What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Is there just one ISP that trolls must use, because they all seem to get a terrible service?

Actually, I have had intermittent problems with long times to respond in the last few days (only from the forum). I wonder if one of the threads is getting too long.
 
Well, I have looked for Rougarou and I have not found him here today (in my place it is today June 29, 2012, Friday, local time 0533 hours). I will check here again next Friday or Saturday; my isp is now performing decently.


Yrreg
 
Well, I have looked for Rougarou and I have not found him here today (in my place it is today June 29, 2012, Friday, local time 0533 hours). I will check here again next Friday or Saturday; my isp is now performing decently.


Yrreg

Enjoy your spaghetti dinner tonight!
 
I still want to know what the hell I can do with a god that I can't do with making anything else up that is so useless.

Unless you have people giving you money because you say you have an in with said god.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Over 40 pages :eye-poppi I gather the argument presented throughout is "sky is blue, grass is green therefore godidit"

I personally don't mind if there is a creator or even a group of aliens who got the ball rolling with this universe. They can even be sitting somewhere this moment laughing at our paranoia for all we know. However, that doesn't make any of these monotheistic religions and their teachings valid. I haven't found a point in praising or worshiping a deity that I'm MORE moral than.

This quote about sums it up regarding fundamentalists -

My problem isn't that I don't believe in god, but rather that I think it is impossible to know anything about him. Of all the faiths there have ever been across all of time and all geography, nobody can have any basis for claiming correctness over another, as it just all a self fulfilling reasoning circle. The same reason I have to reject your god is the same reason I have to reject so many other myths. I refuse to succumb to fear and cast aside common sense to believe any unprovable fairy tale that is untouchable by any scientific method.
 
Well, I have looked for Rougarou and I have not found him here today (in my place it is today June 29, 2012, Friday, local time 0533 hours). I will check here again next Friday or Saturday; my isp is now performing decently.


Yrreg


Another of your weekly reminders that you have absolutely nothing of value to add to this discussion.

Not surprising.

Take a few weeks off to think about it--we won't miss you.
 
So, do this exercise: you look at your nose and think why it is still attached to your face and ultimately what is the agent to whom the credit should go for your nose being attached to your face.


This is actually the soul of Yrreg's argument: if one thinks hard enough, one will realize that god exists.

He has never once, in all the years I've been here, unpacked exactly what steps lead to such a conclusion.

I was considering taking up the mantle for him and just arguing his position, but I cannot argue something that was never an argument to begin with: 1) everything in the universe at some point started to exist; 2) thus, the universe at some point started to exist; 3) ???; 4) God.

Even if we reason by analogy and grant that the universe must have been created, all we come up with is a thing with the ability to create the universe. Like a mother spider, that thing could create the universe and then just die from the effort. Like Al Gore and the internet, the thing created could be much larger and more complex than the creator himself. Like the parents of Courtney Love, the creator might have found the creation to be unmanageable.

See everybody in a week.
 
Well, I have looked for Rougarou and I have not found him here today (in my place it is today June 29, 2012, Friday, local time 0533 hours). I will check here again next Friday or Saturday; my isp is now performing decently.


Yrreg
Yeah, Rougarou has nothing better to do but lurk around here until you happen to turn up. That's really credible.
 
You are now into dodging, return to rational discourse.

When you react to a statement by asking a question addressed to the author of that statement, that is dodging.

What you should do is examine the statement and see whether it has any chance at all of being an access to the actual objective reality of existing things.

So, do this exercise: you look at your nose and think why it is still attached to your face and ultimately what is the agent to whom the credit should go for your nose being attached to your face. That is the way men have thought about things in the actual objective reality of existing things and have come to finally the concept of the unique uncreated creator of the created universe.

That is the ultimate agent for the existence of everything you see which is not due to your own making.

Now, you will dodge again by saying that the concept of God as the unique uncreated creator of the created universe is already an assumption about His existence.

So, it is an assumption to you because you have not done any thinking to arrive at the concept from thinking on the things that are present and do not come from your own making.

That is all right for you to consider it an assumption because of your lack of work in the realm of thinking.

To be true to yourself as a thinking entity, you must now examine the concept of the unique uncreated creator of the created universe and see whether such a concept is valid in the first place.

Now you keep yourself busy examining the concept and tell me in my next visit here how the concept appears to your thinking mind to be valid or invalid.

You will ask me what is a valid concept?

See, you are not informed about what is a valid concept.

You have many thinking to do with concepts, what are they, where do they come from, what are the kinds of, and can we do any serious thinking at all without clear concepts, etc.


I will visit this forum again in a week's time.


My internet service provider is doing a very lousy job, I am experiencing very unstable downloading and specially uploading; but if I stubbornly press the reload link continuously eventually some downloading will take place, and if I am more lucky some uploading will take place.


See you next weekend.



Yrreg
So if God wanted to end all the arguments and get all the atheists on his side, all he'd have to do is knock off a bunch of atheists' noses, right? Why has this not happened? Why does everyone's nose stay on?
 
So if God wanted to end all the arguments and get all the atheists on his side, all he'd have to do is knock off a bunch of atheists' noses, right? Why has this not happened? Why does everyone's nose stay on?

"My atheist's got no nose"
"How does he smell?"
"God! Hahahahahahahahaha!"
 
Well, I have looked for Rougarou and I have not found him here today (in my place it is today June 29, 2012, Friday, local time 0533 hours). I will check here again next Friday or Saturday; my isp is now performing decently.
Perhaps you should do some research and find out how online discussion forums work.
 
yrreg, I ask you the question so I can clarify your position before I answer. So, is it your position that we know God continuously maintains the universe because our noses remain attached to our faces?

If your answer is 'yes', I say 'no.' Our bodies are not continuously maintained. Body parts stop working, unless WE or our doctors maintain them. And, eventually, our bodies stop working completely and we die. After only as little as 150 years after we are born, our noses are no longer attached to our faces. That's not what I would call 'continuously maintained.'

If your answer is 'no', then what is your answer?
 
So if God wanted to end all the arguments and get all the atheists on his side, all he'd have to do is knock off a bunch of atheists' noses, right? Why has this not happened? Why does everyone's nose stay on?
.
Dr. Pangloss had the answer.
We have noses so we can have a place for our spectacles to rest on.
Also, legs, so we can wear pants.
 
So if God wanted to end all the arguments and get all the atheists on his side, all he'd have to do is knock off a bunch of atheists' noses, right? Why has this not happened? Why does everyone's nose stay on?


Hey, what about Tim Strawn? His nose was bit off in a fight. Should he be an atheist or a believer? Is this more evidence to support the existence of a god, or less?

TimStrawn.jpg

I know, the Cat Ballou reference is pretty obscure stuff. But come on, his nose was bit off in a fight!
 
Suppose you look at everything and ask yourself where it comes from?

yrreg, I ask you the question so I can clarify your position before I answer. So, is it your position that we know God continuously maintains the universe because our noses remain attached to our faces?

If your answer is 'yes', I say 'no.' Our bodies are not continuously maintained. Body parts stop working, unless WE or our doctors maintain them. And, eventually, our bodies stop working completely and we die. After only as little as 150 years after we are born, our noses are no longer attached to our faces. That's not what I would call 'continuously maintained.'

If your answer is 'no', then what is your answer?



You are tolking about specifically your nose and my nose.

I feel sorry for you that you do not see the bigger and the biggest picture of things existing in the actual objective reality of existing things.


From your nose and my nose and the nose of every living thing that has a nose we see the bigger picture of things like human beings and animals and the moon and the sun and the galaxies and the sub-atomic particles that are kept in existence and in operation, all of them are maintained to exist and to operate, and that is due to God Who is in concept from our experience with everything that stays in existence and that operates, the unique uncreated creator of the created universe.

You have a very dungeoned look at everything in the world because your world is so very much dungeoned by your habit of seeing only your nose and not everything of which the nose is a one of everything.

Suppose you look at everything and ask yourself where it comes from?

That is how mankind has come to the concept of God by his experience with everything that he is surrounded with from yes his nose and the nose of your parents to the distant stars and into the sub-atomic particles.

The concept that there is God Who is the unique uncreated creator of the created universe.

Let me see if you can do any thinking that is worthy of your mind, because the way you think I fear if you have not gone to schools beyond the nursery levels you are not qualified for greater kinds and ways of knowing, of learning.

Do this task, make a list of things you see everyday both made by man and also specially in nature.

If you want to see one nose and then another one and still on and on you count all the noses that you see everyday in your world, that is already enough for you to think about where all the noses come from which you see now and in your immediate environment, and realize that there are more of noses beyond your environment in everything that breathes with a nose.

And like a child you ask yourself where do all the noses ever in the history of the universe or just in our earth and everywhere at least everywhere on earth come from, asking yourself that question is indicative of a mind that can think in terms of big pictures instead of one single only picture of your nose and my nose.

Mankind has asked itself this question and it has come to the concept of God as the unique uncreated creator of the created universe.

And it has written about this God in order that humans who are not sharp as the people who write about God can learn from them.

Just you do that task, make a list of everything in your daily world of living things and also more important of everything, everything at all, made by man but specially most specially coming in nature without human making, and think where they all come from.

We will now go into this question where do things come from, starting with your nose and my nose, then to your parents and my parents, next to all the things in the sky in space and also down into the heart of the atom?



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom