"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

So supply has nothing to do with price ? Interesting.
Sigh. No, increased supply of houses reduces cost of obtaining housing.

But that's not why housing prices suddenly dropped off a cliff. The sad fact is, as the total supply of housing increased over the preceding decade, prices went up. They went up because, despite the increase of housing acting to reduce the cost of housing, the cost of land was rising rapidly in a speculative bubble. Capisci?

There has to be a link somewhere to define the term "popped bubble" in economics... ?
? I this a question or a statement? It terminates in a question mark, yet there's no question asked.

And yet you seem uninterested in why said demand drops ?
No, I've already explained why it dropped: the economy is over-indebted and can not sustain the current level of debt.

Check out this link

Yeah, just like there is an arbitrary division between a Ford Focus and an Audi. Car is car.
Sigh. And if you're talking about the supply of cars, both Foci (hehe) and Audis count. Duh.
 

Oh, my. You're using Italian instead of English in order to get your point across. I guess I should be impressed... or something.

? I this a question or a statement? It terminates in a question mark, yet there's no question asked.

Oh, yes there is. What's a popped bubble, in economics ?

Sigh. And if you're talking about the supply of cars, both Foci (hehe) and Audis count. Duh.

Really ? So if, say, the supply of Ford Focus dropped dramatically, you'd think Audis would cost more ? Most people already can't afford them. They're not even targeted at the same market.

But, hey, whatever makes you happy. And simplifying things often does. That's why so many people spew out things like "everything's connected" or some other new-age nonsense. It makes it easier to understand the universe when you only have one thing to retain from it. :cool:
 
Oh, my. You're using Italian instead of English in order to get your point across. I guess I should be impressed... or something.
Did you comprehend the words I wrote or not?

Oh, yes there is. What's a popped bubble, in economics ?
Are you looking for some technical definition, or do you simply want me to explain what one is?

Yes. Obviously.

So if, say, the supply of Ford Focus dropped dramatically, you'd think Audis would cost more ? Most people already can't afford them. They're not even targeted at the same market.
If the supply of cars drops, the prices will probably rise, yes. Consider: even though they're targeted to different markets, the various markets are gradients.

But, hey, whatever makes you happy. And simplifying things often does. That's why so many people spew out things like "everything's connected" or some other new-age nonsense. It makes it easier to understand the universe when you only have one thing to retain from it. :cool:
Depending on how you mean it, everything obviously is connected. Everything in existence is the result of a single event that transpired 15 billion years ago or so.
 
I don't know, but after the Great Plague the survivors inherited a world of abundance with less mouths to feed and more bargaining power for labour.

This Depression, which may never end due to a permanently shrinking energy supply, is also likely to drastically reduce the human population but the survivors will live much more frugally than during our passing age of illusionary fossil-fuel based "abundance".

And Jihad Jane denies she wants a return to the Middle Ages.
I admit, I am curious as to what has driven Jane to such a absolute,irrational hatred of Modern Society.
 
Did you comprehend the words I wrote or not?

The "capisci" one, or the rest ?

Are you looking for some technical definition, or do you simply want me to explain what one is?

The first one.

If the supply of cars drops, the prices will probably rise, yes. Consider: even though they're targeted to different markets, the various markets are gradients.

I'm sorry, but I doubt that. Sure enough, all markets are, in the end, connected, but I don't think that shortage in the Focus will increase Audi demands. In fact, I think it won't.

Depending on how you mean it, everything obviously is connected. Everything in existence is the result of a single event that transpired 15 billion years ago or so.

Conceded. I was just bringing the silliness to its logical conclusion. However, the new agers don't mean it that way.
 
But that's not why housing prices suddenly dropped off a cliff. The sad fact is, as the total supply of housing increased over the preceding decade, prices went up. They went up because, despite the increase of housing acting to reduce the cost of housing, the cost of land was rising rapidly in a speculative bubble. Capisci?


I'm not sure if anyone pointed this out to you (I'm not following your back and forth) but the price of "land" wasn't rising so much as the price of "housing". Residential land was increasing very quickly but agricultural land remained fairly steady. This suggests it wasn't the price of land, but the price of the dwelling on that land that was part of the speculative bubble.
 
The "capisci" one, or the rest ?
The stuff I wrote immediately prior to the word "capisci."

The first one.
I don't know that there's a definition for a bubble burst; that concept is obvious enough when you understand the term bubble. A definition for bubble can be found here.

I'm sorry, but I doubt that. Sure enough, all markets are, in the end, connected, but I don't think that shortage in the Focus will increase Audi demands. In fact, I think it won't.
Well, that's nice, but unless you have some reasoning for that belief, it's not worth a lot, is it?

None of this is very instructive, because land isn't like cars. Cars are supplied, whereas the supply of land is fixed. A better example would be Rembrandts: like land, they're fixed in supply and will be priced according to demand.

Conceded. I was just bringing the silliness to its logical conclusion. However, the new agers don't mean it that way.
I don't really understand what silliness you're referring to. Supply and demand don't strike me as particularly silly.
 
drkitten, Free Thinkr - stop the bickering. Attack the argument, not the arguer.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 
I'm not sure if anyone pointed this out to you (I'm not following your back and forth) but the price of "land" wasn't rising so much as the price of "housing".

That's exactly what I pointed out to him; he simply denies it.

Residential land was increasing very quickly but agricultural land remained fairly steady. This suggests it wasn't the price of land, but the price of the dwelling on that land that was part of the speculative bubble.
 
Off-topic posts and bickering moved to AAH.

Keep it civil from now on please.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode

There seems to have been some misunderstanding. This warning by Gaspode was intended to mean that bickering in this thread should stop, not just pause briefly to reboot.

Would it be clearer if infractions were added for emphasis?
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
I'm not sure if anyone pointed this out to you (I'm not following your back and forth) but the price of "land" wasn't rising so much as the price of "housing". Residential land was increasing very quickly but agricultural land remained fairly steady. This suggests it wasn't the price of land, but the price of the dwelling on that land that was part of the speculative bubble.
Office space, and bare land zoned for commercial or residential increased accordingly. I don't have any data immediately handy for the US, but I can show this to be the case in the UK. From this article by Fred Harrison:
pricegraph.jpg


What happens is this: the market for housing and office space heats up. Because land is fixed in supply, that means that the land under existing homes or businesses increases in value; this increase in value makes the owners of that land more wealthy, so they have more to spend. That, in turn, increases prices still more, giving still more money to landowners (this time including new landowners from the first go-round), leaving prices to rise still more. On and on it goes; it doesn't stop until the prices are far beyond reasonable rates of return (a bubble forms). Once debt is maxed out, people realize what has happened, and the bubble pops.

I imagine that agricultural land is already monopolized in the hands of too few, and there's too little turnover, for such a bubble to form for agricultural land in our market.
 
That's exactly what I pointed out to him; he simply denies it.


Oh, well it is fairly well documented. In fact, the price of "land" has gone down in the last 5-10 years, at least on a per acre basis.

saw your post FT: I'm not sure if this applies to NA in the same manner. I know of several "wealthy" farmers in this area who were begged to purchase land at a heavily discounted rate. Due to the zoning, much of the land was worthless in parcels less than 200 acres. There's no way to make money here without owning more than 1000-1500 acres. At that point, an additional 200 acres can be of benefit, if it has the right drainage, access etc. Amazing how they can take off 200 acres in a few hours these days.

and: A quick Google of land prices in this area saw a drastic increase from 1995-1999 then it levelled off.
 
Last edited:
Oh, well it is fairly well documented. In fact, the price of "land" has gone down in the last 5-10 years, at least on a per acre basis.
Again, agricultural land doesn't tell the story. If you dispute that it's the land that's been increasing, simply undertake the following mental exercise:

As we both agree, the prices of "housing" have been rising rapidly over the last decade. Imagine one such area where prices were rising rapidly (as the increases weren't uniform). Say you have a neighborhood, and the average price of the houses in that neighborhood increased from $200,000 to $250,000 in two years. Now imagine that, during that time, one of the houses burned to the ground. Do you think the value of the lot in that neighborhood would have:

A) decreased
B) stayed about the same
C) increased by 25% or more

? I think it's pretty obvious that the land would have increased by more than 25%. The increase in value wasn't owing to houses: houses could still be constructed for about the same cost, and the houses themselves depreciate. The increase is owing to the cost associated with getting a site in an area where there's work opportunities, schools, and the like.

Found this while previewing:
saw your post FT: I'm not sure if this applies to NA in the same manner. I know of several "wealthy" farmers in this area who were begged to purchase land at a heavily discounted rate. Due to the zoning, much of the land was worthless in parcels less than 200 acres. There's no way to make money here without owning more than 1000-1500 acres. At that point, an additional 200 acres can be of benefit, if it has the right drainage, access etc. Amazing how they can take off 200 acres in a few hours these days.
Consider the fact that the farming industry -as presently constituted- is dependent on subsidies, and do the math.

and: A quick Google of land prices in this area saw a drastic increase from 1995-1999 then it levelled off.
Ag. land?
 
Again, agricultural land doesn't tell the story. If you dispute that it's the land that's been increasing, simply undertake the following mental exercise:

As we both agree, the prices of "housing" have been rising rapidly over the last decade. Imagine one such area where prices were rising rapidly (as the increases weren't uniform). Say you have a neighborhood, and the average price of the houses in that neighborhood increased from $200,000 to $250,000 in two years. Now imagine that, during that time, one of the houses burned to the ground. Do you think the value of the lot in that neighborhood would have:

A) decreased
B) stayed about the same
C) increased by 25% or more

? I think it's pretty obvious that the land would have increased by more than 25%. The increase in value wasn't owing to houses: houses could still be constructed for about the same cost, and the houses themselves depreciate. The increase is owing to the cost associated with getting a site in an area where there's work opportunities, schools, and the like.

Found this while previewing:

Consider the fact that the farming industry -as presently constituted- is dependent on subsidies, and do the math.


Ag. land?


I see what you are saying but the "residential" zoning makes or breaks the property value. If the lot is re-zoned agricultural it becomes worthless. The opposite effect is also in play, agricultural land re-zoned residential sky rockets. The lot is only worth the house you can build or not build on it. Which leads to the housing prices being the key factor, not the land itself.

Yes, agricultural land went through the boom in the mid to late 90's here. Whithout research it's hard to say if this was a result of city folk investing in it or farming practises (fertilizer and implements) getting better.
 
http://multimedia.thestar.com/images/4e/21/a26d33a14878a89963afa766ecde.jpeg

Do not hotlink images from another site - see Rule 4.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode


Good read

Economists debate using the D-word

What's a depression is, or whether we're facing one, depends on who you ask

Mar 02, 2009 04:06 PM

Tom Raum
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
Daniel Wagner

WASHINGTON – A Depression doesn't have to be Great – bread lines, rampant unemployment, a wipeout in the stock market. The economy can sink into a milder depression, the kind spelled with a lowercase ``d."
And it may be happening now.
continues
http://www.thestar.com/business/article/595293
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I see what you are saying but the "residential" zoning makes or breaks the property value.
For any given parcel of land. But for land as a whole the rent is what it is, and zoning only determines the relative amount each given lot gets.

See what I'm saying?

If the lot is re-zoned agricultural it becomes worthless. The opposite effect is also in play, agricultural land re-zoned residential sky rockets. The lot is only worth the house you can build or not build on it. Which leads to the housing prices being the key factor, not the land itself.
Not at all, mon frère!

The land is the key factor. Land zoned agricultural is worth less because the usage of the land is artificially restricted by the government. But the value of all land, regardless of zoning, is demand-driven; as I said above, zoning just determines which parcels get the rent.

Yes, agricultural land went through the boom in the mid to late 90's here. Whithout research it's hard to say if this was a result of city folk investing in it or farming practises (fertilizer and implements) getting better.
Probably the latter. I'd also look into changes in the farm bill around that time.
 
Imagine one such area where prices were rising rapidly (as the increases weren't uniform). Say you have a neighborhood, and the average price of the houses in that neighborhood increased from $200,000 to $250,000 in two years. Now imagine that, during that time, one of the houses burned to the ground. Do you think the value of the lot in that neighborhood would have:

A) decreased
B) stayed about the same
C) increased by 25% or more

? I think it's pretty obvious that the land would have increased by more than 25%. The increase in value wasn't owing to houses: houses could still be constructed for about the same cost, and the houses themselves depreciate. The increase is owing to the cost associated with getting a site in an area where there's work opportunities, schools, and the like.
The increase in lot value was owing to houses. It doesn't matter what the cost of building the house is (although builders are easily able to inflate their labour costs in a housing boom so that probably rises too, and so are cement manufacturers probably, and lumber merchants etc.). The lot value is higher because a house with a $250,000 market value can be built there. If the council decided to slap on a ruling that the burned down lot could no longer be used to build housing, the lot value would be lower. And in that scenario, location value would have been separated (confiscated) from land value.

No matter how many times you try this point, there remain holes all over it.
 
The stuff I wrote immediately prior to the word "capisci."

I'm sorry. All that was lost in the Italian.

I don't know that there's a definition for a bubble burst; that concept is obvious enough when you understand the term bubble. A definition for bubble can be found here.

Oh, no, no. Not "burst". "Popped".

Well, that's nice, but unless you have some reasoning for that belief, it's not worth a lot, is it?

Right back at you.

None of this is very instructive, because land isn't like cars.

No, indeed. Just like apples and oranges are neither like land or like cars. For some reason, however, people keep using them in analogies. Curse them!

I don't really understand what silliness you're referring to. Supply and demand don't strike me as particularly silly.

No, of course not. I was talking about some people's need to make things simpler in order to feel like they understand them. But, carry on.
 
The increase in lot value was owing to houses.
No, it wasn't.

It doesn't matter what the cost of building the house is (although builders are easily able to inflate their labour costs in a housing boom so that probably rises too, and so are cement manufacturers probably, and lumber merchants etc.). The lot value is higher because a house with a $250,000 market value can be built there.
?? A house with a $10,000,000 can be built there, or just about anywhere. The value of the lot is higher because of the services and infrastructure provided by government, the opportunities and amenities provided by society, and the physical qualities provided by nature.

If the council decided to slap on a ruling that the burned down lot could no longer be used to build housing, the lot value would be lower.
Duh. All you're saying here is "if the council slapped a ruling that said the land could not be put to its highest and best use, it'd be worth less."

Of course. And it won't be worth anything at all if the council slaps a ruling on it such that it can't be used at all!

And in that scenario, location value would have been separated (confiscated) from land value.
Separated from land? No, it would simply be done away with by prohibiting maximal use.

No matter how many times you try this point, there remain holes all over it.
No, you just continuously try to deny the obvious: that it's land values that increased. You will go to any length at all to deny that fact, because it proves your beliefs false.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom