Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The greatest time savings all around would have been obtained by you having simply dropped "counting coup" into a search box to begin with. That's what I would have done.

You mean, like you searched the thread to find your accusation that my definition was "broad" (or "vague") before saying it was too specific ?

Does it still work if the author is dead? Would you agree then that when a person watches a movie on television they are, for all intents and purposes, really interacting with the characters?

Only in the sense that ratings will affect the authors... in that sense I might retract my contention that a book author interacts with his intended audience, insofar as the "interaction" is one-way only. I'm not sure it could be construed as an interaction at all...
 
That might explain your problem. Although that would be a different thread.

My problem ? I just highlighted yours. Did you completely miss the point, again ?

Just because you CREDIT something as having saved your life doesn't mean it A) has anything to do with it and B) is beyond reproach entirely.

There are a lot of things I love, but it doesn't mean they're perfect, for instance.
 
What's interesting about this debate, in particular the part about the higher power, is that although AA supporters claim that this higher power could be absolutely anything, it's very clear that this higher power can't possibly be the only one you really need: yourself.
 
I'm not sure it could be construed as an interaction at all...
See what I mean? Fuzzy.

What's interesting about this debate, in particular the part about the higher power, is that although AA supporters claim that this higher power could be absolutely anything, it's very clear that this higher power can't possibly be the only one you really need: yourself.
"With few exceptions our members find that they have tapped an unsuspected inner resource which they presently indentify with their own conception of a Power greater than themselves."
- Alcoholics Anonymous Third Edition Appendix II, page 569 (my bold).
 
What's interesting about this debate, in particular the part about the higher power, is that although AA supporters claim that this higher power could be absolutely anything, it's very clear that this higher power can't possibly be the only one you really need: yourself.
Although you've told again and again "yes it can", by people who found it so, and continue to do so.

My problem ? I just highlighted yours. Did you completely miss the point, again ?
Nope. You did though. ;)
 
What's interesting about this debate, in particular the part about the higher power, is that although AA supporters claim that this higher power could be absolutely anything, it's very clear that this higher power can't possibly be the only one you really need: yourself.

Wrong again - you really are showing your ignorance here.
Most of us know we (as in I) had a lot to do with our recovery. We did the work, we turned up to meetings, we did the stepwork, we did the sharing etc.
We also got a lot of help from a lot of others and we could never have done it without help.
 
GB's answer pretty much nails it for me:

"Our interest is the same is yours, we like arguing on forums about topics that interest us." (Of course, as I've noted, I don't always understand all the reasons why I do the things I do.)

Why is it important to you to know why it's important to me? Do you often ask this question of people engaged in discussions on this forum, or do you see this as some kind of special case?

Editing my posts to change the meaning is dishonest.
 
Tsig, I've spent decades thinking along the same lines. 'Why', I'd be asking myself, is the AA membership (taken as a whole - obviously, there are individual differences) so heavily invested in denying the AA program is religious? 'Why' I'd ask myself, if AA is effective for a minority of people with a deadly problem, even if it is religious - why not embrace that publicly? Why run away from it, confuse the issue, defend themselves as 'spiritual not religious' etc?

The answer I came to - after much research, talking personally to thousands of people over the years and examining information & documents at archives not available to the public (and some no longer available to AA members themselves - a policy they only started recently) - the answer I came to was initially repugnant to me (as a then-believing good ole boy AA member).

The answer I came to is this: The AA program is , at it's core, a mind (and body) controlling cult. It's primary purpose (regardless of what it may say in the Steps, or the Traditions, or the Concepts) is to spread & grow itself - to gain new members, and to have those members get still more, so on and so on. Just like any other cult, it's only purpose is to grow and thrive.

It's primary purpose is not to cure or fix members drinking problem - that's a secondary (beneficial) effect (or so they claim - I would disagree that it's any more effective than quitting any other way, including on one's on willpower (the only real way that works).

Just as in any other secretive cult, the fact of the matter is they can't let on what their primary purpose is to the general public (that is, to 'potential' new recruits) - it would turn off too many potential members. Convince people it's for their own good, convince people it's for the betterment of society (ie - treating and removing alcoholic members of society), and not only will people allow the cult to operate freely - they (that is, the public) will support it, fund it, recommend it to friends & family, give money, etc etc.

Bill Wilson says it about as clearly as possible when he states 'Our primary purpose is to be of maximum service to God and other human beings' - the goal of AA isn't to get it's members healthy, but to use them to further it's own growth.

All this is tangential to the topic (and well deserving, in my view, of another separate topic). I summarize: AA defends itself from the religious claim because they know (Bill knew) that converting people to the insanity that is the cult religion of Buchman & Wilson would go down much easier if people joined for another reason entirely (they thought it would help them to quit drinking themselves to death), and society in general would welcome them with open arms (and the gov't would both support and direct resources to them, making the whole thing alot easier - just look at the multibillion dollar recovery industry, churning out potential recruits like mad!)

Thanks for the reply.

Can't add much to it but I did want you to know I read an appreciated it.
 
Editing my posts to change the meaning is dishonest.
As is falsely accusing others of having committed such an act. Both are in fact reportable offenses here. I had to check back to see if I might have made some error in quoting your post, and confirmed that I did indeed quote you verbatim. I can allow the possibility that you may simply have made a mistake. If so, no big deal, it happens. Otherwise, unless you'd like to retract the above accusation or at least provide some explanation of what you could possibly be getting at in making it, I suggest we do go ahead and hand this one off to the mods.
 
Leaving off all the other flip flopping in there - which I may have a question on later - just who would "scrap" AA and from under what authority would this come?

I would assume that rational people would scrap a system that took up all that time and energy and yet had exactly no effect on lowering rates of alcoholism. As individuals they need no authority.

Of course, there will always be those who would continue to go just like there are people who show up at Virgin Mary water spots on windows to plead for help with what ails them.
 
Wrong again - you really are showing your ignorance here.

That's funny...you admit your total ignorance of how AA in conducted in the US and you call others "ignorant"??

Were you this obnoxious before you quit drinking?
 
Wrong again - you really are showing your ignorance here.
Most of us know we (as in I) had a lot to do with our recovery. We did the work, we turned up to meetings, we did the stepwork, we did the sharing etc.
We also got a lot of help from a lot of others and we could never have done it without help.

And yet this is completely contrary to what the Big Book and AA literature says. "No human power could relieve our alcoholism." Will you never turn on your skepticism?
 
Although you've told again and again "yes it can", by people who found it so, and continue to do so.

And yet, that is completely contrary to AA dogma where no human power can relieve your alcoholism.
 
That's funny...you admit your total ignorance of how AA in conducted in the US and you call others "ignorant"??

Were you this obnoxious before you quit drinking?

Yep, more so.
By the way, welcome back R.A.F. Is this the respect you now said you would afford me?

You are aware of course that AA is a worldwide organisation aren't you? :rolleyes:

Haven't you read the Big Book? Obviously not. Chapter 6 if you care to read.

I have on many occasions, you will need to show me where it says this, otherwise it is just a lie:

the goal of AA isn't to get it's members healthy, but to use them to further it's own growth.
 
Last edited:
And yet, that is completely contrary to AA dogma where no human power can relieve your alcoholism.

Another lie?
In how it works it actually says "That probably no human power could have relieved our alcoholism."
Did you note the word PROBABLY?
 
I would assume that rational people would scrap a system that took up all that time and energy and yet had exactly no effect on lowering rates of alcoholism. As individuals they need no authority.

LOL.
Now you are suggesting that the millions of recovering alcoholics and addicts worldwide who do find AA works for them, "scrap it" because a study (that hasn't been done) finds it doesn't work for them.

I'm laughing so hard I think I'm going to wet myself. It would be the first time since I stopped drinking. :D
 
Last edited:
"It is difficult to watch unfounded attacks on homeopathy, that I credit with saving my life, mostly by posters who have no clue what they are attacking."

That might explain your problem. Although that would be a different thread.

My problem ? I just highlighted yours. Did you completely miss the point, again?

Nope. You did though. ;)

Thanks for the fine example of a complete and utter failure, AlBell. I am hoping this is just lack of understanding on your part and not dishonesty.

Nicely played, Belz! :D
 
Another lie?
In how it works it actually says "That probably no human power could have relieved our alcoholism."
Did you note the word PROBABLY?

Ironic that you understand qualifiers here but can't grasp them in other places. Dishonest much?

Regardless of the qualifier though, you can throw that idea out completely because it is, obviously, 100% wrong. A human power CAN relieve your alcoholism.

You really aren't helping AA's case here, Alfie.
 
Last edited:
Ironic that you understand qualifiers here but can't grasp them in other places. Dishonest much?

LOL
And straight back at you: the words "probably", in the big book (ignored by you) and my use of the word "suggested" were also these qualifiers you place such weight on in your own posts, but no-one elses. Curious.

'scuse me, I have to change. :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom