What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Yrreg, pray answer the simplest questions, such as one of mine. I KNOW what created the Universe and YOU deny it. How can you spam on otherwise? You are in denial.

Also, now you are heading toward ad hom. Be careful.
 
But some people have come to the idea that they can participate here by reciting their mantra, I don accept God, I don't accept God, I don't accept, on and on and on, by which they think that they are being so smart about such a tack.

God doesn't exist.

You could at least try to get the words right.
 
..You're content to be led by others, led around by a metaphorical ring in your nose, never learning to think critically, question what you've been told, seek your own answers.
You don't think. You obey..

A young carpenter guy from a bunch of mud huts called Nazareth turns up out of the blue, says "I'm God's son", and pulls miracles and stuff that blows everybody's socks off that makes him almost as big as Elvis, so why shouldn't we believe him?
 
No it doesn't. The Bible clearly admits that people worshipped more than one god; it never verifies that those gods are real, and in fact says that they are manufactured by human hands in contrast to "the living God".

"Thou shalt have no other gods before me." Seems clear enough to me. In something as basic as the Ten Commandments, if those other gods weren't real, it would have said so. If there were no other gods, that particular commandment would have been worded entirely differently. By the way, notice that it does not even forbid them being the object of worship. It merely establishes a hierarchy.
 
So, my purpose in this latest venture to invite atheists to tell me what is their concept of God,
Well, we've been trying to tell you our conc...

One concept of God is the one you all should just come out and state it bravely and examine it: God creator of the universe.

Yrreg

Oh, then you were just lying about asking anything. Does that technique really work with 7 year olds?
 
Just give a brief but pithy account of your link, if you are serious.



Just give a brief but pithy account of your link, if you are serious.

Otherwise, I for one do not take to any such link bereft of at lest concise pre-briefing: because they are routinely tantamount to a wild goose chase.


Serious readers do not invest time and trouble for such blind links, and serious writers always give a brief but pithy account to the link they want readers to look up.




Yrreg
 
I'm sure he won't respond, if anyone does, but what about the "evidence" that Samuel Gridley Howe received (not what he expected or wanted) about the proof of god by those who never heard of him/her/it?

Case in point - Laura Bridgman, Helen Keller's predecessor. She was deaf, dumb, and blind from very early in life and was the first to learn language. She never picked up on the "clues" that Howe dropped her to prompt her to ask, "Who made this? Who made the world?" and all.

When she failed to ask or think of such a thing, he cast her aside like garbage and said that the illness in her infancy "Damaged her soul." :mad:

Also, Helen Keller never asked about any such thing as god/s until told!

What about them? People like them? Unless indoctrinated or having a ring put thru their nose as Slingblade says, they don't know or even consider such things.

Are they damaged? Consigned to hell unless someone "saves" them?

ARGH!!! :mad:
 
A young carpenter guy from a bunch of mud huts called Nazareth turns up out of the blue, says "I'm God's son", and pulls miracles and stuff that blows everybody's socks off that makes him almost as big as Elvis, so why shouldn't we believe him?

Why should you?

Do you believe everything you read? Because you only read about it. You never saw it. You never saw those miracles. You never saw this man. He's been dead for some 2,000 years. But you read about him in a book, and that alone was enough for you. I can't figure out why.

I know of a guy who said he could bend spoons using the power of his mind alone. He even demonstrated doing so.

Do you believe him, too? Him, at least, you can see. He's still alive. There are videos of him, doing his neat little trick. Do you believe this man can bend spoons using the power of his mind alone?

Well? Do you?
 
I saw Harry (?) Blackstone Jr. move a lit lightbulb all around the first several rows of the auditorium. Does that make him truly magical?
I saw it, and the poor lady who screeched when it flew into her face also did! However, Mr. Blackstone profusely apologized to the poor woman and rushed down to make sure she was all right!

I doubt any of us who left the Paramount that night believed any of his demonstrations were truly magical/supernatural.
 
You have got it wrong again, the universe did not come from nothing.

It came from God's will.

How did God create the universe out of nothing pre-existing except God's will.

This is one instance that you have to be God to know how.


And where did God's will, and God, come from?

You've been asked this innumerable times, and you've not been able to provide an answer.

It's getting tiring.
 
Nope.
Again, the Bible acknowledged that other gods were worshipped - but named them as man-made; as false.


Why was the Biblical God so threatened by false gods that he had to make laws that forbade their worship?
 
I will be brief here, the universe is the evidence for itself = zero evidence.

And once again we come to this question:

Yrreg, why does it disturb you so to see people acknowledge that there are things we don't yet know?

You want us to should out that since science doesn't yet know what caused the universe to begin (assuming that question even makes sense), it must have been a god. And therefore penis nose Catholic thinking.

But to an atheist, the universe itself is not evidence for a god, merely evidence that the universe exists. Skeptics tend to be reluctant to extrapolate into the unknown, and doubly reluctant to just assume that since we don't know something, a vaguely-defined supernatural entity must be the cause.

Why? Now that's a good question. There are a few reasons:
1) We rely on the evidence to form our conclusions, not the other way around. And as we live in a physical world, evidence tends to be physical. Assuming a supernatural explanation short-circuits inquiry, celebrating unsupported assertions instead of reliance on fact.
2) Using "god" as an answer explains nothing. We gain no knowledge of how things work, and it gives us no further avenues to research. It is, in short, a dead end to investigation. And despite your protestations to the contrary, it is therefore a form of unthinking to assume god, and form of good thinking to say "I don't know, let's see what we can learn".
3) Who created god? I know you don't like this question; you regard it as flippant. But that's because you don't understand it. The point, simply put, is that if you're going to take one thing to which we don't have a definite answer and plug your god into that gap, what's to stop you from assuming one more gap? Or one less? Why the arbitrary stopping at one god? How do you know this god was uncaused? maybe god's creator was the uncaused one? It's an equally valid supposition. You're the one who needs to do some "genuine thinking" on the matter.


Finally, why do you think we shout "penis" and "guiltless masturbation" at you? Perhaps you don't remember, but they were key elements of arguments you used in failed attempts to prove that god existed, and to prove that atheists secretly know god exists but just ignore it/him/her/hir.


No need to reader further.

I will be brief here, the universe is the evidence for itself = zero evidence.

Try that with you child, point to your nose and tell your child that the nose is evidence of itself.

That is why I keep telling atheists that please take note that evidence is whatever you know leading you to know something else, or more concretely, evidence is any fact you know leading you to know another fact.



You say the universe is the evidence of itself, is not saying anything leading you to know another thing.


Someone says in the internet, atheists say the most darnedest things.

I have the evidence for that statement, here, in the above quoted post, do you, all ye faithful atheists?



Yrreg
 
I will commend you for your post, but it is all you say but no explanation.

You mean you are unable to understand what they say.

Sorry, still no need for you god to explain anything.

You're not interested in dialogue, you just want people to think your ideas are correct. However they're unsupported by any evidence.


:D

Just filter everything through "god must exist otherwise I'm wrong and I can't handle that".


Yet you seem rather unfamiliar with even catholic theology and doctrine and the xian bible in general. Not to forget your complete lack of understanding of physics, biology and logic.

No. Xianity is opposed to rationality, rationality leads to agnosticism and atheism due to the lack of evidence for, and contradictions in, xianity.

Is this supposed yo mean something? Or are you just venting your hatred of Buddhists again?

What are you rambling on about now?

From a logic standpoint I'd say the doctrines of Pastafarianism are more valid than xianity; they're more internally consistent and lack the glaring contradictions and errors that are rampant within xian doctrine.


I will commend you for your post, but it is all you say but no explanation.

Now, tell me what is your complete and ultimate explanation for the existence of the universe.

Start with what you understand to be an explanation of anything at all.




Yrreg
 
Seeing that a so-called god can be anything someone wants it to be, it answers, Nothing, and it therefore worthless.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
You have got it wrong again, the universe did not come from nothing.

It came from God's will.

How did God create the universe out of nothing pre-existing except God's will.

This is one instance that you have to be God to know how.


Now, let us talk about what it is to explain something completely and ultimately.

If you think about it, truly think and not engage in maneuvering out of the issue, there is a necessary being origin of everything and He did not have to depend on another being or use pre-existing things not already coming from Himself.

That is the complete and ultimate explanation for the universe that is not God Himself.

Okay, you don't want to accept the existence of God the necessary being origin of everything that is not God Himself.


As per routine you will seek to cover yourself under the cloak of false humility, I don't know.

Well, if you don't know, then you can excuse yourself and just engage in denying or not admitting that people who know the existence of a necessary being origin of everything that is not Himself, they know.

But why engage in denying, just go away and have a life without ever knowing the origin of everything that has a beginning in the necessary being.

And say to yourself again and again just in case the question does bug you, I don't know; better join other things in the universe who don't have that question sneaking into their minds because they can't have that question emerging in their brain for it is not designed to have such a question arise in it.

Now, if you insist that there are other beings who agree with you, though not human like you and me, let them come forward and join this discussion.


But some people have come to the idea that they can participate here by reciting their mantra, I don accept God, I don't accept God, I don't accept, on and on and on, by which they think that they are being so smart about such a tack.




Yrreg

You have got it wrong again, the universe did not come from nothing.

It came from We Don’t Know's will.

How did We Don’t Know create the universe out of nothing pre-existing except We Don’t Know's will.

This is one instance that you have to be We Don’t Know to know how.


Now, let us talk about what it is to explain something completely and ultimately.

If you think about it, truly think and not engage in maneuvering out of the issue, there is a necessary being origin of everything and The Unknown did not have to depend on another being or use pre-existing things not already coming from The Unknowable.

That is the complete and ultimate explanation for the universe that is not We Don’t Know The Unknowable.

Okay, you don't want to accept the existence of We Don’t Know the necessary being origin of everything that is not We Don’t Know The Unknowable.


As per routine you will seek to cover yourself under the cloak of false humility, I don't know.

Well, if you don't know, then you can excuse yourself and just engage in denying or not admitting that people who know the existence of a necessary being origin of everything that is not The Unknowable, they know.

But why engage in denying, just go away and have a life without ever knowing the origin of everything that has a beginning in the necessary being.

And say to yourself again and again just in case the question does bug you, I don't know; better join other things in the universe who don't have that question sneaking into their minds because they can't have that question emerging in their brain for it is not designed to have such a question arise in it.

Now, if you insist that there are other beings who agree with you, though not human like you and me, let them come forward and join this discussion.


But some people have come to the idea that they can participate here by reciting their mantra, I don accept We Don’t Know, I don't accept We Don’t Know, I don't accept, on and on and on, by which they think that they are being so smart about such a tack.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom