What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

As regards creation stories where God is destroyed, I submit that is not the correct concept of God: insofar as the Christian faith is concerned in God's fundamental relation to the universe which is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.


So you don't believe that particular myth. What makes the Christian myth any truer?

Your "arguments" are pretty weak and unconvincing. Sorry.
 
You say:
Stating that god is the uncreated creator of the universe really doesn't tell us anything about god. It basically supposes a being who just created this universe and then...what?
​

As a matter of logical implication it tells us everything we as humans can know and thus do know when we do genuine thinking.

If you want to know anything about God which is not connected with his creation of the universe and of man, then you have to be God or have access to the mind and heart of God Himself, which is the same as being God.

As regards creation stories where God is destroyed, I submit that is not the correct concept of God: insofar as the Christian faith is concerned in God's fundamental relation to the universe which is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.

In all those such stories their God is not a genuine God, whatever uncreated entity that destroys their God is the genuine God.



Yrreg

And your point is?
 
You're so adorable in your ignorance of logic. And most everything else. You'd make a great cartoon character.


What I find especially amusing is that it apparently takes him 24 hours to come up with one or two of these responses.
 
You say:
Stating that god is the uncreated creator of the universe really doesn't tell us anything about god. It basically supposes a being who just created this universe and then...what?
​

As a matter of logical implication it tells us everything we as humans can know and thus do know when we do genuine thinking.

If you want to know anything about God which is not connected with his creation of the universe and of man, then you have to be God or have access to the mind and heart of God Himself, which is the same as being God.

As regards creation stories where God is destroyed, I submit that is not the correct concept of God: insofar as the Christian faith is concerned in God's fundamental relation to the universe which is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.

In all those such stories their God is not a genuine God, whatever uncreated entity that destroys their God is the genuine God.



Yrreg
I see you broke out your new turbo tosser for this particular serving of word salad. Can you try again in everyday English?
 
You say:
Stating that god is the uncreated creator of the universe really doesn't tell us anything about god. It basically supposes a being who just created this universe and then...what?
​

As a matter of logical implication it tells us everything we as humans can know and thus do know when we do genuine thinking.


In that case, you cannot possibly know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God". All you can know, according to what you posted here, is that some entity created that universe, but you cannot possibly know that your own concept of God is any more correct than any other concept of god.

According to you, the Flying Spaghetti Monster and the Great Green Arkleseizure are just as correct, as concepts of god, as your own God.
 
As regards creation stories where God is destroyed, I submit that is not the correct concept of God: insofar as the Christian faith is concerned in God's fundamental relation to the universe which is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.

In all those such stories their God is not a genuine God, whatever uncreated entity that destroys their God is the genuine God.


But if (as you also claimed in this post) "god is the creator of the universe" is "everything we as humans can know and thus do know when we do genuine thinking" then, according to you, you cannot possibly know that these creation stories in which the creator is destroyed are not correct. All you can know, according to you, is that god is the creator of the universe. You cannot distinguish between creators of the universe that are destroyed in its creation and creators of the universe that are not destroyed in its creation. And if the "genuine God" is not the creator of the universe but something that destroys the creator of the universe, then your definition of God is wrong.
 
Last edited:
Something that has bothered me about the something from nothing question about god is that considering they posit that God always existed eternally, "he" either created the universe from "him"self or he created the universe from nothing.

If he did not create the universe from himself, and he did not create the universe from nothing, then he had to create the universe from something that also was eternal and without a beginning.

*Which is no different than the Big Bang stemming from an eternal state of some kind.
 
Last edited:
Something that has bothered me about the something from nothing question about god is that either God always existed eternally, so he either created the universe from "him"self or he created the universe from nothing.

If he did not create the universe from himself, and he did not create the universe from nothing, then he had to create the universe from something that also was eternal and without a beginning.


:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
...
 
...As regards creation stories where God is destroyed, I submit that is not the correct concept of God: insofar as the Christian faith is concerned in God's fundamental relation to the universe which is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe. ...

correct=christian
How do you know that?
 
Workshop elves at the North Pole (the Void asked for one for Xmas, and had been very good that eternity).
 
Last edited:
God does not engage in all these opotions:
(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.​

​
Other than your unsupported assertions have you any evidence for these statements?
 
Yes, God continuously maintains the universe, in effect and ultimately.




Yrreg
Ah good old Bishop Berkeley again. If the universe is just an idea in the mind of God you can never declare it real.

I have been away from this thread and must stay away for the most part (bust brain cells and double vision) but cannot completely stay away/

One thing Yrreg has never answered, because he never can without giving up his game, is that <MANY people here have studied what he is contending is new and different, over and over, for years and years, and the conclusions are not automatic. Yrreg, here you wil meet many people who have long and hard thought about your issues, in just thge terms you claim none have, gone over and over the arguments and literature, studied it, and not ended up as catholics like you. It is not nearly as simple or as new as You would have it. This is old, old, old stuff, chewed over by far greater minds than yours. Not even all the Catholic apologists and academics agree. You're presenting yourself as a shallow thinker and a knee-jerk adolescent catechist here. You should know better.
 
Last edited:
Ah good old Bishop Berkeley again. If the universe is just an idea in the mind of God you can never declare it real.

I have been away from this thread and must stay away for the most part (bust brain cells and double vision) but cannot completely stay away/

One thing Yrreg has never answered, because he never can without giving up his game, is that <MANY people here have studied what he is contending is new and different, over and over, for years and years, and the conclusions are not automatic. Yrreg, here you wil meet many people who have long and hard thought about your issues, in just thge terms you claim none have, gone over and over the arguments and literature, studied it, and not ended up as catholics like you. It is not nearly as simple or as new as You would have it. This is old, old, old stuff, chewed over by far greater minds than yours. Not even all the Catholic apologists and academics agree. You're presenting yourself as a shallow thinker and a knee-jerk adolescent catechist here. You should know better.

Any verified and kilted Scot would know it (yrreg's supreme validity)is obvious.
 
Last edited:
I will be back tomorrow, when I hope Rougarou and/or Weak Kitten have replied to my last posts here.


Have a good weekend.

It is now here in my place: Sunday, May 20, 2012, 0714 hours, 8 hours in advance of Greenwich.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom