What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Hmm, I've been thinking about it for a bit and now I'm confused again. I'm still good with the definition of god as the creator of this universe but I'm not sure how we come to the conclusion of god being uncreated. What if the creator god of our universe is part of another, greater universe that was created by yet another being? This is getting a little confusing.
 
Hmm, I've been thinking about it for a bit and now I'm confused again. I'm still good with the definition of god as the creator of this universe but I'm not sure how we come to the conclusion of god being uncreated. What if the creator god of our universe is part of another, greater universe that was created by yet another being? This is getting a little confusing.
It is confusing and if it's relevant at all it ends up being a deal breaker for ever really knowing god. Imagine that we are of the universe, and we have only the knowledge that "the universe must have been created" as our starting point (I don't start there, but let's assume Yrreg does). The universe cannot, by definition, contain more information than that on any truly extra-universal creator. It's logic or nothing. Even testimony is a stretch. We are left with one of two choices. We cannot really know except through logical inference or hearsay whether the creator was itself created also, and I have seen no evidence of a good argument there. In one sense, it may be irrelevant, since it remains an unanswerable question, and has no real bearing on the universe itself. But in another sense it is supremely relevant, making it impossible ever to say with certainty that there is only one, uncreated god. Turtles all the way down!
 
Last edited:
Organize your thoughts.

Originally Posted by yrreg
God does not engage in all these options:
(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.
​
because that is all how we humans would consider to be against creator's responsibility.

It is like as we humans would call command responsibility.

Only in the present case it is creator's responsibility.

However, man is free to do what he chooses to do even against the creator.

​



Hi, Yrreg. Before I go on, I want to make sure I'm understanding what you're saying here. Are you essentially saying that we know God takes responsibility for creation because we all know God takes responsibility for creation?

--------------------------

Last edited by Rougarou; 27th May 2012 at 05:49 AM. Reason: Gerry to Yrreg​



Well, there are four options you mention, namely:
(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.
​
And I said that "God does not engage in all these options."

I propose that we take up these options one by one for concurring on them all or not concurring on them all, or concurring/not concurring on some or even just one.


As regards your question:
Are you [ I ] essentially saying that we know God takes responsibility for creation because we all know God takes responsibility for creation?
​

I sincerely beg your indulgence, but will you please reword your question?

Perhaps if you just delete this clause, "because we all know God takes responsibility for creation," for it is redundant unless you can explain what exactly is your point.

==========================


Hmm, I've been thinking about it for a bit and now I'm confused again. I'm still good with the definition of god as the creator of this universe but I'm not sure how we come to the conclusion of god being uncreated. What if the creator god of our universe is part of another, greater universe that was created by yet another being? This is getting a little confusing.



Please don't bring in a new confusion on your part.


In your earlier post you brought up the matter of truth, and I am inviting you and me to work to concur on what is truth, suppose you just if I may sound hard stick to our earlier concern:


Originally Posted by Weak Kitten

Originally Posted by yrreg
As regards creation stories where God is destroyed, I submit that is not the correct concept of God: insofar as the Christian faith is concerned in God's fundamental relation to the universe which is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.

​

Um, I'm sorry but my next question is pretty much the same as many others on this forum. That is, "How do you know that the Christian God is the true god?"

There are so many gods worshiped today, and even more that have been worshiped in the past. As an outsider I really have no reason to see one religion as automatically more valid than any other.

Please do not use the religious text of your own religion as evidence. All the other religions do the same thing and I have no way of telling if one is any better than another.​

Well, we have first to come to concurrence on what is truth.

You are the one bringing up the matter of truth, so you must have a concept of what is truth.

Let me see if we can concur on what is truth.


You see, Weak Kitten, atheists are all the time just into beating the bush but never getting to the issue.

We are talking about the existence of God as per the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe, now you have gone into what is truth by asking or accusing me that I have not told how God as the uncreated creator of the universe is the true God.

God is the uncreated creator of the universe, and the universe is the totality of created existence.

Strictly speaking there is no God as a proprietary God or tribal God of Christians; God is God of everything created and everyone created including atheists who are just into blank insistence that there is no God but always beating about the bush.


Glad that you are around, I took a leave of absence and now have the idea that I will check in every Friday to see whether you and/or Rougarou are still around, when you two have stopped your exchange of thoughts with me, then I will look up posters who have pm'ed me with the desire to exchange thoughts with me on God's existence.



Forgive me for being hard on you, but you must first stick to one issue and finish with it before starting another issue.

You brought up truth, so let us talk about truth.

If you don't care to talk about truth, then recall your words:

Weak Kitten said:
Um, I'm sorry but my next question is pretty much the same as many others on this forum. That is, "How do you know that the Christian God is the true god?"



I am not going to be led hither thither by you if that is your intention in order to skip coming to concurring on concepts you bring up.

You want to talk about the true God or god, then you are going into truth: don't bring in concepts/words unless you are disposed to work to concur with your correspondent poster on the same understanding of the concepts/words you bring up -- but please one at a time.

Organize your thoughts.



Yrreg
 
I don't understand why you are being so hostile. I've been trying to follow along with an open mind this whole time and yet you just don't seem to be moving forward. I've agreed on your definition of a god in the hope that you would show me what the rest of your argument is.

Please, stop going around in circles and move forward. Is there anything more to this discussion or did you just want a definition for future reference?
 
Really, Weak Kitten, I think yrreG has been perfectly clear:
...
You want to talk about the true God or god, then you are going into truth: don't bring in concepts/words unless you are disposed to work to concur with your correspondent poster on the same understanding of the concepts/words you bring up -- but please one at a time. ...
 
If that is the case, why aren't the OP's posts held to the same standard? It would certainly make them a lot shorter, and also reduce the length of the thread through self-disqualification of many of his posts....

Or perhaps it's just another way in a long list of ways to avoid admitting to a failed argument.
 
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.​
Yrreg

You're simply telling us what your subject does. That type of definition has been proposed for millennia.
Why won't you tell us what it is?

That's not being exact and specific; please be exact and specific.That is why I am very exasperated in exchange of ideas with you guys, you tend to tergiversate and/or prevaricate and even calumniate, instead of being exact and specific in reacting to the issue.
Yrreg


Irony rating: 8.75
 
Last edited:
(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.

(5) God is a construct of human imagination.
 
I don't understand why you are being so hostile. I've been trying to follow along with an open mind this whole time and yet you just don't seem to be moving forward. I've agreed on your definition of a god in the hope that you would show me what the rest of your argument is.

Please, stop going around in circles and move forward. Is there anything more to this discussion or did you just want a definition for future reference?

It's all about ego masturbation for Gerry. He's been at this for years and he has never moved forward. He just needs someone to condescend to.
 
There is, of course, also option 6 that Weak Kitten (and a big bunch of gnostics and others) has brought up and which as far as I see cannot be well countered: the universe was created, but not by the only or the greatest god.
 
Yep, it could have been The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe and destroyed itself in making it.

yrreG has never been able to counter or disprove that so it frightens him and he runs away from it.
 
Devil does not engage in all these opotions:
(1) Devil created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) Devil created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) Devil created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) Devil created the universe and personally maintains it.

​
because that is all how we humans would consider to be against creator's responsibility.

Devil is beholden to man completely and all the time owing to creator's responsibility
Devil being creator says everything about Devil that man can and does know about Devil.
What's wrong with this definition of Devil: maker of heaven and earth and everything?
You accept my concepts of universe as the totality of created [by Devil] existence and Devil as the uncreated creator of the universe, what is the point I am trying to make now that you concur with me on concepts?

Well, the point I am trying to make is that with the two concepts concurred on then we can go forward on an expedition to search for Devil the uncreated creator of the universe in the universe which is the totality of created [by Devil] existence.

Where do you want to start in the universe to search for Devil?

You will tell me since I am the one concerned with searching Devil and you are just following me, then I will say let us start with ourselves.


But let me now go to what you say about assumption, at the same time as we are now into ourselves in the universe where we have our also created existence: to search for Devil.

You say:
But to answer your question about assumptions, I think that if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator.​
Assumption has two directions: one is into fiction and the other one is into action.

If you assume that horses were wishes then beggars would ride, that is an assumption into fiction.

Now the assumption that there is an uncreated creator of the universe, that is an assumption into action, to launch on an expedition to search for Devil.


Back to our expedition then to search for Devil starting, with your concurrence if I may, with our nose.

Do we find Devil in our nose?

Well, the assumption is that Devil is the uncreated creator of the universe which is the totality of the created by Devil universe: so we should find Devil in the nose, because the nose is a part of the universe, so it follows that Devil the uncreated creator of the created by Him universe must be there keeping it from falling off if we so much as sneeze.

What do you say, are you finding Devil in the nose, in your nose as also in my nose?

Prove these are different of what you said and explain why in detail.

[Do it or you'll burn in heaven :p]
 
Until one shows that a god is needed for an unknown and it can also be defined with real information, it is useless and serves no purpose but to divide people.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Since yrreg is unable to support the existence of the thing he calls god, perhaps he's an atheist, too, and just hasn't figured it out yet. What do you say, yrreg? Since you can't support the existence of any gods, does that make you an atheist?
 
There is, of course, also option 6 that Weak Kitten (and a big bunch of gnostics and others) has brought up and which as far as I see cannot be well countered: the universe was created, but not by the only or the greatest god.

#7 God(s) created the universe accidentally, and is unaware of it?
 
What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

What is right with making an assertion first "There is a god" and then making everything fit it. One should find information first and then find out what fits that evidence no matter where it leads.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Well, there are four options you mention, namely:
(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.
​
And I said that "God does not engage in all these options."

I propose that we take up these options one by one for concurring on them all or not concurring on them all, or concurring/not concurring on some or even just one.


As regards your question:
Are you [ I ] essentially saying that we know God takes responsibility for creation because we all know God takes responsibility for creation?
​

I sincerely beg your indulgence, but will you please reword your question?

Perhaps if you just delete this clause, "because we all know God takes responsibility for creation," for it is redundant unless you can explain what exactly is your point.

My point is that it sounds to me like you are answering the question "How do we know God continuously maintains creation?" by saying "Because we, as humans, know that a creator has a responsibility to a creation."

But I know at least one human, the one who listed those four examples of what a creator can do after creating, who does not recognize any such creator responsibility. From my own experience creating things, and from observing others, a creator can do any one of those four things, or many other things, with their creations.

In other words, just saying "we all know that's how it is" does not satisfactorily answer the question, as far as I can see.

The one thing we know about creators is that they create. Beyond that, what they do depends on the particular creator, right?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom