I notice that the cries for EVIDENCE seem to have a way of falling silent when this sort of assertion is made. You DO recall my having mentioned having been in AA for more than twenty years, right? If, as you imply, "believe or GTFO" were a common practice, doesn't it seem reasonable to expect that I might have seen that happen at least once in all the thousands of meetings I've attended? That I would see a complete absence of members who do not identify themselves as God-believers?
And that means what? There have been many others who have attended AA who say exactly the opposite of what you say. I have talked to many people in AA and they all say the same thing, "It's his ego talking!" "He hasn't sunk low enough!"
That's BS. The guy just isn't willing to compromise the fact his basic beliefs and there is absolutley no reason he should have to. Belief in God is not a requirement for recovery but it is a requirement to belong to AA.
You're doing a great job of illustrating my point. I wonder: do you feel that this "It's always the other guy's fault" approach has served you well in professional and interpersonal relationships in general? You howl about intolerance of your beliefs (real or imagined) on the part of others -- and all the while, your vitriol speaks just as loudly of your own intolerance. No wonder you so staunchly reject the idea that AA is genuinely tolerant of differing beliefs; the very idea appears to be incomprehensible to you.
No,the difference being, I don't make you change your religious beliefs in order to join a recovery group.
I think people should be able to believe anything they want . . .
ALL PEOPLE, not just the ones who believe what I believe. You want to join my karate club, you can believe anything you want but you can't make it a requirement for anyone else. You want to pray, go ahead, but
WE don't pray.
If you had clarified that you were using a defintion of "religious" so broad . . .
I have already given the definition I am using and that is the standard dictionary definition. I gave it twice in this thread.
The people who have "adopted" a definition are the people on your side of this argument. They have narrowed the definition to the point of absurdity, to the point that many religions wouldn't even fit, in order to "prove" that AA isn't religious.
Go back, read the dictionary, read the AA literature, look at the meetings, look at the writing of the AA people in this thread. It's a fact. AA is religious.
If you had clarified that you were using a defintion of "religious" so broad as to include among fundamentally religious concepts such a simple principle as: admit when you've done wrong, and try to make it right, I could have agreed long ago that by that definition AA is a religious program.
This is a penny ante technique also used by two bit lawyers to confuse facts. They/you bring up one minor point and make it seem like their/your opponent's entire case is built on it when, in fact, that minor point is just that, a minor point in an overwhelming landslide of evidence.
How about you address the real evidence as found in all the quoted AA literature from the inception of AA right down to now? So far, there has been a complete failure on the pro AA side in this thread to do so.
You apparently agree with those religious types who claim that because their dogma provides the only possible basis for moral behavior (or, in the case of this example, simple common decency), atheists can be expected to act without morals. Do you really live by that when you're out there in the world, or is it a just persona that comes out during heated internet discussions?
Do you live by a the creed of projecting your behaviour onto others or is that just something you do in heated internet discussions?
Now that we have that Tom Foolery out of the way maybe you can address the argument and provide some evidence.
Is AA religious? Yes and the evidence, as I see it, is that AA requires one group to go completley against their beliefs, and that group is atheists. The argument can be made that they also force other religions to go against their beliefs as well, which I also agree with but it is most obvious in regard to atheists.