What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

<snip a whole lot of redundancy>

Or that I am making assumptions in asking myself who puts the nose in our face because I am already assuming that there is someone who does put nose in people's face?
Ah, you appear to be learning that some of your questions contain assumptions inherent in them, which means that you are asking leading questions. It's good that you have learned this.

Suppose you just go and think about the answer to the question who puts the nose in our face, okay?
Okay, I've thought about it, and come to the conclusion that the nose arose through a process of evolution by natural selection.

Or you just go away and keep uttering to yourself that you are not going to be kept wasting your time and thinking power on who put the nose in people's face.
You're not the boss of anyone here, so you really should stop telling people to go away. It is rude.

I agree it would be a waste of time thinking about "who" put the nose on the human face, since the natural process of evolution doesn't require a "who".

In a desperate effort to move the conversation on, just imagine for the moment that I accept your premise that God is the uncaused creator of the Universe. What happens next in your argument?
 
Ah, you appear to be learning that some of your questions contain assumptions inherent in them, which means that you are asking leading questions. It's good that you have learned this.

None of Yrreg's questions would be allowed in a court of law. They would lead to a constant stream of objections and a constant stream of ''sustained'' from the judge.
 
In a desperate effort to move the conversation on, just imagine for the moment that I accept your premise that God is the uncaused creator of the Universe. What happens next in your argument?


"Haha, gotcha!"
 
Last edited:
Rougarou has not reacted to my post addressed to him, so I will return tomorrow morning and see whether he has reacted by then.



Yrreg

Run Away Yrreg, when you decide to stop running away and bravely and honestly face some questions, you will title your post "I will stop running away and answer your questions."

Until you decide to be honest and brave, you may continue to only use logical fallacies.
 
Who are you calling "the ancient thinkers"?
When Genesis says "the heaven and the earth", it means literally, the earth, as in, the dirt you are standing on, and the heaven is what you are constantly taking into your lungs and then expelling.
That was done as described in the book, by persuading the ocean to split and half of it to form the firmament, which contains the atmosphere, while that removal of water from the ocean exposes the land that was already there, but had previously been under the surface.
The Bible does not claim God as having created the universe, or anything else for that matter, but the manipulation of things around Him to be more the way He likes.
As for "the ancient thinkers", they do not believe God created the universe, but something else did. The Ancient Greeks believed it was Anankē, a pre-creation consciousness.


Worth repeating.
 
1: In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.

Created, not assembled. And and the primitive tribesmen who wrote Genesis were not aware that there was a universe.
 
Where do we go from here? Start searching for answers.

Now, one question with people curious is who put the nose in our face.

Do you want to ask that question or you think that question is beneath your capability to think about, or beneath your whatever for example dignity to think about?

Now, you might want to go into what is our capability and our dignity that we should think about the question who puts the nose in our face?

Or that I am making assumptions in asking myself who puts the nose in our face because I am already assuming that there is someone who does put nose in people's face?


Suppose you just go and think about the answer to the question who puts the nose in our face, okay?

Or you just go away and keep uttering to yourself that you are not going to be kept wasting your time and thinking power on who put the nose in people's face.




Yrreg

It's an interesting thought, that the nose was created by someone. But why do you think it had to be specifically created by someone?

Many people on this forum have shown evidence that the nose shaped over time. Just like mountains form over time from volcanoes or geological fault lines.

Could it not be that if there is a creator they were incredible enough that they created not a single nose but rather the complex and amazing process by which noses eventually developed?
 
Of course the nose took time to come about, but someone was in charge.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Where do we go from here? Start searching for answers.

Now, one question with people curious is who put the nose in our face.

Do you want to ask that question or you think that question is beneath your capability to think about, or beneath your whatever for example dignity to think about?

Now, you might want to go into what is our capability and our dignity that we should think about the question who puts the nose in our face?

Or that I am making assumptions in asking myself who puts the nose in our face because I am already assuming that there is someone who does put nose in people's face?


Suppose you just go and think about the answer to the question who puts the nose in our face, okay?

Or you just go away and keep uttering to yourself that you are not going to be kept wasting your time and thinking power on who put the nose in people's face.


​



It's an interesting thought, that the nose was created by someone. But why do you think it had to be specifically created by someone?

Many people on this forum have shown evidence that the nose shaped over time. Just like mountains form over time from volcanoes or geological fault lines.

Could it not be that if there is a creator they were incredible enough that they created not a single nose but rather the complex and amazing process by which noses eventually developed?


Of course the nose took time to come about, but someone was in charge.


You ask me:
Could it not be that if there is a creator they were incredible enough that they created not a single nose but rather the complex and amazing process by which noses eventually developed?​

I agree with you that the creator engaged in the complex and amazing process by which the nose eventually developed.

So, there, we have concurred that the creator exists Who ultimately and completely created our nose by a complex and amazing process.

Now, you realize with wonderment that God exists as creator of the nose.

What about the brain in our head, do you also concur with me that God ultimately and completely also created the brain by a complex and amazing process as He also created the nose?

Can we just agree at this point that man was created by God and also all living things by a complex and amazing process which you are truly in wonderment of, and no discredit to you either that you are in wonderment.

--------------------


Rougarou has not returned so far, and I was asking him in reply to his last post what he understands by assumption, because he says that I have assumptions in stating that the universe is the totality of created [by God] existence.

------------------------


I will check back tomorrow and read what you want to bring up about the creator God and the created universe by which God is proven from the existence of the universe as evidence, now that we have agreed that He created man and all living things by a complex and amazing process.

And also read about Rougarou's concept of what is an assumption when he does return.




Yrreg
 
Of course the nose took time to come about, but someone was in charge.
Bare assertion. Do you have any evidence for your unevidenced claim?

You ask me:
Could it not be that if there is a creator they were incredible enough that they created not a single nose but rather the complex and amazing process by which noses eventually developed?​
No, nobody is going to ask you that. Your problem is that you are so wrong about how a real conversation goes. Does it really work like that with 7 year olds?

I agree with you that the creator engaged in the complex and amazing process by which the nose eventually developed.
I agree with you that prositing a magic man is idiotic.

So, there, we have concurred that the creator exists Who ultimately and completely created our nose by a complex and amazing process.

Now, you realize with wonderment that God exists as creator of the nose.
So there, we agree that no creator is needed. You may now start using science and logic and discover the wonder of the real universe.

<snipped more talking to himself>

And also read about Rougarou's concept of what is an assumption when he does return.




Yrreg

Run Away Yrreg
 
Of course the nose took time to come about, but someone was in charge.

Why do you assume someone was in charge?
When are you going to answer my question about why 'morality' proves the existence of the judeo-christian god?
 
Well, I really do not see religion and science conflicting at this point. If we define god as the being who set up the rules of this universe then there is no real problem there. In fact, it makes science an act of religious piety. After all, what could be more pious than to search for the rules by which god shaped the universe?

Think of the rigid rules which scientists follow in their search, never trusting anything without testing it first. Discarding always the books and words of man in favor of the careful observation of nature which, according to your definition, must be the one true book of god.
 
After all, what could be more pious than to search for the rules by which god shaped the universe?


Very Newtonian.

Think of the rigid rules which scientists follow in their search, never trusting anything without testing it first. Discarding always the books and words of man in favor of the careful observation of nature which, according to your definition, must be the one true book of god.


The trouble is that careful observation of nature provides no actual evidence for the existence of any god.
 
You have two questions the way I read you:

Q1. Where do we go from the concepts of God and the universe which you accept from me [ wherefore we do now have a concurrence on the concepts, good! ].

Q2. You want to know what are my assumptions in saying in our now concurred on concept of the universe, namely, the totality of created existence.


I think we must now first deal with Q2, what are my assumptions in saying that the universe is the totality of created [ by God ] existence.

Now, please don't think that I am being evasive, suppose you tell me what you understand by an assumption.


The road to concurrence on anything at all among humans is a long one and tortuous one, but with sincerity and dedication and with total application as we do have a brain, concurrence will be achieved on everything that does matter to the humans who want answers to questions, like is there a God uncreated creator of the universe?

So, again, to the work of concurrence, what is an assumption, you are the one bringing up that term, or you want to withdraw that term?


I am so glad that I don't have to deal with all posters here but you only for the present, until you also leave me -- and then I will see if someone will be available to take your place.




Yrreg

Hi, yrreg. Actually, I didn't mean for my comments to be taken as questions. I accepted your definitions for the sake of argument and now I'm waiting for you to make whatever point you wanted to make.

The note set off by an asterisk was to make it clear that, although I accept your definition of universe for the sake of this discussion, it is not how I would normally define universe.

But to answer your question about assumptions, I think that if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator.
 
In a desperate effort to move the conversation on, just imagine for the moment that I accept your premise that God is the uncaused creator of the Universe. What happens next in your argument?


"Haha, gotcha!"

You ask me:
Could it not be that if there is a creator they were incredible enough that they created not a single nose but rather the complex and amazing process by which noses eventually developed?​

I agree with you that the creator engaged in the complex and amazing process by which the nose eventually developed.

So, there, we have concurred that the creator exists Who ultimately and completely created our nose by a complex and amazing process.

Now, you realize with wonderment that God exists as creator of the nose.


Near enough.
 
To sig it or not to sig it, that is the question.
Whether 'tis nobler in in the mind to suffer
the slings and arrows of outrageous Yrregular thinking,
Or to take arms against a sea of misunderstandings and redundancies
And by opposing, teach him?
 
Of course the nose took time to come about, but someone was in charge.
You have not demonstrated that this is the case. On the contrary, everything we have learned about the way life evolved on this planet does not support the idea of a creator in charge.

You ask me:
Could it not be that if there is a creator they were incredible enough that they created not a single nose but rather the complex and amazing process by which noses eventually developed?
I don't see anyone asking that except you. You really should not attempt to write the script for your opponents in a debate, it's impolite and demonstrates your lack of understanding.

I agree with you that the creator engaged in the complex and amazing process by which the nose eventually developed.

So, there, we have concurred that the creator exists Who ultimately and completely created our nose by a complex and amazing process.
You are agreeing with yourself; nobody here has concurred with you.

Now, you realize with wonderment that God exists as creator of the nose.

What about the brain in our head, do you also concur with me that God ultimately and completely also created the brain by a complex and amazing process as He also created the nose?

Can we just agree at this point that man was created by God and also all living things by a complex and amazing process which you are truly in wonderment of, and no discredit to you either that you are in wonderment.
No. Because this would be not only an incorrect statement of my position, but also an incorrect statement of most of the people taking part in this thread. The nose and the brain of a human being arose by a well understood process of evolution by natural selection. No creator or entity "in charge" is necessary. Unless and until you demonstrate with evidence that this creator exists (or ever existed), the most parsimonious and simple explanation remains the naturalistic one.

You have not reached agreement, you have assumed that your opponents hold a position that they do not hold. Some people might call that dishonesty.

However, many people have said that they will accept for the sake of argument (this means that they don't agree, but they will pretend to do so in order to advance the conversation) that there is an uncaused creator. Now what? What is the next step in your argument?

<snip a bit directed to Rougarou>

I will check back tomorrow and read what you want to bring up about the creator God and the created universe by which God is proven from the existence of the universe as evidence, now that we have agreed that He created man and all living things by a complex and amazing process.
We have agreed no such thing, other than for the sake of argument in order to move things along to your next step.
 
We have reached concurrence, where do we go from here?

Well, I really do not see religion and science conflicting at this point. If we define god as the being who set up the rules of this universe then there is no real problem there. In fact, it makes science an act of religious piety. After all, what could be more pious than to search for the rules by which god shaped the universe?

Think of the rigid rules which scientists follow in their search, never trusting anything without testing it first. Discarding always the books and words of man in favor of the careful observation of nature which, according to your definition, must be the one true book of god.


In other words, God and science are compatible, understanding God as the uncreated creator of the universe, and the universe as the totality of created existence, and science as the continuous endless search by way of observation and experimentation of everything created in the created universe.


Well, Weak Kitten, we have come to our concurrence.

You will ask where do we go from here?

If you are a scientist you continue to search for knowledge of the whole created universe by observation and experimentation with the certainty that there is order and stability in the universe created by the uncreated God.

Now, I am into thinking about atheists, how they can be so blind and so self-blindered in their brain and heart: so I continue to wonder how they can be so blind and so self-blindered, and to continuously come to the conclusion that it is their peculiar psychology which is self-inured as to be so blind and so self-blindered as to choose to not be rational.


What do we do with God?

Just keep Him in mind.



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom