hate for a person looking for a chance at recovery from alcoholism/addiction, to be put off attending AA anywhere on the basis that they needed to convert to christianity (or any religion).

Now, it's been a long thread. We've all probably said some things that are or seem contradictory. So I was asking you for clarification. I don't think you needed to give me the snotty response with the stupid smiley as if I'm some kind of idiot who hasn't been reading the thread. I have, and was reacting to specific things you've said repeatedly.
 
Now, it's been a long thread. We've all probably said some things that are or seem contradictory. So I was asking you for clarification. I don't think you needed to give me the snotty response with the stupid smiley as if I'm some kind of idiot who hasn't been reading the thread. I have, and was reacting to specific things you've said repeatedly.

Apologies for the offending smiley; I actually meant nothing by it except to show confusion.
I see where you are coming from and my best response (without looking up all the individual examples you gave) would be "context".

I think you will find I am usually responding to some 'black and white' opinion of a poster, with a 'black or white' counter comment. In other words, my comment does not necessarily mean that is where my opinion on the matter falls, it is simply to challenge their opinion with a request for evidence, context, further clarification etc.

My opinion is far less black or white and falls into the wonderful world of gray; I see that it is (religious) by certain definitions and it isn't by others.
I also see that some members are religious and others arent.
Additionally I see some members get better with the steps and a higher power, and some with the steps but without. Or without the steps but with a hp (I could go on).

The overall thrust of AA as I have seen it practiced, and as I have interpreted my many years of membership is around total religious freedom, including that of no religion.

Ultimately the decision as to whether the program is or isn't religious boils down to the opinion of one person alone; that of the individual member.

Again, my apologies, I have no personal gripe with you. :cool:
 
Does this mean that you agree that it is possible that AA is religious in parts of the U.S., or are you still insisting that no subgroup of AA can be religious unless it constitutes a specific religion and/or demands that members convert?
Do you suggest that an AA group comprised of, say, fundamentalist YEC's will suddenly chose AA as their means of being religious?

I think that's unlikely; they'll remain YECs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom