Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
My argument rests on showing why your definition of one particular term -- "YOU"-- is so broad as to be useless (which was quite obviously your intent).

What is so obvious to you is, in reality, wrong. The purpose of my definition was simply to exclude spiritual elements and include the unconscious. I don't know about you, but I consider MY hand to be part of ME.

I'm glad you mentioned "everybody else's" interpretation, because the very point I'm making is that we all DO know what the pronoun "YOU" refers to: the self.

Again: what is this "self" you keep talking about, and how is it different from my definition ?

You're asking me to prove a negative.

No, I'm asking you to show, if possible, that AA is a secular organization. That is a positive claim, sir.

My opinion, if you will indulge that, is that the whole "doorknob" thing was never more than a bit of facetious hyperbole; in short, a joke. You know, like my crack about the caffeine?

I'd have agreed, if only people didn't jump in to defend that joke.

To be sure, AA isn't science -- but that doesn't make it religion.

Sigh. Nobody said it was.

The point I've been making since very early in the thread (which your time constraints must have prevented you from either reading or grasping)

Is there a reason for your psychological need to use everything I tell you as some sort of personal attack against me ?

is that where "the real stuff" refers to that which can trigger measureable physiological responses (say), that distinction IS quite fuzzy

In your opinion, can people can interact with unreal things ?

and for the puposes of an alcoholic seeking recovery in AA (or a castaway seeking to preserve some modicum of mental and emotional stability in the face of prolonged isolation), unimportant.

Yes, yes. But that's not the point we're discussing. Whether or not it's _useful_ has no bearing on whether it's _real_.
 
The purpose of my definition was simply to exclude spiritual elements and include the unconscious.
It was quite obvious that your definition had a specific purpose. That's why I called it, among other things, "contrived".

I'm asking you to show, if possible, that AA is a secular organization.
Now that is a moving of goalposts. Evidence in the form of passages from AA literature, which have been posted here more times than I'd care to count, establish that AA's stated purpose is a secular one. You rejected that based on the unproven assertion that "AA members as a rule interpret the higher power to be God" (see post #1956) and attempted to place upon me the burden of disproving that assertion.

I don't know about you, but I consider MY hand to be part of ME.
In a trivial sense, one not relevant to this discussion, yes. (In a sense that is relevant to this discussion, I might ask whether you have ever found it useful to not consider your hand to be part of YOU, but to be part of something else instead. Be honest, now).

Again: what is this "self" you keep talking about, and how is it different from my definition ?
You snipped the portion of my post that contains the answer to that question ("the homunculus") and proceeded as if you'd never seen it.

Is there a reason for your psychological need to use everything I tell you as some sort of personal attack against me ?
Is there a reason for your psychological need to attempt to deconstruct my motives? Never mind, I'll answer that one myself. Yes, there is a reason: evolution tended to deselect those protohumans unable to perform this trick. Your sense of self is a simulation largely designed to enhance this ability by allowing you to pretend to be in my shoes. The ability to imagine and to pretend is central to the creativity and flexibility of human thought.

In your opinion, can people can interact with unreal things ?
People can experience interaction with "unreal things", yes. Absolutely. Just as they can perceive patterns which do not actually exist (and for the same reasons). It might not be unreasonable to consider that a perceived pattern does exist -- the question remaining being one of how useful (or how dangerous) it might be when mapped to some external reality. If the mapping is solely to some internal reality, I don't know what basis there would be for evaluating the results of the analogous test other than to defer to the judgement of the person in question.

Whether or not it's _useful_ has no bearing on whether it's _real_.
Bingo. Where internal states are concerned, internal realities are what count.

And yet the evidence supports his conclusion, making it NOT a belief.
I submit that it's a belief either way.
 
It has been claimed that believing in something is better than not believing.
I'd have to regard that as both an oversimplification and an overgeneralization; there are some situations where the need to bring about changes in one's own internal states supercedes the drawbacks inherent in applying certain means to that end.


That maybe true but it hasn't been established that a false belief works better than a belief that is true.
"I am absolutely alone on this small island, and even if I don't die from injury or starvation, the odds are that I will be driven to suicide by the extreme isolation and the certain knowledge that since the outside world will have written me off for dead, there will be no one left to care what happens to me".


But, it is well established that forcing people (atheists) to try and believe in something they know is false will never be of benefit.
I'm trying hard to find some way of seeing that as based on anything but paranoid delusion on your part.


That you think these things are not related to AA's religosity is evidence that you really have no understanding of the issues. If you are only interested in whether or not AA is religious, you could have bowed out of the discussion long ago as that has been proven.
I'm am also interested in the issue of where it is that atheism ceases to be a philosophical stance and begins to be a wedge that drives people apart -- as effectively as does any (other?) form of fundamentalism. I find much of value in the teachings of some religious doctrines, the interesting thing being that while those principles I find of value are not among those I regard as inherently religious in nature (which rest on supernatural claims), I see a fervor in some militant atheists that would appear to lead them to reject these principles out of hand as having been forever tainted by time spent soaking in the poisoned well of religion.

The issue of amends is a case in point. Time and again, AA's ninth step has been here conflated with the religious principle of "seeking absolution from sin", whereas I see the willingess to admit one's wrongdoings and to make restitution to injured parties as needing have nothing to do with anything supernatural. Much effort has been devoted to establishing AA's religiousity by association. I don't think near enough time has been devoted to critical examination of just exactly what it is that makes a given proposition inherently "religious".
 
I'm trying hard to find some way of seeing that as based on anything but paranoid delusion on your part.

I understand that you can't see past the most basic of arguments. The force applied to atheist AA members is simple. they either believe in a higher power of GTFO. Along with all the peer pressure to fit in, that's a lot of force on someone who is already at "rock bottom."

To top it off, when an atheist leaves for that reason, the members don't re-examine the requirement to believe in a non-existent deity, they disparage the person leaving. "They haven't hit rock bottom yet." "Their ego is driving them." They will either be back or die." Etc.

I'm am also interested in the issue of where it is that atheism ceases to be a philosophical stance and begins to be a wedge that drives people apart -- as effectively as does any (other?) form of fundamentalism.

Atheism becomes a wedge when people force their beliefs onto an atheist. Sure, you like to call them "militant" atheists but really we are just everyday people who are tired of listening to your ******** as truth.

I find much of value in the teachings of some religious doctrines,

It's obvious from your posts here.

. . . I see a fervor in some militant atheists

There's that poisoning of the well again. Religtards like to use names people do not apply to themselves though, so once again I am not surprised by your post.

. . . that would appear to lead them to reject these principles out of hand as having been forever tainted by time spent soaking in the poisoned well of religion.

What part of "tired of the BS passed off as truth" didn't you understand?

The issue of amends is a case in point. Time and again, AA's ninth step has been here conflated with the religious principle of "seeking absolution from sin",

Surprise, surprise! They are one and the same.

I don't think near enough time has been devoted to critical examination of just exactly what it is that makes a given proposition inherently "religious".

A thread this long and you don't thing we have spent enough time? :rolleyes:
 
The force applied to atheist AA members is simple. they either believe in a higher power of GTFO.
I notice that the cries for EVIDENCE seem to have a way of falling silent when this sort of assertion is made. You DO recall my having mentioned having been in AA for more than twenty years, right? If, as you imply, "believe or GTFO" were a common practice, doesn't it seem reasonable to expect that I might have seen that happen at least once in all the thousands of meetings I've attended? That I would see a complete absence of members who do not identify themselves as God-believers?

Atheism becomes a wedge when people force their beliefs onto an atheist.
You're doing a great job of illustrating my point. I wonder: do you feel that this "It's always the other guy's fault" approach has served you well in professional and interpersonal relationships in general? You howl about intolerance of your beliefs (real or imagined) on the part of others -- and all the while, your vitriol speaks just as loudly of your own intolerance. No wonder you so staunchly reject the idea that AA is genuinely tolerant of differing beliefs; the very idea appears to be incomprehensible to you.

A thread this long and you don't thing we have spent enough time?
If you had clarified that you were using a defintion of "religious" so broad as to include among fundamentally religious concepts such a simple principle as: admit when you've done wrong, and try to make it right, I could have agreed long ago that by that definition AA is a religious program. You apparently agree with those religious types who claim that because their dogma provides the only possible basis for moral behavior (or, in the case of this example, simple common decency), atheists can be expected to act without morals. Do you really live by that when you're out there in the world, or is it a just persona that comes out during heated internet discussions?
 
It was quite obvious that your definition had a specific purpose. That's why I called it, among other things, "contrived".

So it was vague AND specific ? How convenient for you.

Now that is a moving of goalposts.

You have a serious problem with definitions: nonreligious would be secular.

Evidence in the form of passages from AA literature, which have been posted here more times than I'd care to count, establish that AA's stated purpose is a secular one. You rejected that based on the unproven assertion that "AA members as a rule interpret the higher power to be God" (see post #1956) and attempted to place upon me the burden of disproving that assertion.

Er... no. AA litterature is definitely religious. What REMAINS is for you to present evidence that this litterature does not represent AA in general.

In a trivial sense, one not relevant to this discussion, yes. (In a sense that is relevant to this discussion, I might ask whether you have ever found it useful to not consider your hand to be part of YOU, but to be part of something else instead. Be honest, now).

Same thing for the unconscious, then. Or why would you consider your hand to be part of YOU but not the unconscious part of the brain ?

You snipped the portion of my post that contains the answer to that question ("the homunculus") and proceeded as if you'd never seen it.

Apologies, then. Would you mind summarizing of pointing me to the right post ?

Is there a reason for your psychological need to attempt to deconstruct my motives?

I'm trying to understand why you're doing what you're doing. I was under the impression that understanding stuff was good.

People can experience interaction with "unreal things", yes.

There's still no real interaction there.

Bingo. Where internal states are concerned, internal realities are what count.

I submit that it's a belief either way.

There you go, again, using the Grand Equivocator argument. Everything's the same, and your belief is your reality. How quaint.
 
So it was vague AND specific ?
I used several words in describing your definition itself, but I don't recall "vague" being among them. It was your purpose that I described as "specific". Was it your time constraints that prevented you from working that out on your own?

nonreligious would be secular.
As in: "Our primary purpose is to stay sober and to help other alcoholics to acheive sobriety".

Same thing for the unconscious, then.
My point. Which brings us back to where we were when AlBell first suggested that "the unconscious" might adequately serve as a "higher power" for some.

Or why would you consider your hand to be part of YOU but not the unconscious part of the brain ?
Keeping in mind that being a mental giant is not a requirement for AA membership, what is pertinent here is what the hypothetical AA member might consider. If making his appeals to, say, the ninety percent of his brain that he doesn't use (deferring to popular wisdom on that point) helps him to do things he feels he can't do "on his own", (like staying sober), I don't see how that's anybody's business but his own.


Apologies, then. Would you mind summarizing of pointing me to the right post ?
I'm glad you mentioned "everybody else's" interpretation, because the very point I'm making is that we all DO know what the pronoun "YOU" refers to: the self. That it defaults to a logically flawed proposition (the homunculus) is beside the point; for the purposes of recovery, what counts is how it feels.



I'm trying to understand why you're doing what you're doing. I was under the impression that understanding stuff was good.
I agree, though some types of understanding may have more value than others. Since you and I are unlikely ever to have dealings IRL, if I don't understand what you're doing, I can just shrug that off as one more tiny thing to add to the massive collection of "things I don't understand". But if -- despite having followed to the best of my ability AA's suggestions regarding an ongoing practice of introspection -- I find that I still don't always understand why I do the things I do -- that's not so easy to shrug off.

There's still no real interaction there.
Are you and I engaged in "real" interaction here?

There you go, again, using the Grand Equivocator argument. Everything's the same, and your belief is your reality. How quaint.
I don't know what orifice you pulled the "everything's the same" strawman out of, but I will accept "your belief is your reality" as a fair characterization of the point I've been making. Dubious, perhaps, as a broad philosophical stance, but a reasonable enough description of the way things work for irrational beings struggling to resolve their own inner conflicts so as to better cope with the demands of life in a confusing and often hostile world.
 
I notice that the cries for EVIDENCE seem to have a way of falling silent when this sort of assertion is made. You DO recall my having mentioned having been in AA for more than twenty years, right? If, as you imply, "believe or GTFO" were a common practice, doesn't it seem reasonable to expect that I might have seen that happen at least once in all the thousands of meetings I've attended? That I would see a complete absence of members who do not identify themselves as God-believers?

And that means what? There have been many others who have attended AA who say exactly the opposite of what you say. I have talked to many people in AA and they all say the same thing, "It's his ego talking!" "He hasn't sunk low enough!"

That's BS. The guy just isn't willing to compromise the fact his basic beliefs and there is absolutley no reason he should have to. Belief in God is not a requirement for recovery but it is a requirement to belong to AA.

You're doing a great job of illustrating my point. I wonder: do you feel that this "It's always the other guy's fault" approach has served you well in professional and interpersonal relationships in general? You howl about intolerance of your beliefs (real or imagined) on the part of others -- and all the while, your vitriol speaks just as loudly of your own intolerance. No wonder you so staunchly reject the idea that AA is genuinely tolerant of differing beliefs; the very idea appears to be incomprehensible to you.

No,the difference being, I don't make you change your religious beliefs in order to join a recovery group.

I think people should be able to believe anything they want . . . ALL PEOPLE, not just the ones who believe what I believe. You want to join my karate club, you can believe anything you want but you can't make it a requirement for anyone else. You want to pray, go ahead, but WE don't pray.

If you had clarified that you were using a defintion of "religious" so broad . . .

I have already given the definition I am using and that is the standard dictionary definition. I gave it twice in this thread.

The people who have "adopted" a definition are the people on your side of this argument. They have narrowed the definition to the point of absurdity, to the point that many religions wouldn't even fit, in order to "prove" that AA isn't religious.

Go back, read the dictionary, read the AA literature, look at the meetings, look at the writing of the AA people in this thread. It's a fact. AA is religious.

If you had clarified that you were using a defintion of "religious" so broad as to include among fundamentally religious concepts such a simple principle as: admit when you've done wrong, and try to make it right, I could have agreed long ago that by that definition AA is a religious program.

This is a penny ante technique also used by two bit lawyers to confuse facts. They/you bring up one minor point and make it seem like their/your opponent's entire case is built on it when, in fact, that minor point is just that, a minor point in an overwhelming landslide of evidence.

How about you address the real evidence as found in all the quoted AA literature from the inception of AA right down to now? So far, there has been a complete failure on the pro AA side in this thread to do so.

You apparently agree with those religious types who claim that because their dogma provides the only possible basis for moral behavior (or, in the case of this example, simple common decency), atheists can be expected to act without morals. Do you really live by that when you're out there in the world, or is it a just persona that comes out during heated internet discussions?

Do you live by a the creed of projecting your behaviour onto others or is that just something you do in heated internet discussions?

Now that we have that Tom Foolery out of the way maybe you can address the argument and provide some evidence.

Is AA religious? Yes and the evidence, as I see it, is that AA requires one group to go completley against their beliefs, and that group is atheists. The argument can be made that they also force other religions to go against their beliefs as well, which I also agree with but it is most obvious in regard to atheists.
 
As in: "Our primary purpose is to stay sober and to help other alcoholics to acheive sobriety".

But not as in: “Each Alcoholics Anonymous group ought to be a spiritual entity having but one primary purpose — that of carrying its message to the alcoholic who still suffers.”

Or even in: "Alcoholics Anonymous, which now has 1,700 groups with 70,000 members and influence far beyond its membership, is a spiritual movement, a faith cure for alcoholism. Men and women find that they have been trying to live without God, and then they discover how to live with God." (By Rev. George A. Little, D.D., founder of AA in Canada)

And the point AAers miss is that their denial that a door knob can be a higher power does not help their case, in fact, it proves the case against them. "Can a door knob be a higher power?" is a trick question and AAers fail.
 
I used several words in describing your definition itself, but I don't recall "vague" being among them. It was your purpose that I described as "specific". Was it your time constraints that prevented you from working that out on your own?

And here you go with your games, again. It's hard to take you seriously at all, now.

As in: "Our primary purpose is to stay sober and to help other alcoholics to acheive sobriety".

Yes. Through God.

My point. Which brings us back to where we were when AlBell first suggested that "the unconscious" might adequately serve as a "higher power" for some.

No, it doesn't. A car engine is not a higher power than the car it's in.

I don't see how that's anybody's business but his own.

By that logic teaching anything is useless because ultimately what you believe is your own business. We're discussing whether a thing can be reasonably considered a higher power.

Since you and I are unlikely ever to have dealings IRL, if I don't understand what you're doing, I can just shrug that off as one more tiny thing to add to the massive collection of "things I don't understand". But if -- despite having followed to the best of my ability AA's suggestions regarding an ongoing practice of introspection -- I find that I still don't always understand why I do the things I do -- that's not so easy to shrug off.

That's odd. I don't value our interactions on the internet as somehow "lower" than those in "real" life. Why shouldn't I seek to understand, then ?

Are you and I engaged in "real" interaction here?

Er... yes. Unless you want to engage in solipsism, we both exist and we interact.

I don't know what orifice you pulled the "everything's the same" strawman out of

Oh, I'm just extrapolating that at some point it'll end up that way. You've managed to equivocate and blurr everything that's been said so far so my prediction can't be too far off.
 
You want to join my karate club, you can believe anything you want but you can't make it a requirement for anyone else.
"Tradition Three: The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking."

I have already given the definition I am using and that is the standard dictionary definition.
And I mean to hold you to it. That's going to require differentiating between that which is based on supernatural claims and that which is not.

It's a fact. AA is religious.
The strength of one's arguments is not bolstered by pounding one's fist on the table, qayak.

This is a penny ante technique also used by two bit lawyers to confuse facts. They/you bring up one minor point and make it seem like their/your opponent's entire case is built on it when, in fact, that minor point is just that, a minor point in an overwhelming landslide of evidence.
The standard by which you measure one point of evidence either fairly reflects the standard by which you measure the rest of the evidence -- or it doesn't. In the case of this particular point, it doesn't look good for you either way.

Suppose that floating around somewhere out there in idea-space there were certain ideas that happened to work out pretty well as a set of guidelines for keeping human societies running smoothly: Don't kill each other, don't steal each other's stuff, etc. By and by, along comes this organized system which eventually comes to be called "Christianity", and it subsumes these ideas and presents them (along with some others) as a formalized set of "commandments". Now, I would argue that (aside from the others I mentioned, which are based on purely supernatural claims), people didn't really need to have these ideas spelled out for them. They emerge naturally as consequences of societies comprised of individuals who need to be able to work together cooperatively despite frequently being in competition with each other at the same time. Even some animal societies (examples on request) exhibit systems for rewarding cooperators and punishing defectors. But Christianity begins by claiming original authorship of these ideas, and then goes on to add another layer: the concept of sin.

According to the best picture I've got of how this sin thing works, you can follow every one of those commandments to the letter and you still won't be free of sin, because you're an heir to the original sin of Adam and Eve. The only way clear of that is grace through His only begotten Son bla bla bla and at about this point is where my inability to resolve what I see as some rather glaring logical inconsistencies begins to preclude any possibility there might have ever been of my becoming a Christian.

My point is this: by refusing to differentiate between the original substrate (the pretty good ideas for getting along) and the overlay (the supernatural claims) -- which is what you are doing when you equate "making amends" with seeking "absolution from sin" -- you are not only throwing the baby out with the bathwater; you're also co-signing Christianity's illegitimate claim to those ideas.

If you really are prepared to go that far, I think that raises serious questions about your ability to formulate reasoned judgements on any of this. At that point, you truly have become the flipside of the crazed religious fundie.
 
Suppose that floating around somewhere out there in idea-space there were certain ideas that happened to work out pretty well as a set of guidelines for keeping human societies running smoothly: Don't kill each other, don't steal each other's stuff, etc. By and by, along comes this organized system which eventually comes to be called "Christianity", and it subsumes these ideas and presents them (along with some others) as a formalized set of "commandments". Now, I would argue that (aside from the others I mentioned, which are based on purely supernatural claims), people didn't really need to have these ideas spelled out for them. They emerge naturally as consequences of societies comprised of individuals who need to be able to work together cooperatively despite frequently being in competition with each other at the same time. Even some animal societies (examples on request) exhibit systems for rewarding cooperators and punishing defectors. But Christianity begins by claiming original authorship of these ideas, and then goes on to add another layer: the concept of sin.

According to the best picture I've got of how this sin thing works, you can follow every one of those commandments to the letter and you still won't be free of sin, because you're an heir to the original sin of Adam and Eve. The only way clear of that is grace through His only begotten Son bla bla bla and at about this point is where my inability to resolve what I see as some rather glaring logical inconsistencies begins to preclude any possibility there might have ever been of my becoming a Christian.

My point is this: by refusing to differentiate between the original substrate (the pretty good ideas for getting along) and the overlay (the supernatural claims) -- which is what you are doing when you equate "making amends" with seeking "absolution from sin" -- you are not only throwing the baby out with the bathwater; you're also co-signing Christianity's illegitimate claim to those ideas.

If you really are prepared to go that far, I think that raises serious questions about your ability to formulate reasoned judgements on any of this. At that point, you truly have become the flipside of the crazed religious fundie.

All of which ignores the fact that AA's tenets are based on the Christian concepts of Sin and Absolution.

And you continue to post tradition 3 as if it were a Get Out Of Religion Free card, evidence to the contrary be damned.

GB
 
And here you go with your games, again. It's hard to take you seriously at all, now.
Try reading my posts more carefully and refraining from putting words in my mouth.

A car engine is not a higher power than the car it's in.
You must not have had as many occasions as I have to sit in the driver's seat of a car that refuses to start. Guess the "unconscious mind" won't work for YOU as a "higher power" then.

We're discussing whether a thing can be reasonably considered a higher power.
Being reasonable is not among the qualities for which alcoholics are best known. If it were, they might not struggle so hard to stay sober in the first place.

That's odd. I don't value our interactions on the internet as somehow "lower" than those in "real" life.
Who said anything about "lower"? In some regards, I'd place them higher (at least potentially so).

Er... yes. Unless you want to engage in solipsism, we both exist and we interact.
Yet we have never seen each other's faces or heard each other's voices. We both appear to be equipped with cognitive features that enable us to compensate for these missing elements -- a process which involves some imagination. I find it quite incredible that without the need for any conscious effort on my part, my mind is capable of providing visuals in this sort of situation, just as it does when I'm listening to a voice on the radio (my internal imagery often turns out to be surprisingly inaccurate, and I find it just as interesting that once I know what the person actually does look like, I am completely unable to revert to the made-up version I was using as a sort of temporary dummy variable). If we continue to interact in this way for long enough, we may become so familiar with each other's thinking as to permit us to predict what the other will say next -- or what he would say given some hypothetical parameters. (I see from your post that you agree with this, just as I knew you would).

Of course, you DO see where I'm going with all of this.
 
All of which ignores the fact that AA's tenets are based on the Christian concepts of Sin and Absolution.

And you continue to post tradition 3 as if it were a Get Out Of Religion Free card, evidence to the contrary be damned.
Try pounding your fist on the table vigorously. Maybe that will help to support your assertions.
 
"Tradition Three: The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking."

"Sustain a simple and inviting environment."

That is listed as the third objective of a particular Catholic church so I guess that proves that Catholic church isn't religious. :rolleyes:

And I mean to hold you to it. That's going to require differentiating between that which is based on supernatural claims and that which is not.

No, read the definition again.

The strength of one's arguments is not bolstered by pounding one's fist on the table, qayak.

Or laying on the floor throwing a temper tantrum, Dynamic.

The standard by which you measure one point of evidence either fairly reflects the standard by which you measure the rest of the evidence -- or it doesn't. In the case of this particular point, it doesn't look good for you either way.

Sure, the standard is the same but the meaning of the evidence isn't the same. Your claim that tradition three proves anything is logically unfounded. There are many, many references to (G)od and (H)igher (P)ower in AA which are clearly referring to a deity and you think one line overides all that.

You think that the third tradition overides the second tradition, steps 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 11, 12 and all the references to God in the Big Book and other AA literature. Sorry, you might be that illogical but I ain't buying into that tripe.

But Christianity begins by claiming original authorship of these ideas . . .

This is a hollow argument. We know where Bill and the boys got their ideas on AA and we know what they meant when they wrote it. How? Because they wrote about it. It is very clear that they meant God when they said "God as we know him" and "Higher Power."

They repackaged religious practices in order to pray on alcoholics. Then they lied about the success rates and put a lot of time and energy into getting their view of alcoholism accepted by authorities and their group accepted as the "one true way."

And nothing has changed int eh intervening years except they don't have to wage a war anymore, their zealous minions do it for them.

If you really are prepared to go that far, I think that raises serious questions about your ability to formulate reasoned judgements on any of this. At that point, you truly have become the flipside of the crazed religious fundie.

Well, being a crazed religious fundy you see any disagreement with your religion as being from "crazed religious fundies." That's what crazed religious fundies do.

You never actually argue a point. You pick something that is close and you take it off on a slight tangent until your argument is against something completely different than that of the original point made by the person you are responding to. It used to be annoying but now I recognize it for what it is.

Have you figured out yet why an AA person saying a door knob is not a "Higher Power" shows the religosity of AA? You do realize the original intent of the question was, don't you? That if you accept a door knob is a higher power, you are an idiot and if you say it isn't a higher power ,and yet you still argue that AA is not religious, you are also an idiot. Do you get that?
 
Try reading my posts more carefully and refraining from putting words in my mouth.

You're getting desperate. I didn't put words in your mouth.

You must not have had as many occasions as I have to sit in the driver's seat of a car that refuses to start.

No, I usually keep my car in working order.

Of course, it just shows how unable you are to understand what I'm saying. In fact you said so right here:

You must not have had as many occasions as I have to sit in the driver's seat of a car that refuses to start.

Yes. Not just the engine of the car, but the car itself doesn't start. That should tell you something. Ther car engine is PART of the car. It cannot be greater that the sum of things it belongs to. This is just basic logic and set theory, really.

Being reasonable is not among the qualities for which alcoholics are best known.

Irrelevant to the discussion.

Who said anything about "lower"? In some regards, I'd place them higher (at least potentially so).

Then why ask the question in the first place ?

Of course, you DO see where I'm going with all of this.

No, I don't. If you'd cut to the chase I might, however.
 
You're getting desperate. I didn't put words in your mouth.
You know Belz, the quality of our discourse seems to be suffering from a certain lack of continuity. It's not like it would have taken a search through the whole thread to figure out what I was referring to there; I had explicitly stated in my very last respose to you which word it was that you tried to put in my mouth. If your memory is that short, and your time constraints (or whatever it is) prevent you from using the little arrow buttons to backtrack through at least the last few posts so as to sort out a triviality like that one, what hope is there of you ever being able to grasp a more abstract point I've been making, distributed across a large number of posts over the last weeks?

We may never know. It now looks like I'm about to encounter some time constraints of my own, so if you're genuinely interested in why I asked whether you and I are engaged in "real" interaction here, and if you really don't see how that fits in with a larger point I've been making (one which I see as at the very heart of this thread's topic), then all I can say for now is that those answers are already contained in previous posts. Learn to use the buttons.

Your posts tend to have a certain "drive-by" flavor which suggests that it is not likely you'll bother. It has become increasingly clear that you haven't taken much time to read or consider what I've been saying. I disagree strongly with GB and qayak on a number of points, but their responses show that they are at least capable of showing that curtesy; I might even be able to rely on them to fairly explain to you what I'm getting at (of course, that would also require genuine interest on your part, and that's the very thing I'm seeing as lacking). I'm sure we'll be talking about some of this stuff again, either in this thread or somewhere else (though probably just as unproductively, and maybe just sort of because we can't help ourselves) -- but for now, I'm going to have to give it a break.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom