What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

The reason I consider gods to be intellectually invalid concepts is that to be valid, a concept must have evidence to support it. To say "Goddidit" is to accept that there is some being--God--without having any actual evidence for it. God is nothing more than a means to explain the unknowable. It has no definition except to that it's undefinable, has no abilities except those which are unknowable, has no nature except that which is indescribable.
I reject a pure "God of the gaps" or "mystic God" for precisely this reason.

Give god affirmative properties, and this is no longer an issue. Historical properties (such as "God did X") are a good example of this.
 
Which is the more ridiculous, to say that the universe was created, or to say that it just decided to create itself?
 
Which is the more ridiculous, to say that the universe was created, or to say that it just decided to create itself?

God doesn't exist.

The scientifically illiterate garner nothing more than my pity and derision.

Also, fallacy of the excluded middle.
 
So, you are down to unverse created itself or it has always existed.

Yrreg said:
You are asking the question who created God if God created everything.

That is what you are into, and I have someone with that non-question in this board earlier, I told him to look up infinite regress and do some genuine thinking.
If we don't need a creator to create God, why do we need one to create the universe? All God does is push things back a step; if an infinite regress is impossible God is unnecessary, and if an infinite regress IS possible, there's no such thing as the Creator or Prime Mover or any of those things.


Okay, very good, if you feel so smug, that is good for your psychology, but I can't say for your cognitive prowess.


Now, you are into

Universe created intself?
Universe has always been around?


Tell me which it is going to be of the two, or you have another one.


You will tell me you don't know, but do some thinking based on the experience of everyone who does think: like everyone who does think and finds something in his bedroom that was not there before, when he thinks about it he will know: that it is either self-created there or it has always been there only he did not notice it -- if no one puts it there at all.

So, unless you are a non-thinking entity, you have to think and infer that the universe has created itself or it has always existed, since you so smartly convince yourself that God is not needed -- but don't forget even Hawking has to bring in the laws of physics or err nature, or more err the multiverse!


We will continue when you have come to the thought of one or the other.

Universe created itself?
Universe has always been existing?



Yrreg
 
So, as I said already, which is it going to be:

God creator of the universe?
Universe created itself?
Univese has always been around?
None of the above. The universe began through a purely natural process. It was not created by some third party, it did not "create itself" (whatever that might mean) and it hasn't always been around. This is consistent with all the evidence that humans in their ingenuity have been able to gather.
 
Which is the more ridiculous, to say that the universe was created, or to say that it just decided to create itself?


...just decided happened to create itself (don't want the universe making decisions until its papers come through). :wink:
 
And no need to bring in many gods, etc., that is certainly if you can and do think, an irrelevancy.


Only the most closed minded, non-thinking people would leave the many supposed gods out of it. To suggest it is irrelevant to bring in many gods when discussing any god shows a lack of cognitive prowess. We will continue when you have come to the thought of all the other possibilities, including the many supposed gods which are in contradiction to any one of the several Christian gods.
 
The question I am referring which is time and again brought up by atheists, is namely:

Who created God?


Why is that a non-question?

It is a non-question because the one asking that question does not know about the concept of God as the creator of the universe, for if you are possessed of the correct concept of God as creator of the universe, and you understand universe as the totality of existence aside from God, then there is no need to ask the question of who or what created God, because then it is obvious from a conceptual framework, God is self-existing.

Now, if you insist that someone or something created God, then you are one step backward to come to the correct information of the concept of God, you have come to God again as the self-existing God.

You say you will ask again who or what created God?

I will say but no insult to you, Don't be silly.

Tell you what, you just go with Bertrand Russell in his debate with Fr. Copleston, and claim that you do not accept any concept of a necessary being which started the whole chain of existence with itself as the origin and necessary source of everything else that is not itself, namely, God.

So, your non-question should be about the existence of a necessary being who started the whole existence of things that are not Himself.


You read so many things from atheist writers who also write from ignorance of the issue going all the way back in time to the very first dawn of human conscious thinking by which mankind came to the concept of God as creator of the universe, and these writers keep repeating the same old old old non-issues, and non-questions.

That is why they atheist writers who are more smart just keep skirting the concept of God as creator of the universe and concentrate on non-questions and non-objections.


If you know how to think and you know history, then you know what is a non-question.




Yrreg


In short:

Yrreg considers it a non-question because it does not fit with how he defines god.
 
Jesus said there is a god, but atheists say there isn't, so who shall we believe?

Don't really care who or what you believe.

You're content to be led by others, led around by a metaphorical ring in your nose, never learning to think critically, question what you've been told, seek your own answers.

You don't think. You obey.

Not really my problem, is it?
 
Jesus said there is a god, but atheists say there isn't, so who shall we believe?

Oh! Oooh! Me!!! *raises hand* Okay, I'm not a great brain, but I would say, "Whoever has the most evidence on his/her side."

In this case, Jesus has none. (If Jesus as described in the bible even existed at all.)

The atheists have all the "lack of evidence for any god/s" on their side, so until evidence to the contrary rears its head, I would say to believe the atheists.
 
But my point is that the universe is the evidence of God the creator, its existence points to the creator: you can only deny this fact by stubborn refusal to admit it.

No, the universe is consistent with your concept of god. Its existence, however, doesn't point to a deity as creator, yours or any other for that matter. You can only deny this fact by stubborn refusal to admit it.
 
You have got it wrong again, the universe did not come from nothing.

Yrreg, you keep saying the problem with atheism is that it says the world came from nothing. Theism says the world came from nothing. The only difference is that it says God made it from nothing, without giving any more thought to how such a thing might have been done. Once you name a creator you are exempt from having to think one moment longer about how the universe came about. Many very wise and very thoughtful people who believe in God, or gods, continue to think very hard about how the universe came about, but many others (and I suspect you're among them) use God as a free pass for intellectual laziness. How did the universe begin? God made it. End of story. You accuse atheists of not thinking, but I see no evidence you're doing much of that. You're certainly not learning anything here.

You seem to have missed the point here, that many many people have thought very very hard about all sorts of theological and cosmological issues. Some have had faith and lost it. Some have lacked faith and found it. Some have started and ended as atheists, and others as theists. Saying that atheists simply have not thought about God, or haven't thought about him right, is not only an insult to many intelligent people here, but it is simply very very stupid.


You have got it wrong again, the universe did not come from nothing.

It came from God's will.

How did God create the universe out of nothing pre-existing except God's will.

This is one instance that you have to be God to know how.


Now, let us talk about what it is to explain something completely and ultimately.

If you think about it, truly think and not engage in maneuvering out of the issue, there is a necessary being origin of everything and He did not have to depend on another being or use pre-existing things not already coming from Himself.

That is the complete and ultimate explanation for the universe that is not God Himself.

Okay, you don't want to accept the existence of God the necessary being origin of everything that is not God Himself.


As per routine you will seek to cover yourself under the cloak of false humility, I don't know.

Well, if you don't know, then you can excuse yourself and just engage in denying or not admitting that people who know the existence of a necessary being origin of everything that is not Himself, they know.

But why engage in denying, just go away and have a life without ever knowing the origin of everything that has a beginning in the necessary being.

And say to yourself again and again just in case the question does bug you, I don't know; better join other things in the universe who don't have that question sneaking into their minds because they can't have that question emerging in their brain for it is not designed to have such a question arise in it.

Now, if you insist that there are other beings who agree with you, though not human like you and me, let them come forward and join this discussion.


But some people have come to the idea that they can participate here by reciting their mantra, I don accept God, I don't accept God, I don't accept, on and on and on, by which they think that they are being so smart about such a tack.




Yrreg
 
I know that most likely a wiggling strand of glitter playing a clarinet piped the Universe into existence.

So, since I KNOW that, how the hell can you spam on otherwise?
 
Since yrreg hides from the question, I'll ask you: A god among how many others? The bible clearly admits to more than one.

No it doesn't. The Bible clearly admits that people worshipped more than one god; it never verifies that those gods are real, and in fact says that they are manufactured by human hands in contrast to "the living God".
 
Roikan, you are giving me too much discredit, shame on you.

Yrreg said:
Correction: I am or call myself a liberal Christian, but I have a very complete and extensive Catholic education in the best schools at home and abroad.


A liberal Christian who denies evolution, condemns masturbation, writes hate speech against other religions and refuses to understand what atheism is.

There's not a liberal bone in your body, Yrreg.


Ryokan, you are giving me too much discredit, shame on you.

I have never engaged in hate speech except in the jaundiced eyes of people who cannot see clearly owing to jaundice.


Now, I am glad that you are neither God nor a fool, because you have changed, for example, you don't anymore style yourself as Resident Buddhist.

And then you no longer sign yourself at the bottom of your message box, the signature that Yrreg has converted you away from Buddhism.

Pray, tell me, did you have a fall out with Buddhism?



Yrreg
 
You have got it wrong again, the universe did not come from nothing.

It came from God's will.

So, when anything pretending to be logic or reason fail you, yrreg, you fall back on the basic bare assertion.

It saves time, I suppose. You have no facts, so a complete debate from you is nothing more than a single premise, anyway.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom