"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

And, in a single sentence, Free Thinkr demonstrates how thoroughly I devastated him and how thoroughly out-of-touch this theory is; he -- or his theory -- can't address the fundamental difference between buying and leasing.
I wanted to come back to this. Let us note that here, drkitten is claiming that, because of my fundamental failure to address the difference between buying and leasing, he has thoroughly devastated my point.

But is this the case?

Let's have a look once more at how we got here:
drkitten said:
Right. More buyers for the same physical houses.
Me said:
Actually, the supply of housing increased considerably. But the supply of land didn't, so prices rose.
It is clear from my reply that the price paid for land -or land value- increased because the supply is fixed and demand increased.

Does it matter whether this land is purchased, rented, or leased? No. Far from "devastating" my point, this is nothing more than a red herring. Whether landowners are renting, leasing, or selling their land, increased demand means greater land rents (higher land values).

Wait until I introduce him to other rights that can be bought and sold -- water rights, airspace rights, mineral rights, logging rights, easements. All of which are property rights, none of which are "land."
What is the nature of these things? I say that each of these things are restrictions of rights to the providence of nature for some, for the benefit of exclusive use by others. The nature of land titles is the same. Factually, mineral rights are in no way fundamentally different from land rights; governments simply arbitrarily choose to treat them differently. In point of fact, mineral rights in the US are quite different from mineral rights in Australia.

But all these things describe the providence of nature, which has been regulated by society in some way such that the liberty to use the resources is restricted for some for the benefit of others. The nature of Georgism is to internalize for government revenue the value owing to the providence of nature, the synergistic efforts of society, and government spending. It's just common sense once you understand it.
 
It is clear from my reply that the price paid for land -or land value- increased because the supply is fixed and demand increased.

And, once again, you're simply wrong. And you can see this all the time in history when people or developers overbuild, and rents fall as a result.

As you point out, the supply of land is fixed -- but the supply of housing depends on how much is built on the land. If you put too many units on the land and oversupply the market, you're not going to be able to fill your units and the prices will drop.

A simple thought experiment will confirm this; assume that both land supply and demand for housing remain fixed. There's enough demand for housing in the $100,000 range to ensure, say, five sales per month. The local developers find some cheap single-family homes (ten of them), rip them down, and put in high-end high-rise condos instead (adding enough luxuries that the nominal price remains the same). So we've just replaced ten single-family homes with 100 condos.

For simplicity, we've got ten developers -- each now trying to flog off 10 condos.

Obviously, the people whose houses were used will buy the first ten units.
Equally obviously, there are five new purchase to expect this month. So we can probably sell 15 of the condos. But who gets to sell them? If we hold the line on our prices, we'll each sell one or two of them by random chance. But if I drop my price, say, to $90,000, I can sell all ten of mine out. Anyone who holds the line on housing is likely out in the cold.

But that's just saying that I have increased the supply of housing and so the price dropped, in accordance with the law of supply and demand. Hopefully as condo prices drop, more people will be willing to buy a condo at $90K than at $100K so that we can at least not be sitting around with unsold units.

But notice that it's not the land that was oversupplied.

Values for housing and values for land are separate. In fact, with this little demand (and this much oversupply), I suspect prices will drop precipitously.

And this is a well-known and well-understood phenomenon. It's so common, it even has a term : overbuilding. (And overbuilding was a real problem in the commercial real estate market in the 1980s0. If, as you suggest, the value is in land and not in housing, how is it even possible to overbuild?

On the other hand, if, at the same time that the developers were frantically building all these condo, lots of people were moving into the area, so that the market for new housing jumped to 150 units/month, then we can all sell out our inventories and there will still be people who want housing. In this case, of course, I can raise my prices.

In this second case, supply of land remained constant, supply of housing went up, but demand of housing went up even higher -- hence rising prices.

Which is exactly what happened in the recent housing bubble.

Whether landowners are renting, leasing, or selling their land, increased demand means greater land rents (higher land values).

If there is increased demand for land then the value of land will go up. If there is increased demand for housing, then the price of land may actually go down, if the amoung of housing per unit of land goes up fast enough.

So, no. Again.

I say that each of these things are restrictions of rights to the providence of nature for some, for the benefit of exclusive use by others.

Yes, we know that's what you say. But we also know that what you say is complete bollocks.

That's the part that you don't realize. The words you use are grammatical. They even are sometimes semantically interpretable. They're simply, tragically, utterly, completely, and beyond the capacity of mere error wrong.
 
Off-topic posts and bickering moved to AAH.

Keep it civil from now on please.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 
Could you clarify this for me? As usual, this seems to be centered around the US or perhaps NA. These days a depression would have to take on a more Global meaning wouldn't it? If China rebounds and continues to grow at 10% per year like they were, Cananda remains insulated from the effects of any US slowdown as we remain a large exporter to China.

China's economy is rapidly contracting, triggering widespread civil unrest. Their wheat crop is failing due to a fungus, which will probably lead to famine. On balance Canada is probably ******, too, if it is depending on trade with China to "insulate" it from global economic collapse.

Likewise the "Great Depression" seems to pale in comparison to the plagues in the 1400's and 1700's. I'm not really a Historian, but these must have caused an econmic depression during those eras.


I don't know, but after the Great Plague the survivors inherited a world of abundance with less mouths to feed and more bargaining power for labour.

This Depression, which may never end due to a permanently shrinking energy supply, is also likely to drastically reduce the human population but the survivors will live much more frugally than during our passing age of illusionary fossil-fuel based "abundance".
 
Last edited by a moderator:
China's economy is rapidly contracting
This must be some new meaning of "rapidly contracting" of which I was previously unaware.

Personally, I think an 8% year-on-year increase in GDP should be called "growth", not "contraction".
http://news.google.com/news?q=china%20gdp%20growth&naughty_word=axminster

Of course, if you have any evidence to the contrary, I'd love to see it :D

I don't know, but after the Great Plague the survivors inherited a world of abundance with less mouths to feed and more bargaining power for labour.
After the plague there was more bargaining power for labour because there was a shortage of labourers. If you take some suppliers out of a market, it tends to strengthen the hand of the remaining suppliers, right?

The labouring classes produced food. Food isn't some fixed quantity that falls from the sky to be divided up among the existing population. Food has to be produced by certain people, and the plague hit these people very badly. Crops failed due to labour shortages. The plague caused severe food shortages and massive food price increases. There were famines. Not a world of abundance.

This Depression, which may never end due to a permanently shrinking energy supply, is also likely to drastically reduce the human population but the survivors will live much more frugally than during our passing age of illusionary fossil-fuel based "abundance".
Did you expect us to take any part of that seriously?
 
This must be some new meaning of "rapidly contracting" of which I was previously unaware.

Personally, I think an 8% year-on-year increase in GDP should be called "growth", not "contraction".
http://news.google.com/news?q=china gdp growth&naughty_word=axminster

Of course, if you have any evidence to the contrary, I'd love to see it
Officially China's economy isn't contracting. There's rather less certainty that growth numbers released by the CPC are "true" of course (one of the oddities has been the stability of fast growth prints over the years and the speed with which the CPC releases the data, compared to rich countries where it usually takes more than a month).

There is--also--a "meme", that unless China grows by at least 6% per annum, social unrest will happen and perhaps unseat the CPC from power. To be honest I have seen this repeated so many times in the last year without any underlying analysis that I am sceptical of it--people mostly just appear to assume it is true and that someone else worked it out once before.

The mechanism would be that the growth in the (urban) labour force in China is so rapid (migration from rural existence) that the economy has to expand at 6% or whatever in order to provide enough of these economic migrants with jobs, otherwise they will be penniless and disenfranchised and congregating around China's urban areas.

That sounds believable as far as it goes. However, viewed somewhat dispassionately, I would say there is little evidence of huge numbers of poor or even starving citizens overthrowing their governments (India, Africa, Asia, LatAm). So I am sceptical about it producing regime change too.
 
That sounds believable as far as it goes. However, viewed somewhat dispassionately, I would say there is little evidence of huge numbers of poor or even starving citizens overthrowing their governments (India, Africa, Asia, LatAm). So I am sceptical about it producing regime change too.

In most cases it takes the army to be starving for there to be regime change and this doesn't guarentee that the lot of the "people" will get any better.

Steve
 
And, once again, you're simply wrong. And you can see this all the time in history when people or developers overbuild, and rents fall as a result.
The rents don't fall because people overbuild: they fall because the people get over-indebted to extend those rents in the first place.

The supply didn't suddenly increase overnight: the demand suddenly dropped off the table.

As you point out, the supply of land is fixed -- but the supply of housing depends on how much is built on the land. If you put too many units on the land and oversupply the market, you're not going to be able to fill your units and the prices will drop.
But that's not the case now. There isn't too much housing: there's too much debt. During the run-up, land prices sky-rocketed, fueled by a massive increase in debt. Now, with society over-burdened by debt, very few are able to buy houses, and the unreasonably-high prices for land still have a ways to fall.

A simple thought experiment will confirm this; assume that both land supply and demand for housing remain fixed. There's enough demand for housing in the $100,000 range to ensure, say, five sales per month. The local developers find some cheap single-family homes (ten of them), rip them down, and put in high-end high-rise condos instead (adding enough luxuries that the nominal price remains the same). So we've just replaced ten single-family homes with 100 condos.

For simplicity, we've got ten developers -- each now trying to flog off 10 condos.

Obviously, the people whose houses were used will buy the first ten units.
Equally obviously, there are five new purchase to expect this month. So we can probably sell 15 of the condos. But who gets to sell them? If we hold the line on our prices, we'll each sell one or two of them by random chance. But if I drop my price, say, to $90,000, I can sell all ten of mine out. Anyone who holds the line on housing is likely out in the cold.

But that's just saying that I have increased the supply of housing and so the price dropped, in accordance with the law of supply and demand. Hopefully as condo prices drop, more people will be willing to buy a condo at $90K than at $100K so that we can at least not be sitting around with unsold units.

But notice that it's not the land that was oversupplied.
?? Of course. More housing means cheaper housing. No doubt about it.

But behold!

Over the course of the last 15 or so years ('92-'07), housing prices drastically increased even as supply was increasing. Why? Because land is fixed in supply, and the increased demand meant increased prices, even though the cost of the improvements may have remained static, or even decreased. This plain fact can be verified simply by checking real estate sites and seeing that prices for bare lots increased correspondingly with housing prices. You're wrong, I'm right. Deal with it.

Values for housing and values for land are separate. In fact, with this little demand (and this much oversupply), I suspect prices will drop precipitously.
They already did drop precipitously. Exactly as Fred Harrison said they would years before they did (noticed he predicted exactly when it would happen).

But not because housing is over-supplied.

And this is a well-known and well-understood phenomenon. It's so common, it even has a term : overbuilding. (And overbuilding was a real problem in the commercial real estate market in the 1980s0.
Hehe. I'll bet the real estate industry wants to pin the blame on over-building! If people realize what's going on in the land market and decide rightly to shift taxation to land values, the real estate industry will be out buku loads of money: unearned money (the best kind!).

If, as you suggest, the value is in land and not in housing, how is it even possible to overbuild?
Because the builders continue to build, anticipating the current rate of sales, but society becomes over-indebted, and no one buys housing, which causes land prices to drop, which leaves developers with white elephants (the developers bought the land at a high price).

On the other hand, if, at the same time that the developers were frantically building all these condo, lots of people were moving into the area, so that the market for new housing jumped to 150 units/month, then we can all sell out our inventories and there will still be people who want housing. In this case, of course, I can raise my prices.

In this second case, supply of land remained constant, supply of housing went up, but demand of housing went up even higher -- hence rising prices.
Prices would have rose even if demand didn't go up faster than the supply of housing: because the supply of land is fixed. You just refuse to know that the result of increased demand on a fixed supply means higher prices.

Which is exactly what happened in the recent housing bubble.
Nope. Fred Harrison explains what happened in the recent housing bubble in the linked article.

If there is increased demand for land then the value of land will go up. If there is increased demand for housing, then the price of land may actually go down, if the amoung of housing per unit of land goes up fast enough.
No, that's false. There cannot be increased demand for housing without there being an increased demand for land.

So, no. Again.
LOL. Ok. You go ahead and show a single instance in the history of the earth where demand for housing increased and the result was lower land prices.

I won't be holding my breath.

Yes, we know that's what you say. But we also know that what you say is complete bollocks.
What I said there is an indisputable fact. Which is why you chose not to challenge it.

That's the part that you don't realize. The words you use are grammatical. They even are sometimes semantically interpretable. They're simply, tragically, utterly, completely, and beyond the capacity of mere error wrong.
Nope. The fact is, the right to, say, cut down trees is a natural liberty of everyone. People are free to cut down trees to their heart's content, unless others actively stop them (the old libertarian "initiate force against them"). The reason there's such a thing as "logging rights" is that we realize, as a society, that too much logging will make us all worse off. So we restrict the liberty of society, and allow logging rights to only a privileged few. The same is essentially true of all the things you named.

That's just the fact of the matter. You won't be arguing otherwise.
 
LOL. Ok. You go ahead and show a single instance in the history of the earth where demand for housing increased and the result was lower land prices.

Already shown. Overbuilding in the 1980s in the USA resulted in lower prices for commercially-zoned land (both developed and undeveloped) precisely because the supply of available commercial office space was already more than the aggregate demand.

No one wanted to buy new commercial land because no one expected to be able to fill the building that would be erected on it.

So not only are you, again, wrong about everything, but in this case, you're wrong about something that has already been brought up in-thread.
 
Last edited:
In most cases it takes the army to be starving for there to be regime change and this doesn't guarentee that the lot of the "people" will get any better.
Well quite. And the millions of migrants out of rice fields aren't soldiers or police, and soldiers/police are paid
 
Off-topic posts and bickering moved to AAH.

Keep it civil from now on please.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode

Thank you.

Can we not just agree that when housing and/or commercial space is in short supply and prices are rising that there will be an associated bidding up of land prices, with the degree of increase dependent on the availability of suitable land that is either vacant or not built to the maximal zoned density?

Construction costs in midtown Manhattan are probably not dramatically different than construction costs in the South Bronx, yet a midtown 2 bedroom condo is going to sell for a lot more money, and that is predominantly based on the fact that it's going to cost a developer a lot more money to buy a plot of land in midtown than in the Bronx.

ETA: Meanwhile, 4th quarter GDP decrease has been revised to 6.2% from the preliminary figure of 3.8%. Anyone but BAC think that this is just an ordinary recession?
 
Last edited:
Already shown. Overbuilding in the 1980s in the USA resulted in lower prices for commercially-zoned land (both developed and undeveloped) precisely because the supply of available commercial office space was already more than the aggregate demand.
No, it resulted in higher land prices, and then the prices crashed as the bubble popped. Actually, the building of commercial properties reflects land prices: land prices don't increase because more properties are constructed, properties are constructed because land prices are increasing.

But they can only increase so far, and then the market can no longer sustain them.

No one wanted to buy new commercial land because no one expected to be able to fill the building that would be erected on it.

So not only are you, again, wrong about everything, but in this case, you're wrong about something that has already been brought up in-thread.
Nope. The value of commercial land with buildings on it collapsed as well. Not because the buildings were there, but because the land bubble popped: until it popped, land values increased tremendously.
 
Can we not just agree that when housing and/or commercial space is in short supply and prices are rising that there will be an associated bidding up of land prices, with the degree of increase dependent on the availability of suitable land that is either vacant or not built to the maximal zoned density?
You and I can. Some others have committed to never knowing that fact, because it proves their beliefs false.

Construction costs in midtown Manhattan are probably not dramatically different than construction costs in the South Bronx, yet a midtown 2 bedroom condo is going to sell for a lot more money, and that is predominantly based on the fact that it's going to cost a developer a lot more money to buy a plot of land in midtown than in the Bronx.
Pretty indisputable, isn't it?

ETA: Meanwhile, 4th quarter GDP decrease has been revised to 6.2% from the preliminary figure of 3.8%. Anyone but BAC think that this is just an ordinary recession?
Many are committed to not knowing that as well. When the 3.8% figure came out, someone on another forum commented "how much you want to bet they upwardly revise that figure in a couple of months?"
 
Last edited:
Can we not just agree that when housing and/or commercial space is in short supply and prices are rising that there will be an associated bidding up of land prices
I already said this:
The land values are imputed from house [or other real property] prices because house [or other real property] prices are what you can observe and measure. And what people bought and sold.

Construction costs in midtown Manhattan are probably not dramatically different than construction costs in the South Bronx, yet a midtown 2 bedroom condo is going to sell for a lot more money, and that is predominantly based on the fact that it's going to cost a developer a lot more money to buy a plot of land in midtown than in the Bronx.
But that doesn't make a new point at all. The "natural providence of the land" in Manhattan isn't really different from the Bronx either. What makes it more valuable is overwhelmingly network effects, which are a human providence. Not "land".
 
Can we not just agree that when housing and/or commercial space is in short supply and prices are rising that there will be an associated bidding up of land prices, with the degree of increase dependent on the availability of suitable land that is either vacant or not built to the maximal zoned density?

Well, you're closer to the truth than Free Thinkr, anyway.

If there's enough "suitable land that is either vacant or not built to the maximal zoned density," then the actual land prices can remain the same or even drop, depending upon how much room there is between the amount that has been currently built and the maximal zoned density.

Similarly, land prices can drop if the zoning commission decides to dramatically increase the maximal zoned density; a plot of undeveloped land can actually lose value in this instance, because it's cheaper to expand existing developed land than it would be to build a new condominium from scratch.

Something like this happened in Colorado in the early 1990s, if I remember right. The state rules for building the "prairie palaces" that were in vogue at the time (and much in demand) among ex-Californians required you to have something like five acres of land upon which to build. Undeveloped land parcels of five acres or more were therefore extremely valuable; a four acre parcel was almost worthless. In response to the high demand, the legislature was considering a change dropping the required land size down.

In response to the mere consideration of this change, the prices for undeveloped five-acre lots dropped considerably. The price for housing continued to increase, but the price for the actual land under the house dropped.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom