What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.

Yrreg​


This is nothing but a straw-man arguement on your part. Moat of us who are atheists do not belittle or laugh at God, and we certainly know what the issue is about.

Ultimately, the argument comes down to the initiator of a series of cause and effect events, the first cause or uncaused cause. Those of us who are unbelievers see the universe itself (in whatever form it existed before the Big Bang) as a sufficient first cause. We see neither the need nor the evidence for a supernatural cause behind the universe itself.

Of course, it is impossible to prove a negative. Therefore the burden of proof rests on theists to demonstrate or present evidence of the existence of God. Rather than indulging in straw-man arguments and bad-mouthing us, present our evidence, and we'll talk about it.​
 
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.

1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.​

​
You know, it's almost certainly pointless engaging with this particular troll, but it struck me that the misrepresentation of the "FSM, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn" argument is actually interesting. Of course, the real form of the argument is not to say "god is a pink unicorn" but to say "why should I believe in God (for whose existence I have no evidence) any more than I would believe in an invisible pink unicorn (for whose existence I have no evidence)?" But you can actually run with yrreg's misstatement of the argument, viz:

"I posit that God is an invisible pink unicorn. Prove me wrong."

This can be expanded, of course, to the general claim that "there are no attributes that God can be proven not to have." (Prove that God is not bearded, is not a poor speaker of Finnish, is not a porcupine, is not angry at the cancellation of Firefly etc. etc.). The corollary of the argument would be that "if I cannot disprove the attribution of any qualities to an entity then I cannot prove that entity's existence, because to be known to exist is to be known to possess some attributes."

That could be more elegantly stated, but I think it works.

Yrreg--care to show how you'd set about proving that God isn't an Invisible Pink Unicorn?
 
[/indent](Prove that God is not bearded, is not a poor speaker of Finnish, is not a porcupine, is not angry at the cancellation of Firefly etc. etc.).

Any being not angry at the cancellation of Firefly is not be worthy of the label "God".
 
Last edited:
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.
Genuine pseudo arguments? Are they like brand new antiques, or boiling hot ice cubes?
1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.
Nope, that's a FAIL. I know several people have explained this before, but I'll try again. When atheists talk about leprechauns or the FSM or the IPU we are not calling any of these things god, nor are we saying that god is any of these things. What we are saying is god is analogous to these things; that there is just as much evidence (ie, none) for the existence of any god you care to name as there is evidence for leprechauns or the FSM or the IPU. There is no evidence for the existence of any of them, not for god, not for any of the others.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.
Nope, I'm afraid that is another FAIL. Atheists don't laugh at god any more than they laugh at the tooth fairy. Both of those entities fall into the category of "imaginary", they aren't funny per se. Now some atheists may well laugh at theists, and at the explanations they come up with. It's not polite but it is understandable. Frankly, if you'd give us some evidence for god that wasn't laughable, we'd stop laughing.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
That mind reading, you are doing it wrong. Atheists do know what the issues are, we just find your arguments unconvincing in the extreme. Do you have any evidence at all, yrreg? If so, please share it.
What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?

I say (as an atheist) that your contentions are false, your evidence lacking, and your arguments fallacious. But other than that, please do carry on.
 
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​

IIRC there were other "genuine pseudo arguments" as well, whataver that means...

What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?

Hmmm... And I thought that atheists and theists would make a full set...

Seriously, yrreg... I mean... Come on... You're like the skinny kid with bad eyesight that keeps kicking the school bully because he thinks that it's a paralyzed puppy...
 
Any being not angry at the cancellation of Firefly would not be worthy of the label "God".

QED

Any being unable to prevent the cancellation of Firefly is not worthy of the label "God."

Super double paradox QED burn!
 
Okay, let us just concern ourselves with the Christian God.

What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.


Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?

Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists.






Yrreg
 
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.


Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?

Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists




Yrreg


???!!!!!
 
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?
Gee, you think we are from another planet and this so-called christain god is new to us, like we have heard about it all our lives.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Yrreg. Please, for the love of all you hold dear, please read this:

Atheists don't believe in ANY god. Not in any concept of the Christian God, not in any concept of the Muslim God, the Norse Gods, the Roman Gods, the Greek Gods, the Chinese Gods, nor in any others you can think of.

We don't believe in any of them. We simply don't believe that any of them exist outside of the human imagination.

It really doesn't matter how you define your god, we still don't believe in it.
 
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Yrreg

FAIL. Atheists lack belief in god(s). Yours isn't special. It's lumped in with all the others without favoritism.

ETA: Agatha beat me to it. Oh well.

ps. We don't believe in IPU or FSM either.
 
Last edited:
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.


Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?

Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists.

What do you mean by "targeting the correct God"? "Correct" in what way? No atheist "targets" any God, because, by definition, an atheist does not believe in any God.

If you want to show that the Christian God is the "correct" God then it's up to you to provide proof of the existence of the Christian God.

You really seem to have this completely backwards, Yrreg.
 
I don't believe in any of them, therefore I don't believe in that one.
 
Last edited:
Yrreg. Please, for the love of all you hold dear, please read this:

Atheists don't believe in ANY god. Not in any concept of the Christian God, not in any concept of the Muslim God, the Norse Gods, the Roman Gods, the Greek Gods, the Chinese Gods, nor in any others you can think of.

We don't believe in any of them. We simply don't believe that any of them exist outside of the human imagination.

It really doesn't matter how you define your god, we still don't believe in it.

Well, there's two possible exceptions to that. One would be the absurdly idiosyncratic. I mean, if I said "my God is a loaf of bread with all the normal powers and properties of a loaf of bread" then you'd be willing to believe in the existence of my God.

The other is the hopelessly vague. For those who say "by God I mean Nature" there is a sense in which you have to say "okeydoke, I agree that Nature exists, and if all you mean by Nature is what anyone else means by Nature then I guess you can call it God or Arthur or Cyril or Maude or anything else you want to call it."

But I don't imagine that that's the particular card Yrreg is holding up his sleeve.
 
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

I assume you're talking about the god of the bible?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.

???

Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?

Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists.

Targeting? Are you sure there is targeting involved? If so, do you really think atheists only "target" the christian god (i.e. your god)?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom