Stipulate ? How can you possibly claim that they are not equivalent in this context ?
I agreed to regard that as a quibble because I don't see further dissection of that to be of much value here, but you're right: as my choice of the word "stipulate" implies, I
don't actually consider "broad" and "vague" to be equivalent in this context. "YOU are the sum of things in your body" I see as analogous to "Consciousness is that special thing that happens in the human brain". Both are useless, but it's not because they are vague; a vague description is still a description. They are useless because they avoid
altogether the burden of actually
describing or
defining their referents, instead merely throwing a wide net over an area where it is alleged that they reside.
One does not consistently insult those they want civil discussions with.
I have previously made reference to a larger ongoing debate (at JREF and elsewhere) over the question of whether civility is necessary or even desirable when adherents of nonsensical beliefs are confronted by atheists (or is it skeptics? The extent to which
those terms should be treated as equvalent is itself sort of a subset of
that debate). Participants in this thread collectively reached a tacit resolution of this question long ago: "AA mentions God; therefore, the gloves are off". You yourself have been involved in that process. Now you come sporting a halo (
again), and all ready to admonish others for being rude? You're not engaged in a discussion at all. You're counting coup.
I don't claim the right to dictate what is relevant to the issue at hand and what is not, but it was YOU who introduced the idea of "
real interaction", and I find that rather interesting. Even if I didn't see it as relevant to some of the key points we're been discussing for 52 pages (which I do), I would
still find it interesting. Your having declined to attempt any response to my earlier questions suggests that it may well be that I find it more interesting than you yourself do. Even upon returning to the other projects that are now occupying an increasing amount of my time (and which are absolutely
screaming at me to tear away from this
right now), I find new questions arising in my mind: If I somehow anticipated all possible points you could raise here, and wrote out my responses in advance and printed them in a book, and you read the book, would that be us interacting? What if I didn't necessarily have YOU specifically in mind when I wrote it? What if I wrote the book and read it myself? (Come to think of it, that's starting to look like my best bet here, but, alas, there's still that problem with the time).
So if I don't understand the gibberish word-salad you type, it means I'm the one with a problem ?
I find that I must entertain a number of possible explanations:
1) You aren't really having trouble understanding what I'm saying, but are just feigning confusion because you see my conclusions as undermining a point of view to which you are strongly committed for whatever reason.
2) I am not expressing my ideas clearly enough.
3) I am expressing my ideas well, but you don't understand them, because I'm completely nuts.
4) I am expressing my ideas well, and you're doing your best to understand what I'm saying, but you're just not very smart.