Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You know Belz, the quality of our discourse seems to be suffering from a certain lack of continuity. It's not like it would have taken a search through the whole thread to figure out what I was referring to there; I had explicitly stated in my very last respose to you which word it was that you tried to put in my mouth. If your memory is that short, and your time constraints (or whatever it is) prevent you from using the little arrow buttons to backtrack through at least the last few posts so as to sort out a triviality like that one, what hope is there of you ever being able to grasp a more abstract point I've been making, distributed across a large number of posts over the last weeks?

We may never know. It now looks like I'm about to encounter some time constraints of my own, so if you're genuinely interested in why I asked whether you and I are engaged in "real" interaction here, and if you really don't see how that fits in with a larger point I've been making (one which I see as at the very heart of this thread's topic), then all I can say for now is that those answers are already contained in previous posts. Learn to use the buttons.

Your posts tend to have a certain "drive-by" flavor which suggests that it is not likely you'll bother. It has become increasingly clear that you haven't taken much time to read or consider what I've been saying. I disagree strongly with GB and qayak on a number of points, but their responses show that they are at least capable of showing that curtesy; I might even be able to rely on them to fairly explain to you what I'm getting at (of course, that would also require genuine interest on your part, and that's the very thing I'm seeing as lacking). I'm sure we'll be talking about some of this stuff again, either in this thread or somewhere else (though probably just as unproductively, and maybe just sort of because we can't help ourselves) -- but for now, I'm going to have to give it a break.

Why is this so important to you?
 
Curiously, I am still trying to figure out why Tsig, Belz, GB et al are at all interested in AA.

I make some generalisations I know when I say: They are not alcoholics, they say it doesn't work - yet want to change the literature to be inclusive for atheists (which it is), they say other programs/therapies work better (but wont name them nor give statistics or studies - save one exception), they want to change the supposed judiciary and/or medical connections, want to legalise some drugs, and on and on we go.

And yet they think and claim that they are making a difference.
On an anonymous internet forum - seriously?

What is their interest? :)
 
Kewl. Free psychotherapy!

Are you licensed?

I just wondered why it is so important to prove that AA is not religious. If it works for you fine but why all the defensiveness?
 
Curiously, I am still trying to figure out why Tsig, Belz, GB et al are at all interested in AA.

I make some generalisations I know when I say: They are not alcoholics, they say it doesn't work - yet want to change the literature to be inclusive for atheists (which it is), they say other programs/therapies work better (but wont name them nor give statistics or studies - save one exception), they want to change the supposed judiciary and/or medical connections, want to legalise some drugs, and on and on we go.

And yet they think and claim that they are making a difference.
On an anonymous internet forum - seriously?

What is their interest? :)

I'm interested in why it's so important to you that AA be not religious.
 
Curiously, I am still trying to figure out why Tsig, Belz, GB et al are at all interested in AA.

I make some generalisations I know when I say: They are not alcoholics, they say it doesn't work - yet want to change the literature to be inclusive for atheists (which it is), they say other programs/therapies work better (but wont name them nor give statistics or studies - save one exception), they want to change the supposed judiciary and/or medical connections, want to legalise some drugs, and on and on we go.

And yet they think and claim that they are making a difference.
On an anonymous internet forum - seriously?

What is their interest? :)

Yes you are generalizing and you have completely missed the point. Our interest is the same is yours, we like arguing on forums about topics that interest us. And each of us has our own motivations for interest in this particular subject.

Mine is that I have had experience with AA and NA, and that I have a lot of issues with these programmes and their effect (both negative and positive, though I tend to see AA as leaning to a net negative) on society, all of which I have mentioned numerous times, and am not going to repeat here.

But seeing as you have me on your ignore list , and you just ignore what people have to say even when you can see their posts, it's no surprise that you still have no idea about our motivations.

Despite some snarky responses on my part to certain other people's snark ;) , I take the issues seriously. And I don't dismiss anyone's points out of hand, not even yours. But I do take into consideration how much weight to give someone's arguments depending on whether or not my "opponent" is willing to engage in honest debate, and on whether or not my "opponent" is willing to admit to ignorance of certain issues.

Insofar as you occasionally are Dr Jekyll and almost seem reasonable enough to admit that you know nothing about how AA operates in the US, and your agreement that Judicial referrals are inappropriate I give you credit.

But sometimes you are Mr Hyde, and demonstrate (or feign) ignorance of AA's: History, Religious Tenets as evidenced in the literature, Proselytization, and Socio-Political/Economic contexts (and the influence AA has had the same). And you aren't above bullying, and disingenuous debate tactics to score points in Mr Hyde mode.

Turn about is Fair Play:

What do YOU think YOU'RE accomplishing an anonymous internet forum? :p

GB
 
Last edited:
Why is this so important to you?
GB's answer pretty much nails it for me:

"Our interest is the same is yours, we like arguing on forums about topics that interest us." (Of course, as I've noted, I don't always understand all the reasons why I do the things I do.)

Why is it important to you to know why it's important to me? Do you often ask this question of people engaged in discussions on this forum, or do you see this as some kind of special case?
 
I'm interested in why it's so important to you that AA be not religious.
Tsig, I've spent decades thinking along the same lines. 'Why', I'd be asking myself, is the AA membership (taken as a whole - obviously, there are individual differences) so heavily invested in denying the AA program is religious? 'Why' I'd ask myself, if AA is effective for a minority of people with a deadly problem, even if it is religious - why not embrace that publicly? Why run away from it, confuse the issue, defend themselves as 'spiritual not religious' etc?

The answer I came to - after much research, talking personally to thousands of people over the years and examining information & documents at archives not available to the public (and some no longer available to AA members themselves - a policy they only started recently) - the answer I came to was initially repugnant to me (as a then-believing good ole boy AA member).

The answer I came to is this: The AA program is , at it's core, a mind (and body) controlling cult. It's primary purpose (regardless of what it may say in the Steps, or the Traditions, or the Concepts) is to spread & grow itself - to gain new members, and to have those members get still more, so on and so on. Just like any other cult, it's only purpose is to grow and thrive.

It's primary purpose is not to cure or fix members drinking problem - that's a secondary (beneficial) effect (or so they claim - I would disagree that it's any more effective than quitting any other way, including on one's on willpower (the only real way that works).

Just as in any other secretive cult, the fact of the matter is they can't let on what their primary purpose is to the general public (that is, to 'potential' new recruits) - it would turn off too many potential members. Convince people it's for their own good, convince people it's for the betterment of society (ie - treating and removing alcoholic members of society), and not only will people allow the cult to operate freely - they (that is, the public) will support it, fund it, recommend it to friends & family, give money, etc etc.

Bill Wilson says it about as clearly as possible when he states 'Our primary purpose is to be of maximum service to God and other human beings' - the goal of AA isn't to get it's members healthy, but to use them to further it's own growth.

All this is tangential to the topic (and well deserving, in my view, of another separate topic). I summarize: AA defends itself from the religious claim because they know (Bill knew) that converting people to the insanity that is the cult religion of Buchman & Wilson would go down much easier if people joined for another reason entirely (they thought it would help them to quit drinking themselves to death), and society in general would welcome them with open arms (and the gov't would both support and direct resources to them, making the whole thing alot easier - just look at the multibillion dollar recovery industry, churning out potential recruits like mad!)
 
I'm interested in why it's so important to you that AA be not religious.

Simple.
I would hate for a person looking for a chance at recovery from alcoholism/addiction, to be put off attending AA anywhere on the basis that they needed to convert to christianity (or any religion).

The fact is, religion isn't a requirement. This said, I do and have acknowledged its roots in same (via Bill W). One is given more than sufficient wiggle room to modify the program to fit ones personal needs.

I celebrated 11 years sober yesterday and I credit AA with a lot of that. If I had thought AA was a religious program when/before I turned up, I would not be alive today and enjoying the life I have.

I sincerely want others to have that too.

Cheers
 
Tsig, I've spent decades thinking along the same lines.
..one huge snip of nonsense removed..

And yet you still turn up to meetings?

Anyhow....

evidence please of this little gem:

'Our primary purpose is to be of maximum service to God and other human beings' - the goal of AA isn't to get it's members healthy, but to use them to further it's own growth.
 
Last edited:
There are several sections - in different areas of AA literature - that state this in one form or another. I'm sure you know your AA literature & the AA program just as well as I do, but for the sake of discussion & brevity, I'll mention the first occasion: AA's Core Program (The Big Book) Pg 77 "But this is not an end in itself. Our real purpose is to fit ourselves to be of maximum service to God and the people about us."

There are other places saying nearly identical sentiment - you can find those on your own.

Not an obnoxious goal, certainly - laudable even (well, without the 'to God' part). But here, as well as within many other paragraphs scattered throughout much of the AA program, it's clear that stopping drinking is only a small step to something greater - greater referring to conscious contact with & doing the will of God with a capital G. Besides the fact that the core AA textbook and other Conference Approved literature frequently mentions things such as 'quitting drinking is only the beginning', it's also clear that nearly anyone who attends an AA meeting and states "I've quit drinking for x number of years or months, not having any problems with it' will be met with statements saying 'Well, you're on a dry drunk ' or 'You're just whistling in the dark' or 'If you stop or slow down on your AA program your only options are death, insane asylum, or jail' or 'If you think you're cured (I used the word Recovered) why don't you go out and try some controlled drinking?' - statements and advice I've heard hundreds and hundreds of times. That last one being particularly evil, with the intent of sending someone out to drink so we (members of AA) can watch them come crawling back, thereby confirming our own delusions and (in the view of AA) appropriately punishing the transgressor.

Try another technique I've down countless times - announce during your particular time to speak that God (with a capital G) is not necessary to get and stay sober, that you've been sober on your own will power & knowledge, with a little help from the medical community.

I'll let you guess what happens - I know the outcome, as I've done it myself. More than once I've said that in front of more than 1000 other members.

The result - every time - is not an example of love or tolerance.
 
Last edited:
And yet you still turn up to meetings?

Anyhow....

evidence please of this little gem:

That's right. Keep snipping any inconvenient and uncomfortable information that might make you actually think! :rolleyes:

Anyway, clearly Tinyal has done a ton of his own research to support his thesis, and it can't be easily dismissed. But he's certainly not the only one to note the "cultish" aspects of AA, and build a body of evidence to support it.

AA:Cult or Cure 2nd edition

I'm a little reticent about using the terminology of "cult" myself (like Alfie, most folk seem to tune you out the moment someone uses that term--sort of like the way some people just tune out when they hear "conspiracy theory"--but he seems to tune out the moment AA is accurately described as religious anyway). Generally speaking, its usage is as a pejorative that religions hurl at each other. However, insofar as any religion/religious organization can be synonymous with "cult", the term could just as easily be applicable to AA.

In any case Charles Bufe builds a strong case for his thesis, and much of his research confirms Tinyal's proposition.

GB
 
I had explicitly stated in my very last respose to you which word it was that you tried to put in my mouth. If your memory is that short

Speaking of short memory:

My argument rests on showing why your definition of one particular term -- "YOU"-- is so broad as to be useless (which was quite obviously your intent).

and then:

I used several words in describing your definition itself, but I don't recall "vague" being among them. It was your purpose that I described as "specific".

So "so broad as to be useless" is not "vague" ? Also, notice how my "intent" changes from one of your posts to the other.

Your entire post now is trying to make me appear as not following the thread at all, when in fact you apparently forgot your own arguments and points. And it's funny you accuse me of not bothering to check previous posts when you obviously didn't bother to, yourself.
 
Last edited:
Curiously, I am still trying to figure out why Tsig, Belz, GB et al are at all interested in AA.

I make some generalisations I know when I say: They are not alcoholics, they say it doesn't work - yet want to change the literature to be inclusive for atheists (which it is), they say other programs/therapies work better (but wont name them nor give statistics or studies - save one exception), they want to change the supposed judiciary and/or medical connections, want to legalise some drugs, and on and on we go.

And yet they think and claim that they are making a difference.
On an anonymous internet forum - seriously?

What is their interest? :)

Yours is obviously elitism.
 
Our real purpose is to fit ourselves to be of maximum service to God and the people about us."[/I][/B]

So you were making things up when you said:

the goal of AA isn't to get it's members healthy, but to use them to further it's own growth.

And endeavour to sell it as a Bill Wilson quote.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom