What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Yrreg,
I again have to express concern about your well being. In the past your posts were well crafted and written well, I again hope that you are well. They now seem to lack many of the qualities you displayed in the past.
 
Nope.
Again, the Bible acknowledged that other gods were worshipped - but named them as man-made; as false.

I need help with this, AvalonXO -

Astroloth - Judges 2:13, Samuel 7:3-4

Baal - 2 Samuel 2:8; 1 Kings 17:1, 18:17-19; 2 Kings 1:2-5; Jeremiah 9:13-16; Hoseah2:2-13, 14-22

Baal-zebul - 2 Kings 1:2-5

Bel - Isaiah 46:1-4 (also in apochraphal chapters removed from Daniel)

Beelzebul - Mark 3:22

Chemosh - Numbers 21:29, Judges 11:24

"Day Star" and Dawn - Isaiah 14:12-15

Hadad-rimmon - Zechariah 12:11

Ishtar - Jeremiah 44:15-28

Marduk - Jeremiah 50:2-3

Milkom - 2 Samuel 12:30

Nabu - Isaiah 46:1-4

Sakkuth and Kaiwan - Amos 5:26

Tammuz - Isaiah 17:9-11; Ezekiel 8:14-18; Daniel 11:36-39


are all in the bible. Where are they named specifically as false? I'm not being sarcastic, I just want my research to be correct. I'm sure that of course the new religion trying to take over would indeed claim that every other god is false - that is not surprising. I just don't know WHERE they are claimed as false.
 
Just give a brief but pithy account of your link, if you are serious.



Yrreg

Give a brief but logical explanation for where your god(s) came from. If your post contains logic, you may title it, "This post contains logic." Otherwise, you may not.
 
You are amenanble that the nothing scientists are charlatans.

[...]

Yrreg said:
However, I suggest you read the atheist scientists socalled who have a nice explanation, namely, nothing is the origin of everything, but read more insight-fully, and see how they understand nothing.

Scientists, atheist or otherwise, do not contend that the Universe came from nothing. They contend that immediately after the big bang there was a massive expansion from a singularity (at least, that is my understanding, and I welcome scientific correction on this). Please do not misrepresent science, do some research and find out what is the current understanding of the origins of the universe.

[...]



You are amenanble that the nothing scientists are charlatans.

Here, read the words from established newspapers, just two only, but the general thought about scientists being charlatans is obvious, and that is my point, they use the word nothing but it is in fact something.

The Grand Design [Hawking], an extract of which appears in the Times today, sets out to contest Sir Isaac Newton's belief that the universe must have been designed by God as it could not have been created out of chaos.
"Because there is a law such as gravity, the universe can and will create itself from nothing," he writes. "Spontaneous creation is the reason there is something rather than nothing, why the universe exists, why we exist.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2010/sep/02/stephen-hawking-big-bang-creator

-------------------

The point of the book [A Universe From Nothing], Dr. Krauss, a self-described nonbeliever, writes at the outset, is not to try to make people lose their faith, but to illuminate how modern science has changed the meaning of nothingness from a vague philosophical concept to something we can almost put under a lab microscope. […] Dr. Krauss delineates three different kinds of nothingness.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/21/s...xplain-a-universe-springing-from-nothing.html

​

Okay, guys, choose your kinds of nothing, courtesy of the nothing scientists.


Agatha, I like to exchange thoughts with you on what the nothing scientists understand by nothing, and that they are charlatans, for why use the word nothing and all the time they understand it to mean not nothing but something? Except that they are into word sleight of hand.



So, they the nothing scientists make atheists very happy in their atheists' psychology, but when I point out to them that it is not really nothing but something, atheists will call back, penis.



Yrreg
 
I need help with this, AvalonXO -

Astroloth - Judges 2:13, Samuel 7:3-4

Baal - 2 Samuel 2:8; 1 Kings 17:1, 18:17-19; 2 Kings 1:2-5; Jeremiah 9:13-16; Hoseah2:2-13, 14-22

Baal-zebul - 2 Kings 1:2-5

Bel - Isaiah 46:1-4 (also in apochraphal chapters removed from Daniel)

Beelzebul - Mark 3:22

Chemosh - Numbers 21:29, Judges 11:24

"Day Star" and Dawn - Isaiah 14:12-15

Hadad-rimmon - Zechariah 12:11

Ishtar - Jeremiah 44:15-28

Marduk - Jeremiah 50:2-3

Milkom - 2 Samuel 12:30

Nabu - Isaiah 46:1-4

Sakkuth and Kaiwan - Amos 5:26

Tammuz - Isaiah 17:9-11; Ezekiel 8:14-18; Daniel 11:36-39


are all in the bible. Where are they named specifically as false? I'm not being sarcastic, I just want my research to be correct. I'm sure that of course the new religion trying to take over would indeed claim that every other god is false - that is not surprising. I just don't know WHERE they are claimed as false.


Don't forget Psalm 82:1, "God standeth in the congregation of the mighty; he judgeth among the gods."
 
You have got it wrong again, the universe did not come from nothing.

It came from God's will.

How did God create the universe out of nothing pre-existing except God's will.

This is one instance that you have to be God to know how.


Now, let us talk about what it is to explain something completely and ultimately.

If you think about it, truly think and not engage in maneuvering out of the issue, there is a necessary being origin of everything and He did not have to depend on another being or use pre-existing things not already coming from Himself.

That is the complete and ultimate explanation for the universe that is not God Himself.
Okay, you don't want to accept the existence of God the necessary being origin of everything that is not God Himself.


As per routine you will seek to cover yourself under the cloak of false humility, I don't know.

Well, if you don't know, then you can excuse yourself and just engage in denying or not admitting that people who know the existence of a necessary being origin of everything that is not Himself, they know.

But why engage in denying, just go away and have a life without ever knowing the origin of everything that has a beginning in the necessary being.

And say to yourself again and again just in case the question does bug you, I don't know; better join other things in the universe who don't have that question sneaking into their minds because they can't have that question emerging in their brain for it is not designed to have such a question arise in it.

Now, if you insist that there are other beings who agree with you, though not human like you and me, let them come forward and join this discussion.


But some people have come to the idea that they can participate here by reciting their mantra, I don accept God, I don't accept God, I don't accept, on and on and on, by which they think that they are being so smart about such a tack.




Yrreg

No, it is not an explanation. It's an assertion. It is a confession that you know nothing about how it was done, and it remains a mystery. The only difference here between you and an atheist is that you can say "you have to be God to know how" and thereby sanction your ignorance as divinely ordained, rather than facing it as a challenge to further thought.
 
From Yyreg - And say to yourself again and again just in case the question does bug you, I don't know; better join other things in the universe who don't have that question sneaking into their minds because they can't have that question emerging in their brain for it is not designed to have such a question arise in it.


What???
 
Shame, you people don't get God correctly, but also don't read correctly.

Just wondering, shouldn't it be "closed-minded" beliefs, instead of "close-minded?" No offense!

[Don't know really whose post you are referring to above.]

But Gerry saying you are but a "humble brain..." made me choke on my Diet Coke. Damn you Gerry, or Yergg...or whoever you are!

Now, as for -

What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

How about asking, "What's wrong with heaven and earth and everything?"
That could likely go on forever, and as long as this thread already is, I'd bet THAT one would go on even longer.


I am not talking about myself in regard to humble brain, but to atheists like Agatha who claim to not know the complete and ultimate explanation for the universe, because they do not know, and science has not yet come to the assistance to explain how the universe came about.

Read my post again.

Yrreg said:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8258264&postcount=1265


[Title of post] You are into the fallacy of ignorance, claiming ignorance is not thinking.
Agatha said:
Yrreg, your God does not exist. It's a story, made up by primitive peoples with a limited understanding of the universe and how it came to be.

We also have a limited understanding of the universe and how it came to be, albeit a far greater understanding than people thousands of years ago, but instead of making up a story, we're content to say "we don't know yet, we'll try to find out".

The source of your misunderstanding is revealed by your question above where you ask what atheists have in substitute for God. We've been telling you for years, we don't have anything as a substitute for God.

Until you understand this very basic and vital point, your monologues here (for your posts are not dialogue; you rarely discuss anything but merely restate your argument with increasing rudeness until you get carded) are pointless exercises.


[Agatha] You are into the fallacy of ignorance, claiming ignorance is not thinking.

However, I suggest you read the atheist scientists socalled who have a nice explanation, namely, nothing is the origin of everything, but read more insight-fully, and see how they understand nothing.

You see, your insistence that you don't know the complete and ultimate explanation of existence, is just that, stubbornness to not think; but you forget to mention that you must be humble and not be so presumptuous [mocking exhortation to humility] as to employ your brain to think on for a sensible answer to the question of the complete and ultimate explanation for existence.

You have gone into the fallacy of ignorance, but you have forgotten to accompany it with the fallacy of appeal to your humility [mocking exhortation to humility], that should win you the atheists' Nobel Prize for ignorance and humility.


I am having or attempting to engage in a thinking-ful dialog with people here, but if they don't want to think instead of shouting penis, etc., then claim that I am into a monologue, what can I do but continue to explain my ideas and hope to engage someone who will really genuinely relevantly think on my ideas, and engage me with their thoughts.

By the way, how do you get out of the maze that I put slingblade in.

You say, I don't know.

[ You mean, I don't think. ]


Shame, you are again into the plea of ignorance but you should say also that you are just a very humble brain [mocking exhortation to humility].


About my own brain, I prescind from humility or arrogance, but I seek to delve into the complete and ultimate explanation for the universe.


Please read correctly, Minarvia.


You people don't get the correct information of the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

Again, shame: if you also don't have the habit of reading correctly.




Yrreg
 
Thanks, jsfisher, Psalm 82:1!

As with many things in the Bible, there are contradictions both as to the number of gods and to whether some or all but one are false. I'd suggest that even "false" gets confused, since in context it can mean either man-made or not-supreme.
 
About my own brain, I prescind from humility or arrogance, but I seek to delve into the complete and ultimate explanation for the universe.


No, you don't. You don't delve or question at all. All you do is just say, "God did it."

That is useless and an utter evasion.
 
Last edited:
Ah, here is the humility of Agatha in all its brilliance, but no need, just think!

Originally Posted by yrreg
You are into the fallacy of ignorance, claiming ignorance is not thinking.
No, I would claim that ignorance is not learning.

Originally Posted by yrreg
However, I suggest you read the atheist scientists socalled who have a nice explanation, namely, nothing is the origin of everything, but read more insight-fully, and see how they understand nothing.
Scientists, atheist or otherwise, do not contend that the Universe came from nothing. They contend that immediately after the big bang there was a massive expansion from a singularity (at least, that is my understanding, and I welcome scientific correction on this). Please do not misrepresent science, do some research and find out what is the current understanding of the origins of the universe.

Originally Posted by yrreg
You see, your insistence that you don't know the complete and ultimate explanation of existence, is just that, stubbornness to not think; but you forget to mention that you must be humble and not be so presumptuous as to employ your brain to think on for a sensible answer to the question of the complete and ultimate explanation for existence.
On the contrary, admitting that one doesn't know the answer is humility. Arrogance is pretending that you know answers where no true, evidenced answer is yet possible. Stubbornness is persisting in beliefs without evidence. Which one of us has the humilty to understand that the human race does not have all the answers, Yrreg, you or me? Which one of us is being arrogant and stubborn and insisting that he knows things without evidence?

Originally Posted by yrreg
You have gone into the fallacy of ignorance, but you have forgotten to accompany it with the fallacy of appeal to your humility, that should win you the atheists' Nobel Prize for ignorance and humility.
You are wrong, and unnecessarily insulting. Kindly refrain from insulting people here, it's against the rules and damages your argument.

Originally Posted by yrreg
I am having or attempting to engage in a thinking-ful dialog with people here, but if they don't want to think instead of shouting penis, etc., then claim that I am into a monologue, what can I do but continue to explain my ideas and hope to engage someone who will really genuinely relevantly think on my ideas, and engage me with their thoughts.
One thing you are not doing is dialogue here. There are more atheists than theists, but you choose to come here to post your ideas, nobody forces you to do so. The problem is, as it has been on countless forums and discussion boards over the last few years, that you do not do your part in reading and responding to what people are actually saying. Your idea of a dialogue is where you post your ideas and everyone else thinks about them, but that is a monologue. To be a dialogue you have to also listen to the responses you get and think about them. Until you do that, which will entail a good deal less repetition and a great deal more honesty, your threads will be a monologue from you.

Other people try honestly and sincerely to engage you, they try to explain what they mean by using analogies which you seem to wilfully misunderstand, and after a while they give up trying to engage you in dialogue and make jokes instead. If you improved your posting style, this would not happen. If you listened and really thought about what people are saying, you would understand why people bring up the Flying Spaghetti Monster. You would not dismiss them as just shouting "spaghetti", because that is not what it's about. It's an analogy, intended to show people that just as there is no evidence for the existence of the FSM, so there is equally no evidence for your God.

If you started to use the brain that you claim God gave you, you should be able to understand the workings of an analogy. If your English comprehension isn't up to understanding analogies/metaphors/similes, just explain that your English isn't sufficient and people will simplify the language of their arguments accordingly.

Originally Posted by yrreg
By the way, how do you get out of the maze that I put slingblade in.

You say, I don't know.

[ You mean, I don't think. ]
How dare you put words into my mouth, and judge me based on what you think or hope I would say. How dare you be so rude and arrogant that you think you can speak for me or anyone else here. I've put up with your insults (and only reported the most egregious ones) on this board for a long time, I have tried to engage you honestly and sincerely despite the fundamental difference in our beliefs, and in return you think you can put words in my mouth and judge me on that? I request an apology for that, Yrreg; you have crossed an important line and it does not reflect well on you at all.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Shame, you are again into the plea of ignorance but you should say also that you are just a very humble brain.
Humility is a good thing; it drives us to find out more. You should try a little Christian humility sometime, instead of arrogantly crowing about your unsupported, unevidenced close-minded beliefs.


And notice the close-minded term used by her [Agatha -- last line above], I thought I was the one Minarvia was referring to.

But I think close-minded is accepted for narrow-minded, although close-minded is more than narrow-minded, err, worse.


About 2,730,000 results (0.30 seconds) hits from google for close-minded, used by Agatha.

About 2,380,000 results (0.31 seconds) hits from google for closed-minded, preferred by Minarvia.




Yrreg
 
Hope you will forgive me, but please refer me to your posts at least one.

Yrreg,

You are far too selective in your posts. You have ignored mine, and I sincerely wish to see your responses to them. Would you please reconsider?


Hope you will forgive me, but please refer me to your posts at least one.



Yrreg
 
About my own brain, I prescind from humility or arrogance, but I seek to delve into the complete and ultimate explanation for the universe.


Please read correctly, Minarvia.


You people don't get the correct information of the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

Again, shame: if you also don't have the habit of reading correctly.




Yrreg

I read correctly and I wasn't talking about you. You do write strangely, tho, and are difficult to understand.

What the heck does Google hits have to do with anything? Just because tons of people say, "I could care less" when they mean, "I couldn't care less" doesn't make them correct. Is that what you mean? Like so many who do not correctly use "you're" "your" properly makes them correct if lots of people do that?

*shakes head*

I don't understand you. Numbers of mis-use does not prove that it is correct.

If that's even what you mean? :confused:
 
As with many things in the Bible, there are contradictions both as to the number of gods and to whether some or all but one are false. I'd suggest that even "false" gets confused, since in context it can mean either man-made or not-supreme.


There are definitional questions, too. Are angels gods? In their role as messengers, they're equivalent to Hermes and Iris from the Greek pantheon, whom the Greeks call "gods"; Christians, "angels". If I were a bible apologist, I'd be tempted to fob off any excess gods as uppity angels.
 
Last edited:
You don't see it? Infinite regress is no explanation because it is still regressing.

^
Yes and no.
I've had a good time researching infinite regress, actually.
But I'm puzzled as to why yrreG thinks that concept bolsters his case for the judio-christian creator god.


You don't see it? Infinite regress is no explanation because it is still regressing.

When it stops regressing then you have a situation of the buck stops here.


But of course you don't see that, because you are not running all the way in your mind to the end of the socalled infinite regress.

Tell you what, your mind is really very versatile, but if you don't use it correctly you will be enslaved in infinite regress and infinite fore-gress: that if you were an engineer who have to get down to reality and start building, your client will throw you out and get another one whose feet are planted on planet earth or the actual objective reality of existing things, where there is no such thing as an infinite regress and no infinite fore-gress.


So, do this mental exercise, just lie down in bed so that you are comfortably positioned, and regress with the question who created God and repeat who created God, and see how long you can go on and on and on with that regress, or fore-gress, namely, then God made another God, and then God made another God, and then God made another God.

How long can you reach before you die?

That is the mental trick you can play on yourself, but you are not going to do that trick on and on and on, unless you want to be slave to your perverted logic.

The same with mathematics, it can be perverted so that you will never come to anything useful except a lot of useless thinking that will make you question the existence of God, but remember you can also use mathematics to build things in the actual objective reality of existing things, that's where mathematics is genuinely useful to mankind -- instead of abusing it to build up all kinds of bizarre mental constructs.


Okay, now you go ahead and start the mental exercise of repeating who created God, who created God, or who will have created God, and on and on either backward or forward.

Then when you pass out and die, I will say good riddance, joke only, you are out of here.



Yrreg
 
Is that a question or a declarative sentence, destruction of God?

The basic question, I presume, is, why does not RoboTimbo's theory work for you? It is, of course, nonsensical, yet it resembles your own theory (at least as far as you've been able to articulate it) in all details except nomenclature. Actually, it answers somewhat better, since the simultaneous creation of the universe and destruction of the creator solve many other vexing issues of how a god might interact with his creation. If you cannot do any better than RoboTimbo's jocular post, you have a big problem.


"...since the simultaneous creation of the universe and destruction of the creator..."


Is that a question or a declarative sentence, destruction of God?


Let us go back to three questions, in regard to the complete and ultimate explanation of the universe:

God creator?
Universe created itself?
Universe has always existed?



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom