Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You'll forgive me if I don't believe you. Humans are not Vulcans. It is emotion, not logic, that rules our lives.

First off, I didn't say that logic was the only thing in my life. Again you're reading more than there is in the post I wrote. I said that I didn't subscribe to the way of thinking that concludes based on feelings. Of course sometimes I fail in that regard, but at least I try to ignore those feelings as much as I can, and that's a step forward.

Second, I resent your claim that we are "ruled" by emotions. Strongly influenced, sure. Ruled ? No. There wouldn't be any science if that were the case.

And Nolan knew Wilson was just a volleyball.

Case closed, then. Wasn't a real interaction.

Irrelevant to the question at hand

That might be why I specifically said "that has nothing to do with whether AA is religious". Again you forget what's been said about a day ago.
 
However, I would argue that as social animals we are hard-wired for interaction with others of our kind (if only in the same general sense that we are hard-wired for language aquisition; that is: just as we do not come pre-equipped with an installed language, we do not come pre-equipped with the skills we will need for successful navigation of the social landscape -- but we do come pre-equipped with a fierce propensity for learning them).

We are constantly watching how others respond to our actions, anticipating how they might react to things we might do, etc. The expectations others place upon us (real or imagined; spoken or unspoken) are quite often a much stronger motivating force than our own personal desires (which, fully indulged, would probably have most of us spending the bulk of our time sitting around munching on whatever form of snack could be obtained for the least amount of effort). We often reach our greatest potential by deliberately placing ourselves in situations (participating in discussions on this forum being one possible example) which offer "a chance for us to have other human beings push us to excel". Neither the crowd's cheers nor the drill instructor's vituperations impart to the athelete or the marine recruit any strength he does not already possess, but it may increase his ability to access that strength.

That is exactly what Wilson did for Nolan. Hands bloodied in his desperate struggle to make fire, Nolan was nearing the end of both his strength and his courage -- except he wasn't; what he was nearing the end of was his ability to access those inner resources -- and he recognized his need to have some help with that. Nolan was obviously not a religious man or the solution would have been boringly predictable, and there weren't any drill instructors around, so what he did was effectively to create a cognitive partition: Nolan on one side, Wilson on the other (cheering him on, goading him, whatever; sort of like a big round Jiminy Cricket). He didn't need a power greater than himself so much as he needed a presence other than himself, and he fabricated one out of the only available materials, imparting to it certain attributes which, obviously, he himself possessed.

Now, it's tempting to wax all condescending: "Well, I guess I can see why a guy stranded on a remote uninhabited island might be driven to a crazy thing like that, but I quit playing those games when I was about seven years old". But what is most noteworthy is not that an average guy was able to pull off this cognitive partitioning trick -- it is the ease with which he was able to do so, and the ease with which we, as the audience, accept it. That implies a certain familiarity with that process despite the protestations of those who would deny having any such propensity, apparently viewing this as more of a bug than a feature -- and imparts a hollow ring to objections having to do with the ability others might have to similarly externalize aspects of their selves.

Nolan is fully aware of what Wilson is. Wilson started off as a joke for Nolan's amusement and then as Nolan's mental state spiralled down after so many years of being alone, he adopted him as a confidant.

But, and it is a huge BUT, at no time did Nolan think that Wilson did anything for him. He didn't see Wilson as any sort of HP. He didn't ask Wilson to rescue him from the island. He didn't ask him to save him from pounding surf when he left the island. He didn't pray to him on the island or after. Nothing.

Wilson was a simple imaginary friend and Nolan knew it. So, this analogy is not an accurate representation of what AA describes from a HP, nor is it anything like what AA members have described in this thread.

The only thing in common is that Wilson and the AA HP are imaginary. At no time did Nolan see Wilson as a higher power.

As to whether it is religious, I see that deriving from beliefs having a public aspect. Imaginary friends may be drawn from the same well as any manner of spirits, but to qualify as elements of a religious belief system, their existence must be acknowledged by more than just one person.

This is exactly what happens. If you ask a million Christians what their god is, each will have a different understanding. If you ask a million AA members what their god is, they will each have a different understanding. This was intentionally done by Bill W. He wanted AA to be more inclusive so he made God into "God as we understood him" in order to include all religious people. He then went on to discuss atheists and agnostics and stated flat out that theirs was to just be a temporary belief until they came to know God in some way.

