What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I think yrreg may have vanished again.

Could it be yrreG is celebrating Corpus Christi?


No, he's just restricted himself to only visiting on Fridays:
Glad that you are around, I took a leave of absence and now have the idea that I will check in every Friday to see whether you and/or Rougarou are still around, when you two have stopped your exchange of thoughts with me, then I will look up posters who have pm'ed me with the desire to exchange thoughts with me on God's existence.


Not that it makes any difference as far as his contributions to the thread are concerned - we can just look at what he has already posted and imagine him repeating it.
 
Read my message #1783 again if ever you did at all.

I don't understand why you are being so hostile. I've been trying to follow along with an open mind this whole time and yet you just don't seem to be moving forward. I've agreed on your definition of a god in the hope that you would show me what the rest of your argument is.

Please, stop going around in circles and move forward. Is there anything more to this discussion or did you just want a definition for future reference?


Read my message #1783 again if ever you did at all.


I will abstain now from dealing with you, but concentrate on Rougarou.

I am only one poster here you atheists are legion.


I cannot be pulled hither-thither but you atheists are jumping in all directions which is no direction at all.

You have no system at all, read your mentors and see whether they have any system at all either.

And it cannot be otherwise with you guys, since you subscribe to randomness and understand it as chaos, whereas mankind came already with the first dawn of conscious reason that there is cosmos instead of chaos in the universe.


Okay, good-bye Weak Kitten, as I said already I will concentrate on Rougarou.



Yrreg
 
Read my message #1783 again if ever you did at all.


I will abstain now from dealing with you, but concentrate on Rougarou.

I am only one poster here you atheists are legion.


I cannot be pulled hither-thither but you atheists are jumping in all directions which is no direction at all.

You have no system at all, read your mentors and see whether they have any system at all either.

And it cannot be otherwise with you guys, since you subscribe to randomness and understand it as chaos, whereas mankind came already with the first dawn of conscious reason that there is cosmos instead of chaos in the universe.


Okay, good-bye Weak Kitten, as I said already I will concentrate on Rougarou.



Yrreg

Nothing could be further from the truth.

You are not being pulled hither-thither, unless you have redefined that term to mean "in a direction that proves that Yrreg's argument has no merit".

Complaining that the atheists are "legion" is irrelevant to the merit of the argument you put forward.

It is somewhat damning to your logic and rationale to have such a number of people all telling you the same thing over and over again: YOUR. LOGIC. IS. FLAWED.

Dealing with one or many is utterly irrelevant to your case.

Come back when you have something credible to contribute, or have proven that you have actually learned something in the course of this thread.
 
Organize your thoughts and keep to one issue at a time.

Originally Posted by yrreg

Well, there are four options you mention, namely:
(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.*​
And I said that "God does not engage in all these options."

I propose that we take up these options one by one for concurring on them all or not concurring on them all, or concurring/not concurring on some or even just one.


As regards your question:
Are you [ I ] essentially saying that we know God takes responsibility for creation because we all know God takes responsibility for creation?​
I sincerely beg your indulgence, but will you please reword your question?

Perhaps if you just delete this clause, "because we all know God takes responsibility for creation," for it is redundant unless you can explain what exactly is your point.

​

My point is that it sounds to me like you are answering the question "How do we know God continuously maintains creation?" by saying "Because we, as humans, know that a creator has a responsibility to a creation."

But I know at least one human, the one who listed those four examples of what a creator can do after creating, who does not recognize any such creator responsibility. From my own experience creating things, and from observing others, a creator can do any one of those four things, or many other things, with their creations.

In other words, just saying "we all know that's how it is" does not satisfactorily answer the question, as far as I can see.

The one thing we know about creators is that they create. Beyond that, what they do depends on the particular creator, right?


You say:
My point is that it sounds to me like you are answering the question "How do we know God continuously maintains creation?" by saying "Because we, as humans, know that a creator has a responsibility to a creation."
​

It is like this and I hope you can absorb this thought: I am talking in terms of concepts and not in terms of objects, in the world of our thinking and not yet in the world of the actual objective order of existing things like the nose in our face.

So, the idea of a creator embeds the idea of a creator being responsible for His creation, i.e. in the world of thinking -- can you absorb this thought or you do not know the distinction between thinking in our mind and doing and being outside our mind.

You say:
But I know at least one human, the one who listed those four examples of what a creator can do after creating, who does not recognize any such creator responsibility. From my own experience creating things, and from observing others, a creator can do any one of those four things, or many other things, with their creations.
​

Please tell me who is this human being, because you must not take any human being's words as to be authority for yourself, you must do your own seeing and thinking; I like to know the identity of this human being and see whether he has any serious thinking habit, or he is just shooting forth slogans and cliches and imagining himself to be an authority.


Now, dear Rougarou, you just choose one of your four options about God's undertakings and we will exchange thoughts on that one in the realm of thinking -- please don't mess up the world of thinking with the world of objective actual reality of being and doing in the domain of existing things.

I hope you can absorb that distinction and keep it in your conscious mind as you think and write.

Organize your thoughts and keep to one issue at a time.

*This is one option of God that we have at its turn to exchange thoughts with special subtlety -- when we come to it.



Yrreg
 
Please tell me who is this human being, because you must not take any human being's words as to be authority for yourself, you must do your own seeing and thinking; I like to know the identity of this human being and see whether he has any serious thinking habit, or he is just shooting forth slogans and cliches and imagining himself to be an authority.


You do realize that "shooting forth slogans and cliches and imagining himself to be an authority" is all you have to offer, and all you have ever offered, don't you?
 
And it cannot be otherwise with you guys, since you subscribe to randomness and understand it as chaos, whereas mankind came already with the first dawn of conscious reason that there is cosmos instead of chaos in the universe.


You think such idiocy makes sense to anyone else but yourself?

Okay, good-bye Weak Kitten, as I said already I will concentrate on Rougarou.


Yrreg


Translation: I will take my ball and play only with those I choose to play with.

What an arrogant, purposely ignorant approach. You are making even more of a fool of yourself.
 
You say:
My point is that it sounds to me like you are answering the question "How do we know God continuously maintains creation?" by saying "Because we, as humans, know that a creator has a responsibility to a creation."
​

It is like this and I hope you can absorb this thought: I am talking in terms of concepts and not in terms of objects, in the world of our thinking and not yet in the world of the actual objective order of existing things like the nose in our face.

So, the idea of a creator embeds the idea of a creator being responsible for His creation, i.e. in the world of thinking -- can you absorb this thought or you do not know the distinction between thinking in our mind and doing and being outside our mind.

You say:
But I know at least one human, the one who listed those four examples of what a creator can do after creating, who does not recognize any such creator responsibility. From my own experience creating things, and from observing others, a creator can do any one of those four things, or many other things, with their creations.
​

Please tell me who is this human being, because you must not take any human being's words as to be authority for yourself, you must do your own seeing and thinking; I like to know the identity of this human being and see whether he has any serious thinking habit, or he is just shooting forth slogans and cliches and imagining himself to be an authority.


Now, dear Rougarou, you just choose one of your four options about God's undertakings and we will exchange thoughts on that one in the realm of thinking -- please don't mess up the world of thinking with the world of objective actual reality of being and doing in the domain of existing things.

I hope you can absorb that distinction and keep it in your conscious mind as you think and write.

Organize your thoughts and keep to one issue at a time.

*This is one option of God that we have at its turn to exchange thoughts with special subtlety -- when we come to it.



Yrreg

That person is me. I know from personal experience as a creator and by observing other creators that we cannot assume that creators maintain their creations. In fact, in the vast majority of cases, creations are eventually abandoned by their creators.

You've already chosen one of the options and I've been discussing it with you. You chose that God created the universe and continuously maintains it. Now I'm waiting for you to explain how you know this. The only answer you've given, that we recognize that creators have a responsibility to their creations, does not agree with my experience and observations. Even in cases where we may think a creator SHOULD maintain their creations, we cannot assume that they WILL, because they usually don't.

Edit: Just to be clear, my experience refers both to physical creations as well as to concepts in my mind that have been abandoned rather than continuously maintained.
 
Last edited:
...

I am only one poster here you atheists are legion.


I cannot be pulled hither-thither but you atheists are jumping in all directions which is no direction at all. ...And it cannot be otherwise with you guys, since you subscribe to randomness and understand it as chaos, whereas mankind came already with the first dawn of conscious reason that there is cosmos instead of chaos in the universe. ...

You mean, mankind is as old as the cosmos?


...It is like this and I hope you can absorb this thought: I am talking in terms of concepts and not in terms of objects, in the world of our thinking and not yet in the world of the actual objective order of existing things like the nose in our face. ...
:)
 
...

It is like this and I hope you can absorb this thought: I am talking in terms of concepts and not in terms of objects, in the world of our thinking and not yet in the world of the actual objective order of existing things like the nose in our face.

...

If yrreg had the ability to drive the same he has the ability to suddenly change lanes more than once in the middle of a sentence, he'd put Michael Schumacher to shame.

That, and he being the embodiment of the special pleading fallacy.
 
*This is one option of God that we have at its turn to exchange thoughts with special subtlety -- when we come to it.



Yrreg

Another option which you run away from is The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe and was destroyed in its creation.

Why do you run away from that, yrreG? Why are you in such terror of The Flying Spaghetti Monster? Did you get a bad meatball one time? Did someone burn your garlic toast?
 
I am only one poster here you atheists are legion.

But there's a legion of theists in this forum. Nobody comes in your support because of the lack of quality of your argumentation. What evidence have I about this fact? More than what you have offered about your supposed devil god.

It's clear you have to seed an arbitrary notion first in order to build upon that notion without caring to prove any connection with reality. That's why you continuously ask for someone to agree on premises you have carefully "carved" to your convenience in order to move on. Several years, some probation periods, and thousands of posts later, you're still in square one. That's not proof of endurance or Job's patience but evidence of a fly bouncing trying to get through the glass because it cannot behave as if there's something transparent that is up or on the sides and it's not air.
 
Please tell me who is this human being, because you must not take any human being's words as to be authority for yourself, you must do your own seeing and thinking...


You do realize that you just told us not to take any human being's words as authority, and that would include these as well, yes? Yay for self-contradictions!
 
Was I not being polite or understanding enough? I've been trying to follow what you've been say Yrreg but it's been difficult. Do you always brush people aside just because they try to get clarification from you?

Please, a question to the board in general. Have I not been completely polite and tried honestly to understand? Have I not conceded point after point in the hopes of hearing the next part of Yrreg's argument?
 
Absolutely, you have been unfailingly polite and courteous, and you have conceded points arguendo in order to get Yrreg to move on. Unfortunately, he's chosen to treat you with the same arrogant dishonesty which has always characterised his debates here; as soon as his chosen person goes "off" the script he has imagined, he moves on to the next person and back to the beginning of his argument.

He's set himself this Sisyphean task of proving by Socratic methods his particular brand of Catholicism; he doesn't really want replies unless they agree with everything he says. As he's invariably wrong, his fluency in English is poorer than he realises and he isn't actually very good at Socratic debate, that isn't going to happen. Don't take it personally, he'll be back in a few days choosing someone else who he thinks will be at his beck and call.
 
You think such idiocy makes sense to anyone else but yourself?


Translation: I will take my ball and play only with those I choose to play with.

What an arrogant, purposely ignorant approach. You are making even more of a fool of yourself.
Not possible.
 
Was I not being polite or understanding enough? I've been trying to follow what you've been say Yrreg but it's been difficult. Do you always brush people aside just because they try to get clarification from you?

Please, a question to the board in general. Have I not been completely polite and tried honestly to understand? Have I not conceded point after point in the hopes of hearing the next part of Yrreg's argument?
You didn't agree with him. You aksed him questions that he doesn't want (or know how) to answer. That means that you are stupid. That means that he won't talk to you.

Welcome to Yrreg's world. :boggled:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom