Free Thinkr
Muse
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2006
- Messages
- 738
I wanted to come back to this. Let us note that here, drkitten is claiming that, because of my fundamental failure to address the difference between buying and leasing, he has thoroughly devastated my point.And, in a single sentence, Free Thinkr demonstrates how thoroughly I devastated him and how thoroughly out-of-touch this theory is; he -- or his theory -- can't address the fundamental difference between buying and leasing.
But is this the case?
Let's have a look once more at how we got here:
drkitten said:Right. More buyers for the same physical houses.
It is clear from my reply that the price paid for land -or land value- increased because the supply is fixed and demand increased.Me said:Actually, the supply of housing increased considerably. But the supply of land didn't, so prices rose.
Does it matter whether this land is purchased, rented, or leased? No. Far from "devastating" my point, this is nothing more than a red herring. Whether landowners are renting, leasing, or selling their land, increased demand means greater land rents (higher land values).
What is the nature of these things? I say that each of these things are restrictions of rights to the providence of nature for some, for the benefit of exclusive use by others. The nature of land titles is the same. Factually, mineral rights are in no way fundamentally different from land rights; governments simply arbitrarily choose to treat them differently. In point of fact, mineral rights in the US are quite different from mineral rights in Australia.Wait until I introduce him to other rights that can be bought and sold -- water rights, airspace rights, mineral rights, logging rights, easements. All of which are property rights, none of which are "land."
But all these things describe the providence of nature, which has been regulated by society in some way such that the liberty to use the resources is restricted for some for the benefit of others. The nature of Georgism is to internalize for government revenue the value owing to the providence of nature, the synergistic efforts of society, and government spending. It's just common sense once you understand it.