What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?


Yrreg

There are 40,000 (and counting) different sects of Christians, some with very few and very subtle variations on what they believe God is, and some with quite major differences.

Since I have no desire to define all 40,000 "Christian" Gods, and certainly none of the other Gods I lack a belief in, please be specific?

Give us the attributes of the one (out of 40,000) Christian God you accept, then we can talk.

I have a feeling that this will either not be responded to, or a "No True Scotsman" appeal will be forthcoming (or that this post will not even be read, since the OP always seems to be debating himself, and not the responses on his threads.

Norm
 
Well, according to my pseudo-orthodox atheist calendar, this month I'm targeting Odin for non-belief, next month is Zeus, and it's always Baal in October. I don't think the Christian god is in the rotation for special non-belief targeting until 2012. It's really really hard work to not believe in all the gods all the time, especially for us atheists who are sorely lacking in ordinary intelligence or human certainty. One at a time, that's my motto. Of course, that makes for a really long rotation.
 
Seems to me that Yrreg is jumping the gun.

To start from first principles: Yrreg, if you want a serious, honest debate please answer the the following - what do you believe, and why?
 
Seems to me that Yrreg is jumping the gun.

To start from first principles: Yrreg, if you want a serious, honest debate please answer the the following - what do you believe, and why?

Welcome PaulJ,

Trust me, Gerry has long ago demonstrated that an honest, serious debate is the last thing he wants.
 
Gerry.
You seem to me to be at least as obsessed with Atheists as you clearly are with your religion.
Did you expect to spend so much time gibbering on about Atheists when you first left the atheist fold?
Couldn't you have just waved a nonchalant hand at religion the first time you were aware of it?
Give it a swerve and keep life simple. Just be good to people and stop the obsession.

Its really not necessary.
 
Last edited:
theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact
Yrreg

Please tell me what you understand by the word "explain", Yrreg

I will give you some hints:

It does not mean the same thing as "tell"
It does not mean the same thing as "preach"
It does not mean the same thing as " assert"

How are you using the word?
 
Last edited:
It has already been explained to yrreg (repeatedly) that when we discuss such concepts as the Flying Spaghetti Monster etc, we are not calling his god a Flying Spaghetti Monster.

What we are doing is comparing his (and, incidentally, our own) lack of belief in a Flying Spaghetti Monster to our lack of belief in his god.

The subject of the analogy is the lack of belief, not god.


But yrreg either cannot or will not understand this.

He seems to prefer to take umbrage at us calling his god names.

It plays into his idea that atheists are mean.





Yrreg. Please, for the love of all you hold dear, please read this:

Atheists don't believe in ANY god. Not in any concept of the Christian God, not in any concept of the Muslim God, the Norse Gods, the Roman Gods, the Greek Gods, the Chinese Gods, nor in any others you can think of.

We don't believe in any of them. We simply don't believe that any of them exist outside of the human imagination.

It really doesn't matter how you define your god, we still don't believe in it.


Quoted in the (small) hope that yrreg reads and comprehends.



Seems to me that Yrreg is jumping the gun.

To start from first principles: Yrreg, if you want a serious, honest debate please answer the the following - what do you believe, and why?


If yrreg had wanted a serious, honest debate, he wouldn't have started with a strawman and a snide title.
 
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?
That it's not based on evidence or logic.

Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?
Because you're consumed by irrelevancies.

Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists.
You don't get it, do you?

Your concept of God is irrelevant. Your beliefs are not special. We don't believe in any gods at all.
 
Why do you people bother, anyways? It's a testament to your will and your endurance of mind to be able to continually bash your collective heads against such an indestructible wall.
 
Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists.

Swing and a miss!

Atheism isn't "anti-god", no matter what value of "god" you pick.
Atheism is "lack of belief in all gods". This includes whichever correct god you think you've found this week.

Think of it as "god-indifferent", much like the aforementioned invisible pink unicorn in my closet. I don't check every night to make sure it isn't there; I'll worry about its existence if it ever shows up.
 
I think I get it.
The concept of God exists, whether God exists or not.
For those that believe God does not exist, (the christian one, btw) how would they imagine that concept to be? Or, what do we think a theist is imagining, when they imagine God? (This wording has a more pro-atheist approach, but it may be the same thing yrreg was trying to get at.)
 
<SNIP>
and if all you mean by Nature is what anyone else means by Nature then I guess you can call it God or Arthur or Cyril or Maude or anything else you want to call it." <SNIP>


Maude???

Hmmmm... for some reason, that brings a tune to my head:



Lady Godiva was a freedom rider
She didn't care if the whole world looked.
Joan of Arc with the Lord to guide her
She was a sister who really cooked.

Isadora was the first bra burner
And you're glad she showed up. (Oh yeah)
And when the country was falling apart
Betsy Ross got it all sewed up.

And then there's Maude.
And then there's Maude.
And then there's Maude.
And then there's Maude.
And then there's Maude.
And then there's Maude.
And then there's

That old compromisin', enterprisin', anything but tranquilizing,
Right on Maude !!!!!!! :cool:
 
Swing and a miss!

Atheism isn't "anti-god", no matter what value of "god" you pick.
Atheism is "lack of belief in all gods". This includes whichever correct god you think you've found this week.
Right.

Yrreg, what your concept of God is, is up to you to define, not us.

You define it, and we'll tell you why we don't believe in it.

Think of it as "god-indifferent", much like the aforementioned invisible pink unicorn in my closet. I don't check every night to make sure it isn't there; I'll worry about its existence if it ever shows up.
Or you start finding invisible pink holes in all your shirts...
 
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God. Yrreg

Ummm.... You just don't get it Yrreg, do you. The whole point of atheism
is that we DON'T accept as FACT to be EXISTING, the christian god or ANY god. Obviously, we know that believers in ANY god accept the fact that their god exists, because they ARE BELIEVERS.
That part we already got, and rightfully acknowledge...that people who believe in god (any god, including the christian god), believe that their god exists. That goes without saying, and is needlessly written as a caveat in your sentence for some unknown reason that only furthers to bewilder us and add to the confusion myself and others have in attempting to comprehend exactly what you're asking.

If it's for us to suspend our logic, rational thought, and critical thinking, and somehow BELIEVE in, or pretend to BELIEVE in the existence of the christian (or any) god, you're just being a plain old silly troll goose.
 
Last edited:
But we do believe in Cthulhu and Yog-Sothoth. I mean, we're all intelligent people here.

Ummm.. Are you trying to tell me that there are people out there who DON'T BELIEVE in Cthulhu AND Yog-Sothoth??? You're kidding me, right? This must be some kind of joke. Say it ain't so..say it ain't so.
C'mon now.... this has GOT TO BE a joke. I get it...alright..where's the cameras...where's Allen Funt (oh, he's dead...never mind)..umm I mean..how about Peter Funt???
Or that Ashton Kutcher fella. Someone's tryin to pull my leg....

Oh you guys..you almost had me goin there. Almost *punk'd* the good DrZ.
I'm a little too smart to have the sheep pulled over my eyes.

To think....someone actually NOT believing in Cthulhu and Yog-Sothoth...LOL
That's just too funny..and ridiculous. And for a second..just one second..I ALMOST bought into it. Now, how RIDICULOUS of a thought is that. Sheer lunacy, if you ask me. Even having to tell people that we believe in these 2.... almost had me going there... that there might be someone so blind, so utterly without any intelligence or common sense that they'd even question their existence... WHEW.... :jaw-dropp
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom