Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
LOL
And straight back at you: the words "probably", in the big book (ignored by you) and my use of the word "suggested" were also these qualifiers you place such weight on in your own posts, but no-one elses. Curious.

'scuse me, I have to change. :D

Already stated in an edit to an earlier post but here it is again:

Regardless of the qualifier though, you can throw that idea out completely because it is, obviously, 100% wrong. A human power CAN relieve your alcoholism.

You really aren't helping AA's case here, Alfie.
 
LOL (again - I am having a great day).:D

I'm not helping AAs case, or the 'case against' the OP by showing that religion and a higher power isn't necessary? :boggled:

I'm going to run out of clean pants at this rate.
 
Will this thread never end?

Well I think it could have ended weeks ago. The question was/is "why do people in AA insist it is not religious?".

The AAers here have answered that to the best of their ability.

Others disagree with their responses and incorrectly assume we are all deists because AA has assisted in giving us sobriety and that word (God) appears time after time in the literature. They seem at great pains to try and prove AA is religious when there are many practical examples that show that it doesn't have to be - which in itself actually answers the OP.

These 'others' seem to be intolerant god haters, who at the mere mention of the word god go into apoplexy. One wonders how they get along in a country that has "In God we trust" on their currency.

At any rate, the OP has been answered. AAers insist that AA isn't religious because many can and do utlise the program and the fellowship without any requirement of this God they (the others) hate so much.

This seems to drive the god haters to drink and thus, the thread does not end. :)
 
Last edited:
Well I think it could have ended weeks ago. The question was/is "why do people in AA insist it is not religious?".

The AAers here have answered that to the best of their ability.

Others disagree with their responses and incorrectly assume we are all deists because AA has assisted in giving us sobriety and that word (God) appears time after time in the literature. They seem at great pains to try and prove AA is religious when there are many practical examples that show that it doesn't have to be - which in itself actually answers the OP.

These 'others' seem to be intolerant god haters, who at the mere mention of the word god go into apoplexy. One wonders how they get along in a country that has "In God we trust" on their currency.

At any rate, the OP has been answered. AAers insist that AA isn't religious because many can and do utlise the program and the fellowship without any requirement of this God they (the others) hate so much.

This seems to drive the god haters to drink and thus, the thread does not end. :)

There's no hate whatever in anything I've posted - however, it (once again) goes without saying that if a person 'utilizes the program' without any of the god-bothering from AA materials/the big book , then that person is not - most definitely not - practicing the AA program. What they are doing is what has come out of treatment centers (for the most part) over the last 20 years, as an entire mix of people (drug addicts, sex addicts, bleh bleh blah) got forced into AA by the legal & social system here in the USA. These people (in the minds of most old timers > 25 yrs sober I've met - and I've met hundreds personally) brought along a new agey sort of philosophy, that included things such as 'god is not required' which are in direct conflict with what AA teaches
I repeat my claim that if aaalfie (or anyone else) - in whatever country - attends any AA meeting and makes the statement 'neither god, nor any higher power is needed to get and stay sober' then that person will very likely come under substantial pressure to change, will be ostracized, not invited to after meeting activities, will become isolated from the rest of the group in all sorts of social ways - some more obvious than others. They will be told things like 'some people are too intelligent to get the program', or 'your best thinking got you here', or that they are on a dry drunk, etc.
If you (and apparently thousands of others in Australia, according to some - which I seriously doubt is as widespread in AA Australia as Aaalfie seems to be suggesting) are doing is something different- good for you!
But it's not AA - what a program that doesn't include God/higher power is called is SOS , SMART, etc - not AA.
And that's all there is to it.
 
There's no hate whatever in anything I've posted - however, it (once again) goes without saying that if a person 'utilizes the program' without any of the god-bothering from AA materials/the big book , then that person is not - most definitely not - practicing the AA program. What they are doing is what has come out of treatment centers (for the most part) over the last 20 years, as an entire mix of people (drug addicts, sex addicts, bleh bleh blah) got forced into AA by the legal & social system here in the USA. These people (in the minds of most old timers > 25 yrs sober I've met - and I've met hundreds personally) brought along a new agey sort of philosophy, that included things such as 'god is not required' which are in direct conflict with what AA teaches
I repeat my claim that if aaalfie (or anyone else) - in whatever country - attends any AA meeting and makes the statement 'neither god, nor any higher power is needed to get and stay sober' then that person will very likely come under substantial pressure to change, will be ostracized, not invited to after meeting activities, will become isolated from the rest of the group in all sorts of social ways - some more obvious than others. They will be told things like 'some people are too intelligent to get the program', or 'your best thinking got you here', or that they are on a dry drunk, etc.
If you (and apparently thousands of others in Australia, according to some - which I seriously doubt is as widespread in AA Australia as Aaalfie seems to be suggesting) are doing is something different- good for you!
But it's not AA - what a program that doesn't include God/higher power is called is SOS , SMART, etc - not AA.
And that's all there is to it.


You sound angry.
And wrong. Why? Because ...

THE ONLY REQUIREMENT FOR MEMBERSHIP IS A DESIRE TO STOP DRINKING.

Have you got that yet? :rolleyes::boggled::)
 
Last edited:
At any rate, the OP has been answered. AAers insist that AA isn't religious because many can and do utlise the program and the fellowship without any requirement of this God they (the others) hate so much.

This is as ridiculous as saying the catholic church isn't religious because many people can and do utilize the catholic program without believing they are eating a chunk of christ flesh in a waffer and drinking christ blood in wine.

The question has been answered though. It has been shown throughout this thread that the only way anyone can insist AA is not religious is through delusion.
 
What's interesting about this debate, in particular the part about the higher power, is that although AA supporters claim that this higher power could be absolutely anything, it's very clear that this higher power can't possibly be the only one you really need: yourself.

Another puzzle lies in the other steps. Look at the attributes AA gives this god:

11: Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.

1) God has a will.

2) God desires something for you.

3) You can communicate with god through prayer.

4) God will give you power to carry out his will.

6: Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character

5) God can remove character defects.

3: Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.

6) God cares for you.

5: Admitted to God, to ourselves and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

7) God hears you.

By all indications, this must be a deity. Inanimate objects don't care, communicate, hear, want, or possess a will. That leaves natural beings but you don't pray to natural beings. That leaves super-natural beings.
 
Last edited:
See what I mean? Fuzzy.

Arriving at a definitive definition of a thing so complex as interaction (in human terms) isn't supposed to be easy. If you thought it would be, that's your problem, not mine. Perhaps YOU'd like to propose an easier definition. If we could agree to it and move on, wouldn't it be better than to throw useless bits like yours above at one another ?

"With few exceptions our members find that they have tapped an unsuspected inner resource which they presently indentify with their own conception of a Power greater than themselves."

Sure. But you've spent so much time and energy arguing that the unconscious is not part of YOU that I don't see where you think this is taking us.
 
Although you've told again and again "yes it can", by people who found it so, and continue to do so.

Fine. So just to be clear: AA and yourself agree that YOU can be your OWN higher power ?

Nope. You did though. ;)

I see. So you're just mirroring everything I say and hoping that, somehow, that'll stump me ? 6 year-old kids use this form of argument, so it's not the first time I encounter it.

Let me help you: the point I was making was that you could say that you credit just about anything with your recovery and life, but it doesn't make it true. Otherwise all those wackos who yap about the benefits of homeopathy would be automatically right; same with alien abductions, etc.
 
Last edited:
Wrong again - you really are showing your ignorance here.
Most of us know we (as in I) had a lot to do with our recovery.

Really ? I thought step 1 was:

"We admitted we were powerless over alcohol".

If that's step one, and all other steps derive from it, how can your own actions have anything to do with recovery ? I'll remind you that one of the next steps is "turn our will and our lives over to the care of [insert your higher power here]".
 
Translation: "La la la la la. I can't hear you !"

Pretty much. Alfie puts me on ignore everytime he doesn't have a response to simple questions about his reasoning. I think this is the third time in this thread.

What he calls ad homs, aren't. He doesn't understand the definition. Calling someone who lies a liar isn't an ad hom.
 
Arriving at a definitive definition of a thing so complex as interaction (in human terms) isn't supposed to be easy. If you thought it would be, that's your problem, not mine.
I disagree. I see the problem arising out of the need for a definitive definition of "real interaction". Because it was you who introduced that qualifier, that makes it your problem, and I knew it wouldn't be easy, but then, that's a lot of what makes it fun.

Sure. But you've spent so much time and energy arguing that the unconscious is not part of YOU that I don't see where you think this is taking us.
It's really not MY argument. I have merely observed that the "self" portion of "a power greater than ourselves" defaults to a simple intuitive construct: the conscious self ("YOU"), which is, by definition, separate from the "unconscious". Attempting to deconstruct that -- to identify and rigorously examine the essential premises upon which it rests -- is a task which has occupied philosophers for centuries, and they have more recently been joined in this quest by neurologists and cognitive psychologists and others. I have called this "a romp through a quagmire" to indicate that I see this not only as a problem which remains largely unsolved, but as one which may even remain to be properly framed.

My main argument here (again) is that for the purposes of an alcoholic in AA it doesn't have to be solved -- no more than it has to be solved for the purposes of any average person just interested in getting through the day (or night).

Have another look at the quote I provided above:

"With few exceptions our members find that they have tapped an unsuspected inner resource which they presently indentify with their own conception of a Power greater than themselves."

I submit that "a power greater than themselves" implies "a power other than themselves". I won't dispute that some of the underlying assumptions are open to question (beginning with the one Descartes expressed as "cogito ergo sum"), just as I would not dispute that there might be some valid basis for questioning whether anything truly qualifying as "real interaction" ever took place between Tom Hanks' character in Cast Away and the character "Wilson" (who was, after all, a volleyball).

I will venture this rather sweeping statement:
Human behavior, in general, is not driven by that which is most logically rigorous but by that which is most intuitively compelling.
 
'Membership doesn't Equal Practicing The Actual Program!

You sound angry.
And wrong. Why? Because ...

THE ONLY REQUIREMENT FOR MEMBERSHIP IS A DESIRE TO STOP DRINKING.

Have you got that yet? :rolleyes::boggled::)

Your post doesn't apply - you are confusing 'Membership' with 'Actually practicing the AA program'. Stop bringing up the membership statement as it has nothing to do with the AA program - We (well, everyone but you) aren't talking about membership, we are talking about the AA program.

Got That??

Just because someone claims they are a member - does that automatically mean they are doing what the program says? Of course it doesn't - there is no way you (or anyone else) can claim that. I see 1000's of people every year (sometimes I see that many in just a week) attending meetings, claiming they are 'members' - voting in regional & area functions, or just on a break / release from their latest recovery home of choice - who don't give squat about the program, or anything else.

All these people and more may claim (and actually be) members - but never open a big book, or do any step work, or have any relationship whatever with the Program.

I repeat: Membership doesn't equal Practicing/Actually Doing. And when it comes to Practicing/Doing, God (with a capital G) - a very specific God (one who can hear you, one who can take action to remove one's defects, - the specifics of this God are finely detailed in the AA program) - such a God (and turning one's live over to it) is absolutely a requirement of the program.
 
Have you considered using colors too? Apparently fonts and bolding just aren't getting your "message" across.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom