What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​


What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?





Yrreg

I say that you're a troll. Your entire argument is one giant flame. This supports what I have said in previous threads: no argument forwarded by yrreG can last for more than two sentences without degenerating into an attack on the intelligence of atheists.

What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.


Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?

Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists.






Yrreg

As the others have said, it doesn't matter which god we take the Christians to mean. We don't believe in any of them. Except Cthulhu, of course.
But, for your information, I was raised Roman Catholic. So your god used to be my god. I read the Bible, went to Sunday school and Catholic Faith Formation like a good little boy, and prayed every day. Then one day I realized that it was all a hunk of bull****. Like I said, your god used to be my god. I know exactly what I'm denying.

FAIL. Atheists lack belief in god(s). Yours isn't special. It's lumped in with all the others without favoritism.

ETA: Agatha beat me to it. Oh well.

ps. We don't believe in IPU or FSM either.

But we do believe in Cthulhu and Yog-Sothoth. I mean, we're all intelligent people here.
 
Yrreg: What concept of the christian god as in the existant god which you deny are you denying?

Atheists: What d'ya got?
 
Yrreg: What concept of the christian god as in the existant god which you deny are you denying?

Atheists: What d'ya got?

yrreg: Infinite ignorance. And you?

Atheists: We've got science.

yrreg: Bah! My dragon style defeats it all! Bow before my might!
 
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.


Is there some alternate version of English in which these sentences make sense?

[Note to Yrreg: This is not "pretending not to understand." This is genuinely having no idea what you're on about.]
 
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?


To answer your question honestly and without getting off track, the God that the Christians believe exists:

  • Has a name, Yahweh.
  • Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.
  • Is responsible for the creation of plants, animals, and humans on earth.
  • Is responsible for the creation of angels, and other beings in heaven.
  • Is one, but at the same time three, being(s). One of which was known as logos, but was made flesh and is now called Jesus.
  • Is referred to as being male.
  • Revealed himself to mankind on various occasions in various forms.
  • Directed the recording of these revelations in written form known as the Holy Bible.
  • Demands obedience and worship.
  • Chose one family to live while destroying every other human on earth.
  • Chose one family and it's descendants to be his people.
  • Dictated rules for worship, sacrifice, and behavior.
  • Sent a part of himself, Jesus, as a blood sacrifice to forgive the disobedience of his people.
  • Will punish for eternity all who do not accept or believe that Jesus died for the forgiveness of their disobedience.
  • Will grant eternal life and bliss to all those who do accept and believe that Jesus died for the forgiveness of their disobedience.
  • Will destroy heaven and earth and build a new heaven and earth with Jesus on the throne of the kingdom of God and the twelve disciples as rulers over the twelve tribes of his chosen people.
  • Etc.

Is this the God that you are "humanly certain" exists? Have I left anything out? Is there anything above that is incorrect?

Is this the God that we are going to hear arguments for or against?
 
Is there some alternate version of English in which these sentences make sense?

[Note to Yrreg: This is not "pretending not to understand." This is genuinely having no idea what you're on about.]

I'm not 100% sure, but I don't think English is yrreG's native language. If it is, then he should be very, very sad.
 
He's in the Philippines, and I don't think English is his first language.
 
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​


What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?





Yrreg


Three strawman arguments.
 
What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?
That's some top-notch second-rate analysis.
 
What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?





Yrreg

I say:

1. Define your god.

2. Give me evidence that your god exists.
 
What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?

Yay, Yrreg finally included everybody! :) I feel so special now. (((group hug)))

(((all sing Kumbaya and toast marshmallows by the campfire)))
 
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​


What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?





Yrreg


Regarding point one, as has been stated earlier in this thread but I will reiterate here, all mention of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, the IPU, ancient norse or greek gods, etc. are used only in the form of analogy. If I say computer memory can be thought of a series of containers into which bits of information can be placed, I am not saying that computer memory is containers.

What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.


Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?

Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists.






Yrreg



The above, along with point three in your first message in this thread (also quoted above), is really where any discussion/debate between you and atheists, including myself, breaks down before it even gets started.

As you are making the affirmative claim, "God exists," it falls to you to define what you mean by God. You do not get to presuppose God and then have someone try to disprove you, as an arbitrary statement cannot be disproven. You must define and support your supposition. We can then have a discussion about the validity of your claims, whether they have merit and what conclusions can be drawn.

Using "The Christian God" as your definition is not sufficient. The attributes ascribed to the Christian God varies from church to church, such as Catholics, Lutherans and Southern Baptists. Saying the "God of the Bible" is not sufficient as there are various translations and interpretations of the Bible which are not consistent. Even within the Bible, any version, there is the question of which God you are choosing: the God of the Old Testament, the God of the New Testament or some combination of the two.

Yrreg, if you define what you mean by "God," then we have a starting point. Until then you might as well be talking about "Zrgles," because we won’t know what you mean.

LTW
 
1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.
This is satire, especially pointed to show that the same "logic" you use wrt to the god you believe in looks absurd when you apply it to these other made up entities.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.
Atheists don't believe in a god or gods, so there is no way possible that you have observed atheists "laughing at god". As far as laughing at theists who are laughable, should theists have a special immunity from this treatment? I give you permission to laugh at atheists who behave laughably. (You have to admit, theists are so much better at it! Praying in tongues, defending literalist interpretation of scriptures, denying modern science, televangelizing, etc.)

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
I'm not sure what you mean by this one. I know anytime I discuss the existence of god with a theist, I will quickly insist on a definition of the term "God". Most conventional definitions of god are internally inconsistent, or obviously inconsistent with the real world, or both. I'm not pretending when I'm asking for a definition of this term.


What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?

That's like decrying that modern physicists aren't really interested in the "academic inquiry" of phlogiston, or that modern medical researchers have no interest in the "academic inquiry" of chi or the humours.

I'm happy to engage in a debate on the existence of gods, but I find the idea that I should consider "the issue of God" to be a subject of "academic inquiry" to be. . . laughable!
 
well honestly i do laugh at the christian god, its a laughable fantasy.
 
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​


What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?





Yrreg
Let me say this slowly, so you can follow it. there is no god except in the mind of it's believers. No Zeus, no Jupiter, no Odin/Woden, No Krsna, no Yahweh, No Allah, No Rama, no anything. Feel free to show us undisprovable, positive proof we are wrong and you win. Words won't do it, "Logic" proves only itself, philosophy won't hack it. Real, physical, unfaked and unfakable physical proof is what you need. And I am absolutely certain you have not one iota of that - as does no other religion's apologists. If you had it, it would have been presented long ago and still be present for the purpose.
 
Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.
And you wonder why you get laughed at?

It's up to you to support your claim that god exists. First, you've got to define what you mean by god or "concept of God accepted by Christians".

I don't deny that such a concept exists (see below for reservations), but that the concept doesn't refer to anything in the real world. (See also leprechauns, FSM, IPU, the Tooth Fairy, satyrs, flying horses, etc.)


Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?
I'm guessing you ask this question rather than defining your terms because you think it gives you an argumentative advantage.

At any rate, I know quite a lot about various Christian concepts of God. There is not one single universal concept among all Christians. They are quite varied and in some regards contradictory.

So--which one do you want to talk about? (I'm most well-versed in the Roman Catholic ideas, and I do prefer to discuss them because they're spelled out in black and white in St. Joseph's Baltimore Catechism, so when we discuss these terms theists can't go slipping back and forth using them ambiguously or changing their claims.)
 
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​


What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?





Yrreg
Sorry, left this unstated, comparing your so-called god to the FSM, IPU, lper etc. is not callin it them, just noting there is exactly the same amount of proof of their existence as there is of it's.

And, to reiterate, words/arguments can only "prove" other combinations of words/arguments. All the words and logic in the world cannot prove the nonexistence of a bird against me holding one chirping in my hand. AND...All the words and logic in the world cannot prove the existence of a "god" against the lack of presence in a physical form observable to all and demonstrating god-attributes.
 
Don't you think that the phrase "Genuine pseudo arguments" is essentially an open admission that Yrreg is trolling? It has to be a deliberate joke, surely?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom