People are notoriously bad at determining their own internal states.
I not only agree with that, I do so most enthusiastically. Interesting, too, the way the word "determining" works just as well there in either of two senses:
People are notoriously bad at evaluating their own internal states.
People are notoriously bad at controlling their own internal states.
I can recall times when I declared "I'm over being angry about this", or "I'm over being sad about that" -- and meant it in
both of those senses (I think!) -- but ended up getting a look at the limits of my ability to make such authoritative pronouncements when I got ambushed later on by an embarassing episode of emotional incontinence related to the matter.
Of course, "notoriously bad at" does not automatically equate to "completely incapable of". As I've been saying for some weeks now, it all derives from the nature of human cognition as a complex interaction between submodules, some of which 'we' do not have full access to. We cannot always simply perform a brute force search through memory, but only issue a query and hope that an answer is returned; we cannot simply reach down inside and flip a switch labeled "believe this" or "quit being afraid of that". That doesn't mean we have no way whatsoever of influencing those outputs, it just means that some of the modules that produce them are black boxes. We cannot
reprogram those modules, because the source code is not available to us -- but we may be able to
reconfigure them, or at the very least get them to produce different outputs, once we learn how to associate certain types of outputs with certain types of inputs (in a
"It went zip when it moved and bop when it stopped and whirr when it stood still -- I never knew just what it was and I guess I never will" sort of sense). Considering just how complex a gizmo we're dealing with, "notoriously bad" might be considered fairly good. Put a chimp in the cockpit of a 747 in mid-flight, and if he can learn enough by just frobbing around on the controls to enable him to accomplish a landing not punctuated by a fireball -- that's actually pretty impressive.
Over time, each of us collects a little bag of tools we can use to manage our internal affairs. (For the alcoholic,
alcohol becomes the most important of these -- or maybe it is better viewed as a substitute for
having an adequate collection). Yes, obviously, some of these tools might not hold up well to the sort of scrutiny to which we subject scientific claims, and yes, obviously, they can cease to provide a good cost:benefit return if not relinquished when the appropriate time for that arrives. Tired of the Wilson analogy? How about the Red Knight in The Fisher King? Not exactly a friend, but certainly imaginary. Is it necessary to have experienced a trauma on the order of what Perry experienced in order to see the possible value of a thing like that? Is the value of the analogy negated by the fictional nature of the example? I
personally know a woman whose son was abducted and sold into slavery -- except he wasn't; I happen to know that he was actually killed in a car crash. Would I be helping her by confronting her with that reality? If the price of
dealing with it -- with "what it is" -- is PTSD-induced catatonia, which is crazier: insisting on that, or just indulging the fantasy?
The desired end result of a program of recovery is better management of internal states. When a person becomes so obsessed by the tools
other people use in managing their own internal affairs that they begin dedicating large amounts of time to finding clever ways to attack those approaches, I can only look at that as part of a process by which they are seeking to relieve tensions in their own internal states. This thread may never have had a chance of being a lively-but-friendly philosophical examination of the nuances of "religious" versus "non-religious" belief -- of the essence of religiousity itself -- but then, I notice that threads which ARE dedicated to that but which lack the emotionally-charged impetus of being framed relative to AA (or whatever) quickly scroll off the front page.
Hmmm...