I think it is ridiculous that people in this thread will twist and turn Bill W.'s words to mean anything but what they actually say. If Bill W. had not wanted AA to be religious he could, and would, have made that very clear but he didn't. What he did was make it perfectly clear to anyone who reads his stuff that AA is religious. The people in this thread who think differently are nothing more than religious apologists.
 
Evidence doesn't require worship or belief.
No, it doesn't. Evidence doesn't really do much of anything but sit there waiting to be interpreted -- and within different interpretive frameworks, the same evidence may lead to very different conclusions (an insight I obtained at about age thirteen, largely through watching "Perry Mason" while having my after school snack). Again, it is the very reason for peer review and all that. You seem to think that evidence really does speak for itself, and you simply could not be more wrong.

The question being discussed in this thread is not whether Elwood is Religious, it is whether the organization he belongs to is Religious.
And as EVIDENCE of that, you present the fact that the organization is made up of people (and was founded by people) who hold religious beliefs. It's called: "circular reasoning".
 
The point being that Nolan did what he had to do in order to survive -- both physically and mentally -- and then he left it all behind. After he returned to civilization, there was simply no need for Wilson in order for Nolan to deal with amazingly profound changes in his life trying to adjust to what had transpired.
Right (though it is fun to consider how things might have gone had Wilson not come unlashed from the raft and drifted away after that storm; you know: "So, whatcha got in the bag there, Nolan?"..."It's Wilson, and he doesn't like strangers, so just keep your hands off the damn bag").

Re-mapping the analogy back to recovery, the question seems to be whether the alcoholic ever reaches a point where he can be considered to have made it off the island. That one gets batted back and forth quite a bit, and I don't see there being any easy answers to it -- but it doesn't seem to be particularly relevant to AA's religiousity one way or the other. One of the benefits of leaving it up to the individual to define "higher power" is that he may redefine that any time he choses (or, more acccurately in my view, anytime he finds that, with or without effort on his part, his concept of that has changed over time).
 
Again you're reading more than there is in the post I wrote.
I do tend to do that. If this is a character flaw, I can console myself with the thought that a certain amount of that is pretty much unavoidable when attempting to communicate with beings who, for a great variety of reasons, may not always say what they mean, or mean what they say, or even have the benefit of complete knowledge of the paths they have taken in reaching their own conclusions.

Second, I resent your claim that we are "ruled" by emotions. Strongly influenced, sure.
If you will allow the modifier "Very strongly influenced", I think we may have the basis for another stipulated agreement. I submit that the influence of logic over emotion is weaker than the influence of emotion over logic. I may be able to think of a dozen logical reasons why I should not have that last piece of cheesecake, or why I should not continue on a path toward becoming sexually involved with this particular person (or, of course, why I should not pick up a drink), and if I keep repeating those reasons to myself firmly enough, logic may win out. But for every time logic maintained the upper hand in one of those little inner struggles, there are a hundred times when emotion raised itself up to its full height, swatted logic aside like the proverbial ninety-seven pound weakling, and said "Hell with all that; we're gonna DO this". Maybe that makes me different from you?

Case closed, then. Wasn't a real interaction.
Well, hold on. I think when we start talking about strictly internal events -- mental games and interaction across cognitive partitions and whatnot -- the boundaries between the "real" and the "unreal" become hopelessly fuzzy. If I am angry, or depressed, or if I find a thing puzzling, or hysterically funny, is any of that "real"? Is there any objective standard we could use to measure the reality of the purely subjective?
 
Wilson started off as a joke for Nolan's amusement and then as Nolan's mental state spiralled down after so many years of being alone, he adopted him as a confidant.
I cannot agree with that interpretation. At the time, Nolan was engaged in a desperate struggle for survival, which hinged on his success or failure at creating fire. I can allow that he had yet to appreciate how vital a role Wilson would later come to have in his life, and that he was bemused (but not exactly amused) by his recognition that his sanity was hanging by a thread.


But, and it is a huge BUT, at no time did Nolan think that Wilson did anything for him. He didn't see Wilson as any sort of HP. He didn't ask Wilson to rescue him from the island. He didn't ask him to save him from pounding surf when he left the island. He didn't pray to him on the island or after. Nothing.
I agree, and these are important points.

Wilson was a simple imaginary friend and Nolan knew it. So, this analogy is not an accurate representation of what AA describes from a HP, nor is it anything like what AA members have described in this thread.
Absolutely right. I introduced the Wilson analogy to demonstrate how easy it is for the average person to rearrange his mental furniture, and how a person facing a difficult challenge might benefit from doing that (and in doing so I certainly do not mean to minimize the potential for great detriment that co-exists with that; it quite often seems to turn out that the things that can work most strongly in our favor are the very ones that can also work most strongly against us).

If you ask a million Christians what their god is, each will have a different understanding. If you ask a million AA members what their god is, they will each have a different understanding.
There is a particular quote that comes to mind upon my reading that:

"When people thought the earth was flat, they were wrong. When people thought the earth was spherical, they were wrong. But if you think that thinking the earth is spherical is just as wrong as thinking the earth is flat, then your view is wronger than both of them put together."
 
I think it is ridiculous that people in this thread will twist and turn Bill W.'s words to mean anything but what they actually say.

You do ? Not me. Christians twist the very words of the Bible to mean something else than what it says whenever it suits them. In all other cases, though, the Bible is inerrant.
 
I do tend to do that. If this is a character flaw, I can console myself with the thought that a certain amount of that is pretty much unavoidable when attempting to communicate with beings who, for a great variety of reasons, may not always say what they mean, or mean what they say, or even have the benefit of complete knowledge of the paths they have taken in reaching their own conclusions.

Phew! Lucky you weren't talking about me, there.

If you will allow the modifier "Very strongly influenced", I think we may have the basis for another stipulated agreement.

Done.

Well, hold on.

Dammit.

I think when we start talking about strictly internal events -- mental games and interaction across cognitive partitions and whatnot -- the boundaries between the "real" and the "unreal" become hopelessly fuzzy. If I am angry, or depressed, or if I find a thing puzzling, or hysterically funny, is any of that "real"? Is there any objective standard we could use to measure the reality of the purely subjective?

That's why we usually rely on health professionals to make that kind of diagnostic. People are notoriously bad at determining their own internal states.
 
I cannot agree with that interpretation. At the time, Nolan was engaged in a desperate struggle for survival, which hinged on his success or failure at creating fire.

You know, guys, as much as it can be fun to use analogies for debates, I think this one's been taken too far.

Cast Away is a movie. The script, and therefore everything Nolan does, is a work of fiction written by a person based on his/her interpretation of what such a situation would be like. The usefulness of the analogy is reduced because we have no idea how realistic the portrayal of said situation was.
 
People are notoriously bad at determining their own internal states.
I not only agree with that, I do so most enthusiastically. Interesting, too, the way the word "determining" works just as well there in either of two senses:

People are notoriously bad at evaluating their own internal states.
People are notoriously bad at controlling their own internal states.

I can recall times when I declared "I'm over being angry about this", or "I'm over being sad about that" -- and meant it in both of those senses (I think!) -- but ended up getting a look at the limits of my ability to make such authoritative pronouncements when I got ambushed later on by an embarassing episode of emotional incontinence related to the matter.

Of course, "notoriously bad at" does not automatically equate to "completely incapable of". As I've been saying for some weeks now, it all derives from the nature of human cognition as a complex interaction between submodules, some of which 'we' do not have full access to. We cannot always simply perform a brute force search through memory, but only issue a query and hope that an answer is returned; we cannot simply reach down inside and flip a switch labeled "believe this" or "quit being afraid of that". That doesn't mean we have no way whatsoever of influencing those outputs, it just means that some of the modules that produce them are black boxes. We cannot reprogram those modules, because the source code is not available to us -- but we may be able to reconfigure them, or at the very least get them to produce different outputs, once we learn how to associate certain types of outputs with certain types of inputs (in a "It went zip when it moved and bop when it stopped and whirr when it stood still -- I never knew just what it was and I guess I never will" sort of sense). Considering just how complex a gizmo we're dealing with, "notoriously bad" might be considered fairly good. Put a chimp in the cockpit of a 747 in mid-flight, and if he can learn enough by just frobbing around on the controls to enable him to accomplish a landing not punctuated by a fireball -- that's actually pretty impressive.

Over time, each of us collects a little bag of tools we can use to manage our internal affairs. (For the alcoholic, alcohol becomes the most important of these -- or maybe it is better viewed as a substitute for having an adequate collection). Yes, obviously, some of these tools might not hold up well to the sort of scrutiny to which we subject scientific claims, and yes, obviously, they can cease to provide a good cost:benefit return if not relinquished when the appropriate time for that arrives. Tired of the Wilson analogy? How about the Red Knight in The Fisher King? Not exactly a friend, but certainly imaginary. Is it necessary to have experienced a trauma on the order of what Perry experienced in order to see the possible value of a thing like that? Is the value of the analogy negated by the fictional nature of the example? I personally know a woman whose son was abducted and sold into slavery -- except he wasn't; I happen to know that he was actually killed in a car crash. Would I be helping her by confronting her with that reality? If the price of dealing with it -- with "what it is" -- is PTSD-induced catatonia, which is crazier: insisting on that, or just indulging the fantasy?

The desired end result of a program of recovery is better management of internal states. When a person becomes so obsessed by the tools other people use in managing their own internal affairs that they begin dedicating large amounts of time to finding clever ways to attack those approaches, I can only look at that as part of a process by which they are seeking to relieve tensions in their own internal states. This thread may never have had a chance of being a lively-but-friendly philosophical examination of the nuances of "religious" versus "non-religious" belief -- of the essence of religiousity itself -- but then, I notice that threads which ARE dedicated to that but which lack the emotionally-charged impetus of being framed relative to AA (or whatever) quickly scroll off the front page.
Hmmm...
 
I am struggling to remember just how far after his rescue the movie ran for you to know all that. :rolleyes:


I'm making it up as I go, doing exactly what you do with AA.




Right (though it is fun to consider how things might have gone had Wilson not come unlashed from the raft and drifted away after that storm; you know: "So, whatcha got in the bag there, Nolan?"..."It's Wilson, and he doesn't like strangers, so just keep your hands off the damn bag").

Re-mapping the analogy back to recovery, the question seems to be whether the alcoholic ever reaches a point where he can be considered to have made it off the island. That one gets batted back and forth quite a bit, and I don't see there being any easy answers to it -- but it doesn't seem to be particularly relevant to AA's religiousity one way or the other. One of the benefits of leaving it up to the individual to define "higher power" is that he may redefine that any time he choses (or, more acccurately in my view, anytime he finds that, with or without effort on his part, his concept of that has changed over time).


Well, I can certainly agree that "being sober" or being "in sobriety" is more than just a lack of drugs or alcohol used as a coping mechanism.
 
No, it doesn't. Evidence doesn't really do much of anything but sit there waiting to be interpreted -- and within different interpretive frameworks, the same evidence may lead to very different conclusions (an insight I obtained at about age thirteen, largely through watching "Perry Mason" while having my after school snack). Again, it is the very reason for peer review and all that. You seem to think that evidence really does speak for itself, and you simply could not be more wrong.

And as EVIDENCE of that, you present the fact that the organization is made up of people (and was founded by people) who hold religious beliefs. It's called: "circular reasoning".

That's the first time I've EVER heard TEXTUAL EVIDENCE been called circular reasoning. But considering that you deliberately mis-state my position, it's hardly surprising ("made up of people"--False, I never said that. "Founded by people"--No, it's not merely that they are religious, it's that they specifically state in writing their religious intent for AA). And you know this because I have been consistent on these points from the beginning of this thread.

Just like your bogus syllogism, your "circular reasoning" is bogus. And in this case, the Evidence LITERALLY does "speak for itself". No interpretation required.

I would question your comprehension skills and your analytical skills. But I know better now, you just prefer using sophistry skills.

You and the other AA apologists are the one's basing your arguments on anecdote and sophistry using the "made up of people" and "we're all individuals" line.

Hmmm, where have I heard THAT before...oh right:

Monty Python's Life of Brian:
Brian: Look, you've got it all wrong! You don't need to follow me, you don't need to follow anybody! You've got to think for yourselves! You're all individuals!
The Crowd (in unison): Yes! We're all individuals!
Brian: You're all different!
The Crowd (in unison): Yes, we are all different!
Man in Crowd: I'm not.
Another Man: Shhh!

GB
 
Further demonstrating your inability to distinguish the evidence from the logic used in interpreting the evidence.

You wouldn't know Logic if it bit you on the @$$. "Logic" without Evidence to support it is just Babble, aka Speculation and/or Sophistry. You can justify and rationalize anything with "Logic" if you don't have any evidence to back up your assertions.

You haven't provided any evidence for your assertions, therefore you have no logic.

GB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom