Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You mean similar to the way you and few others here want AA to be religious and simply decide it is?

What Qayak said! :p

Or do you really want us to repeatedly bombard you with AA's own words as they are printed in their own literature? :rolleyes: If so, we could just repeatedly repost our posts which have already refuted your claims categorically.

GB
 
Last edited:
How can you expect to make any progress if your insults put your opponents into such a disposition as they are no longer listening to you ?
In the context of the larger ongoing discussion I've mentioned, I believe one of the main arguments from the "gloves off" camp is that the word "opponents" tends to imply that "they" probably aren't predisposed to listening to begin with, and aren't going to get that way no matter what you do -- but in this discussion, that has not constituted a hard barrier to identifying at least some points of agreement with some of my "opponents" (even though they have occasionally needed to be reminded of having agreed on those points). My personal experience has often been that if you want to see a guy's best stuff, you gotta get him riled up a little. It sounds like you are now openly declaring that you haven't been listening to me (as if that were not already obvious), and claiming that all responsibility for that falls on me. Again in the context of the larger discussion, I believe that the position of the "gloves off" camp would be that that doesn't EVEN fly.

HUH? Google right there at your fingertips, and your response upon encountering a phrase you are unfamiliar with is: "Huh?".

"Real" as in "real vs imagined". Surely you see the difference.
I surely see that distinction as potentially a lot fuzzier than you do.

Otherwise any belief, no matter what its consequences are, is acceptable and should never be countered or argued against on the basis that its the believer's reality and that that's ok.
I already have argued that where management of that person's internal states is concerned, it's nobody else's business. Some of my "opponents" have agreed. I have also argued that this is precisely the approach AA takes with respect to the beliefs of the individual AA member. That view we have identified as a key point of disagreement.

What have I declined,
Woops! Lost the thread again, have you?
...and why do I get the impression that your only goal in your discussion with me is to argue against me, and not my points ?
I don't see any YOU here. All I see is your points (or, more often, a yawning void where I might have expected some actual points to have appeared).


Well, we would interact to the extent that any author interacts with his audience.
And to what extent is that? Is not the author writing to an imagined audience? An anticipated audience? Once the book is actually printed, published, and read, does that constitute imagined interaction suddenly becoming real?
 
It sounds to me like he might have found a good support group in AA to assist with the transition. Sadly - from what you say he was scared off by the god talk. What a shame he thought he had to convert to something when he didn't.

I can't speak for the particular person qayak was describing, but do you not understand that someone can be turned off by the religious aspects of (a particular group of) AA without being under the impression that they "had to convert to something"?

Imagine someone who has been diagnosed with cancer goes to a cancer support group meeting, and it turns out that much of the meeting consists of members discussing the various homeopathic and other "alternative" snake oil treatments they are taking. Indeed, their whole approach is based on the notion that somehow, somewhere, they'll find the magical cure. "Oh," the group members insist, "you don't have to become a believer in 'alternative' medicine to be a member of this group -- take what you want and leave the rest!"

"Thanks but no thanks," says our skeptical cancer patient. "It's true that nobody is putting a gun to my head and demanding that I 'convert' to anything, but the woo-woo stuff infects almost everything you do, so there's very little here that I want to 'take,' and it's not worth it to me to sit through all the nonsense for a few kernels of useful stuff."

Is that such an irrational position? Can you not see that "conversion" is not the litmus test?
 
It sounds to me like he might have found a good support group in AA to assist with the transition. Sadly - from what you say he was scared off by the god talk. What a shame he thought he had to convert to something when he didn't.

He didn't think he had to convert to anything. His issue was simply that he went to church for religion and AA for help with his alcoholism but found more religion in AA than in any church he ever attended.

Plus, he was an amazing piano player and churches have pianos, AA meetings don't. :D

If it be the decision of the membership to change things, so be it; I will lose no sleep over it.

The collective conscience fallacy. Thinking that there is a collective conscience shift prior to individuals shifting. It doesn't happen that way which is why AA doesn't change. Each individual is waiting for the collective conscience shift.

Ironically, I watched a video posted on my nephew's Facebook wall. It is the leader of some wackjob militia from Alaska giving a speech on his new system of government. His system goes like this.

Single Executive - the "go to" guy.
Judiciary - based on two rules.
Militia- to keep people from destroying the system.

He makes the point that the militia is so great because it relies on the collective conscience of the entire militia when a problem arises and anything the Executor says is just a "suggestion."

Looks like the beginnings of a great dictatorship to me . . . Just sayin'! :D

What I strenuously object to however is outsiders thinking they can dictate what to do, how to do it, and when to do it.

I don't know that anyone expected AA to change because people on the JREF thought they were religious.

But, why is it wrong for outsiders to have an opinion and what is it that makes you feel you have to automatically argue against an idea just because it comes, or is agreed to by outsiders? Many people inside AA find it religious as well.

Also, AA isn't a secret society. Any "outsider" can be privy to all the information with a little leg work. Correct me if I am wrong, but this just seems like a petty "Us -vs- Them" issue for you.

So.... Why, when you say AA doesn't work, would you want to change the language?

As I have already explained. These two topics are unrelated but let me explain anyway.

First, no one knows how effective it is. The evidence is very poor and a proper study needs to be done. I can't make a sure fire call on how effective it is OR if there is something simple that can be done to make AA effective.

Changing the language simply makes the organization more inclusive and seeing as there isn't a good reason to exclude the ones who this would include (according to AA literature and my own thoughts), it seems only right and wise to change the wording.

Now, having a choice between a proper study on AA effectiveness and a word change, I would choose the study. After that, one can determine whether a word change is worth the effort.
 
I can't speak for the particular person qayak was describing, but do you not understand that someone can be turned off by the religious aspects of (a particular group of) AA without being under the impression that they "had to convert to something"?

You are right - I did make an assumption or two here. But I felt them fair assumptions given the context of the discussion around this supposed conversion issue qayak seems to have.

He didn't think he had to convert to anything. His issue was simply that he went to church for religion and AA for help with his alcoholism but found more religion in AA than in any church he ever attended.
Plus, he was an amazing piano player and churches have pianos, AA meetings don't. :D


Mine does.
There are also musical and singing groups of AA scattered about.
But you aren't seriously suggesting that he rejected AA because it wasn't musical enough? But seriously - are you saying he rejected AA because he perceived some conversion to god, as opposed to a higher power of his own choosing? If I had done the same thing I would be where he is.

But, why is it wrong for outsiders to have an opinion and what is it that makes you feel you have to automatically argue against an idea just because it comes, or is agreed to by outsiders? Many people inside AA find it religious as well.

I didn't say I had a problem with opinions, but others dictating their requirements for change.

Also, AA isn't a secret society. Any "outsider" can be privy to all the information with a little leg work. Correct me if I am wrong, but this just seems like a petty "Us -vs- Them" issue for you.

Wrong.
It is simply a please "mind your own business" issue. If you aren't a member, why change it when there are other programs that do not have a higher power requirenment?

As I have already explained. These two topics are unrelated but let me explain anyway.

First, no one knows how effective it is. The evidence is very poor and a proper study needs to be done. I can't make a sure fire call on how effective it is OR if there is something simple that can be done to make AA effective.

Which completely contradicts the arguments from your side that state AA does not work. It also contradicts the studies (I loosely use the term) that also say it doesn't work.
I might be wrong, but I could have sworn you said it didn't work earlier in the thread too. Please correct me if I am wrong on this last point.

Changing the language simply makes the organization more inclusive and seeing as there isn't a good reason to exclude the ones who this would include (according to AA literature and my own thoughts), it seems only right and wise to change the wording.

But why does it meed to be changed when there are other service providers?

Now, having a choice between a proper study on AA effectiveness and a word change, I would choose the study. After that, one can determine whether a word change is worth the effort.

So now you are saying don't change it until we have a study on its effectiveness? I am genuinely confused.:boggled:
 
Last edited:
In the context of the larger ongoing discussion I've mentioned, I believe one of the main arguments from the "gloves off" camp is that the word "opponents" tends to imply that "they" probably aren't predisposed to listening to begin with

That's an awesome way to approach arguments. In fact, why does this board exist at all ? Maybe it should just be the flame wars part. After all nobody listens to the others' arguments. :rolleyes:

HUH? Google right there at your fingertips, and your response upon encountering a phrase you are unfamiliar with is: "Huh?".

Heaven forbid you'd actually explain it in your own words. It'd actually have been shorter than your actual response.

I surely see that distinction as potentially a lot fuzzier than you do.

Do go on.

Woops! Lost the thread again, have you?

Ha. Why did I even expect you to clarify, I'll never know.

I don't see any YOU here. All I see is your points

And yet you fail to adress them.

And to what extent is that? Is not the author writing to an imagined audience? An anticipated audience? Once the book is actually printed, published, and read, does that constitute imagined interaction suddenly becoming real?

That's why I said "to the extent". They are not directly communicating/interacting, but they're expecting someone to read it and when someone does they are indirectly but really interacting with the author.

Why is that so difficult for you ?
 
Why? There's plenty here to laugh at.

Watching "skeptics" work on their confirmation biases is good fun.

Confirmation bias ? Before I saw the numbers I assumed that AA worked; because I was told so.

The confirmation bias is yours. Apparently it's a cult thing. If you've been touched by AA you can say no ill of it.
 
It is difficult to watch unfounded attacks on an organization that I credit with saving my life, mostly by posters who have no clue what they are attacking.
 
Why? There's plenty here to laugh at.

Watching "skeptics" work on strengthening their confirmation biases is good fun.

Not as entertaining as watching you "non-theist" AAers flounder without any evidence to back up your assertions that AA isn't religious. :D

GB
 
It is difficult to watch unfounded attacks on an organization that I credit with saving my life, mostly by posters who have no clue what they are attacking.

Wow! :eye-poppi I didn't know pointing out that an organization is religious automatically qualified as an attack.

In fact, for all the issues I DO have with AA, I'm not opposed to the idea that you and others feel that it helped you; I'm even rather happy for you.

I only object to the pretense that AA isn't religious, and of course all the other stuff I've consistently mentioned that goes along with it.

GB
 
That's an awesome way to approach arguments. In fact, why does this board exist at all ? Maybe it should just be the flame wars part. After all nobody listens to the others' arguments.
I hope you do realize that I was paraphrasing the position of what I am calling the "gloves off" camp, one side of the recent "Don't be a Dick" debate (which I don't see us resolving here). I don't entirely disagree with the spirit of your comments, but I still find myself somewhat torn on the issue. My usual policy is to at least try to resist the temptation to be the first one to take off the gloves -- but once the gloves are off they're off, and I don't see much to be gained by pretending otherwise. Out there in the world, I make every effort to treat others with kindness and respect even when they're stupid and wrong. Inside this forum, weighing the relative merits of various opposing ideas is simply what we do, and there is generally a rather low tolerance for whining about being treated rudely, especially by those who demonstrate little reluctance to dish it out themselves.

Heaven forbid you'd actually explain it in your own words. It'd actually have been shorter than your actual response.
The greatest time savings all around would have been obtained by you having simply dropped "counting coup" into a search box to begin with. That's what I would have done. Why introduce further noise into the channel by clogging it with these sorts of trivialities?


That's why I said "to the extent". They are not directly communicating/interacting, but they're expecting someone to read it and when someone does they are indirectly but really interacting with the author.
Sort of a collapse of the wave function thing then. Interesting. Now we're into the meat. Does it still work if the author is dead? Would you agree then that when a person watches a movie on television they are, for all intents and purposes, really interacting with the characters?
 
But you aren't seriously suggesting that he rejected AA because it wasn't musical enough?

No, that was his sense of humour.

But seriously - are you saying he rejected AA because he perceived some conversion to god, as opposed to a higher power of his own choosing?

No, never said that at all. I said, he was a christian already, which is why he went to church on Sundays. What he objected to was the AA meetings being more religious than the services at church on Sundays.

If I had done the same thing I would be where he is.

There's nothing to support that claim.

I didn't say I had a problem with opinions, but others dictating their requirements for change.

Nobody's done that in this thread.

Wrong.
It is simply a please "mind your own business" issue. If you aren't a member, why change it when there are other programs that do not have a higher power requirenment?

No, it isn't. You have stated that everyone is allowed an opinion and that is all that has been expressed here. This is a case of you getting defensive about a simple fact.

Which completely contradicts the arguments from your side that state AA does not work. It also contradicts the studies (I loosely use the term) that also say it doesn't work.
I might be wrong, but I could have sworn you said it didn't work earlier in the thread too. Please correct me if I am wrong on this last point.

You are correct, I did. The point being that AA makes some claims and you make some claims using certain evidence but that evidence can be interpreted in such a way that it shows AA has no more effect than would be expected through spontaneous remission.

You dogmatically insist on an interpretation that is based on evidence that is flawed so I just take the other interpretation because it is equally as reliable. Actually, more so.

But why does it meed to be changed when there are other service providers?

Well, I think that one of two changes has to be made. AA needs to change the wording to align with their claim to be non-religious or they need to change the claims and admit that they are religious.

So now you are saying don't change it until we have a study on its effectiveness? I am genuinely confused.:boggled:

No, I said "If I had a choice between . . ." One reason I said to do the study first is because if AA really is completely ineffective, then there is no need to change the wording as the program would simply be scrapped.
 
No, I said "If I had a choice between . . ." One reason I said to do the study first is because if AA really is completely ineffective, then there is no need to change the wording as the program would simply be scrapped.

Leaving off all the other flip flopping in there - which I may have a question on later - just who would "scrap" AA and from under what authority would this come?
 
It is difficult to watch unfounded attacks on an organization that I credit with saving my life, mostly by posters who have no clue what they are attacking.

"It is difficult to watch unfounded attacks on homeopathy, that I credit with saving my life, mostly by posters who have no clue what they are attacking."
 
"It is difficult to watch unfounded attacks on homeopathy, that I credit with saving my life, mostly by posters who have no clue what they are attacking."
That might explain your problem. Although that would be a different thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom