What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

As regards creation stories where God is destroyed, I submit that is not the correct concept of God: insofar as the Christian faith is concerned in God's fundamental relation to the universe which is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.

Yrreg

Um, I'm sorry but my next question is pretty much the same as many others on this forum. That is, "How do you know that the Christian God is the true god?"

There are so many gods worshiped today, and even more that have been worshiped in the past. As an outsider I really have no reason to see one religion as automatically more valid than any other.

Please do not use the religious text of your own religion as evidence. All the other religions do the same thing and I have no way of telling if one is any better than another.
 
Well, we have first to come to concurrence on what is truth.

Originally Posted by yrreg
As regards creation stories where God is destroyed, I submit that is not the correct concept of God: insofar as the Christian faith is concerned in God's fundamental relation to the universe which is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.
​



Um, I'm sorry but my next question is pretty much the same as many others on this forum. That is, "How do you know that the Christian God is the true god?"

There are so many gods worshiped today, and even more that have been worshiped in the past. As an outsider I really have no reason to see one religion as automatically more valid than any other.

Please do not use the religious text of your own religion as evidence. All the other religions do the same thing and I have no way of telling if one is any better than another.


Well, we have first to come to concurrence on what is truth.

You are the one bringing up the matter of truth, so you must have a concept of what is truth.

Let me see if we can concur on what is truth.


You see, Weak Kitten, atheists are all the time just into beating the bush but never getting to the issue.

We are talking about the existence of God as per the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe, now you have gone into what is truth by asking or accusing me that I have not told how God as the uncreated creator of the universe is the true God.

God is the uncreated creator of the universe, and the universe is the totality of created existence.

Strictly speaking there is no God as a proprietary God or tribal God of Christians; God is God of everything created and everyone created including atheists who are just into blank insistence that there is no God but always beating about the bush.


Glad that you are around, I took a leave of absence and now have the idea that I will check in every Friday to see whether you and/or Rougarou are still around, when you two have stopped your exchange of thoughts with me, then I will look up posters who have pm'ed me with the desire to exchange thoughts with me on God's existence.



Yrreg
 
You see, Weak Kitten, atheists are all the time just into beating the bush but never getting to the issue.

The issue is that no god or gods exist, so why should atheists agree with you on a definition of god?
 
Strictly speaking there is no God
You never spoke a truer word, and I suspect you never will again.

Yrreg, you need to show some evidence for this God of yours. You have the burden of proof by positing that God exists, so kindly evidence* this God or accept it is a matter of faith. Faith is by definition a belief without evidence, and can be dismissed equally without evidence.

*Verbing nouns weirds language.
 
Well, we have first to come to concurrence on what is truth.

Gerry's strategy is essentially to robotically repeat "we have first to come to concurrence on what is X" until everyone agrees to his definition of X.
 
Gerry's strategy is essentially to robotically repeat "we have first to come to concurrence on what is X" until everyone agrees to his definition of X.

We will never agree,given the fact that most of us agree that X does not exist. When will Yrreg realize that?
 
Yrreg, do you honestly believe this strategy of yours of refusing to have a discussion with most of the posters in this thread, and not even answering the questions of the two that you arrogantly decided were worthy of your attention is convincing anyone of the merits of your arguments?

What are you trying to accomplish in this thread?
 
Yrreg, do you honestly believe this strategy of yours of refusing to have a discussion with most of the posters in this thread, and not even answering the questions of the two that you arrogantly decided were worthy of your attention is convincing anyone of the merits of your arguments?

What are you trying to accomplish in this thread?

If he's trying to promote atheism then he is doing a grand job.
 
^
Stewed ox-tail, yes!

...Strictly speaking there is no God as a proprietary God or tribal God of Christians; God is God of everything created and everyone created including atheists who are just into blank insistence that there is no God but always beating about the bush. ...

And you know that because?
 
You see, Weak Kitten, atheists are all the time just into beating the bush but never getting to the issue.


Yrreg, you have been beating about the bush without ever getting to the point for 45 pages of this thread.

Are you an atheist?
 
Yrreg, you have been beating about the bush without ever getting to the point for 45 pages of this thread.


... for over 2200 posts... since November of 2005... almost six and a half years. That's some serious time invested into an endeavor which has never showed even a glimmer of success. A rational person would find a new hobby.
 
... for over 2200 posts... since November of 2005... almost six and a half years. That's some serious time invested into an endeavor which has never showed even a glimmer of success. A rational person would find a new hobby.

He doesn't realize that his ''gotchas'' are doomed to failure from the first post.
 
You see, Weak Kitten, atheists are all the time just into beating the bush but never getting to the issue.
Pot%2520meet%2520kettle.gif



Gerry's strategy is essentially to robotically repeat "we have first to come to concurrence on what is X" until everyone agrees to his definition of X.
Jabba is doing something similar in the Shroud thread; it seems to be a believer/wooster thing.

He doesn't realize that his ''gotchas'' are doomed to failure from the first post.
Yep.
 
God does not engage in all these opotions:
(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.

​

because that is all how we humans would consider to be against creator's responsibility.

It is like as we humans would call command responsibility.

Only in the present case it is creator's responsibility.

However, man is free to do what he chooses to do even against the creator.



Yrreg

Hi, Yrreg. Before I go on, I want to make sure I'm understanding what you're saying here. Are you essentially saying that we know God takes responsibility for creation because we all know God takes responsibility for creation?
 
Last edited:
Hi, Yrreg. Before I go on, I want to make sure I'm understanding what you're saying here. Are you essentially saying that we know God takes responsibility for creation because we all know God takes responsibility for creation?


"The good bits are God's responsibility but the bad bits are our fault."

;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom