What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Okay, let that pass about Buddhism, and about my being a liberal Christian...

But the rest you had no problems with? Surely you must agree that someone who doesn't believe in evolution, which the Catholic Church and the Pope himself accepts, can't be a liberal Christian.



I didn't then, and I still don't understand why you put so much weight on custom titles. It's been many years, Yrreg, and I've had many custom titles since then. Some as an attempt to be funny, and some more self describing.



Maybe I should put it back, along with other select quotes from your past... Like when you claimed to be an atheist. Remember that? :)



No.



Okay, let that pass about Buddhism, and about my being a liberal Christian...


We are or I am interested to know what is your concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

Please don't tell me that because don't accept the existence of God then you don't have to entertain any information about God.

Now, are you going to ask me why you must have information about God in order to not accept God's existence?

[ I give up. ]




Yrreg
 
Irrelevant post, into ignorance again, so I will not bother with you.

Yrreg said:
I will commend you for your post, but it is all you say but no explanation.

Now, tell me what is your complete and ultimate explanation for the existence of the universe.

Start with what you understand to be an explanation of anything at all.




Yrreg


Gerry, the fact is that nobody can yet state, with any supporting evidence, a complete and ultimate explanation for the existence of the universe. You seem to think this means that any asserted explanation, no matter how fantastic, is intrinsically superior to an honest admission of ignorance. You've indicated in the past your misinterpretation of honest admissions of ignorance as statements of disinterest, but you couldn't be further from the truth. And you are just as wrong regarding this belief.

If someone asks who committed a robbery and the police investigators state that they don't presently know because they don't have enough evidence to name a suspect, it doesn't mean that the question is open for you to assert that the robbery was committed by an invisible leprechaun. Noting that the investigators can't currently provide an answer does not legitimize your explanation simply because you make a positive claim of knowledge. In short, saying, "My magical explanation must be correct because you haven't offered a naturalistic answer of your own" couldn't be more wrong. It is better to admit our ignorance and hope for further evidence than to simply make stuff up.


Irrelevant post, into ignorance again, so I will not bother with you.


Just the same, irrelevant analogy, the existence of the universe is not somebody having stolen something.


Try again, do another analogy.


At the same time, give serious attention to figure out what it is to explain something.




Yrreg
 
Any God that is the creator of the universe is The GOD.

There were two questions. The first observed that your concept of God in the Christian faith as creator of the heavens and Earth is necessary but not sufficient. You have failed to distinguish your god from many, many others. What other characteristics can you cite for your god?

The second question was how many gods are there. As AvalonXQ has argued, many of the so-called gods recognized in the Bible can be discounted as false, but I would counter with not all. There are several blanket admissions of multiple gods in the Bible. So, how many are there?


For completeness, hear are the questions in their original posts.



Any God that is the creator of the universe is The GOD.

Now you want to add more things to God creator of the universe, you are welcome, but just make sure that they are not incompatible with God creator of the universe, because that is what He is fundamentally in relation to the universe.

So, you will say that God is supposed to be good, merciful, intelligent, etc., but He is not according to your evaluation: however, first get an authorization from someone with power to authorize you to evaluate, judge God in regard to goodness, mercy, intelligence, etc.



Yrreg
 
We are or I am interested to know what is your concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.


I don't accept the existence of gods so I don't have to entertain any information about gods.

Please don't tell me that because don't accept the existence of God then you don't have to entertain any information about God.


You don't understand the concept of atheism. In all the time you've been posting here at the JREF forum you never have. And it seems likely you never will. Think about it instead of dishonestly misrepresenting the position of atheists.

Now, are you going to ask me why you must have information about God in order to not accept God's existence?


Nope. I will tell you that without objective evidence to support the existence of something, it's folly to consider the existence of that thing. The evidence we do have supports the notion that gods, all of them, are imaginary beings which were created by humans. Read that again: Gods were created by humans. Humans were not created by gods.

[ I give up. ]


Promise?
 
We were going in that direction but you took back your words on facts.

Yrreg said:
Dear Mojo, just let us talk about evidence for the existence of God, by firstly that we two come to concurrence on what is evidence, what is the target of evidence, and how evidence operates.


Why don't you tell us how you think evidence operates?



We, you and I, were going in that direction but you took back your words on facts.


Here is again my concept of what is evidence:

Evidence is any fact man knows leading him to know another fact.

And if I remember you define evidence as directed toward the proof of a proposition.


Anyway, you agreed with me about facts then later you took back your words.

I will stop here because I don't want to resume our discussion owing to... I will just stop here.


Now, you want me to talk to readers and posters here about how evidence operates, on this task I will deal with Mojo when he does take the interest to dialog with me, and we will first draw up common rules: one of which is that a party must not take back his words, unless he admits that he was mistaken but not in order to prevent the realization of points of concurrence, in particular when already a concurrence has already been reached on a particular point.



Yrreg
 
I will prove it if you join me in the expedition to prove it.

Yrreg said:
You say the concept of God in the Christian faith is not valid, prove it.

You say the concept of god in the Christian faith is valid, prove it.


I will prove it if you join me in the expedition to prove it.


Here is the expedition, let us two go look at the universe and ask ourselves the questions:

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?



My experience with atheists is that they will always run away from any expedition.




Yrreg
 
Now, you will say that history proves I have left this forum time and again.

Now, you will say that history proves I have left this forum time and again.

I have not run away but left it in order to be busy with more productive undertakings.

Then I come back again and also now when I have the inspiration to put aside some time to see whether they are atheists here who are like Antony Flew, but so far it is the same people who are always into irrelevancies.


Okay, let us take the expedition to search for God in the universe, by us you atheists and I a theist working on the answers to these questions:

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?




Yrreg
 
Okay, GM, you guys are always griping that people don't understand you.

Tell me what you want me to understand you about.



Yrreg
 
I will prove it if you join me in the expedition to prove it.

Here is the expedition, let us two go look at the universe and ask ourselves the questions:

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?


Those are stupid questions to ask if the purpose of the inquiry is to objectively determine whether gods exist.

My experience with atheists is that they will always run away from any expedition.


And my experience with Christians is that it requires dishonesty and ignorance in varying proportions in order for them to maintain their belief in invisible magical beings.

You have no objective evidence to support the notion that your god exists, so your claim that it does exist can be dismissed as nonsense.
 
Now, you will say that history proves I have left this forum time and again.

I have not run away but left it in order to be busy with more productive undertakings.

Then I come back again and also now when I have the inspiration to put aside some time to see whether they are atheists here who are like Antony Flew, but so far it is the same people who are always into irrelevancies.


Okay, let us take the expedition to search for God in the universe, by us you atheists and I a theist working on the answers to these questions:

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?




Yrreg

Hi, Yrreg. Since you and I have never had a discussion here, I'm not the "same people," and I will not "run away."

To answer your questions:

I don't know if the universe has always existed, and I think the question depends upon what you mean by "always existed." If the universe explodes in a Big Bang, expands, contracts, and explodes again over and over forever, does that count as always existing? Or is each explosion a separate universe?

Does the universe create itself? Since I don't know if it always existed, this question is irrelevant, I think. Still, what do you mean by "create"? Does the Big Bang count as the universe creating itself?

God created the universe? Are these questions meant to be sequential or independent? If I don't know whether the universe always existed or not, how could I speculate on who or what may have created it? That aside, I think you would need to define God and demonstrate God's existence before you could logically present Him/Her/It as an explanation for the creation of the universe. Agreed?

Disclaimer: I've not read the rest of the thread, so if you've already answered these questions, please point me to the post. Thanks.
 
We, you and I, were going in that direction but you took back your words on facts.


Here is again my concept of what is evidence:

Evidence is any fact man knows leading him to know another fact.

And if I remember you define evidence as directed toward the proof of a proposition.


Anyway, you agreed with me about facts then later you took back your words.

I will stop here because I don't want to resume our discussion owing to... I will just stop here.


Now, you want me to talk to readers and posters here about how evidence operates, on this task I will deal with Mojo when he does take the interest to dialog with me, and we will first draw up common rules: one of which is that a party must not take back his words, unless he admits that he was mistaken but not in order to prevent the realization of points of concurrence, in particular when already a concurrence has already been reached on a particular point.



Yrreg

Yrreg, you realise people can still see the exchange you had with Loss Leader earlier in this thread, don't you? I mean, it's obvious that you're not telling the truth here (either deliberately or because you really didn't understand the whole exchange). Either way, it's pretty clear you're not making any progress in understanding what evidence is - maybe you should revisit the clear explanations Loss gave, and see if you can comprehend the logic better this time.
 
My Filipino daughter-in-law, a Christian, has read a few of your last posts, Gerry.

She says: Ako nahihiya sa inyo. Ikaw ay sira ang bait.
 
You (Mojo) say the concept of God in the Christian faith is not valid, prove it.
But to be rational you have to first examine it, in order to prove it not valid. ...

Mojo actually wrote:
"How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?
Why should all these other supernatural entities be rejected in favour of your own personal concept of "God"? "
Your answer misrepresents Mojo's statement.
Was that a deliberate 'strawman' on your part?

... first let us talk about evidence, that is very important to you and all atheists who think that they have discovered evidence to be the death of God. ...

Could you explain what you mean by the death of God?



Any God that is the creator of the universe is The GOD. ...

Does this mean you accept the possiblity the judean-christian god is NOT the creator of the universe?

... I will deal with Mojo when he does take the interest to dialog with me, and we will first draw up common rules: one of which is that a party must not take back his words, unless he admits that he was mistaken but not in order to prevent the realization of points of concurrence, in particular when already a concurrence has already been reached on a particular point. ...

This is an open discussion thread, yrreG. You don't get to set the rules.
 
You say the concept of God in the Christian faith is not valid, prove it.

But to be rational you have to first examine it, in order to prove it not valid.





Yrreg

Take two, you say concept of God in Christian faith not valid, prove it.

But keep in mind that you must examine it in order to prove it not valid.



Yrreg

Dear Mojo, just let us talk about evidence for the existence of God, by firstly that we two come to concurrence on what is evidence, what is the target of evidence, and how evidence operates.


You have a lot in your mind as to risk being scattered-brain, but to be systematic first let us talk about evidence, that is very important to you and all atheists who think that they have discovered evidence to be the death of God.



Yrreg


I did not claim that your concept is not valid: I asked how you know that it is valid, and why it should be considered any more valid than any of the concepts that you dismiss.

You have completely failed to address either of the questions I asked. At least this time you quoted them rather than simply omitting them from your response, but you distorted their meaning in an attempt to justify evading them.

Here they are again:

How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?

Why should all these other supernatural entities be rejected in favour of your own personal concept of "God"?
 
Last edited:
Well, it depends on how you define "always". If time started at the big bang, then there wasn't any time at which the universe didn't exist.

Would you say that the universe immediately after the big bang was the same as we know it now?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom