The left definitely did claim Saddam had to stay in power. They even tried to get the sanctions dropped. Maybe they love a madman who going to stand up to the nasty West, like the Soviets did.
Yep. I've had many long, tedious exchanges with leftists over the issue of Saddam's "sovereignty". Or his supposed stabilizing influence on the fractious tribes he rode herd on. Or as a bulwark against undesirable Iranian expansionism, etc.
Competent tryrants know how to keep the Bull Left appeased.
1. existentially threaten the U.S. and Israel at every opportunity, whether credibly or not.
2. crush any uprising quickly and completely, like Saddam did the Shiites and Kurds. Do not allow an uprising to continue long enough to put the Bull Left in the awkward position of being obligated to support the uprising. After the uprising is crushed, the Bull Left will begin caterwauling at the U.S. for not rushing to the rescue, irrespective of practical limitations. Then the Bull Left will "accept reality" and assert that the tyrant is a bad man, but must not be overthrown because he is "sovereign" and is "not a threat to us".
These two simple tactics will have the left screeching like wounded banshees if the U.S. threatens to lay a hand on the cantankerous but obviously necessary tyrant.
Other tyrants, like Mubarak, are not necessary. They are mere puppets of the Merkins and the Zionists. This type of tyrant cannot escape the wrath of the Bull Left by quickly crushing an uprising, or not crushing it. Even if he's never attacked any other country. Particularly if he's never attacked Israel.
It's all very complicated, like quantum mechanics. Don't try to understand it.