What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

You are now manipulative but not honest.

Originally Posted by yrreg

You say:
My point is that it sounds to me like you are answering the question "How do we know God continuously maintains creation?" by saying "Because we, as humans, know that a creator has a responsibility to a creation."
​
It is like this and I hope you can absorb this thought: I am talking in terms of concepts and not in terms of objects, in the world of our thinking and not yet in the world of the actual objective order of existing things like the nose in our face.

So, the idea of a creator embeds the idea of a creator being responsible for His creation, i.e. in the world of thinking -- can you absorb this thought or you do not know the distinction between thinking in our mind and doing and being outside our mind.

You say:
But I know at least one human, the one who listed those four examples of what a creator can do after creating, who does not recognize any such creator responsibility. From my own experience creating things, and from observing others, a creator can do any one of those four things, or many other things, with their creations.
​
Please tell me who is this human being, because you must not take any human being's words as to be authority for yourself, you must do your own seeing and thinking; I like to know the identity of this human being and see whether he has any serious thinking habit, or he is just shooting forth slogans and cliches and imagining himself to be an authority.


Now, dear Rougarou, you just choose one of your four options about God's undertakings and we will exchange thoughts on that one in the realm of thinking -- please don't mess up the world of thinking with the world of objective actual reality of being and doing in the domain of existing things.

I hope you can absorb that distinction and keep it in your conscious mind as you think and write.

Organize your thoughts and keep to one issue at a time.

*This is one option of God that we have at its turn to exchange thoughts with special subtlety -- when we come to it.



Yrreg

​


That person is me. I know from personal experience as a creator and by observing other creators that we cannot assume that creators maintain their creations. In fact, in the vast majority of cases, creations are eventually abandoned by their creators.

You've already chosen one of the options and I've been discussing it with you. You chose that God created the universe and continuously maintains it. Now I'm waiting for you to explain how you know this. The only answer you've given, that we recognize that creators have a responsibility to their creations, does not agree with my experience and observations. Even in cases where we may think a creator SHOULD maintain their creations, we cannot assume that they WILL, because they usually don't.

Edit: Just to be clear, my experience refers both to physical creations as well as to concepts in my mind that have been abandoned rather than continuously maintained.


I get the impression that you are engaged in manipulation of concepts and words but neglecting cognitive completeness, consistency, and honesty.

Before I proceed further, allow me to bring your mind back to your acceptance whereby we concur on the following concepts of God and of the universe.


[ Post from Rougarou, #1564/page32 051212 date 0521 hrs (local time Philippine time 8 hours in advance of Greenwich) ]

[...]

Originally Posted by yrreg

[...]

So, who is going to be first to give his concept of universe and of God, you or I?

Since I am sure God exists I have to present my concept of God, and it is the following:
God is the uncreated creator of the universe.
​

Now, since I also know that the universe exists and I am part of the universe and I exist, my concept of the universe is the following:
The universe is the totality of created existence.
​

Now, please keep in mind that those are my concepts of universe and of God, let me see what you have and we can work on to come to concurrence on our concepts of universe and of God.

​

Again, since they are your terms for making your argument, I will let you define what you mean when you use them.

God: uncreated creator of the universe.
universe: the totality of created existence.
​

Accepting your definitions for the sake of argument*, where does the expedition go from here?

[...]


So, tell me are you a creator like God the uncreated creator of the totality of created existence?


You see, Rougarou, you are not after getting to the facts but after manipulation of concepts and words and a lot of silly thinking just to cater to your own sense of being and acting so smugly, and totally oblivious that there are readers who do see your gimmick immediately and clearly, that you are a manipulator of concepts and words and silly thinking.

Don't engage in that tack, it is not worthy of honest and serious thinking.


So, I say that God is beholden to his creation that is why He is also the maintainer of His creation the universe and mankind.

Are you as a creator like God Who you concur with me is the uncreated creator of the totality of the created universe?

Tell me, what are you trying to prove, that God is not responsible and not beholden and not concerned with His creation, just because you and your ilk claim to create and to not be concerned with your socalled creation?

Forgive me, but don't be silly specially with silly dishonesty.


Now, you will ask me what is my proof that God is continuously maintaining His creation?

The proof is the fact that your nose and the whole universe where you and your nose are parts of is still around, with your nose still attached to your face and you are still around .... <SNIP>

Edited, breach of Rule 0, Rule 12.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar


Dear Rougarou, I 'commend' you for your stubbornness but that is not the right persistence in the search for the facts, honest search that is.

Regrets that I have to use harsh words on you.


Yrreg

*
Some of Prof Dawkins’s contemporaries are not impressed. Dr Daniel Came, a philosophy lecturer and fellow atheist, from Worcester College, Oxford, wrote to him urging him to reconsider his refusal to debate the existence of God with Prof Craig.
In a letter to Prof Dawkins, Dr Came said: “The absence of a debate with the foremost apologist for Christian theism is a glaring omission on your CV and is of course apt to be interpreted as cowardice on your part.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/rel...-for-refusing-to-debate-existence-of-God.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So you're saying we know that God continuously maintains the universe because our noses remain attached to our faces?

In all sincerity, I'm wondering if you're pulling my leg, yrreg. :)
 
Using our human shortcomings to think you're proving a god is stupid.

We are only human and our creations, such as they are, fall apart without maintenance, and often enough even with. What does this have to do with any gods? I think a god worth bothering even to say hello to would be able to make a creation that stands by itself. Any less, and it's a poor excuse for a god.

Of course you have yet to offer any worthwhile claim of a creation in the first place, but apart from that you can offer no positive refutation of my thesis regarding any creation that might have occurred. Human behavior is utterly worthless in any assumption of what a god might or could do.
 
I get the impression that you are engaged in manipulation of concepts and words but neglecting cognitive completeness, consistency, and honesty.

Before I proceed further, allow me to bring your mind back to your acceptance whereby we concur on the following concepts of God and of the universe.

So, tell me are you a creator like God the uncreated creator of the totality of created existence?

You see, Rougarou, you are not after getting to the facts but after manipulation of concepts and words and a lot of silly thinking just to cater to your own sense of being and acting so smugly, and totally oblivious that there are readers who do see your gimmick immediately and clearly, that you are a manipulator of concepts and words and silly thinking.

Don't engage in that tack, it is not worthy of honest and serious thinking.


So, I say that God is beholden to his creation that is why He is also the maintainer of His creation the universe and mankind.

Are you as a creator like God Who you concur with me is the uncreated creator of the totality of the created universe?

Tell me, what are you trying to prove, that God is not responsible and not beholden and not concerned with His creation, just because you and your ilk claim to create and to not be concerned with your socalled creation?

Forgive me, but don't be silly specially with silly dishonesty.


Now, you will ask me what is my proof that God is continuously maintaining His creation?

The proof is the fact that your nose and the whole universe where you and your nose are parts of is still around, with your nose still attached to your face and you are still around -- <SNIP>

Edited by Locknar: 
Moderated content redacted.



Dear Rougarou, I 'commend' you for your stubbornness but that is not the right persistence in the search for the facts, honest search that is.

Regrets that I have to use harsh words on you.


Yrreg

*

wow, that's some full-blown narcissism you've got happening there.

Nothing you've done so far has indicated that you are competent to pass judgement on anybody's logic. This latest bloviation only reinforces the conclusion....
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I get the impression that you are engaged in manipulation of concepts and words but neglecting cognitive completeness, consistency, and honesty.
Before I proceed further, allow me to bring your mind back to your acceptance whereby we concur on the following concepts of God and of the universe.

So, tell me are you a creator like God the uncreated creator of the totality of created existence?

You see, Rougarou, you are not after getting to the facts but after manipulation of concepts and words and a lot of silly thinking just to cater to your own sense of being and acting so smugly, and totally oblivious that there are readers who do see your gimmick immediately and clearly, that you are a manipulator of concepts and words and silly thinking.

Don't engage in that tack, it is not worthy of honest and serious thinking.

So, I say that God is beholden to his creation that is why He is also the maintainer of His creation the universe and mankind.

Are you as a creator like God Who you concur with me is the uncreated creator of the totality of the created universe?

Tell me, what are you trying to prove, that God is not responsible and not beholden and not concerned with His creation, just because you and your ilk claim to create and to not be concerned with your so-called creation?

Forgive me, but don't be silly specially with silly dishonesty.

Now, you will ask me what is my proof that God is continuously maintaining His creation?

The proof is the fact that your nose and the whole universe where you and your nose are parts of is still around, with your nose still attached to your face and you are still around -- <SNIP>

Edited by Locknar: 
Moderated content redacted.


Dear Rougarou, I 'commend' you for your stubbornness but that is not the right persistence in the search for the facts, honest search that is.

Regrets that I have to use harsh words on you.

Yrreg

*


Yrreg:

You are out-of-line. You really need to calm down. Seriously. Most of the post I quoted is abusive and rude (hilighted sections). Such insults and direct personal attacks are against the membership agreement, which is something you should know from personal experience, having been suspended more than once for such behavior. A portion of it is pretty damned close to advocating suicide (hilighted, bolded, italicized and underlined), which is an instant-ban offense.

I know your title says you're "studying hate speech", but this is not the place to practice it. Calm down, before you get banned.

And apologize to Rougarou.

Once you begin behaving in a polite and respectful manner, perhaps we can get back into discussing the failures of your argument, as presented here:

click for link
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You see, Rougarou, you are not after getting to the facts but after manipulation of concepts and words and a lot of silly thinking just to cater to your own sense of being and acting so smugly, and totally oblivious that there are readers who do see your gimmick immediately and clearly, that you are a manipulator of concepts and words and silly thinking.


:id:
 
You missed the fireworks show of his buddhist hate.


Looking at the end of this post, I can see why yrreg objects to Buddhism. It goes against all of yrreg's principles:
[From the Kalama Sutra by Gautama]

01. Do not believe in anything simply because you have heard it long ago.
02. Do not believe in traditions simply because they have been handed down for many generations.
03. Do not believe in anything simply because it is spoken and rumored by many.
04. Do not confirm anything just because it agrees with your scriptures.
05. Do not foolishly make assumptions.
06. Do not abruptly draw conclusions by what you see and hear.
07. Do not be fooled by outward appearances.
08. Do not hold on tightly to any view or idea just because you are comfortable with it.
09. Do not accept as fact anything that you yourself find to be logical.
10. Do not be convinced of anything out of respect and deference to your spiritual teachers.
11. Do not believe in anything merely on the authority of your teachers and elders.


See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalama_Sutta

In short, the Kālāma Sutta is opposed to blind faith, dogmatism and belief spawned from specious reasoning.
 
Last edited:
You see, Rougarou, you are not after getting to the facts but after manipulation of concepts and words and a lot of silly thinking just to cater to your own sense of being and acting so smugly, and totally oblivious that there are readers who do see your gimmick immediately and clearly, that you are a manipulator of concepts and words and silly thinking.

Don't engage in that tack, it is not worthy of honest and serious thinking.


So, I say that God is beholden to his creation that is why He is also the maintainer of His creation the universe and mankind.

Are you as a creator like God Who you concur with me is the uncreated creator of the totality of the created universe?

Tell me, what are you trying to prove, that God is not responsible and not beholden and not concerned with His creation, just because you and your ilk claim to create and to not be concerned with your socalled creation?

Forgive me, but don't be silly specially with silly dishonesty.


Now, you will ask me what is my proof that God is continuously maintaining His creation?

The proof is the fact that your nose and the whole universe where you and your nose are parts of is still around, with your nose still attached to your face and you are still around -- <SNIP>

Edited by Locknar: 
Moderated content redacted.



Dear Rougarou, I 'commend' you for your stubbornness but that is not the right persistence in the search for the facts, honest search that is.

Regrets that I have to use harsh words on you.


This is one of the more egregiously abusive and rude posts you have made in recent times, Yrreg, and quite apart from your rudeness, incivility and personal attacks against Rougarou being against the MA, you have also slipped in a sentence which could be read as advocating suicide, which generally results in a ban. Rougarou has been unfailingly courteous to you, and nobody deserves the sort of invective you have displayed above.

If you cannot post in a civil fashion, don't post at all.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
<idiocy snipped>*

You shouldn't be mad at others for your inability to form a logical argument.

Is your concept of The Flying Spaghetti Monster the same as mine? Do you comprehend that The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe and was destroyed in its making? Since Sunday is your Spaghetti dinner night, you come to the conclusion as all rational people do above the age of 7 that The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe and was destroyed in its making. You use your nose to smell the garlic bread, proving that The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe and was destroyed in its making.

Be sure you acknowledge The Flying Spaghetti Monster before your banning for advocating suicide again.
 
Last edited:
I get the impression that you are engaged in manipulation of concepts and words but neglecting cognitive completeness, consistency, and honesty.

Wow. The above coming from the person who constantly wants to shoehorn words into whatever he sees fit. I'm sure every irony-meter in the world just went up in smoke.

Can there be more dishonesty in so few words?

Greetings,

Chris
 
If this follows the typical yrreG pattern:

1. yrreG has it handed to him
2. yrreG realizes it long after everyone else does
3. yrreG turns tail and flees the thread
4. yrreG licks his wounds and goes into hibernation mode
5. yrreG starts a new thread and never mentions this one again
6. yrreG eventually convinces himself that he won against the evil atheists
7a. yrreG insults people who won't follow the script he uses on 7 year olds <==== You are here
7b. yrreG gets banned
 
7a. yrreG insults people who won't follow the script he uses on 7 year olds <==== You are here
7b. yrreG gets banned

Don't kid yourself. He'll go to ground for a little while and come back to start to start another discussion, having learned nothing.
 
The proof is the fact that your nose and the whole universe where you and your nose are parts of is still around, with your nose still attached to your face and you are still around .... <SNIP>

Edited, breach of Rule 0, Rule 12.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar


Dear Rougarou, I 'commend' you for your stubbornness but that is not the right persistence in the search for the facts, honest search that is.

Regrets that I have to use harsh words on you.


Yrreg

*

Isn't this phase three of the Yrreg Wagon Trail?
 
Could it be that we're the butt of an epically ironic Poe? That would go a long way to explain the word salad.

I don't see Poe's Law as the excuse some do. Whether he's dead serious or is badly trying to make some satirical statement, he's still not acting reasonable.

Being a hipster troll that's trollling "ironically" doesn't make you any less of a troll.
 
Last edited:
...So, I say that God is beholden to his creation that is why He is also the maintainer of His creation the universe and mankind.... Now, you will ask me what is my proof that God is continuously maintaining His creation?

The proof is the fact that your nose and the whole universe where you and your nose are parts of is still around, with your nose still attached to your face and you are still around ....

I'm starting to see yrreG's idea about god.
It's an interesting one- god as a juggler, if you will, maintaining spinning plates on poles.

Why is it necessary to maintain the universe?
Is there some reason to think it can't survive on its own?
 
I'm starting to see yrreG's idea about god.
It's an interesting one- god as a juggler, if you will, maintaining spinning plates on poles.

Why is it necessary to maintain the universe?
Is there some reason to think it can't survive on its own?
The only reason I can see is that Yrreg's god is a very small, human scaled one and he lacks the imagination to conceive of a real god. Yrreg's god is just another Yrreg with magic powers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom