Well I think it could have ended weeks ago. The question was/is "why do people in AA insist it is not religious?".
The AAers here have answered that to the best of their ability.
Others disagree with their responses and incorrectly assume we are all deists because AA has assisted in giving us sobriety and that word (God) appears time after time in the literature. They seem at great pains to try and prove AA is religious when there are many practical examples that show that it doesn't have to be - which in itself actually answers the OP.
These 'others' seem to be intolerant god haters, who at the mere mention of the word god go into apoplexy. One wonders how they get along in a country that has "In God we trust" on their currency.
At any rate, the OP has been answered. AAers insist that AA isn't religious because many can and do utlise the program and the fellowship without any requirement of this God they (the others) hate so much.
This seems to drive the god haters to drink and thus, the thread does not end.
There's
no hate whatever in anything I've posted - however, it (once again) goes without saying that if a person 'utilizes the program' without any of the god-bothering from AA materials/the big book , then that person is not -
most definitely not - practicing the AA program. What they
are doing is what has come out of treatment centers (for the most part) over the last 20 years, as an entire
mix of people (drug addicts, sex addicts, bleh bleh blah) got
forced into AA by the legal & social system here in the USA. These people (in the minds of most old timers > 25 yrs sober I've met - and I've met hundreds
personally) brought along a new agey sort of philosophy, that included things such as 'god is not required' which are in
direct conflict with what AA teaches
I repeat my claim that if aaalfie (or anyone else) - in whatever country - attends any AA meeting and makes the statement 'neither god, nor any higher power is needed to get and stay sober' then that person will very likely come under
substantial pressure to change, will be ostracized, not invited to after meeting activities, will become
isolated from the rest of the group in all sorts of social ways - some more obvious than others. They will be told things like 'some people are too intelligent to get the program', or 'your best thinking got you here', or that they are on a dry drunk, etc.
If you (and apparently thousands of others in Australia, according to some - which I seriously doubt is as widespread in AA Australia as Aaalfie seems to be suggesting) are doing is
something different- good for you!
But it's
not AA - what a program that doesn't include God/higher power
is called is SOS , SMART, etc -
not AA.
And that's
all there is to it.