What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

There are two kinds of men, and also women, or mankind, those in need of God and...

There are two kinds of men, and also women, or mankind, those in need of God and those not in need of God.

I am of the kind that is in need of God.



Now, needing God or not needing God, I am inviting atheists who don't need God, just the same to join with theists or just join me, Yrreg a rational theist Christian, to come to a uniform concept of God, so that we can then proceed together to look for the entity that corresponds to our mutually worked out construct of God, in all the nooks and crannies of the whole totality of existence including the physical universe.





Yrreg
 
zooterkin said:
Are you familiar with how the books which make up the bible were decided on?

If I weren't I am sure Milligan would want their degree back. Yes I knew that even before my first year at seminary. You see I think for some big events God took the universe off auto pilot and tweaks it a bit, case study was Constantine's conversion to Christianity. In Hoc Signo Vinces, Constantine did, which allowed us to, and I am happy to say that we are still at the helm with everyone's best interests at heart.I am not as in your face as my more traditional brethren are, and do the absolute minimum to make sure anyone who wants to know the good news does.

I'm not sure you understood the point that was being made. Christianity is not the only monotheistic religion; oddly, the others are also under the impression that god has revealed the truth to them in holy words. How does one tell which is correct?

There are many ways to discern truth my friend. A tiny group of Christians that were hated as much as your group is today, and they rose above all the other religions is not evidence but a hint. Fulfilled Bible prophesy is another, but atheist doctrine makes it VERY difficult for an atheist realize that the bible is an accurate book.

Then there are the many other evidences that that I use because they are so in your face obvious. If you don't like a big thick book of theology get a popular book like a case for the creator and ignore what the secular critics have said (they have to say its a lie etc) and attempt to read it with an open mind. If you would have already of read it you would know what many of my evidences are, but not all.

I'm not really sure why you felt the need to go back and edit that in.

Sometimes I go back and what I think is my words for grammar and spelling using the WP, and accidentally edit the entire thing by mistake. If I change the wording of an author I do my best to put emphis mine etc, everyone makes mistakes, eh?

Thanks for your reply.

; {>
 
But you atheists are not in the quest for God.

Just the same, being fellow humans, because you love fellow humans even theists who are diametrically opposite to yourselves, please simply humor us, and we all with your indulgence and collaboration after we have come to a uniform concept of God, we can all go forth and locate that God.

What do you say to that?

I'm not going snipe hunting with you, yrreg. Sorry. Nor am I going to check my closet tonight for the invisible pink unicorn. I have no need to waste my time looking for things I don't believe in, see.

Nor am I going to "just humor you". It's your god -- you define it, you provide the evidence to demonstrate it exists. No evidence? No belief on my part. End of story.

The same methodology applies to all gods. Someone who believes in that god should define it and provide evidence for its existence. I am willing to examine that evidence. But I am not going to posit, even for the sake of argument, that such a god actually exists until and unless I see some evidence.
 
Last edited:
You know, guys atheists here, I am -- come to think of it -- I am into getting inputs from you about the God, the concept that is, the existence of which theist Christians must believe in or for Yrreg I know from reason to exist as a fact, in order that we can all atheists and theists start looking for that mutually construed God, that being namely that corresponds to the concept that is that can be acceptable to both atheists and theists, all of the best intentions and best honesty in the quest for God.

But you atheists are not in the quest for God.

Just the same, being fellow humans, because you love fellow humans even theists who are diametrically opposite to yourselves, please simply humor us, and we all with your indulgence and collaboration after we have come to a uniform concept of God, we can all go forth and locate that God.

What do you say to that?




Yrreg

Since you are so sure of this god, why don't you do the locating? Then present us with a good argument or evidence using coherent language. That's really all there is to it. You see, whether you like it or not, and whether or not you have actually read the posts in which this has been pointed out (over and over again, in many different ways, clearly, politely, confusingly, impolitely, seriously and jokingly, but over and over and over again!), many here are quite willing to accept your working definition of god; have, in fact, done the searching for that god, and in some cases even believed in the existence of that god at some time in their lives. And some of us have gone so far as to study the subject in churches, schools and colleges, some of us even so far as to study it with wise and worthy philosophers and theologians. This is not really a problem of not agreeing on a definition. Atheists are atheists because they do not believe that the definition describes a true or even possible entity.
 
I don't know if Wolly is an expert or not. He has not claimed to be one when speaking to me. And as I said If he is an expert he is being disingenuous or lacking that part of his education when he tells you and anyone who will listen the falsehood the big bang implies more than one universe.
Liar.

I never said that, in fact I went to great pains to point out that I wasn't saying that.

I don't suppose you can point to a post where wollery or anyone else actually says that?

You can't, because that is not what the argument was. The big bang does not imply more than one universe; it also doesn't imply only one, either.
DaH-na dah-na dahna dahnadahnada na <<<< that was supposed to be Jaws music

Gawd.....just when you thought it was safe in another thread...
So, you admit that you can't point to where I said that, as much as admitting that you lied?

I personally find it offensive when people tell blatant lies about me.

Please apologise.
 
Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.


Yrreg,

The Flying Spaghetti Monster, the Invisible Pink Unicorn, leprachauns, fairies, time-travelling chimpanzees, etc. are merely used as tools to highlight the silliness of some of your arguments. We are not ridiculing God, we are replacing the word "God" in your arguments to show that there is no difference in believing in God or believing in any of the above.

The arguments you present for the existence of God work with any of the above imaginary entities. You need to explain why the argument is acceptable when it refers to God, but unacceptable when it refers to anything else.

For example:

You only have pseudo-arguments against the Invisible Pink Unicorn. You bad-mouth the Invisible Pink Unicorn by calling it Yahweh.


What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.

Let me just invite you, Phase Inverter, for the present to your words in the following line in your list, the second item:

  • [God] Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.

That line from you say in very few words what I myself as a rational theist and a Christian understand to be God, namely, the maker of everything including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


This is dishonest and misleading. Your question was "What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?".

Your definition is too vague, since it could describe Zeus, the Flying Spaghetti Monster, the Invisible Pink Unicorn or Vishnu. Since you wanted the concept of God as accepted by Christians, you need to try again.
 
I really regret that I cannot answer you all, because I have other things to do aside from having a good time in web forums.

Just trust me that I am all for getting to the facts of God or no God, and at present trying to get us both, me a rational theist Christian and you guys atheists, to come to a mutually acceptable concept of the Christian God -- but please no fine print about my excluding thereby all the other attributes of God in the Christian faith.

There is just no *the* God concept of Christianity. You might isolate a few things which are more prevalent than others. Maybe you'll even hit on one or the other universality, but those hardly will be recognizably Christian. (Whether it actually is mutually acceptable - by both the 'sides' that you talk about - is fairly irrelevant.)


Okay, without as I said excluding all the other attributes of God in the Christian faith, for the present can we agree to keep to this concept of God from yours truly:

  • God is the maker of everything in the totality of existence including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


There is plenty of ground which is simply not covered by your single point here.

Would any necessary being count? I would not think so. Something which could meaningfully be referred to as being conscious, as having a mind seems absolutely necessary and not negotiatable to me. (With all the strings attached of course ...)

What about something like prayer? Could you really separate Christianity and its God from prayer and whether they are listened to, or even answered. What about salvation? The afterlife? The Trinity? The Bible? Jesus? Etc.

None of these very relevant Christian issues are either addressed or even hinted at in your definition. They are simply absent.


Your definition tastes suspiciously like water, when what you need is something which is more like a Pangalactic Gargleblaster. (Not meant offensive)


And please don't bring in all those irrelevant characters like Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechauns, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

Yes, I know, you want to tell me and all theists that for you God is of the same category insofar as evidence is concerned.

And I am telling you endlessly that no, God is not of the same category even on the basis of evidence, except your kind and constriction of evidence which is in a dungeon of your own making.
 
Last edited:
There are two kinds of men, and also women, or mankind, those in need of God and those not in need of God.

I am of the kind that is in need of God.

Excellent, yrreg. Admitting you have a problem is the first step to recovery.

Now, needing God or not needing God, I am inviting atheists who don't need God, just the same to join with theists or just join me, Yrreg a rational theist Christian, to come to a uniform concept of God, so that we can then proceed together to look for the entity that corresponds to our mutually worked out construct of God, in all the nooks and crannies of the whole totality of existence including the physical universe.

Really? You really want to work together to come up with a construct of god? Excellent. Ok, I'll start: God is pink and invisible, and it has this pointy thing on its head.

Ok, your turn to add something.
 
delete...I accidentally responded to pixie post...I am saving the personal content and triage them for last, and may post it again later.

; {>
 
Last edited:
You are too negativistic, too pessimistic, too independent of God.

That doesn't look like a very good exercise. First, your made-up magical sky daddy isn't particularly interesting, yrreg. Second, there is nothing to locate since your uninteresting made-up magical sky daddy doesn't exist.

How about we discuss the spiritual teachings of the IPU?


You are too negativistic, too pessimistic, too independent of God.

You will never be of any benefit to mankind.

Look back to what atheists communists sought to bring about an atheist utopia, which came to nothing in very brief historical time.

Look back to the French Revolution leaders, all atheists like you guys here, they ended up killing each other, like the Russian atheists revolutionaries of very recent years, they came to nothing.


At no time in the history of mankind had atheists ever had all the resources of government to bring about utopia to the half of mankind they enslaved, and they failed miserably to uplift mankind even just on material needs.

Look at North Korea today.
What an atheist paradise, eh?


Of course, you will insist that the ills of the atheist regimes during the cold war years were not due to atheists as atheists but due to atheists as communists totalitarians.

So their being atheists and humanists and rationalists, and everything good and terrific for mankind did not succeed to keep them away from being despotic totalitarians who murdered more peoples ever in the whole history of mankind, than any other adherents of any worldviews or visions for mankind.

Wherefore, being atheists does not spell any reassuring hope for mankind to get ahead to better conditions for everyone, quite the opposite.





Yrreg
 
.
Men like Jim Jones, or Marshall Applewhite , or Prophet Yahweh, or.... the list of deluded people claiming to be THE outlet for the divine truth is endless.
L. Ron Hubbard, Joseph Smith, Muhammed, Mary Baker Eddy....

False prophets that were not following anything in the bible, they preached false doctrine. The bible warns about these people. Just compare what they are saying with scripture. They may sprinkle scripture in with thiere own peverted adgenda but if it doesnt correlate with the bible dont drink the koolaid.

; {>
 
You are too negativistic, too pessimistic, too independent of God.

You will never be of any benefit to mankind.

Look back to what atheists communists sought to bring about an atheist utopia, which came to nothing in very brief historical time.

Look back to the French Revolution leaders, all atheists like you guys here, they ended up killing each other, like the Russian atheists revolutionaries of very recent years, they came to nothing.


At no time in the history of mankind had atheists ever had all the resources of government to bring about utopia to the half of mankind they enslaved, and they failed miserably to uplift mankind even just on material needs.

Look at North Korea today.
What an atheist paradise, eh?


Of course, you will insist that the ills of the atheist regimes during the cold war years were not due to atheists as atheists but due to atheists as communists totalitarians.

So their being atheists and humanists and rationalists, and everything good and terrific for mankind did not succeed to keep them away from being despotic totalitarians who murdered more peoples ever in the whole history of mankind, than any other adherents of any worldviews or visions for mankind.

Wherefore, being atheists does not spell any reassuring hope for mankind to get ahead to better conditions for everyone, quite the opposite.





Yrreg

If someone else wrote that passage, with "Christian" in place of "atheist," you'd be whining to the mods right now about how unfairly you're treated. Can you give us some reason, other than the fact that you are obdurately tone-deaf to your own arrogant and insulting expression, why we should not report that post?
 
Yrreg,

You provided the following definition and asked us to accept it in order to move forward:


God is the maker of everything in the totality of existence including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


I am willing to accept a modified form of this definition, as follows:


  • God is the one and only, eternal, supernatural maker of everything in the totality of existence including the physical universe, the author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


The modification I have made is to bring the definition closer to what I believe you are arguing. I will explain my reasons:

1. Your definition allows God to have a beginning. Since you are arguing that God has no maker, he must be eternal. Therefore, I have inserted the word "eternal".

2. Your definition allows for the existence of other gods, which I assume you do not believe exist. Since God is eternal, it is conceivable that other eternal gods exist. Since gods never had a beginning, they do not require a creator. Therefore, under your definition, there could be millions of gods. My definition does away with this problem by inserting "one and only".

3. Your definition would allow for time-travelling humans, animals or aliens to be defined as God. Since I assume you would not accept this, I have inserted the word "supernatural". This word also fits your understanding of God, since you believe him to be outside the physical universe.

Yrreg,

Are you willing to accept this modified definition of God?

If so, please begin presenting your arguments for its existence.
 
wollery; said:
Liar. I never said that, in fact I went to great pains to point out that I wasn't saying that.

You read my post wrong. I said that another member said you were an astrophysicist with a PhD, making fun of my words,to get you out of your shell I began addressing you as Mr PhD of astrophysics in the heat of debate several times, then you said that, you have never claimed to have a PhD in astrophysics.

So, you admit that you can't point to where I said that, as much as admitting that you lied?

No

I personally find it offensive when people tell blatant lies about me.
Please apologise.

I did apologize to you or at least I thought I did, but I am not going to go through thousands of words of font to find it, and I am not even sure what you think I lied about.

; {>
 
Last edited:
You read my post wrong. I said that another member said you were an astrophysicist with a PhD, making fun of my words,to get you out of your shell I began addressing you as Mr PhD of astrophysics in the heat of debate several times, then you said that, you have never claimed to have a PhD in astrophysics.



No



I did apologize to you or at least I thought I did, but I am not going to go through thousands of words of font to find it, and I am not even sure what you think I lied about.

; {>
No, point to where I said that the Big Bang implies more than one Universe.

Or apologise for saying that I did.
 
RevDisturba said:
You read my post wrong. I said that another member said you were an astrophysicist with a PhD, making fun of my words,to get you out of your shell I began addressing you as Mr PhD of astrophysics in the heat of debate several times, then you said that, you have never claimed to have a PhD in astrophysics.




I don't know if Wolly is an expert or not. He has not claimed to be one when speaking to me. And as I said If he is an expert he is being disingenuous or lacking that part of his education when he tells you and anyone who will listen the falsehood the big bang implies more than one universe.

; {>

You, sir, are an out and out liar.
 
You can't educate a man who's determined to remain ignorant.

When you use words that are obvious religious slurs the world over (except in dirty little corners where anything goes) and act like you can't understand the correlation of religious insults with racial and sexual identification smears and taunts, while feigning ignorance or ? then it is you that is beyond help not I. The person that uses religious and racial slurs etc as a matter of conversation or debate are lacking in several areas of human compassion and maturity.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Okay, let us get going into the concept of God, without bringing in spaghetti.

Okay, let us get going into the concept of God, without bringing in spaghetti.



I say that:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


First important word in that definition of God, the word maker.


Do you atheists have any trouble with the word maker, just that word, please for now, don't go into the invisible pink unicorn, and above all keep that spaghetti in the kitchen, we are into serious business, finding out if anyone conversant with English is having any trouble with word maker.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom