What the Palestinians Really Want

again, please cite the international law which states that the Israelis are entitled to all the land from the river to the sea.

Since nobody made that claim I see no reason anyone should cite anything to support it, much less me.

That's what I meant by substandard. Astounding, really, that you needed that pointed out.

ETA: and for this quality of discourse, you go back on ignore.
 
Excellent, thank you. :)

um..do you know what Mossad does? along with assassinating supposed and unconvicted terror suspects, they provide counter-intelligence and disinformation.

WTF should I trust a media organization that has tied to such an organization?

if MEMRI wants my trust, they need to drop anyone that has ever had any connection to the Mossad or any other Israeli intelligence group.

I mean, we are supposed to be skeptics, are we not?

would YOU trust a media outlet that had functional ties to the CIA, MI6, the ISI?????? I sure hope not.

I mean honestly, Wildcat thinks that the UN and media in Lebanon has been infiltrated by Hezbollah, but we KNOW that MEMRI has connections to Mossad. Yet for SOME reason, you wanna give MEMRI a full pass, and still be suspicous of the UN. why could that be?

why might that be? hmmm.....
 
Last edited:
um..do you know what Mossad does? along with assassinating supposed and unconvicted terror suspects, they provide counter-intelligence and disinformation.

WTF should I trust a media organization that has tied to such an organization?

if MEMRI wants my trust, they need to drop anyone that has ever had any connection to the Mossad or any other Israeli intelligence group.

I mean, we are supposed to be skeptics, are we not?

would YOU trust a media outlet that had functional ties to the CIA, MI6, the ISI?????? I sure hope not.

I mean honestly, Wildcat thinks that the UN and media in Lebanon has been infiltrated by Hezbollah, but we KNOW that MEMRI has connections to Mossad. Yet for SOME reason, you wanna give MEMRI a full pass, and still be suspicous of the UN. why could that be?

why might that be? hmmm.....

for many here, it appears that anything that casts israel in a bad light is automatically dismissed as lies, while anything that casts the palestinians in a bad light is embraced as undeniable truth.
 
um..do you know what Mossad does? along with assassinating supposed and unconvicted terror suspects, they provide counter-intelligence and disinformation.

WTF should I trust a media organization that has tied to such an organization?

if MEMRI wants my trust, they need to drop anyone that has ever had any connection to the Mossad or any other Israeli intelligence group.

I mean, we are supposed to be skeptics, are we not?

would YOU trust a media outlet that had functional ties to the CIA, MI6, the ISI?????? I sure hope not.

I mean honestly, Wildcat thinks that the UN and media in Lebanon has been infiltrated by Hezbollah, but we KNOW that MEMRI has connections to Mossad. Yet for SOME reason, you wanna give MEMRI a full pass, and still be suspicous of the UN. why could that be?

why might that be? hmmm.....
All of that is completely irrelevant Thunder. The video isn't muted, any English speaker who is also fluent in Arabic can check the translation.

AFAIK, no one has claimed the translation of this video is in error or mistranslated.

You see Thunder, to a skeptic the evidence speaks for itself. Your handwaving it away the same way truthers handwave away OBL videos speaks volumes about your critical thinking skills.
 
You see Thunder, to a skeptic the evidence speaks for itself. Your handwaving it away the same way truthers handwave away OBL videos speaks volumes about your critical thinking skills.

and how, Wildcat, do you justify your handwaving away of anything the UN or Lebanese media has to say about Hezbollah?

gut instinct?

woman's intuition?

6th sense?
 
for many here, it appears that anything that casts israel in a bad light is automatically dismissed as lies, while anything that casts the palestinians in a bad light is embraced as undeniable truth.
Are you going to claim the video is faked?

How would you feel about an Israeli government official on video talking about how all Muslims will be expelled from Israel, would you be so flippant about that?
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United...42#French_version_vs._English_version_of_text

"Withdrawal of Israel armed forces from territories occupied in the recent conflict"

That can be interpreted as some of the territories, rather than all. Fair enough. It is ambiguous. Strange how you don't see the same some/all ambiguity in the Hamas charter, even after other quotes are given which speak of Jews living under Islam. One would think such quotes would remove the ambiguity and clarify that only some Jews would be killed in the fighting.

Since that sentence from UN242 is ambiguous, you give some quotes in the linked thread on this ground:

I’d get into an argument over it, and it really does seem as though you would argue it at a much higher level than others on this forum have in the past, but for now I’ll table it with the understanding that at least your accepting that there is an argument to be made is a tacit agreement that Palestinians are not “entitled” to everything and that “international law” is not as definitive on the subject as you first seemed to believe.



BTW, wiki also says: "During a symposium on the subject Lord Caradon said that Israel was in clear defiance of resolution 242. He specifically cited the "annexation of East Jerusalem" and "the creeping colonialism on the West Bank and in Gaza and in the Golan.""

I thought you'd be interested in that, seeing as you value what the authors of 242 say

Certainly. It would make no sense to cite him when he says something you like and then repudiate him when he says something you don’t like. I would imagine he doesn’t like the Israeli annexation of East Jerusalem because it was done unilaterally and not as part of a negotiated agreement. In exactly the same way all other borders need to be negotiated, and not merely assumed.
 
With or without the Mossad MEMRI will be what it is, an Israeli propaganda site. I've been unable to find anyone critical of their translations so I have to trust that they're correct.

Would I trust that they're giving me the whole unbiased story ? No way.
 
and how, Wildcat, do you justify your handwaving away of anything the UN or Lebanese media has to say about Hezbollah?

gut instinct?

woman's intuition?

6th sense?
Your premise is a lie, though I do enjoy seeing you flail about so.

You may actually be better off posting smilies... as Abraham Lincoln once said "It is better to say nothing and be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt."
 
With or without the Mossad MEMRI will be what it is, an Israeli propaganda site. I've been unable to find anyone critical of their translations so I have to trust that they're correct.

Would I trust that they're giving me the whole unbiased story ? No way.
All videos are sourced as to the broadcast date and station. Everything can be checked out. The video I linked to was from Al Aqsa TV, as broadcast on November 5, 2010. And it's a 5 minute clip, not a 10 second snippet taken out of context.
 
All videos are sourced as to the broadcast date and station. Everything can be checked out.

Good. When I find the time, I will show them to my Egyptian co-worker.

until then, I don't trust MEMRI any further than I can drop them down a well.
 
How would you feel about an Israeli government official on video talking about how all Muslims will be expelled from Israel, would you be so flippant about that?

I'd happily make a thread about it, and you would surely disregard it as an insane nutcase who has no real authority or legitimacy. You might even accuse him of being a self-hating double-agent.
 
Last edited:
All videos are sourced as to the broadcast date and station. Everything can be checked out. The video I linked to was from Al Aqsa TV, as broadcast on November 5, 2010. And it's a 5 minute clip, not a 10 second snippet taken out of context.

Yes, I watched it. I even cranked up the volume for full effect even though I don't speak the language. MEMRI even provided a transcript, which I matched up to the subtitles in the video just to see if they were trying to pull a fast one there.

Nope.
 
This is merely equivocating for the fact that it's an attempt to paint me as sympathetic with Hamas - ie, character assassination. Deal with it.

You misuse the term "equivocating", but that’s not important.

It is an attempt to portray Atlanta Palestine Solidarity and the ISM as sympathetic with Hamas, but those groups are sympathetic with Hamas. If their character is assassinated over it, it their fault for being sympathetic with Hamas, not mine, Skeptics or anyone else’s fault for pointing it out.

Oh sure, I bet if you talked to individual members they would express reservations Hamas, how they’re too religious or not on board enough with the “greater cause”, but in the end they’re still the romantic figures, the Che Gueveras of the modern age who are putting their lives on the line to strike out against their “oppressors”,

Uh....No, you're completely wrong here. APS was no more a "sub-group" of the ISM than it was a "sub-group" of the American Friends Service Committee or the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee.

That may be your opinion, but having looked over the materials associated with both organizations, I believe they are very similar as far as goals and outlook. If you would like to point out differences, I’d be happy to listen to the experience of an insider.

But thank you for essentially admitting that your goal is to draw "associations" whether or not they are based in reality.

Pathetic.

No, I’m only interested in the associations that are based on reality. I invite you to participate in that discussion because I know your personal experience would bring a lot of information to the table, but I’d suggest you set aside this ridiculous “you’re bad just for raising the issue” nonsense.
 
This is merely equivocating for the fact that it's an attempt to paint me as sympathetic with Hamas - ie, character assassination.

Join the club. Today I've been compared to 9-11 Truthers and called a Hamas apologist. Personal attacks is the only card these guys have. It says soooooooo much more about them, than it says about us.

Cheers mate...and keep fighting the good fight. You know we have the facts and justice on our side.
 
Last edited:
It is an attempt to portray Atlanta Palestine Solidarity and the ISM as sympathetic with Hamas, but those groups are sympathetic with Hamas.

Hah...No. Repeating the lie doesn't magically make it true. Sorry.

That may be your opinion,
Not opinion. Fact. One of us is in a position to know this in absolute certainty; that person is not you.

but having looked over the materials associated with both organizations,
Not particularly carefully, apparently.

I believe they are very similar as far as goals and outlook. If you would like to point out differences, I’d be happy to listen to the experience of an insider.
Even if that were true, "similar as far as goals and outlook" does not a "sub-group" make. You're backpedalling.

No, I’m only interested in the associations that are based on reality.
And yet, you continue to perpetuate associations that are not.

I invite you to participate in that discussion because I know your personal experience would bring a lot of information to the table, but I’d suggest you set aside this ridiculous “you’re bad just for raising the issue” nonsense.
And yet, when the information I provide conflicts with your preconceived notions, you dismiss it out of hand.

If you're not going to approach the subject with an open mind and will simply believe whatever you want to anyway, then why, exactly, should I bother?
 
Last edited:
Hah...No. Repeating the lie doesn't magically make it true. Sorry.

dude, don't hold your breath waiting for these guys to use facts rather than lies. Lies and personal attacks is all they got.

oh, and baseless claims. those too.

and backtracking from those claims. and watering them down to a state that might be able to be justified.
 
A battle against Jews, not just "zionists". The Covenant also proclaims that Palestine is exclusively for Muslims, others will have to live elsewhere if they want to live.

still waiting for evidence that Hamas will kill, exile, or convert ANY non-Muslims in Palestine..once Hamas rules it all.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom