What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.

Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?

Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists.

Yrreg

Would that be the Christian God of the Anglican Communion or the Christian God of the Assyrian Church of the East or the Christian God of the Eastern Orthodox Church or the Christian God of the Oriental Orthodox Church or the Christian God of the Roman Catholic Church or the Christian God of the Other Churches that call themselves Catholic or the Christian God of the Pre-Lutheran Protestants or the Christian God of the Lutheranists or the Christian God of the Reformed Churches or the Christian God of the Presbyterianists or the Christian God of the Congregationalist Churches or the Christian God of the Anabaptists or the Christian God of the Brethren or the Christian God of the Methodists or the Christian God of the Pietists and Holiness Churches or the Christian God of the Baptists or the Christian God of the Apostolic Churches or the Christian God of the Irvingites or the Christian God of the Pentecostalists or the Christian God of the Charismatics or the Christian God of the African Initiated Churches or the Christian God of the United and uniting churches or the Christian God of the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers) or the Christian God of the Stone-Campbell Movement or the Christian God of the Southcottites or the Christian God of the Millerites and Comparable groups or the Christian God of the Anglo-Israelists or the Christian God of the Latter Day Saints or the Christian God of the Prairie Saints or the Christian God of the Rocky Mountains or the Christian God of the Oneness Pentecostalism or the Christian God of the Unitarianism and Universalists or the Christian God of the Swedenborgianism or the Christian God of the Messianic Judaism or the Christian God of the New Thought or the Christian God of the ethnic or syncretic religions incorporating elements of Christianity or the Christian God of the New Age movements or the Christian God of the Religions associated with the Yoruba or the Christian God of Esoteric Christianity?

Or is it another one you have made up?

Which church should I go to?

I wouldn't want to mess it up and go to the wrong one. One of them must be right. They all think the others are wrong.



Just askin' ...


.
 
Last edited:
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.

1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.
2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.
3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​
What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?

Yrreg, you know the answer to your own question don't you? Most Atheists are secure in their beliefs are not angry child like insulting jerks. Some sites have more than their fair share of abusive atheist AND Christians.

The best thing to do is to not answer any replies that contain bait words such as the FSM, or associating religious icons with mythical figures, or calling religion myth. Those kind of comments belong in juvenile hall or to be used amongst school children*. I see a this forum slightly trending upward towards ethical and debate in good faith and away from the Brownshirt/insultive' quagmire of the past. That bodes well for the future of our site (JREF).

; {>

oops I was making my assessment of this forum getting better by the first few comments on page one, on page two I see the rhetoric and hate speech heating up from the usual suspects, sad!

It seems that we still have a good measure of our unsavory juvenile types eh? Well this forum may still yet be a good place to post if the weeds can be pulled.


* The school children of the mentioned offensive insulting people. If I caught my children using those taunts and remarks they would be grounded of a week or worse.
 
Last edited:
The best thing to do is to not answer any replies that contain bait words such as the FSM, or associating religious icons with mythical figures, or calling religion myth.


That neither you nor Yrreg can see that those are not bait words nor attempts to annoy you: but are in fact perfectly legitimate arguments which have not been addressed speaks volumes. This has been explained many times, not least in this thread. When you have answered the points it may be those arguments will be abandoned. Trying to pretend you are being insulted is just a way of avoiding the issues, so far as I can see.
 
The best thing to do is to not answer any replies that contain bait words such as God and Jesus, or calling evolution myth.
 
You see, atheists, again you try to evade the question...

You see, atheists, again you try to evade the question, not only try but actually avoiding the issue, instead going into what I call genuine pseudo arguments of bad mouthing God, laughing at God, and insisting you don't know nothing about the concept of God as understood by Christians.

For latecomers, see my opening message, and my message in post #14.


Yes, atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods, but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God.




Yrreg
 
You see, atheists, again you try to evade the question, not only try but actually avoiding the issue, instead going into what I call genuine pseudo arguments of bad mouthing God, laughing at God, and insisting you don't know nothing about the concept of God as understood by Christians.

For latecomers, see my opening message, and my message in post #14.


Yes, atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods, but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God.




Yrreg

How about this: I do not believe in any entities who are said to be a source of absolute morality.
 
Yes, atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods, but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God.

As has been pointed out to you several times before, atheists lack belief in any and all gods. Choose/define one. Atheists lack belief in it. Simple, isn't it?
 
You see, atheists, again you try to evade the question, not only try but actually avoiding the issue, instead going into what I call genuine pseudo arguments of bad mouthing God, laughing at God, and insisting you don't know nothing about the concept of God as understood by Christians.
I don't know what you're reading, but it's clearly not the comments in this thread. Please point to a post where any of the things you allege occurred.

For latecomers, see my opening message, and my message in post #14.
Really, there's no need, your comments are there for all to see.


Yes, atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods,
Yes, you're getting the idea.

but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in,
All of those for which there is no evidence of their existence.

in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God.

It still hasn't clicked, has it? How well do you understand the concept of all the Hindu gods? Do you lack belief in them?
 
Thanks, Phase Inverter, for being relevant.

Originally Posted by yrreg
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

​

To answer your question honestly and without getting off track, the God that the Christians believe exists:

  • Has a name, Yahweh.
  • Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.
  • Is responsible for the creation of plants, animals, and humans on earth.
  • Is responsible for the creation of angels, and other beings in heaven.
  • Is one, but at the same time three, being(s). One of which was known as logos, but was made flesh and is now called Jesus.
  • Is referred to as being male.
  • Revealed himself to mankind on various occasions in various forms.
  • Directed the recording of these revelations in written form known as the Holy Bible.
  • Demands obedience and worship.
  • Chose one family to live while destroying every other human on earth.
  • Chose one family and it's descendants to be his people.
  • Dictated rules for worship, sacrifice, and behavior.
  • Sent a part of himself, Jesus, as a blood sacrifice to forgive the disobedience of his people.
  • Will punish for eternity all who do not accept or believe that Jesus died for the forgiveness of their disobedience.
  • Will grant eternal life and bliss to all those who do accept and believe that Jesus died for the forgiveness of their disobedience.
  • Will destroy heaven and earth and build a new heaven and earth with Jesus on the throne of the kingdom of God and the twelve disciples as rulers over the twelve tribes of his chosen people.
  • Etc.

Is this the God that you are "humanly certain" exists? Have I left anything out? Is there anything above that is incorrect?

Is this the God that we are going to hear arguments for or against?


Let me just invite you, Phase Inverter, for the present to your words in the following line in your list, the second item:

  • [God] Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.

That line from you say in very few words what I myself as a rational theist and a Christian understand to be God, namely, the maker of everything including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.

Yes, just keep to that line from your list and also my expanded version of that line, that is the concept of God which I am humanly certain in fact exists.

For the present don't go into anything else, just stick to that line from your list and as I said, which I expand into my own version as stated above.




Yrreg
 
Ok. We are back to "What is wrong with this defintion of God "

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=135293

I will ask the mods to merge this thread, shall I ? Yes, I believe I will

ETA: only trouble is deciding whether is is better merged with that one or with:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=147728 or even

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=148459

Hmm. I will stick with my first thought but if the mods think either of the others more appropriate so be it.
 
Last edited:
and insisting you don't know nothing about the concept of God as understood by Christians.


  • Learn to write. Start by avoiding double negatives.
  • I was raised Episcopalian. It isn't that I don't know about the Christian concept of god, but that I think it's a bunch of bunk.
Yes, atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods, but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in,
What part of "all" do you not understand?

I'll make it slightly more clear. I lack belief in 100% of the concepts of god that I have been exposed to in this life. The ones I haven't ever heard of yet I can reserve judgment on, but I deem it unlikely that I won't lack belief in those, too.

So, you go ahead and hold your concept up, and I'll proceed to lack belief in it.

How's that?
 
  • [God] Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.
For the present don't go into anything else, just stick to that line from your list and as I said, which I expand into my own version as stated above.

Yrreg

Your god(s) have no other attributes than that? Your god(s) affect nothing in daily life?

If so, then we can talk.
 
Your god(s) have no other attributes than that? Your god(s) affect nothing in daily life?

If so, then we can talk.

I don't know about yours, but my god, the Great Cthulhu, has immeasurable impact on daily life. He eats about five people a day around here.
 
You see, atheists, again you try to evade the question, not only try but actually avoiding the issue, instead going into what I call genuine pseudo arguments of bad mouthing God, laughing at God, and insisting you don't know nothing about the concept of God as understood by Christians.

For latecomers, see my opening message, and my message in post #14.


Yes, atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods, but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God.




Yrreg
There is no issue to avoid. I do not go out of my way to read writings directed against any god or gods.I do not believe they exist,end of story.How can I have a concept about something that does not exist? I never enter into discussion about the existence or non-existence of The Flying Spaghetti Monster or Ganesh the Hindu elephant god,so why should I debate with you about your delusion? Believe what you want to believe,I don't give a flying one.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom