Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I disagree. I see the problem arising out of the need for a definitive definition of "real interaction". Because it was you who introduced that qualifier, that makes it your problem, and I knew it wouldn't be easy, but then, that's a lot of what makes it fun.

As I hope you guessed, the reason why I said "real" interaction is the same reason why I'd need to specify that I'm talking, for instance, about a "real" bird. It doesn't magically create a new category because you can imagine nonexistent species of fowl. It simply means that I exclude "imaginary" interactions from the set of "interactions". "Real" was merely used to remind you that I'm talking about reality.

I fully understand (unless I'm wrong) that you're saying that the reality of the interaction doesn't change the fact that it has an impact on the person doing the "interacting". Sure. But the reverse is true: it doesn't make the interaction real.

It's really not MY argument. I have merely observed that the "self" portion of "a power greater than ourselves" defaults to a simple intuitive construct: the conscious self ("YOU"), which is, by definition, separate from the "unconscious".

Not really. What's "conscious" and what's "unconscious" varies from one moment to the next, so how can you possibly distinguish the two so easily ? The conscious and unconscious are simply separated by a thin, variable veil. It's a far cry from saying that they are distinct entities entirely.

It's like saying that your arm isn't really part of "you", or that you don't really feel pain but that you experience an indirect sensation of pain. That's just obfuscation. To me, "You" means the whole of you, not just some small arbitrary part.

I submit that "a power greater than themselves" implies "a power other than themselves".

I fully agree. It follows from the wording of the phrase. My post about that was simply to point out that, in truth, it's the person herself who stops drinking. Nobody is doing that for her, so in reality there IS no power greater than yourself when it comes to drinking or addiction in general. Of course, that has nothing to do with whether AA is religious, just whether AA is wrong.
 
Your post doesn't apply - you are confusing 'Membership' with 'Actually practicing the AA program'. Stop bringing up the membership statement as it has nothing to do with the AA program - We (well, everyone but you) aren't talking about membership, we are talking about the AA program.

I actually agree with that - to a point. But.... those of you state that there is a REQUIREMENT to a specific god are wrong - and lie. For someone who has supposedly been around AA for 20 years I am absolutely amazed you have never heard of Good Orderly Direction, Great Outdoors etc.

Explain that please?

You might also explain how you have practiced the program without a higher power for 20 years. Seems you haven't been, yet you still go. It seems one doesn't need to do the program exactly as SUGGESTED to get sober. Ergo, this one and only god you speak of is not a requirement for anything and that the steps are (as said) suggested.

You might also explain that. You are the living example of why God is not required.
 
Last edited:
As I hope you guessed, the reason why I said "real" interaction is the same reason why I'd need to specify that I'm talking, for instance, about a "real" bird. It doesn't magically create a new category because you can imagine nonexistent species of fowl. It simply means that I exclude "imaginary" interactions from the set of "interactions". "Real" was merely used to remind you that I'm talking about reality.
Well, there have never been any real birds in my mind, as far as I know, but the only evidence I have that you exist is some characters appearing on a monitor. While we are "interacting" here, I am imagining a conversation taking place between us and transcribing my portion into text -- and if it happens that you've gone off and gotten flattened by a UPS truck during the interim, that status of that conversation with respect to it being "real" or merely "imagined" will have changed, and I won't even know it.

I fully understand (unless I'm wrong) that you're saying that the reality of the interaction doesn't change the fact that it has an impact on the person doing the "interacting". Sure. But the reverse is true: it doesn't make the interaction real.

I find the proposed terms of this agreement acceptable.

What's "conscious" and what's "unconscious" varies from one moment to the next, so how can you possibly distinguish the two so easily ? The conscious and unconscious are simply separated by a thin, variable veil. It's a far cry from saying that they are distinct entities entirely.
Quagmire muck. What counts here is how it feels.

I fully agree. It follows from the wording of the phrase. My post about that was simply to point out that, in truth, it's the person herself who stops drinking. Nobody is doing that for her, so in reality there IS no power greater than yourself when it comes to drinking or addiction in general.
I can also agree with that.

However, I would argue that as social animals we are hard-wired for interaction with others of our kind (if only in the same general sense that we are hard-wired for language aquisition; that is: just as we do not come pre-equipped with an installed language, we do not come pre-equipped with the skills we will need for successful navigation of the social landscape -- but we do come pre-equipped with a fierce propensity for learning them).

We are constantly watching how others respond to our actions, anticipating how they might react to things we might do, etc. The expectations others place upon us (real or imagined; spoken or unspoken) are quite often a much stronger motivating force than our own personal desires (which, fully indulged, would probably have most of us spending the bulk of our time sitting around munching on whatever form of snack could be obtained for the least amount of effort). We often reach our greatest potential by deliberately placing ourselves in situations (participating in discussions on this forum being one possible example) which offer "a chance for us to have other human beings push us to excel". Neither the crowd's cheers nor the drill instructor's vituperations impart to the athelete or the marine recruit any strength he does not already possess, but it may increase his ability to access that strength.

That is exactly what Wilson did for Nolan. Hands bloodied in his desperate struggle to make fire, Nolan was nearing the end of both his strength and his courage -- except he wasn't; what he was nearing the end of was his ability to access those inner resources -- and he recognized his need to have some help with that. Nolan was obviously not a religious man or the solution would have been boringly predictable, and there weren't any drill instructors around, so what he did was effectively to create a cognitive partition: Nolan on one side, Wilson on the other (cheering him on, goading him, whatever; sort of like a big round Jiminy Cricket). He didn't need a power greater than himself so much as he needed a presence other than himself, and he fabricated one out of the only available materials, imparting to it certain attributes which, obviously, he himself possessed.

Now, it's tempting to wax all condescending: "Well, I guess I can see why a guy stranded on a remote uninhabited island might be driven to a crazy thing like that, but I quit playing those games when I was about seven years old". But what is most noteworthy is not that an average guy was able to pull off this cognitive partitioning trick -- it is the ease with which he was able to do so, and the ease with which we, as the audience, accept it. That implies a certain familiarity with that process despite the protestations of those who would deny having any such propensity, apparently viewing this as more of a bug than a feature -- and imparts a hollow ring to objections having to do with the ability others might have to similarly externalize aspects of their selves.

Of course, that has nothing to do with whether AA is religious, just whether AA is wrong.
I don't see it having anything to do with whether AA is "wrong" (perhaps because I'm not even sure what that means). As to whether it is religious, I see that deriving from beliefs having a public aspect. Imaginary friends may be drawn from the same well as any manner of spirits, but to qualify as elements of a religious belief system, their existence must be acknowledged by more than just one person.
 
Last edited:
I don't see it having anything to do with whether AA is "wrong" (perhaps because I'm not even sure what that means). As to whether it is religious, I see that deriving from beliefs having a public aspect. Imaginary friends may be drawn from the same well as any manner of spirits, but to qualify as elements of a religious belief system, their existence must be acknowledged by more than just one person.

How about the existence of an imaginary friend being acknowledged in the Texts of the Religious Organization itself?

GB
 
Dymanic said:
I fully understand (unless I'm wrong) that you're saying that the reality of the interaction doesn't change the fact that it has an impact on the person doing the "interacting". Sure. But the reverse is true: it doesn't make the interaction real.

I find the proposed terms of this agreement acceptable.
How so? Why don't you deem the interaction "real"?
 
Quagmire muck. What counts here is how it feels.

Unfortunately that's why we have religion: we too often prefer to rely on what it feels like rather than what it is. You'll forgive me if I don't subscribe to this way of thinking.

Now, it's tempting to wax all condescending: "Well, I guess I can see why a guy stranded on a remote uninhabited island might be driven to a crazy thing like that, but I quit playing those games when I was about seven years old".

And then even then I knew it was just a game.

I don't see it having anything to do with whether AA is "wrong" (perhaps because I'm not even sure what that means).

Simply that AA doesn't work, in my view; individual testimonies aside, of course.
 
Can you have a real interaction with something that doesn't exist ?

Well, a real imaginary interaction is real even if it's imaginary. ;)
(I mean something's really happening inside my head).

Ouch! I think I just confused myself. :confused:

Now I know why I avoid interacting with Dymanic's word salads. :boggled:

GB
 
However, I would argue that as social animals we are hard-wired for interaction with others of our kind (if only in the same general sense that we are hard-wired for language aquisition; that is: just as we do not come pre-equipped with an installed language, we do not come pre-equipped with the skills we will need for successful navigation of the social landscape -- but we do come pre-equipped with a fierce propensity for learning them).

We are constantly watching how others respond to our actions, anticipating how they might react to things we might do, etc. The expectations others place upon us (real or imagined; spoken or unspoken) are quite often a much stronger motivating force than our own personal desires (which, fully indulged, would probably have most of us spending the bulk of our time sitting around munching on whatever form of snack could be obtained for the least amount of effort). We often reach our greatest potential by deliberately placing ourselves in situations (participating in discussions on this forum being one possible example) which offer "a chance for us to have other human beings push us to excel". Neither the crowd's cheers nor the drill instructor's vituperations impart to the athelete or the marine recruit any strength he does not already possess, but it may increase his ability to access that strength.

That is exactly what Wilson did for Nolan. Hands bloodied in his desperate struggle to make fire, Nolan was nearing the end of both his strength and his courage -- except he wasn't; what he was nearing the end of was his ability to access those inner resources -- and he recognized his need to have some help with that. Nolan was obviously not a religious man or the solution would have been boringly predictable, and there weren't any drill instructors around, so what he did was effectively to create a cognitive partition: Nolan on one side, Wilson on the other (cheering him on, goading him, whatever; sort of like a big round Jiminy Cricket). He didn't need a power greater than himself so much as he needed a presence other than himself, and he fabricated one out of the only available materials, imparting to it certain attributes which, obviously, he himself possessed.

Now, it's tempting to wax all condescending: "Well, I guess I can see why a guy stranded on a remote uninhabited island might be driven to a crazy thing like that, but I quit playing those games when I was about seven years old". But what is most noteworthy is not that an average guy was able to pull off this cognitive partitioning trick -- it is the ease with which he was able to do so, and the ease with which we, as the audience, accept it. That implies a certain familiarity with that process despite the protestations of those who would deny having any such propensity, apparently viewing this as more of a bug than a feature -- and imparts a hollow ring to objections having to do with the ability others might have to similarly externalize aspects of their selves.

nominated.
Thanks Dynamic. Fantastic post.
 
nominated.
Thanks Dynamic. Fantastic post.

Yes indeed, Fantastic Post for demonstrating (though rather unempirically) why imaginary friends can help us access inner resources. Thanks again for helping to make the case that the Religious Imaginary Friend (God) in AA's literature makes AA a Religious Organization. :D

Well Done! :bigclap


Oh wait...you were trying to make the case that AA isn't a Religious Organization weren't you? ;)

In that case, you lose! :(

GB
 
Unfortunately that's why we have religion: we too often prefer to rely on what it feels like rather than what it is. You'll forgive me if I don't subscribe to this way of thinking.
You'll forgive me if I don't believe you. Humans are not Vulcans. It is emotion, not logic, that rules our lives. I have seen nothing here that suggests you are in any way special in this regard. The "scientific method", peer review, double-blind studies, all the rigorous methodology of science -- these stand as monuments to the fact that humans suck at "what it is".

And then even then I knew it was just a game.
And Nolan knew Wilson was just a volleyball.

Simply that AA doesn't work, in my view; individual testimonies aside, of course.
Irrelevant to the question at hand just as it has been all of the other hundreds of times that argument has appeared in this thread.
 
Now I know why I avoid interacting with Dymanic's word salads.
Of course, simply having placed ourselves in a situation which offers a chance for us to have other human beings push us to excel is no guarantee that we will actually rise to that challenge. For some, participation in these discussions is functionally equivalent to sitting around munching on snacks.

Thanks again for helping to make the case that the Religious Imaginary Friend (God) in AA's literature makes AA a Religious Organization.
It's cute when you crow about your little perceived victories this way. Reminds me of the little imaginary games my grandson plays.
 
You'll forgive me if I don't believe you. Humans are not Vulcans. It is emotion, not logic, that rules our lives. I have seen nothing here that suggests you are in any way special in this regard. The "scientific method", peer review, double-blind studies, all the rigorous methodology of science -- these stand as monuments to the fact that humans suck at "what it is".

No wonder you sound like a Theist. You hate evidence. Thanks for spelling it out clearly for once.

GB
 
Of course, simply having placed ourselves in a situation which offers a chance for us to have other human beings push us to excel is no guarantee that we will actually rise to that challenge. For some, participation in these discussions is functionally equivalent to sitting around munching on snacks.

Yes, I find the rigorous demands to provide evidence for my assertions continually pushes me to exceed. But you apparently think providing evidence is a silly little game.

It's cute when you crow about your little perceived victories this way. Reminds me of the little imaginary games my grandson plays.

Well, when your rationalizations for Imaginary Friends support my thesis that AA is about having an Imaginary Friend (with the power to remove your sins) it reminds me of how my nephew ran down to the wrong end of the field and kicked the ball into his own team's goalposts.

GB
 
No wonder you sound like a Theist. You hate evidence.
You sound like one too. You worship evidence. You think it is all powerful; knows all, sees all. You're a throwback to turn of the (twentieth) century academia, all cocky about having it all so figured out that there would soon be no further need for universities. Russell and Whitehead, pre-Gödel. We're peering through a keyhole with a candle here, GB, and one of the things we can be most sure of is that there are some things we're never going to figure out.

When you finish your snack, care to take a stab at the "public aspect" issue I raised above? How about another syllogism?

A religious construct 2 billion people call "God" may, for an individual, serve as an imaginary friend.
Elwood P. Dowd has an imaginary friend,
therefore,
Elwood P. Dowd is religious.

Are you beginning to get the hang of how this syllogism thing works?
 
You sound like one too. You worship evidence. You think it is all powerful; knows all, sees all. You're a throwback to turn of the (twentieth) century academia, all cocky about having it all so figured out that there would soon be no further need for universities. Russell and Whitehead, pre-Gödel. We're peering through a keyhole with a candle here, GB, and one of the things we can be most sure of is that there are some things we're never going to figure out.

Evidence doesn't require worship or belief.

I've said it before, and I'll say it again, I'd be more than happy to speculate about wooish stuff with you on wooish topics. It's in my Signature Quotes.

But in a debate, one is expected to provide evidence, not speculation.

When you finish your snack, care to take a stab at the "public aspect" issue I raised above? How about another syllogism?

A religious construct 2 billion people call "God" may, for an individual, serve as an imaginary friend.
Elwood P. Dowd has an imaginary friend,
therefore,
Elwood P. Dowd is religious.

Are you beginning to get the hang of how this syllogism thing works?

But that's not the equation here. Your False Syllogism may be how YOU think, but it's not how I think.

The question being discussed in this thread is not whether Elwood is Religious, it is whether the organization he belongs to is Religious. And to answer that, I don't need a syllogism, all I need is evidence (and I've got it in spades).

GB
 
That is exactly what Wilson did for Nolan. Hands bloodied in his desperate struggle to make fire, Nolan was nearing the end of both his strength and his courage -- except he wasn't; what he was nearing the end of was his ability to access those inner resources -- and he recognized his need to have some help with that. Nolan was obviously not a religious man or the solution would have been boringly predictable, and there weren't any drill instructors around, so what he did was effectively to create a cognitive partition: Nolan on one side, Wilson on the other (cheering him on, goading him, whatever; sort of like a big round Jiminy Cricket). He didn't need a power greater than himself so much as he needed a presence other than himself, and he fabricated one out of the only available materials, imparting to it certain attributes which, obviously, he himself possessed.

Now, it's tempting to wax all condescending: "Well, I guess I can see why a guy stranded on a remote uninhabited island might be driven to a crazy thing like that, but I quit playing those games when I was about seven years old". But what is most noteworthy is not that an average guy was able to pull off this cognitive partitioning trick -- it is the ease with which he was able to do so, and the ease with which we, as the audience, accept it. That implies a certain familiarity with that process despite the protestations of those who would deny having any such propensity, apparently viewing this as more of a bug than a feature -- and imparts a hollow ring to objections having to do with the ability others might have to similarly externalize aspects of their selves.


Once Nolan got off the island (in other words, he got sober) did he cart around Wilson with him -- or in this case, since Wilson floated off, create a new Wilson to cart around? Did he tell everyone he knew how Wilson kept him sane during his ordeal? Did he start traveling around to other natural disaster survivors and proclaim to them how their life could return to some sort of normalcy, if they just make a Wilson of their own conception with whom they can converse?

Or perhaps he invited others to hear Wilson give a guest lecture of what it was like living with Nolan alone on that island all that time...

The point being that Nolan did what he had to do in order to survive -- both physically and mentally -- and then he left it all behind. After he returned to civilization, there was simply no need for Wilson in order for Nolan to deal with amazingly profound changes in his life trying to adjust to what had transpired.
 
Once Nolan got off the island (in other words, he got sober) did he cart around Wilson with him -- or in this case, since Wilson floated off, create a new Wilson to cart around? Did he tell everyone he knew how Wilson kept him sane during his ordeal? Did he start traveling around to other natural disaster survivors and proclaim to them how their life could return to some sort of normalcy, if they just make a Wilson of their own conception with whom they can converse?

Or perhaps he invited others to hear Wilson give a guest lecture of what it was like living with Nolan alone on that island all that time...

The point being that Nolan did what he had to do in order to survive -- both physically and mentally -- and then he left it all behind. After he returned to civilization, there was simply no need for Wilson in order for Nolan to deal with amazingly profound changes in his life trying to adjust to what had transpired.

I am struggling to remember just how far after his rescue the movie ran for you to know all that. :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom