What the Palestinians Really Want

Details here.

Folks -- those who are supporting the Palestinians are simply supporting genocide. Sorry to ruin the fantasies.

Amen.

Palestinians do not really want peace.

Of course people here generally will not believe this. To me, they are just as kookie as the "birthers".
 
Folks -- those who are supporting the Palestinians are simply supporting genocide.

I support the Palestinian right to a state in the West Bank and Gaza.

are you accusing me of supporting genocide against my own people?
 
I did

It appears you're OK with the idea of "convert to my religion and we won't kill you" I'm not.

You must have read someone else's posts.
I've not said I'm okay with anything. And I've not characterised Hamas' position in that way. I have said they want to create an Islamic state, where other religions will live 'under the wing of Islam'. I'm not okay with that, and I've not said I'm okay with it. What I have said is that it is not genocide.

Tell me what you think "the realisation of Allah's promise" means in this context FireGarden. I eagerly await the mental gymnastics necessary to explain how this doesn't actually mean "killing the Jews", even though that's what it actually says.

The context is the whole document. Repeating the one part of it over and over does not help you.

I tried to make that clear with some quotes from the IRA's Green Book:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6520505&postcount=177
 
You must have read someone else's posts.
I've not said I'm okay with anything. And I've not characterised Hamas' position in that way. I have said they want to create an Islamic state, where other religions will live 'under the wing of Islam'. I'm not okay with that, and I've not said I'm okay with it. What I have said is that it is not genocide.

Under the wing of Islam are weasel words. What, exactly, do they mean by that and given the brutality of Hamas, do you think there's much of a difference between this and forcing conversions ?

Genocide is one of those difficult words. In popular understanding it's meaning is to kill off an entire population or at least kill enough members of that population so the survivors become refugees. Now, we're being treated to meanings like Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group. If we go with the causing serious mental harm aspect, then yes, we can use genocide as a term applicable to both sides in this conflict.

Personally, I like the "old',popular definition better and think that applying it in the context of this conflict is nothing more than hyperbole. But, sometimes, you gotta go with the flow, suck it up, and use it. even if it is retarded.
 
Last edited:
Peace as a 2 state solution, Israel overwhelmingly supports. Polls have supported this as stated ad nauseum. The poll provided earlier paints a different picture for the Palestinians (also provided) as the 2 state solution that would eventually see a 1 state solution.

No attempt at moral equivalence works here DC. Tried and failed n+1
 
Peace as a 2 state solution, Israel overwhelmingly supports. Polls have supported this as stated ad nauseum. The poll provided earlier paints a different picture for the Palestinians (also provided) as the 2 state solution that would eventually see a 1 state solution.

No attempt at moral equivalence works here DC. Tried and failed n+1

From the likud party platform...

http://www.knesset.gov.il/elections/knesset15/elikud_m.htm

"The Government of Israel flatly rejects the establishment of a Palestinian Arab state west of the Jordan river."

peace is a 2 state solution bigjell?
 
Describe what the passage I cited means, in your interpretation.

The IRA has squat to do with it.

Yes, that's right. The IRA had nothing to do with it -- 'it' being something or other.

What I'm talking about, and the reason the IRA's Green book was relevent, is words being taken out of context.

As I've said before, but you seem to like repetition, regarding the passage you quote:
It means Hamas think they are fighting a battle which was foretold and they are promised victory. They also expect a miracle to help them out.

In your interpretation, why do Hamas quote (in that same charter) verse 60:8 from the Quran?
http://www.sacred-texts.com/isl/quran/06002.htm

Doesn't that mean, if they wish to have the love of God, that they have to act justly towards those who didn't fight them?

Compare that to what the IRA said in their Green Book.

Describe to me what this means, in your interpretation:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Gr...manual)#Military_objectives_in_the_Green_Book

But with the possible exceptions of the Brit Ministers in the 'Northern Ireland Office' and certain members of the judiciary, the overtly unarmed branches of the establishment are not so clearly identifiable to the people as our enemies as say armed Brits or R.U.C.

[...] By now it is clear that our task is not only to kill as many enemy personnel as possible...

They clearly state their enemy are not merely the armed variety. And they state their intention to kill as many as possible. What does it mean? Taken literally, it means they are going to kill and kill and kill. As long as Britain has an 'establishment', members of it will be killed.

Do you call it genocidal? I wouldn't. But I don't see how you can avoid it if all you're going to do is read snippets here and there and ignore everything else.
 
It means Hamas think they are fighting a battle which was foretold and they are promised victory. They also expect a miracle to help them out.
A battle against Jews, not just "zionists". The Covenant also proclaims that Palestine is exclusively for Muslims, others will have to live elsewhere if they want to live.

In your interpretation, why do Hamas quote (in that same charter) verse 60:8 from the Quran?
http://www.sacred-texts.com/isl/quran/06002.htm
And what does that mean to Hamas?

Doesn't that mean, if they wish to have the love of God, that they have to act justly towards those who didn't fight them?
What does "justly" mean to Hamas? Do you think it means the same to them as it does to you?

But thanks for at least making an attempt to explain why the Hamas Covenant doesn't really mean what it plainly says.

Ignoring the irrelevant bits about the IRA. Hamas is not the IRA.
 
A battle against Jews, not just "zionists". The Covenant also proclaims that Palestine is exclusively for Muslims, others will have to live elsewhere if they want to live.

The covenent talks of all religions living under the wing of Islam. But you know that. It's been pointed out to you before. We even discussed it, and how 'under' is not the same as 'alongside'.

And what does that mean to Hamas?

It must mean as much as the other things in their charter.

But thanks for at least making an attempt to explain why the Hamas Covenant doesn't really mean what it plainly says.

Thanks for continuing this monthly tradition of ignoring everything except what suits you. eg:

Ignoring the irrelevant bits about the IRA. Hamas is not the IRA.

I explained the relevence, and it was not about comparing the IRA to Hamas. It was about illustrating how I knew you could not be consistent and limit analysis of the Green Book to what I quoted.

But I'm sure you knew that.
 
The covenent talks of all religions living under the wing of Islam. But you know that. It's been pointed out to you before. We even discussed it, and how 'under' is not the same as 'alongside'.
Even under the most liberalinterpretation of taht, you're talking about an actuial apartheid state (unlike the pretend one the wingnuts claim Israel is), with civil rights dependent on whiat your religion is.

But even under this interpretation, those who don't submit will be killed, yes?

It must mean as much as the other things in their charter.
Avoidance noted. I'll ask again: What does taht mean to Hamas?


Thanks for continuing this monthly tradition of ignoring everything except what suits you. eg:
If you squint just right Hamas wants only to kill the Jews who don't submit to the will of Islam, or who demand the most basic of human rights.

Real humanitarians these guys are!

I explained the relevence, and it was not about comparing the IRA to Hamas. It was about illustrating how I knew you could not be consistent and limit analysis of the Green Book to what I quoted.

But I'm sure you knew that.
Explain it all you want, it's completely irrelevant. Hamas and the IRA are not motivated by the same things. The mafia is a much closer comparison to the IRA than Hamas is.
 
more lies.
You can stamp your little feet and pout and cry all you like, doesn't change the facts.

Hamas Covenant said:
The Islamic Resistance Movement believes that the land of Palestine is an Islamic Waqf consecrated for future Moslem generations until Judgement Day. It, or any part of it, should not be squandered: it, or any part of it, should not be given up. Neither a single Arab country nor all Arab countries, neither any king or president, nor all the kings and presidents, neither any organization nor all of them, be they Palestinian or Arab, possess the right to do that. Palestine is an Islamic Waqf land consecrated for Moslem generations until Judgement Day. This being so, who could claim to have the right to represent Moslem generations till Judgement Day?
 
You can stamp your little feet and pout and cry all you like, doesn't change the facts.

how about you back-up your pathetic claim that Hamas wants all Jews and Christians to leave Palestine, even if the land comes under Hamas control.

prove that Hamas wants a Palestine for Muslims ONLY.

its a pathetic lie and you know it. you simply hope no one will call you on it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom