Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
What I wonder is why Dymanic left just as he was shown wrong.
Aw, ya miss me! That's sweet!

I would still like to investigate this "real interaction" business a little further when time permits, so if it won't keep you from doing important things to help your community or anything, maybe you'd like to gnaw on this for a while:

If the delay between our responses were a week or two instead of a few hours, that would still count as us interacting, right? How about if I read your posts and consider some responses but don't actually take the time to type one out, and meanwhile you're sitting around wondering why I left (even though I stated the reason quite clearly) does that still count as us interacting?
 
Simple.
I would hate for a person looking for a chance at recovery from alcoholism/addiction, to be put off attending AA anywhere on the basis that they needed to convert to christianity (or any religion).

The fact is, religion isn't a requirement. This said, I do and have acknowledged its roots in same (via Bill W). One is given more than sufficient wiggle room to modify the program to fit ones personal needs.

I celebrated 11 years sober yesterday and I credit AA with a lot of that. If I had thought AA was a religious program when/before I turned up, I would not be alive today and enjoying the life I have.

I sincerely want others to have that too.

Cheers
This. And 14 years.
 
No, I'd like you to man up and adress my last post concerning your accusation that I wasn't paying attention when in fact it was you doing that.
My word: "broad".
Your word: "vague".

You seem to see this as important. I myself do not, but if it helps to remove an obstacle to substantive discussion, I will stipulate that "broad" = "vague", and withdraw my earlier objection.

That's about all the time I have right now to devote to minor semantic quibbling. I actually do find this business of "real interaction" quite interesting, and very relevant to the question(s) at issue here. If you share this interest, and if you have any further thoughts on that, I'll respond when I can. I am glad to finally see you at least demonstrate an ability to use those buttons, because if there's any hope of us continuing our discussion on the actual substance here, I need to be able to assume that your are able to follow the thread of our exchange (if necessary, ignoring unrelated comments as essentially noise in the channel). I'll know you've lost the thread again if I see you come back again with something like "What in the blue hell are you talking about ?" where a bit of backtracking would easily have made that clear -- but I'm not going to be able to keep taking the time to bring you back up to speed. Fair enough?
 
but if it helps to remove an obstacle to substantive discussion, I will stipulate that "broad" = "vague", and withdraw my earlier objection.

Stipulate ? How can you possibly claim that they are not equivalent in this context ?

That's about all the time I have right now to devote to minor semantic quibbling.

Yes, that is without a doubt what you were doing, in fact.

I am glad to finally see you at least demonstrate an ability to use those buttons

Liar, liar, pants on fire. On one hand you say you want to have a rational discussion with me, and on the other you keep insulting me because of a pretense you had about me that has been, I'd like to remind you, proven wrong. One does not consistently insult those they want civil discussions with.

because if there's any hope of us continuing our discussion on the actual substance here, I need to be able to assume that your are able to follow the thread of our exchange

Right back at you, considering you can't even remember your own sentences.

I'll know you've lost the thread again if I see you come back again with something like "What in the blue hell are you talking about ?"

So if I don't understand the gibberish word-salad you type, it means I'm the one with a problem ? You need help with that hubris ?
 
Simple.
I would hate for a person looking for a chance at recovery from alcoholism/addiction, to be put off attending AA anywhere on the basis that they needed to convert to christianity (or any religion).

I don't know a lot of alcoholics and yet I know a couple such people.

One quit on his own and has been sober for more than five years. He tells me he doesn't think about drinking at all anymore. When he goes out for dinners, he has a glass of wine to make toasts with.

We buried the other one last month.

The fact is, religion isn't a requirement. This said, I do and have acknowledged its roots in same (via Bill W). One is given more than sufficient wiggle room to modify the program to fit ones personal needs.

Both the previous people I mentioned quit specifically because of the religious mumbo jumbo in AA.

I celebrated 11 years sober yesterday and I credit AA with a lot of that. If I had thought AA was a religious program when/before I turned up, I would not be alive today and enjoying the life I have.

Congratulations. You worked hard and deserve a good life.

I sincerely want others to have that too.

Perfect. Let's focus on this one point. If you believe AA isn't religious why are you so against the wording of the literature being changed to reflect that and to be more inclusive?
 
Simple.
I would hate for a person looking for a chance at recovery from alcoholism/addiction, to be put off attending AA anywhere on the basis that they needed to convert to christianity (or any religion).

Wait, wait. You don't want AA to be religious and therefore you simply decide that it isn't ? Or did I misinterpret that ?
 
You mean similar to the way you and few others here want AA to be religious and simply decide it is?
 
You mean similar to the way you and few others here want AA to be religious and simply decide it is?

Well, no. We actually use the definition of the word to show it is. You discard definitions, make up a bunch of stuff that isn't true, and claim "therefore AA isn't."

But hey, whose counting? :p
 
Stipulate ? How can you possibly claim that they are not equivalent in this context ?
I agreed to regard that as a quibble because I don't see further dissection of that to be of much value here, but you're right: as my choice of the word "stipulate" implies, I don't actually consider "broad" and "vague" to be equivalent in this context. "YOU are the sum of things in your body" I see as analogous to "Consciousness is that special thing that happens in the human brain". Both are useless, but it's not because they are vague; a vague description is still a description. They are useless because they avoid altogether the burden of actually describing or defining their referents, instead merely throwing a wide net over an area where it is alleged that they reside.

One does not consistently insult those they want civil discussions with.
I have previously made reference to a larger ongoing debate (at JREF and elsewhere) over the question of whether civility is necessary or even desirable when adherents of nonsensical beliefs are confronted by atheists (or is it skeptics? The extent to which those terms should be treated as equvalent is itself sort of a subset of that debate). Participants in this thread collectively reached a tacit resolution of this question long ago: "AA mentions God; therefore, the gloves are off". You yourself have been involved in that process. Now you come sporting a halo (again), and all ready to admonish others for being rude? You're not engaged in a discussion at all. You're counting coup.

I don't claim the right to dictate what is relevant to the issue at hand and what is not, but it was YOU who introduced the idea of "real interaction", and I find that rather interesting. Even if I didn't see it as relevant to some of the key points we're been discussing for 52 pages (which I do), I would still find it interesting. Your having declined to attempt any response to my earlier questions suggests that it may well be that I find it more interesting than you yourself do. Even upon returning to the other projects that are now occupying an increasing amount of my time (and which are absolutely screaming at me to tear away from this right now), I find new questions arising in my mind: If I somehow anticipated all possible points you could raise here, and wrote out my responses in advance and printed them in a book, and you read the book, would that be us interacting? What if I didn't necessarily have YOU specifically in mind when I wrote it? What if I wrote the book and read it myself? (Come to think of it, that's starting to look like my best bet here, but, alas, there's still that problem with the time).

So if I don't understand the gibberish word-salad you type, it means I'm the one with a problem ?
I find that I must entertain a number of possible explanations:

1) You aren't really having trouble understanding what I'm saying, but are just feigning confusion because you see my conclusions as undermining a point of view to which you are strongly committed for whatever reason.
2) I am not expressing my ideas clearly enough.
3) I am expressing my ideas well, but you don't understand them, because I'm completely nuts.
4) I am expressing my ideas well, and you're doing your best to understand what I'm saying, but you're just not very smart.
 
We buried the other one last month.

Alcohol kills alcoholics.

Both the previous people I mentioned quit specifically because of the religious mumbo jumbo in AA.

Yep, I've seen plenty walk away prematurely with bad results. What other "better treatments" did your deceased friend try?

Perfect. Let's focus on this one point. If you believe AA isn't religious why are you so against the wording of the literature being changed to reflect that and to be more inclusive?

I believe I answered that earlier. I will happily try and dig up my original responses if you can answer this:
If you believe AA doesnt work, why would you want to make it more inclusive?

Wait, wait. You don't want AA to be religious and therefore you simply decide that it isn't ? Or did I misinterpret that ?

You are right of course: You have misinterpreted - which is not unusual, as noted here...

It isn't 2) or 3).
 
Last edited:
Alcohol kills alcoholics.

Some. Of course, I know some non-alcoholics and even children who have died the same way.

Yep, I've seen plenty walk away prematurely with bad results. What other "better treatments" did your deceased friend try?

Actually, he had more success with the treatment programs than he ever did with AA. But that is a study group of one.

I believe I answered that earlier.

Thought I read the whole thread. Must have missed it.

I will happily try and dig up my original responses if you can answer this: If you believe AA doesnt work, why would you want to make it more inclusive

History says you won't answer my question if I answer yours so . . . whatever.
 
Dodges noted.

You mean, my response to your dodge. Still waiting on the quid pro quo you agreed to eons ago so I doubt you will give any answer even if I answer your question. But if you answer mine, I will answer yours.

You are correct in that I didn't tell you what program he was in when you asked. I had written it but when I changed the response to the question I obviously deleted that part.

It is a government funded program through a mental health and addiction centre. Unfortunately, the program in the centre is the government's 'point to' program when critics come calling and there is no transitional step in place for people leaving. For those with a support network to return to, there is a very high success rate. For those who return to street life, it isn't so good.

This man lived on the street of Vancouvers East Side for the past 22 years so it is pretty hard to say alcoholism was his only problem. For sure it was a major one but there were others. A very troubled life.
 
It sounds to me like he might have found a good support group in AA to assist with the transition. Sadly - from what you say he was scared off by the god talk. What a shame he thought he had to convert to something when he didn't.


But to answer your question about changing the language. To put it briefly, I have no objection to it changing, and I'm not actually sure why you think I had.
My objections are simply that we have 'rules' (traditions) that have served AA members and the fellowship fairly well so far. If it be the decision of the membership to change things, so be it; I will lose no sleep over it.

What I strenuously object to however is outsiders thinking they can dictate what to do, how to do it, and when to do it.

I imagine also you want to know why I don't move to change things. That is simple too - I see no need to. As an agnostic with hundreds of atheist and theist friends in AA it is obvious to me that the god thing poses no real issue where I live; remembering too that I have conceded time and again that I do not profess to know how things work in individual groups in the US. That said, if people say "you have to have god, and it has to be my god" (or similar), it is these people who are not practicing the religious tolerance that I believe they should be in accordance with the traditions and steps.

So.... Why, when you say AA doesn't work, would you want to change the language?
 
Last edited:
I have previously made reference to a larger ongoing debate (at JREF and elsewhere) over the question of whether civility is necessary or even desirable when adherents of nonsensical beliefs are confronted by atheists (or is it skeptics? The extent to which those terms should be treated as equvalent is itself sort of a subset of that debate).

Of curse it is. How can you expect to make any progress if your insults put your opponents into such a disposition as they are no longer listening to you ?

"AA mentions God; therefore, the gloves are off".

No. AA mentions God repeatedly, therefore it is religious.

You're counting coup.

Huh ?

I don't claim the right to dictate what is relevant to the issue at hand and what is not, but it was YOU who introduced the idea of "real interaction", and I find that rather interesting.

"Real" as in "real vs imagined". Surely you see the difference. Otherwise any belief, no matter what its consequences are, is acceptable and should never be countered or argued against on the basis that its the believer's reality and that that's ok.

Your having declined to attempt any response to my earlier questions suggests that it may well be that I find it more interesting than you yourself do.

What have I declined, and why do I get the impression that your only goal in your discussion with me is to argue against me, and not my points ?

If I somehow anticipated all possible points you could raise here, and wrote out my responses in advance and printed them in a book, and you read the book, would that be us interacting? What if I didn't necessarily have YOU specifically in mind when I wrote it?

Well, we would interact to the extent that any author interacts with his audience.

1) You aren't really having trouble understanding what I'm saying, but are just feigning confusion because you see my conclusions as undermining a point of view to which you are strongly committed for whatever reason.

That would be me wasting my own time. I have no energy to spend on faking my own opinions.

2) I am not expressing my ideas clearly enough.

A possibility.

3) I am expressing my ideas well, but you don't understand them, because I'm completely nuts.

Another possibility

4) I am expressing my ideas well, and you're doing your best to understand what I'm saying, but you're just not very smart.

Another possibility.

But as I expected before I even started to read your false "quadrichotomy", you've forgotten a number of options.

56) You're expressing your ideas as best you can, and I'm doing my best to understand them, but we're simply not on the same page.

73) You're spending too much time trying to ascertain what MY problem is to have a look at yours.

etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom