What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Okay, no more mention of Dawkins, what is your complete and ultimate explanation...

I can see that yrreg noticed the occurrence of the word "Dawkins" in my last post, and took it as an excuse to ignore all the other words in it. So here's that post again, but reworked so that the offending word doesn't appear. Hopefully yrreg can comment on some of my other words:

The ancients came up with gods because they hadn't invented science yet. Once science was invented and people started to be able to make conclusions based on evidence, there was no longer any need to invoke a god as an explanatory principle.

Science has made it possible to be an intellectually fulfilled atheist, by explaining what had previously only been explained through god. Every testable statement religion has made about the universe has, on scientific examination, found to be more or less inaccurate.

God is no longer required as an explanatory principle. Now we have science, which is much more reliable.


Okay, no more mention of Dawkins, what is your complete and ultimate explanation for the universe from science?

God creator: out, not allowed.
Universe created itself?
Univrese has always existed?



Yrreg
 
That is why I keep telling atheists that please take note that evidence is whatever you know leading you to know something else, or more concretely, evidence is any fact you know leading you to know another fact.

It's still wrong, however many times you say it.
 
Of course we cannot know God completely unless we are God, but some things, yes.

We can never define God because we don't know who he is. Jesus said "nobody knows God except me".


Of course we cannot know God completely unless we are God, but some things, yes.

On a lesser matter, I submit we can never know the universe unless we are its creator, but we do know enough to be certain that the nose will not fall off our face when we sneeze.



Yrreg
 
"...since the simultaneous creation of the universe and destruction of the creator..."


Is that a question or a declarative sentence, destruction of God?



Yrreg
Neither. It's an assertion that The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe and was destroyed in its making. The Flying Spaghetti Monster wasn't a god, he just created the universe. Ask yourself why your penis doesn't fall off. If you are into thinking you will see that it is the only answer.

Do you have the correct concept in your mind of The Flying Spaghetti Monster? They Flying Spaghetti Monster always was and nothing created it but it created the universe and was destroyed.

Do you see now why your concept of a fictional Christian god is silly?
 
Of course we cannot know God completely unless we are God, but some things, yes.

On a lesser matter, I submit we can never know the universe unless we are its creator, but we do know enough to be certain that the nose will not fall off our face when we sneeze.



Yrreg

Tell that to Michael Jackson.
 
"...since the simultaneous creation of the universe and destruction of the creator..."


Is that a question or a declarative sentence, destruction of God?


Let us go back to three questions, in regard to the complete and ultimate explanation of the universe:

God creator?
Universe created itself?
Universe has always existed?



Yrreg
It is neither. It is a portion of a declarative sentence. I don't think you're taking care with language here.

But in case you did not comprehend what I meant, I meant that the notion of a self-immolating creator gets rid of a lot of the problems religions have, such as the illogic of a transcendent being interacting with the physical universe, and the moral dilemma of God's tolerance for evil. I don't think it's true, but it's more attractive than many religious doctrines.

But we digress a bit. You still haven't come up with anything new. It's not helping.
 
yrreg said:
Okay, no more mention of Dawkins,
Dawkins.

This isn't a refutation, it's a petulant demand that you be allowed to control the conversation, by ignoring concepts you don't like from an author you can't refute.

Of course we cannot know God completely unless we are God, but some things, yes.
What would those be? How can we know them? How can we prove them?

On a lesser matter, I submit we can never know the universe unless we are its creator
I can know every aspect of a rock despite not being its creator. On the other hand, anyone who's written code can tell you that the mere fact that you made something does not mean that you know it all--the concept of emergent properties renders such simplistic views of knowledge invalid. So, why can't we know the universe without being its creator?

but we do know enough to be certain that the nose will not fall off our face when we sneeze.
Yes, but it has nothing to do with gods.

what is your complete and ultimate explanation for the universe from science?
We don't have one yet. And any honest scientist is more than willing to admit it--after all, if science knew everything, it'd stop. That said, the fact that science doesn't know everything in no way permits you to make up fairy tales to explain the unexplained.

You don't see it? Infinite regress is no explanation because it is still regressing.

When it stops regressing then you have a situation of the buck stops here.
"Infinite" doesn't work that way. "Infinite" means that there's no "stop"--it merely goes on INFINITELY. Let's say I accept that, because the universe exists, it needs a creator. Well, that creator needs a creator. And that one needs a creator. And THAT one needs a creator. And so on, INFINITELY. There's no place for the buck to stop--infinity plus one equals infinity.
 
Please, for the love of your chosen god/s, sit back, think, rest, and maybe get to a doctor. I am also becoming worried about your mental state and deterioration in your writing. It is becoming increasingly more difficult to evn decipher what you are trying to say.
 
I don't think you're taking care with language here.

You don't THINK? I know he's not taking care with language. J.R.R. Tolkien could come to a point in fewer words than Gerry and that's saying something considering he wrote over 1100 pages about a bunch of midgets walking. The only difference is Tolkien would understand the definition of the words he used. And there would be wizards. Though I think Gerry's god might be a wizard so that might be another similarity.
 
Last edited:
You don't see it? Infinite regress is no explanation because it is still regressing.

When it stops regressing then you have a situation of the buck stops here.

...So, do this mental exercise, just lie down in bed so that you are comfortably positioned, and regress with the question who created God and repeat who created God, and see how long you can go on and on and on with that regress, or fore-gress, namely, then God made another God, and then God made another God, and then God made another God.

How long can you reach before you die?

That is the mental trick you can play on yourself, but you are not going to do that trick on and on and on, unless you want to be slave to your perverted logic. ...
Okay, now you go ahead and start the mental exercise of repeating who created God, who created God, or who will have created God, and on and on either backward or forward.

Then when you pass out and die, I will say good riddance, joke only, you are out of here. ..
...I have never engaged in hate speech except in the jaundiced eyes of people who cannot see clearly owing to jaundice. ...

So, it's turtles all the way down, then?
Until the 'buck stops here' at the judeo-christian god?
And you know this because?


EventHorizon said:
... The only difference is Tolkien would understand the definition of the words he used. And there would be wizards. Though I think Gerry's god might be a wizard so that might be another similarity.

YrreG believes the universe was created by an incantation, so that's not a bad argument. Gandalf's origin's ARE cloaked in mystery, after all.
 
yrreg: In order to understand God, you must have a concept of God.
yrreg's straw atheist: Well, I have no concept of God, in that I don't believe in him.
yrreg: Imagine the creator of heaven and earth and everything.
YSA: Well, ok, for argument's sake, I can imagine such a being
yrreg: HAHA! GOTCHA! If you can imagine God, then he exists!!!!!!!!!!111elventyone
YSA: Oh, praise Jesus! Finally I know why I have a nose, and a penis, and I can end all this guiltless masturbation I've been doing!
[YSA exits, but gets run over by a unicorn herd]
 
Yrreg, you posted:
Easy to say I have not answered questions, tell me which ones.


I replied:
All of them.

But here are a couple in particular:

The concept of God with atheists is that they get it all wrong and miss it.

Take this mantra of atheists who always insist that they are against all gods, goddesses, deities, divinities, whatever spaghettis, invisible pink unicorns, celestial teapots, tooth fairies, Santas, sky daddies, they just don't believe them, etc.

That is certainly not to come to the correct concept of God, specially in the Christian faith, namely, God the creator of the universe.


You have provided no evidence that the concept of God in the Christian faith is any more valid than the concepts of any other "gods, goddesses, deities, divinities, whatever spaghettis, invisible pink unicorns, celestial teapots, tooth fairies, Santas, [or] sky daddies". That is the whole point.

How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?

Why should all these other supernatural entities be rejected in favour of your own personal concept of "God"?


You responded:
All of them.

But here are a couple in particular:

[...]


You have provided no evidence that the concept of God in the Christian faith is any more valid than the concepts of any other "gods, goddesses, deities, divinities, whatever spaghettis, invisible pink unicorns, celestial teapots, tooth fairies, Santas, [or] sky daddies". That is the whole point.
Just keep to the concept of God creator of the universe.


The problem is not no evidence but which is needed and how much.

Now, to be thinking folks, atheists whould get together to agree among themselves what is evidence, which kind is required in connection with God creator of the universe, and how much.

Otherwise you can continue to harp on no evidence but remember you can be blind to evidence unless someone more sight-ful and open-minded than you point it out to you.


But my point is that the universe is the evidence of God the creator, its existence points to the creator: you can only deny this fact by stubborn refusal to admit it.



So, as I said already, which is it going to be:

God creator of the universe?
Universe created itself?
Univese has always been around?


And no need to bring in many gods, etc., that is certainly if you can and do think, an irrelevancy.



Yrreg


When you quoted my post, you copied and pasted the quotation from it, but you missed something out. Can you see what it is?

It is the two sentences at the end with question marks at the end of them. You wouldn't be trying to avoid answering them, would you? In case the omission was a result of some sort of confusion on your part, here they are again in bold to make it easier for you to spot them:

How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?

Why should all these other supernatural entities be rejected in favour of your own personal concept of "God"?
 
And notice the close-minded term used by her [Agatha -- last line above], I thought I was the one Minarvia was referring to.

But I think close-minded is accepted for narrow-minded, although close-minded is more than narrow-minded, err, worse.


About 2,730,000 results (0.30 seconds) hits from google for close-minded, used by Agatha.

About 2,380,000 results (0.31 seconds) hits from google for closed-minded, preferred by Minarvia.




Yrreg


Yreeg, do you realise that his post of yours entirely fails to address anything in the post it was replying to?
 
yrreg said:
By the way, how do you get out of the maze that I put slingblade in.

You say, I don't know.

[ You mean, I don't think. ]
How dare you put words into my mouth, and judge me based on what you think or hope I would say. How dare you be so rude and arrogant that you think you can speak for me or anyone else here. I've put up with your insults (and only reported the most egregious ones) on this board for a long time, I have tried to engage you honestly and sincerely despite the fundamental difference in our beliefs, and in return you think you can put words in my mouth and judge me on that? I request an apology for that, Yrreg; you have crossed an important line and it does not reflect well on you at all.


Putting words into other people's mouths is nothing new for yrreg: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=1454229#post1454229
 
Ryokan, you are giving me too much discredit, shame on you.

I have never engaged in hate speech except in the jaundiced eyes of people who cannot see clearly owing to jaundice.

But the rest you had no problems with? Surely you must agree that someone who doesn't believe in evolution, which the Catholic Church and the Pope himself accepts, can't be a liberal Christian.

Now, I am glad that you are neither God nor a fool, because you have changed, for example, you don't anymore style yourself as Resident Buddhist.

I didn't then, and I still don't understand why you put so much weight on custom titles. It's been many years, Yrreg, and I've had many custom titles since then. Some as an attempt to be funny, and some more self describing.

And then you no longer sign yourself at the bottom of your message box, the signature that Yrreg has converted you away from Buddhism.

Maybe I should put it back, along with other select quotes from your past... Like when you claimed to be an atheist. Remember that? :)

Pray, tell me, did you have a fall out with Buddhism?

No.
 
The question I am referring which is time and again brought up by atheists, is namely:

Who created God?

Why is that a non-question?

It is a non-question because the one asking that question does not know about the concept of God as the creator of the universe, for if you are possessed of the correct concept of God as creator of the universe, and you understand universe as the totality of existence aside from God, then there is no need to ask the question of who or what created God, because then it is obvious from a conceptual framework, God is self-existing.
<snippage of much repetitive babble>
This all of nonsense does not even remote answer the question; you are, as usual, attempting to wallpaper over your inability to answer difficult questions with irrelevancies.
 
Since yrreg hides from the question, I'll ask you: A god among how many others? The bible clearly admits to more than one.
Dozens of times in fact.

You have got it wrong again, the universe did not come from nothing.

It came from God's will.
Evidence?
How did God create the universe out of nothing pre-existing except God's will.
Evidence?
If you think about it, truly think and not engage in maneuvering out of the issue, there is a necessary being origin of everything and He did not have to depend on another being or use pre-existing things not already coming from Himself.
Evidence?
That is the complete and ultimate explanation for the universe that is not God Himself.
Evidence?


No it doesn't. The Bible clearly admits that people worshipped more than one god; it never verifies that those gods are real, and in fact says that they are manufactured by human hands in contrast to "the living God".
Nope.
Again, the Bible acknowledged that other gods were worshipped - but named them as man-made; as false.
Nope.
"And against all the gods of Egypt I will execute judgment."
"For the LORD your God is God of gods, and Lord of lords."
"Wilt not thou possess that which Chemosh thy god giveth thee to possess?"
"The gods that have not made the heavens and the earth, even they shall perish from the earth, and from under these heavens. "

I will commend you for your post, but it is all you say but no explanation.

Now, tell me what is your complete and ultimate explanation for the existence of the universe.
Several other explanations for the existence of the universe were propose, by me among others, in your previous threads. You refused to address them.

I am around. I am always around.
Good to see you've got the omniscience working. :)

Okay, no more mention of Dawkins, what is your complete and ultimate explanation for the universe from science?

God creator: out, not allowed.
Universe created itself?
Univrese has always existed?
Again, several other explanations for the existence of the universe were propose, by me among others, in your previous threads. You refused to address them.

But the rest you had no problems with? Surely you must agree that someone who doesn't believe in evolution, which the Catholic Church and the Pope himself accepts, can't be a liberal Christian.
Like most god botherers he accepts the bits that suit him.
 
And notice the close-minded term used by her [Agatha -- last line above], I thought I was the one Minarvia was referring to.

But I think close-minded is accepted for narrow-minded, although close-minded is more than narrow-minded, err, worse.


About 2,730,000 results (0.30 seconds) hits from google for close-minded, used by Agatha.

About 2,380,000 results (0.31 seconds) hits from google for closed-minded, preferred by Minarvia.

Closed-minded is what I meant; it was a typo which I did not catch at the time of submitting the post.

Google is not a metric of the correct usage of a phrase, merely an estimation of how many web pages contain that phrase. In itself, a google search tells you nothing of the author's intent nor of the preferred style in English writing.

Having said that, despite quoting portions of my post twice and the whole thing once, you have failed to address or respond in a substantive way to any of my points, nor have you had the courtesy or good manners to apologise for misrepresenting my views and putting words into my mouth.

This thread is now on its 35th page and since it started in early 2009 you have failed to move past your insistence that everyone should accept your concept of God. Several people have agreed, for the sake of argument and to move the discussion forward, that they will agree with your concept of God (while continuing to deny God's existence) and we are now waiting for you to move to whatever the next stage of your argument entails.

You appear to be trying, without success, to persuade atheists with the Kalām cosmological argumentWP, and it really is time you moved to a more persuasive argument, should you have one. This is a sceptics' site, what will be persuasive here is evidence. If you have any, now is the time to present it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom